CS Paper Radar

Monitor-Validity Failures: LLM Safety Evidence Paths at Evolving Framework Boundaries

Junchi Liao

cs.AI cs.CRcs.SE ·submitted 2026-10-16 12:09 UTC · v1

Abstract

Modern LLM applications rely on runtime monitors that inspect tool calls, traces, streams, detector outputs, and verifier inputs. This creates an interface-reliability problem: a framework path may remain operational while policy-relevant evidence never reaches its decision point. In one representative case, a regex detector returned a positive match, but the framework stranded the result before the block decision. This differs from jailbreaks and detector errors because the evidence is already recognized yet disconnected from enforcement. We study this repair-boundary signature with canary contracts: parent/fixed confirmation units that place a known payload only on the changed evidence surface and record monitor visibility together with the downstream decision for action-boundary cases. Applying the protocol to public framework repairs, we confirm 18 evidence-path failures across 11 LLM or agent safety project groups and four implementation ecosystems. Nine are established-boundary repairs, eight are new-surface policy-coverage gaps, and one is a boundary-only evidence case. Fourteen reach E1 enforcement boundaries: seven native action outcomes, six configured enforcement boundaries, and one synthetic-consumer consequence. The remaining cases affect verifier, safety-prompt, or observability channels. The cases form carrier, adapter, authority, and surface families and show how ordinary application behavior can remain intact while a safety-specific evidence path misses its decision. Exact revisions, deterministic outcomes, negative controls, and a frozen prospective audit document the confirmation rule. Monitor assumptions therefore need regression tests at the schemas, streams, tools, and adapters that frameworks evolve.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

From Approval to Execution: Reconstruction-Aware Repair Analysis for LLM-Agent Software

cs.SE ·2026-09-22 ·Junchi Zhu, Zhenguang Liu, Shaojing Fan, Jianhai Chen, Qinming He
highly cited similarity 0.69
Abstract

Approval mechanisms have become a primary safeguard for consequential actions in LLM-agent software. Yet the action shown for approval is often not the object ultimately consumed: workflow reload, transcript projection, argument rebinding, and durable-state lookup may reconstruct it before execution. Existing fieldflow and check-coverage analyses can establish that expected fields were inspected, but not that the inspected object version reaches the sink or that no replacement intervenes between check and use. Consequently, a locally complete repair may still leave a residual authorization bypass after reconstruction. We address this problem through three designs. (1) We formulate reconstruction-stable authorization (ReSA) over representation transitions, sink dependencies, consumed versions, and grant scope. (2) We derive obligations that judge candidate repairs and expose residual sink suffixes. (3) We implement the analysis in APAS-Finder and freeze predictions before an independent sink oracle observes execution. Predictions agree with all 28 controlled outcomes. Four matched pairs require opposite judgments despite identical field-flow and check coverage; a CodeQL composite recovers all eight when supplied object flow, dominance, interference, and the same grant contract. Two analysts agree on all four model-validation dispositions and 19/20 sink dependencies. On released consumers, five repairs prevent 60/60 tested out-of-scope effects, while three mechanism contrasts expose the predicted residual effects. Repair sufficiency therefore depends on the reconstructed action consumed, not merely on an approval record or earlier checked representation.

0.47

guardscope: Measuring Which Actions Runtime Controls Check in LLM Agent Systems

cs.AI ·2026-11-11 ·Kentaroh Toyoda, Alex Leung, Bhuvaneswari U
code/data similarity 0.69
Abstract · Code is available at https://github.com/VulcanLab/guardscope

Large-language model (LLM) agents execute actions on external systems through tool calls, and enterprises deploy runtime controls, such as agent gateways, to check this behavior in real time. However, a control can only evaluate the actions that cross the point where it is placed, and an agent can act through more paths than the tool-call channel; no existing work measures this coverage against kernel-level ground truth. In this paper, we present guardscope, a framework that makes this coverage measurable. guardscope works in two stages: a static stage that predicts which of an agent's 15 action paths a control can check from its source, and an empirical stage that runs a fixed workload on a deployment that realizes one of eight topology designs and classifies every executed action as checked, bypassed, or prevented by reconciling the control's decision records against kernel-level ground truth. guardscope makes a control's coverage claim verifiable: a runtime control developer can publish which paths its product inspects under a kernel-verified protocol. We conducted experiments with two agent harnesses and real runtime controls, including Microsoft's agent governance toolkit and agentgateway. guardscope is available at https://github.com/VulcanLab/guardscope.

0.29

Beyond the Patch: Reconstructing an Incomplete-Fix Patch Bypass in LLM Agent Frameworks with Control-Gated, Benign Probes

cs.CR ·2026-11-16 ·Chaitanya Garware
similarity 0.69
Abstract · 6 pages, 3 figures, 1 table

Replaying a vulnerability's original proof-of-concept after patching tests whether its reported trigger remains reproducible, but does not establish that the underlying security invariant holds on other code paths. We present a benign, control-gated reconstruction method and a pilot study across four LLM agent frameworks and four invariant classes. For PraisonAI, we compare original-trigger replay (B0) with a distinct sibling-path probe (M). We also perform five before/after reconstructions across Langroid, Agno, and CrewAI. Each run reports VIOLATION, NO_VIOLATION_OBSERVED, or INCONCLUSIVE, gated by a positive authorized control. Probes use inert markers or builtins-reachability checks. At PraisonAI 4.6.31, the original tool-loading trigger is blocked while the tool_override path still violates the invariant. This reproduces the publicly documented CVE-2026-44334 bypass of CVE-2026-40287; neither tested path shows a violation at 4.6.32. For CrewAI, we observe a violation in tested release 1.11.0 and confinement in 1.11.1, without claiming the earliest fixed release. Fourteen harness-validation scenarios produced their expected verdicts. Only one same-version B0-versus-M divergence is demonstrated. The PraisonAI probes invoke loader functions directly and establish boundary behavior under the supplied setup, not a full end-to-end exploit. A non-violation verdict applies only to the tested probe, version, and configuration and is not a proof of safety. This pilot reconstructs a known incomplete fix; it neither introduces a new testing technique nor estimates vulnerability prevalence.

0.22

Formal Runtime Verification for Tool-Using LLM Agents: An Offline Same-Benchmark Study on AgentDojo and STAC

cs.CR ·2026-10-07 ·Nikolaos Kekatos, Stylianos Basagiannis, Marinelio Chintri, Alexios Lekidis, Tom Nianios +3 more
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.69
Abstract · 14 pages, 1 figure, 13 tables. Accepted at the 8th Workshop on CPS&IoT Security and Privacy (CPSIoTSec '26), co-located with ACM CCS 2026, T…

Guardrails for tool-using LLM agents are usually application-specific rules, which makes multi-step, data-dependent safety policies hard to specify, audit and reuse. As a declarative alternative, we evaluate metric first-order temporal logic (MFOTL), replaying the recorded trajectories that AgentDojo, STAC and R-Judge already ship through the unmodified MonPoly monitor, offline and without running an agent. On these corpora, five generic obligations flag 71.8% of STAC attack chains and 70.1% of successful AgentDojo attacks, but also fire on 29.3% of benign runs. This imprecision stems from the corpora rather than the logic: they rarely record approvals and never record timestamps, so history-dependent obligations reduce to detecting risky action types. Where the trace does carry relational context, provenance-aware policies discriminate better; that context, however, is itself attackable, and one planted line defeats a naive provenance check on 94-99% of the runs it would otherwise flag. Binding provenance to the lookup that produced it closes this evasion at no cost in detection or benign firing. Taken together, these results show that formal temporal monitoring adds value exactly when the trace exposes trustworthy history. We therefore quantify how far current benchmarks are from that point and propose a twelve-field enforcement-ready trace schema.

0.55

StateWise: Diagnosing and Repairing Persistent Operational State Before Agent Actions

cs.SE cs.AI ·2026-10-04 ·Yongyuan Peng, Zhou Feng, Tongying Wu, Jiahao Chen, Yuan Su +3 more
similarity 0.69
Abstract · 21 pages, 8 figures

LLM agents combine reasoning, tool use, and persistent memory to support work across tasks by reusing stored operational records as premises for later actions. However, environmental or requirement changes can invalidate these records, while existing action review, provenance tracking, and clarification mechanisms may leave the underlying persistent state uncorrected. Our audit of coding-agent trajectories identifies candidate failure chains in which invalid records are reused, leading to task failures and unsafe modifications. We propose StateWise, a framework for diagnosing and repairing persistent operational state before action execution. StateWise uses record-level counterfactual replanning to identify decision-critical records, then establishes their current validity through reliability checks, read-only verification of machine-observable facts, and targeted clarification of developer-owned intent. Typed evidence grounding binds evidence to specific records and scopes, enabling persistent corrections with repair lineage. The agent then replans from the repaired state, followed by an independent state-action check before execution. We evaluate StateWise on 150 executable coding-agent cases across diverse runtime environments, workspace configurations, and repository settings, complemented by cross-model evaluations. Under corrupted persistent state, StateWise achieves 93.3% overall correctness, compared with 38.7% for the baseline agent, with no unsafe actions. Component ablations, multi-task experiments, and transfer evaluations further demonstrate effective recovery, persistent corrections, and transferability across repositories and tool interfaces.

0.24

AgentTriage: Replayable Security Diagnosis Across Heterogeneous Agent Runtimes

cs.AI cs.CR ·2026-10-22 ·Jie Ying, Xutao Zhang, Ningyuan Chen, Mengce Zheng, Jun Li +2 more
code/data similarity 0.68
Abstract

When tool-use agents write files, execute code, or send data, their final responses do not explain the resulting security events, and heterogeneous runtimes expose the relevant evidence through incompatible interfaces. We present AgentTriage, an executable contract for replayable security diagnosis across heterogeneous runtimes. The contract admits conclusions whose claims cite canonical runtime events and requires abstention when mandatory evidence is missing. Runtime overlays normalize native observations, while a deterministic pipeline joins invocation and result lifecycles, constructs a typed provenance graph, selects a policy-decisive slice, and binds claims to recorded evidence. Given the same normalized trace, overlay version, and pre-run policy oracle, the diagnosis can be recomputed and its claims re-checked without language-model judgment. Across five runtimes, one contract captures all 159 applicable executions, with an audit of native and synthesized identifiers. On 120 adjudicated cases, AgentTriage achieves 0.858 grounded joint diagnosis, 0.966 required-evidence coverage, and a 0.036 unsupported-claim rate, improving joint diagnosis by 0.175 (95% CI [0.092, 0.258]) over the strongest same-schema baseline. These results quantify the precision of replayable diagnosis and the observation boundaries that require abstention. We release an open-source implementation and selected sanitized evidence at https://github.com/AsnGs/agenttriage-open-source.

0.28

Why LLM Agents Collapse Without Oversight: The Enforcement Gap as the Mechanism Behind Emergence World Failures

cs.AI ·2026-09-14 ·Yuhang Wang
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 27 pages, 3 figures, 8 tables. Submitted to ICLR 2027

Binding the audit flag in Reflexion-style agents --- without changing the auditor --- reduces attack success rate substantially, reaching near zero on models whose flags parse cleanly. This single control-flow change exposes the \textbf{enforcement gap}: the controller receives a safety flag and executes anyway. Separating detection probability $p_d$ from enforcement probability $p_e$ establishes that $p_e \approx 0$ by default across every framework we tested, making detection quality \emph{formally irrelevant} to security when enforcement is absent --- a finding consistent with the spontaneous collapses recorded in unsupervised frontier-agent deployments~\citep{emergence2026}. Residual attack success concentrates where flags are unparseable or auditors leak; an RL-trained enforcement controller handles hedged and malformed verdicts that rule-based parsing cannot, cutting ambiguous-critique failure to a fraction of the rule-based baseline. Concurrent filtering and information-flow defenses address detection, not enforcement, leaving the binding constraint untouched. The Audit Enforcement Specification (AES) packages three concrete requirements that close each residue independently; each primitive is adoptable without redesigning the host framework, and no deployed framework currently implements any of them.

0.29

SpecGuard: Detecting Multi-Turn LLM Jailbreaks via Specification-Based Runtime Monitoring

cs.CR ·2026-10-26 ·Junle Li, Siqi Chen, Jiakai Li, Bingzhuo Zhong
code/data similarity 0.68
Abstract

Multi-turn jailbreaks turn dialogue safety into a trace property: a violation may become identifiable only when user intent and assistant behavior are considered across multiple turns. Existing guard models largely classify individual messages or exchanges and return risk scores or labels, without executable safety semantics or a formally checkable decision trail. We present SpecGuard, a training-free, specification-driven framework for monitoring multi-turn LLM interactions. SpecGuard uses a fixed atomic-proposition contract to map natural-language observations into causally scoped, evidence-backed facts, and expresses forbidden interaction patterns as Linear Temporal Logic specifications. Each specification is compiled into a symbolic finite automaton that incrementally consumes the resulting dialogue trace. The same monitoring mechanism supports buffered runtime checking and retrospective auditing, while accepting runs produce replayable witnesses that identify the triggered specification, supporting facts, and relevant dialogue turns. Experiments on multi-turn safety benchmarks show that SpecGuard consistently outperforms representative open-source guard models while maintaining controlled false-positive rates. These results demonstrate a practical path from heuristic risk classification toward formally specified, verifiable, and auditable LLM safety monitoring, without learned detector parameters or access to the protected model.

0.32