CS Paper Radar

Do in-silico metrics filter designed enzymes for catalysis?

Ziqi Zhang, Wei Zhang, Zhaohong Deng

cs.CE ·submitted 2026-10-17 03:53 UTC · v1

Abstract

Computational metrics are widely used to prioritize enzyme designs for experimental testing, yet their ability to capture catalytic function remains poorly established. Here, we systematically evaluate 33 in-silico metrics across four complementary tasks: distinguishing active from inactive enzymes, identifying substrate specificity, ranking enzyme variants by activity, and detecting perturbations to catalytic residues. We assess these capabilities using natural enzymes, computationally designed enzymes, activity-altering variants, and controlled structural perturbations that compare catalytic residues with matched non-catalytic sites. No single metric consistently captures all aspects of catalytic function. In activity discrimination, catalytic-residue intra-residue repulsion achieves the highest AUROC among the evaluated metrics for both natural enzymes (0.61) and 192 designs that passed the filters of their original design campaign (0.80). For substrate discrimination, interface predicted TM-score (ipTM) performs best (AUROC 0.70), whereas the catalytic pKa range shows the strongest association with activity across single-point variants of BglB (Spearman's rho = 0.48). In controlled perturbation tests, the minimum per-chain predicted TM-score (pTM) has a mean probability of 0.75 of responding more strongly to perturbations at catalytic residues than to matched perturbations at non-catalytic sites. These results reveal substantial variation in what current computational metrics capture, underscoring the need to distinguish structural confidence and physical plausibility from direct evidence of catalytic function when prioritizing enzyme designs.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

KineCouple: Substrate-conditioned residual readout for enzyme kinetic prediction

cs.AI q-bio.QM ·2026-11-06 ·Chun Kang, Yunbo Zhang, Fanhu Zeng, Jian Liu, Siwei Deng +1 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Accurate prediction of enzyme kinetic parameters can support enzyme engineering and metabolic modeling by complementing experimental characterization. Existing prediction methods often pool residue-level protein features before combining them with substrate features. Such substrate-independent pooling cannot adapt residue weighting to the substrate during aggregation, potentially diluting information relevant to a specific enzyme-substrate pair. Since the contributions of individual residues to catalysis can depend on the substrate, substrate-conditioned aggregation offers a way to emphasize residue features relevant to the prediction. We introduce KineCouple, which uses substrate queries and residue-level keys and values in cross-attention, allowing the substrate to guide residue selection before aggregation. The model preserves the global protein representation and adds a gated correction defined as the difference between the conditioned readout and a uniform readout. ProtT5 and MolT5 remain frozen, and separate models predict kcat and Km on a logarithmic scale. In pooled out-of-fold predictions on the CataPro benchmarks, KineCouple reduces kcat RMSE from 1.333 to 1.330 and increases PCC from 0.492 to 0.496 relative to reproduced CataPro. For Km, RMSE decreases from 0.998 to 0.997 and PCC increases from 0.633 to 0.634. Spearman correlation also improves for both tasks.

0.19

RangeFinder: Predicting Ligand Property Ranges from Protein Pockets

cs.LG q-bio.BM ·2026-11-02 ·Alan Nadelsticher Ruvalcaba, Chris Alvin, Supratik Mukhopadhyay, Adam Bess
publishedcode/data similarity 0.59
Abstract · Accepted at the AI for Drug Discovery workshop --- NeurIPS 2026

Identifying ligands for a protein target requires searching a vast chemical space for a comparatively small set of compatible molecules. Existing machine learning approaches primarily address this problem by generating candidate ligands or scoring individual protein-ligand pairs, but provide limited information about the broader chemical space compatible with a binding pocket. We introduce RangeFinder, an SE(3)-equivariant transformer pocket-level model, trained and evaluated on BioLiP2 data, that predicts ranges over nine physicochemical ligand properties directly from pocket structure, chemistry, and evolutionary context. Using an intersection-over-union objective and evaluation metric (range-IoU), RangeFinder achieves a range-IoU of $0.464 \pm 0.002$, outperforming all deployable baselines while requiring only $12.2$ ms per pocket. We also quantify our method's ability to reduce the ligand search space while retaining compatible binders; in this regard, RangeFinder achieves a Reduction-Recall F-Score of $0.543 \pm 0.011$ --- once again outperforming all deployable baselines. Ablation experiments indicate that RangeFinder's performance depends more strongly on the density and quality of ligand supervision than on any individual input modality or specialized training strategy. Together, these results position RangeFinder as an inexpensive and effective molecular filtering prior, with demonstrated potential in narrowing the ligand search space of target pockets before docking, generation, or synthesis. The code for this project can be found at: https://github.com/alannadels/RangeFinder.

0.45

TopU-LBVS: A Realistic Multi Target Benchmark for Ligand Based Virtual Screening

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-09-24 ·Surbhi Kumar, Yuhe Zhou, Varun Shiralkar, Niu Huang, Baris Coskunuzer
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.57
Abstract · 75 pages

Ligand-based virtual screening (LBVS) is a practical first-pass tool in early-stage drug discovery, but existing benchmarks can overestimate performance through random negatives, easy decoys, limited target coverage, and non-standardized evaluation protocols. We introduce TopU-LBVS, a multi-target benchmark for LBVS under hard-negative screening conditions. Starting from curated ChEMBL~35 bioactivity data, TopU-LBVS covers 93 protein targets across 7 protein classes and constructs target-specific screening libraries with property-matched, structurally similar decoys at a fixed 1:40 active-to-decoy ratio. Libraries contain roughly 400 to 10,000 compounds and are designed to reduce simple physicochemical and nearest-neighbor fingerprint shortcuts. TopU-LBVS provides three fixed protocols. TopU-LBVS-full evaluates ChEMBL$^\ast \rightarrow$ TopU generalization across all 93 targets. TopU-LBVS-low evaluates low-data TopU $\rightarrow$ TopU learning within the hard-negative distribution. TopU-LBVS-mini provides a compact seven-target protocol with a paired random-decoy control that changes only the test decoys, enabling low-cost development and direct measurement of the gap between random ChEMBL$^\ast$ and TopU decoys. Across ten reference baselines spanning fingerprint methods, molecular GNNs, fingerprint hybrids, and modern molecular models, performance under random-decoy evaluation degrades sharply under hard-negative screening. We release data, fixed splits, evaluation code, and baseline implementations for reproducible comparison of future LBVS and molecular representation learning methods. Code and data are available at https://github.com/topu-benchmark/topu-lbvs and https://huggingface.co/datasets/topu-benchmark/topu-lbvs.

0.38

SurfSpec: Enhancing Off-Target-Agnostic Specificity by Bounding Pocket-Ligand Geometric Mismatch

cs.LG q-bio.QM ·2026-09-02 ·Minyeong Hwang, Yoorim Gang, Ziseok Lee, Wooyeol Lee, Young Bin Park +3 more
theoryhot direction similarity 0.56
Abstract

Lead optimization in structure-based drug design aims to improve target binding while avoiding unintended interactions with off-target pockets. However, existing affinity-driven methods do not explicitly control specificity, whereas current specificity-aware approaches commonly require prior knowledge of off-target structures. We address off-target-agnostic specificity-aware lead optimization by analyzing the geometric mismatch between a ligand and the target pocket. We provide a conservative specificity lower bound for geometrically separated off-targets without requiring access to off-target structures. By metricizing pocket--ligand mismatch, the triangle inequality shows that reducing target--ligand mismatch improves a conservative lower bound on mismatch to a separated off-target class, which can be translated into a specificity lower bound through an empirical geometry--affinity calibration. Motivated by this analysis, we introduce SurfSpec, an off-target-agnostic lead optimization framework that iteratively grows ligands toward under-occupied regions of the target pocket surface. SurfSpec alternates between linker generation toward selected target-surface patches, which provides geometric pseudo-labels, and refinement under a pocket-conditioned ligand prior, which restores these pseudo-labels into valid ligands. On the CrossDocked2020 test set, SurfSpec reduces geometric mismatch and outperforms evaluated off-target-agnostic lead optimization baselines in empirical specificity, while maintaining competitive target-affinity improvement.

0.30

Adaptive catalyst discovery emerges from composable scientific intelligence

cs.LG ·2026-11-10 ·Wentao Li, Qilong Cai, Qi Lei, Jinxing Chen, Ruixuan Chen +19 more
benchmark similarity 0.56
Abstract · 29 pages, 8 figures

Catalysis underpins chemical manufacturing, yet knowledge for catalyst design remains dispersed across experimental observations, computational data and catalysis subdisciplines. To overcome this challenge, we present Composable Catalytic Intelligence (CatAI), a physics-grounded modular AI framework that learns 1.8 million structure-property relations and organizes them into 30 physicochemical encoders. This reusable intermediate layer enables task-specific models to guide catalyst discovery for targeted reactions and objectives. Across benchmark tasks, CatAI achieves a 7.8% lower task-averaged prediction error than the next-best models. In experimental validation, CatAI identified a new confined-passable pocket catalyst applicable in industrial homogeneous polymer synthesis with 9 times the activity of the commercial benchmark. In parallel, it guided autonomous closed-loop optimization of a highly active Cu-based geminal-atom photocatalyst for C-O coupling reactions surpassing the traditional Ni-based systems. This approach connects property-level data to catalytic objectives, supporting physicochemical knowledge reuse across mechanistically distinct systems through computational screening and iterative model-experiment feedback.

0.24

SpecOpt: Contact-Diff Reasoning for Agentic Molecule Optimization Toward Binding Specificity

cs.AI ·2026-09-18 ·Thao Nguyen, Heng Ji
benchmark similarity 0.56
Abstract

Off-target protein binding is a major source of adverse effects for small-molecule drugs, yet most structure-based molecular design methods focus on generating selective compounds de novo rather than improving the selectivity of existing, well- characterized drugs. We introduce specificity optimization (SpecOpt), a molecular design task that seeks constrained structural modifications to an existing compound that increase its binding preference for an intended target over known off-targets while preserving its structural identity and drug-like properties. To enable systematic evaluation, we construct a ChEMBL-derived benchmark from compound-target interaction data, identifying intended targets through curated drug-mechanism annotations and off- targets through measured activities. We then develop an agentic framework that docks each compound against its intended target and off-targets, compares the resulting poses through residue-aware atom-protein contacts, and provides these differential interactions to a large language model to propose targeted structural modifications. Candidates are retained only if they satisfy molecular similarity, ADMET, and target-off-target docking selectivity criteria. On 915 compounds, the agent improves the target- off-target binding gap for 84.8% of compounds, shifting the mean gap from -0.72 to +0.47 kcal/mol while maintaining a mean Tanimoto similarity of 0.72 to the starting compounds. Ablation studies identify residue-specific contact information as the critical optimization signal: replacing residue identities with binary contact indicators eliminates improvement on all 29 ablation compounds. These results establish SpecOpt as a distinct molecular design problem and demonstrate residue-aware differential interactions as an effective signal for improving the specificity of existing compounds.

0.08

Which reported inputs govern molecular docking reproducibility? A benchmark from reporting audit to independent re-execution

cs.DL ·2026-09-29 ·Giap Duc Ha
benchmark similarity 0.56
Abstract · 29 pages, 8 figures, 6 tables. Retained derived data, verification code and source limitations included as ancillary files

Computational docking results can be re-executed only when the molecular system and protocol are specified, yet reporting checklists do not quantify how strongly individual method fields affect the reported score. We combined a span-verified audit of 50 open-access papers with controlled one-factor perturbations, a Vinardo scoring-function check and a Vina cross-docking extension covering 12 targets in 7 protein families, and re-execution of 37 published claims on local and independent cloud infrastructure. Search-related fields were sparsely reported, but perturbing box centre, box size, exhaustiveness or random seed produced median absolute score changes of no more than 0.08 kcal mol$^{-1}$; ligand protonation and identity produced median changes of 0.19 and 0.29 kcal mol$^{-1}$, respectively, whereas receptor structure produced the largest change (1.02 kcal mol$^{-1}$; n = 85; P < 0.001), and 22% of 116 unique reported ligand strings remained unresolved or ambiguous after deterministic name normalization. These measurements yielded empirical field weights for the NewScience Evidence score and identified exact receptor structure, machine-resolvable ligand identity and protonation state as primary reporting elements; 29 of 37 local and 27 of 37 cloud re-executions were within 2.0 kcal mol$^{-1}$ of the reported score, but these descriptive rates do not estimate experimental replication or a calibrated probability of reproduction.

0.28

Elucidating the Space of Enzymatic Reaction: A Unified Benchmark and Pretrained Model

cs.AI q-bio.QM ·2026-10-08 ·Yutong Hu, Tianming Huang, Yanbo Zhao, Qiongyu Zhang, Shixiang Tang +4 more
benchmark similarity 0.55
Abstract

Existing reaction models primarily learn molecular transformations, whereas enzy- matic reactions depend jointly on molecular structure and catalytic function. We formulate this problem as learning an enzymatic reaction space linking reactants, products, and Enzyme Commission (EC) annotations. To characterize this space, we introduce VenusRX-Bench, a unified benchmark for forward reaction prediction, single-step retrosynthesis, and EC-number prediction. VenusRX-Bench integrates reactions from multiple biochemical databases with standardized curation, leakage- controlled splits, and consistent evaluation. Benchmarking representative chemical and enzymatic models reveals a clear chemical-to-enzymatic domain gap, driven by limited domain data, catalytic-context dependency, and the difficulty of modeling large biomolecular structures. To bridge this gap, we develop VenusRX, a unified T5-style sequence-to-sequence model for enzymatic reactions. VenusRX jointly learns forward prediction, ret- rosynthesis, and reaction reconstruction, with two-stage training on millions of template-expanded reactions followed by real biochemical reactions. In addition, optional EC conditioning incorporates catalytic context, while Molecule Library- Constrained Decoding improves the generation of complex biomolecules. Across benchmark tasks and challenging generalization splits, VenusRX achieves the best or competitive performance on most evaluated settings over representative chem- ical and enzymatic baselines. Moreover, EC information consistently improves reaction prediction, while learned reaction representations support accurate EC prediction, revealing a bidirectional relationship between reaction structure and catalytic function. Together, VenusRX-Bench and VenusRX provide a unified framework for elucidating and modeling enzymatic reaction space

0.08