CS Paper Radar

Regulating for an AI Commons: Adopting, sustaining, and defending people-first innovation trajectories

Abhineet Nayyar, Mallory Knodel, Kimberlee Weatherall, Gunn Jiravuttipong

cs.CY ·submitted 2026-10-16 09:47 UTC · v1
position

Abstract

Technological principles of openness, interoperability, and decentralization are integral to building an AI economy that is accountable to the public and truly responsive to local needs and constraints. However, Big Tech's firm control over essential elements of the stack (such as chips, cloud, models, data, and talent) limits valuable alternatives from reaching the scale necessary for sustained growth. Worse still, hyperscalers continue to enclose and extract value from publicly funded and volunteer-driven technologies without adequately distributing these returns. We see consolidated power within a few entities and "enshittification" of once-transformative innovations. Embedding ethical micro-level tools (like open data repositories or small-language models) into workflows is promising, but without a consistent innovation strategy, they also often end up perpetuating and being appropriated by the same exploitative trajectories. Instead, this whitepaper outlines a three-pillared holistic and intentional policy approach that i) actively pushes for the adoption of cooperative technologies in existing and emerging systems, ii) sets up collective institutional structures to sustain and maintain them in the long-term, and iii) introduces regulatory proposals that limit private entities from disempowering them through uncontrolled enclosure and extraction. Through desk research and purpose-specific case studies, we argue for the importance of such an approach in the Global South, where structural constraints around infrastructure, financing, and policy governance make it difficult for AI commons and cooperative AI tools to emerge and survive. The paper concludes with key open questions for campaigners, policy advocates, researchers, and grassroots organizers to consider and explore while working towards peoples' solidarity within and between Global South countries.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Open Science, Closed Models: How Funding Shapes AI in Science

cs.DL ·2026-09-21 ·Ana Trišović, Janakan Sivaloganathan
published similarity 0.67
Abstract · Accepted to AAAI/ACM Conference on AI, Ethics and Society (AIES) 2026

How funding shapes AI engagement in science is poorly understood despite its structural importance. We analyze 104,226 papers (2018-2025), linking funding acknowledgments to how each paper engages with foundation models: whether it extends a model (fine-tunes or builds on it), uses one without modification, or references models only peripherally. We report three findings. First, both private and public funding are associated with greater AI engagement. Public funding is associated with more off-the-shelf and open-weight use, while private funding is associated with greater model extension. Industry cloud credits are associated with less open-weight use, consistent with greater reliance on closed models. Second, industry involvement is associated with model extension, suggesting that corporate resources reach science through coauthorship, though this channel is concentrated in Computer Science and Global North collaborations. Third, the gap across research systems is not one of AI adoption but of control. Off-the-shelf use is rising across fields and country groups, and the least publicly funded group, the Global South, now has the highest share of API-only engagement (0.4% to 10.0% of engaged papers). China shows the opposite profile: the highest public-funding share and lowest API-only engagement, with extension remaining stable as it declines across the Global North. Standard capacity indicators show convergence in AI adoption even as dependence on proprietary infrastructure diverges.

0.23

From Pilots to Production: Lessons in Cross-Institutional Federated Training and Artificial Intelligence for Science

cs.DC ·2026-09-30 ·Olivera Kotevska, Max Carlson, Yan Gao, Francis Jeanson, Yijiang Li +7 more
positioncode/data similarity 0.65
Abstract

Many of the most valuable scientific datasets cannot be centralized: they are proprietary, export-controlled, classified, or bound by data-sovereignty restrictions. This inverts the usual paradigm: the model must move to the data, making federated artificial intelligence (AI) core infrastructure for open science. We synthesize lessons from U.S. Department of Energy national laboratories, industry deployments, and the open-source community into a structured account of moving federated AI from pilot demonstrations to dependable, multi-site production. The lessons come from five concurrent efforts spanning leadership-class supercomputers and cloud infrastructure in regulated settings. We organize them around an adapted \textit{five-domain readiness frame} and a stratified view of the stack beneath a trained model: data architecture, privacy and security controls, trust and verification, governance and socio-technical factors, and operations, the layers that decide whether a pilot becomes dependable. The question shifts from ``can we train it?'' to ``can we operate it, audit it, and change it safely?'' We report systems lessons in memory efficiency, reliability, and synchronization; set out what privacy, security, and decentralized trust require in production, and what is not yet validated there; and identify cross-cutting open problems (asynchronous federation, leakage auditing, verification standards, and harmonized data contracts) that we argue warrant a dedicated, international, open-science working group.

0.16

Open at the Edge, Captured at the Center: llama.cpp and the Political Economy of Local AI Inference

cs.CY ·2026-08-19 ·Woohyeuk Lee, Hanlin Li, David Gray Widder
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 18 pages, 7 figures

Critical scholarship on open AI has focused on model releases and cloud ecosystems, leaving the local inference infrastructure that makes open-weight models runnable on user-owned devices largely unexamined. We address this gap through a mixed-methods analysis of llama$.$cpp, combining 7,681 merged pull requests from March 2023 through March 2026 with repository discussions, corporate statements, and contributor blogs. We show that local inference broadens participation at execution while relocating capture into the infrastructure that makes execution possible. Through hardware backends, model integration labor, and Hugging Face's February 2026 absorption of the project, we document how control shifts to hardware vendors, model distributors, and core maintainers while model owners and individual contributors bear the cost of making models runnable. These dynamics suggest that preserving openness outside the cloud requires attention to the infrastructure that makes models runnable, not just to the models themselves. This calls for policy mechanisms--analysis of format dependencies and vendor influence, model compatibility requirements, and sustained public funding for inference tooling--that extend beyond model release conditions to the infrastructure layer.

0.23

Infrastructure and its Discontents: Contestations of Power in Canada's AI Governance Scaffold

cs.HC cs.CY ·2026-10-27 ·Christelle Tessono, Nusrat Jahan Mim, Shion Guha
similarity 0.63
Abstract

This paper develops a critical theoretical framework for understanding national Artificial Intelligence (AI) strategies through the lens of "Governance as Infrastructure." Integrating insights from Infrastructure Studies, Science and Technology Studies (STS), this paper employs Black Feminist Technoscience (BFTS) to reveal how AI governance infrastructures are assembled, maintained, and contested, and whose forms of knowledge, labour, and experience are rendered visible or invisible in these processes. We analyze the Canadian AI governance landscape through in-depth interviews with bureaucrats, civil society advocacy groups, academic researchers, and industry actors. Our inductive thematic analysis reveals how AI governance infrastructure enacts specific configurations of power, particularly through the politics of expertise; how actors navigate profound ambiguities related to AI's opacity, often involving strategic ignorance; and how mechanisms for justice and accountability struggle to address AI-related harms. We contend that a BFTS perspective highlights the limitations of current governance approaches and points toward alternative infrastructural designs prioritizing care, maintenance, participatory democracy, and adaptive temporalities to foster more equitable and accountable technology governance.

0.21

A Regulatory Placebo? The Systemic Failure of Mandatory GenAI Labeling

cs.CY cs.AI ·2026-08-17 ·Jingyi Chen, Chaofan Bu, Shibo Yan, Xuesong Li
published similarity 0.62
Abstract · 18 pages, 1 figures

We examine the worldwide trend of mandatory labeling of generative artificial intelligence(GenAI) as a reactive, symbolic form of legislation triggered by technological panic and institutional responses. From a technical perspective, this study demonstrates that current mandatory labeling not only creates implementation dilemmas but also risks hindering the evolutionary trajectory of AI technology. We then systematically analyze the three dominant theoretical strands of this regime, the value dilution theory, the information authenticity theory, and the proactive regulation theory, and find that they are products of regulators' cognitive limitations in understanding the logic of modern technology. Not only do such formalistic compliance requirements become a regulatory placebo, but they also obscure the genuine legal demands of the technological era. This challenges the current governance paradigm and suggests a shift from identity-label governance to content governance, with an urgent need to address the complex problems associated with GenAI.

0.20

AI in the EGI e-infrastructure -- Past experiences and future strategies

cs.DC cs.AIcs.CY ·2026-10-29 ·Gergely Sipos, Sergio Andreozzi, Marco Rorro, Andrea Manzi, Tiziana Ferrari
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 8 pages, 1 figure. Preprint of a paper submitted to the proceedings of the 28th Conference on Computing in High Energy and Nuclear Physics (…

The EGI Federation has provided federated e-infrastructure services to European and global science for over 15 years. We review EGI's early experiences with AI in the interTwin and iMagine Horizon Europe projects, which built digital twins in physics and environmental sciences and an image-analysis platform for aquatic research. We then examine how the AI landscape has changed since 2023 and argue that the focus of AI in science has shifted from model training to adapting and applying AI to specific domains, projects and questions. Building on these lessons, we present the AI strategy emerging from the EGI Federation Strategy 2026-2030, organised around three enablers: (1) an AI-ready infrastructure connecting compute, data and application resources across the continuum; (2) human skills to know what is possible with AI and how to implement it; and (3) trust, to run AI with confidence even in high-risk environments. We describe the projects implementing each enabler, including federated LLM inference, AI-ready data platforms and AI competence centres, and discuss a division of labour with EuroHPC's AI Factories, RAISE, research infrastructures and EOSC, in which EGI specialises in the customisation and long-term operation of AI for research.

0.18

Report of the 2026 Workshop on Next-Generation Ecosystems for Scientific Computing: Harnessing Community, Software, and AI for Cross-Disciplinary Team Science

cs.CE cs.SE ·2026-08-27 ·Lois Curfman McInnes, Dorian Arnold, Prasanna Balaprakash, Mike Bernhardt, Franck Cappello +43 more
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 27 pages, 2 figures

Scientific computing is undergoing rapid transformation as advances in artificial intelligence, heterogeneous computing, automation, and data-intensive research reshape not only computational tools but also the institutions, workforce models, and collaborative practices that support scientific discovery. This report synthesizes insights from the 2026 Workshop on Next-Generation Ecosystems for Scientific Computing, the second in a three-year series focused on strengthening scientific computing ecosystems through socio-technical co-design. Workshop discussions identified four interdependent strategic themes: software ecosystems for AI-enabled scientific discovery; trust, validation, and traceability; human-AI teaming and paradigm shifts; and workforce, pedagogy, and governance. The report translates these themes into eight priorities for community action spanning shared research infrastructure, trust and traceability, user experience, human-AI teaming, workforce development, cross-sector coordination, stewardship and sustainability, and evaluation of scientific value. Together, these priorities outline directions for building scientific computing ecosystems that remain trustworthy, sustainable, innovative, and resilient as AI assumes a growing role in scientific work.

0.13

Research-Native by Construction: Minimal Nodes, Re-verifiable Workflows, and Compounding Memory for Long-Horizon Scientific Agents

cs.SE cs.AI ·2026-09-28 ·Di Wang, Yu Liu, Bing Cui, Chaoqun Ji, Dongyuan Ni +3 more
benchmark similarity 0.61
Abstract · 34 pages, 8 figures, 8 tables

We describe AfS (Agent for Science), a platform built for long-horizon scientific work, where a project runs for tens of hours across dozens of agent runs with a human present only occasionally. Most agents for science are general coding agents with a skills folder attached, and they inherit that lineage's failure mode: under pressure to finish, they fabricate, skip, or smooth over. Our design rests on one claim: most of the credibility of machine-made research can be moved from asking the model to behave to making the non-compliant state unrepresentable. We encode research discipline as mechanically enforced laws (commitment before measurement; unforgeable freezing; reports are not facts; evidence persists but verdicts do not; negative results are first-class; mechanical questions to the framework and semantic judgment to the model), organized around three time horizons: a minimal set of research nodes within a run, an inquiry contract with frozen closure conditions and a hash-chained artifact ledger within a project, and a two-tier knowledge base with promotion by rewriting across projects. This is a system description written under one rule: each mechanism appears in exactly one place, with the invariant it enforces, the failure it prevents, the way it is realized, and the cost it imposes. It covers the node contract, the write-path gates, the two-tier memory, and the runtime substrate. Three traces walk real failure attempts through the mechanisms that catch them, and two closed campaigns are included as worked illustrations rather than as an evaluation. We report no benchmark: a process-integrity suite that would support quantitative comparison is under construction, and what we can measure today is only the operating cost of the machinery.

0.32