CS Paper Radar

Retrieval-triggered Action Projection Adjustment for Frozen VLA Policies: An Empirical Study and Failure Analysis

Jinming Wang, Ruiheng Zhang, Yong Wang, Zipan Xiong, Keyuan Luo

cs.RO ·submitted 2026-10-17 09:08 UTC · v1

Abstract

Frozen Vision-Language-Action (VLA) policies cannot incorporate previously encountered failures without updating the underlying model. We present retrieval-triggered projection correction (RTPC), an auditable external-memory wrapper for frozen OpenVLA policies that retrieves stress-collected local-depth records and applies translation-only projection correction while keeping rotation and gripper commands unchanged. RTPC is evaluated on CALVIN single-task manipulation using primary and independent replication cohorts. In the primary evaluation, RTPC reduced a depth-based near-collision or stall proxy event rate without changing task-success count. However, this reduction was not reproduced in the independent replication, and retrieved correction directions were not distinguishable from random same-family directions. Analysis identifies endpoint coupling, batch sensitivity, and the lack of a trigger-matched memory-free baseline as limitations for attributing effects to retrieval-based correction. These findings do not establish physical safety improvement or memory-specific benefits, but provide an empirical evaluation and failure analysis of retrieval-conditioned intervention for frozen VLA policies.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Imagining Recovery: Inference-Time Counterfactual Realignment for Vision-Language-Action Models

cs.RO cs.CV ·2026-08-14 ·Yanyan Zhang, Disheng Liu, Kai Ye, Chaoda Song, Xinpeng Li +4 more
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Vision-language-action (VLA) models have improved the flexibility and generality of robotic manipulation, yet they remain fragile to online disruptions, such as changes in task goal, scene configuration, or robot state. Existing recovery methods often require failure data, policy retraining, or external corrective agents, introducing additional data requirements and execution risks. We propose Counterfactual Realignment (CoRe), a training-free framework that recovers a frozen VLA at inference time without failure data. Upon detecting a deviation, CoRe imagines how the policy would continue toward the current goal from a recent viable state, using synthesized observations in place of physical execution, and then minimally realigns the robot and scene to rejoin this imagined continuation before returning control to the policy. Recovery is therefore planned without physical trial-and-error, preserves completed task progress, and handles both mid-episode instruction changes and physical perturbations in a unified manner. Extensive experiments across multiple simulators, VLA backbones, and real-world settings show that CoRe improves success rates by up to 85.0 percentage points to near-nominal levels while reducing physical restorations by 42.2%, without policy fine-tuning or failure-specific recovery training.

0.41

REMM: Revisable Embodied Memory for Manipulation

cs.RO ·2026-10-08 ·Revanth Krishna Senthilkumaran, Ruwan Wickramarachchi, Alessandro Oltramari, Jonathan Francis
code/data similarity 0.70
Abstract · 12 pages, 8 figures. Project page: https://revanthsenthil.github.io/remm/

Long-horizon manipulation requires robots to retain task-relevant history while revising conclusions no longer supported by physical evidence. Retaining observations alone does not specify which completed conditions should be withdrawn after a disturbance or which obligations require repair. We introduce REMM, Revisable Embodied Memory for Manipulation, a supervisory memory layer for a frozen G0.5 vision-language-action executor. REMM separates an append-only evidence history from revisable task state and explicitly links derived relations and completed conditions to their supporting facts. When accepted evidence changes a supporting fact, it withdraws dependent conclusions and schedules targeted recovery at verified skill boundaries without updating the executor. Across 51 physical trials, including operator-assisted runs, REMM improves mean recorded task progress over the strongest baseline from 57% to 91% in intervention recovery and from 43% to 70% in sequence recall. Complementary video diagnostics show improved grounding of retained history into the next instruction, including comparisons with $π_{0.5}$-compatible high-level planner adaptations. These results support revisable memory as a practical interface for continued manipulation without policy retraining. Project: https://revanthsenthil.github.io/remm/.

0.34

Reuse Before You Retrieve: Diagnosing Headroom and Complementarity for Test-Time Augmentation of Embodied Multimodal Policies

cs.RO ·2026-08-18 ·Yuhwan Jeong, Kuk-Jin Yoon
published similarity 0.70
Abstract · Accepted to ECCV 2026 workshop

Frozen vision-language-action (VLA) policies are increasingly improved at test time by sampling additional policy behaviors or introducing external demonstrations. Yet there is little guidance for deciding which intervention a deployed policy actually needs. Additional sampling is useful only when better behavior already exists within the policy's stochastic rollouts and can be identified, whereas retrieval is most useful when the relevant action prior is not reliably represented by the policy. We study this decision through two measurable factors, recoverable headroom and retrieval complementarity, which characterize how much useful behavior is already available to recover and whether an external action prior fills a measurable gap. We evaluate an episode-level retry selector under retryable or parallel execution, together with retrieval across multiple frozen VLA policies and environments. The selector consistently recovers substantial latent capability across all tested VLA backbones on LIBERO, with gains of up to 21.0 success-rate points that closely track recoverable headroom. It also transfers to a different robot and simulator and remains effective under degraded observations, while experiments with autoregressive OpenVLA illustrate the distinction between available headroom and the ability to rank candidate rollouts. Retrieval behaves differently, improving the policy with the largest measured action-prior gap and providing further gains when combined with selection. Together, these results provide an empirical basis for characterizing test-time augmentation opportunities by separating capability that can be recovered from the frozen policy from behavioral priors that may need to be introduced externally.

0.43

MIKASA-Robo-VLA: Benchmarking Memory in VLA Models for Long-Horizon Manipulation

cs.LG cs.AIcs.RO ·2026-09-30 ·Egor Cherepanov, Nikita Kachaev, Aleksandr I. Panov, Alexey K. Kovalev
surveybenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.70
Abstract · 57 pages, 39 figures, 38 tables

Vision-language-action policies often see only one or a few recent frames, which makes it difficult to evaluate how they use information that disappears during a task. We introduce MIKASA-Robo-VLA, a benchmark of 90 language-conditioned manipulation tasks. All but 10 hide the cue an action depends on. Those 10 are reactive controls. MIKASA-Robo, the suite it rebuilds, has 32 tasks and uses language only in a representative VLA subset. Here every task provides an instruction, while memory-dependent tasks hide a task-relevant cue and reactive controls keep it available. For 70 tasks, environment phase timings specify an information gap, and for 28 of them the gap exceeds the 16-frame window of the widest fixed-context VLA we survey. The gap counts only the interval the cue is provably absent, not the full duration a policy must retain it, so every memory-dependent task still requires memory by construction, including the ones whose measured gap is short. We release 22,500 oracle trajectories across 10 memory types in RLDS and LeRobotDataset v3. A reference $π_{0.5}$ baseline with current images and proprioception, but no observation history or explicit memory module, is fine-tuned on 14 tasks and achieves 0.211 $\pm$ 0.044 mean task success. Its lower success on the evaluated Long-split tasks is confounded by open-loop chunking and the memory types represented in that subset. Project page: https://mikasarobo.github.io/

0.55

ConflictVLA-Bench: Benchmarking Behavioral Responses of Vision-Language-Action Models to Premise Conflicts

cs.AI cs.RO ·2026-09-25 ·Liyu Hou, Yuan Wu, Yi Chang
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.69
Abstract · 8 pages, 4 figures

While Vision-Language-Action (VLA) models perform strongly on manipulation tasks, their responses to invalid task premises remain underexplored. Existing evaluations of premise conflicts often focus on terminal task outcomes, yet task failure alone cannot distinguish behavioral disengagement from continued pursuit followed by an execution error. We call the latter pattern Failed Persistence. To study this phenomenon, we introduce ConflictVLA-Bench, which pairs conflict rollouts with premise-consistent reference rollouts and evaluates both outcomes and execution processes. Built on LIBERO, the benchmark contains 2,826 prompt-conditioned conflict tasks spanning four conflict families, four structural configurations, and two prompt conditions. Across all eight VLAs, invalid premises reduce original goal completion by at least 17.3 percentage points, with the reduction reaching 56.2 percentage points for OpenVLA. Crucially, even when models succeed on premise-consistent tasks and fail on their matched conflict tasks, they often continue to approach the original targets, retain early trajectory structure, and show limited action magnitude suppression. Failed Persistence therefore recurs across the evaluated models. Explicit premise checking does not consistently produce selective and coordinated behavioral changes. These findings show that terminal failure alone establishes neither behavioral disengagement nor refusal and that outcomes alone are insufficient for VLA evaluation. Experimental data and additional details are available on the project page: https://github.com/EmbodiedAISurvey/ConflictVLA-Bench

0.53

SR-VLA: Stall-Reduced VLA Execution via Predicted-Input Lookahead and Selective KV Cache Repair

cs.RO eess.SY ·2026-11-17 ·Tao Zhang, Yi Zhong, Jinhao Ruan, Yipeng Gao, Linfeng Zhong +2 more
similarity 0.69
Abstract

Vision-language-action (VLA) policies incur control stalls when inference blocks the next action chunk. Asynchronous early inference can hide latency, but its results may be inconsistent with the arriving actual inputs. Unconditional reuse risks acting on mismatched inputs, whereas full recomputation discards useful precomputation. We propose SR-VLA, combining predicted-input lookahead with selective KV cache repair. During current chunk execution, a lightweight action-conditioned predictor generates next-boundary visual observations and proprioceptive state. These predictions, together with the task instruction, drive the frozen VLA to precompute a speculative KV cache and action chunk. After real inputs are available to VLA, predicted--real differences and task conditions determine whether to accept the action chunk or trigger selective KV repair. On LIBERO, SR-VLA achieves $2.67\times$ and $1.27\times$ query speedups over the respective synchronous $π_{0.5}$ and OpenVLA-OFT baselines, while maintaining competitive average task success rates. Under target-motion perturbation, success remains baseline-comparable, with $1.52\times$--$1.93\times$ query speedup.

0.28

AGM: Achievement-Grounded Memory for Closed-Loop Agents with Frozen VLA Policies

cs.RO cs.AI ·2026-08-30 ·Hongbo Gao, Zeyu Ni, Xin Wen, Siyu Xu, Ruifeng Li +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.69
Abstract · 26 pages, 9 figures

Frozen vision-language-action (VLA) policies offer broad manipulation skills but execute open-loop action chunks without tracking task progress, so the agent cannot reliably decide whether to continue, retry, or terminate. External memory is a natural remedy, yet we find it can be harmful when attempted actions are recorded as completed progress: transient execution failures become persistent task-state errors, and such a memory can underperform no progress memory at all. We propose Achievement-Grounded Memory (AGM), a lightweight closed-loop framework for frozen VLA policies. AGM represents a task as a static subgoal sequence with a dynamic progress pointer and advances the pointer on physically verified achievement rather than on attempts. Proprioceptive gripper-load cues decide when to verify; coherent point tracking verifies grasps, and language-conditioned cross-view comparison, read by a single trained 2.43M-parameter verification head, verifies placements. The policy, tracker, and encoder remain frozen, the head is the only trained component, and deployment needs no auxiliary vision-language model. On the RoboMME Counting benchmark, AGM reaches 100.0% on PickXTimes and 84.0% on BinFill, surpassing the strongest memory-augmented baseline by 7.7 points on the four-task average, and the gains carry over to a physical robot, where AGM reaches 100.0% and 82.0%. These results suggest that reliable embodied memory depends more on disciplined state updates than on memory capacity.

0.45

Outcome-Conditioned End-Effector Geometry Across Vision-Language-Action Policies

cs.RO cs.AI ·2026-09-18 ·Xingyu Lin, Zhuang Li, Zhongrun Wu, Shouquan Zhou, Dehui Du
similarity 0.69
Abstract · 8 pages, 3 figures, 7 tables, 23 references. Submitted to ICRA 2027

Vision-language-action (VLA) policies solve the same manipulation task through different action interfaces, but task success alone does not establish whether their physical executions agree. We study cross-policy end-effector geometry in 15,000 closed-loop LIBERO rollouts from four policies. The primary clean-condition analysis forms 3,600 configuration-matched, and therefore dependent, policy pairs. Both-success pairs have a median normalized dynamic time warping distance of 0.0120 m versus 0.0380 m when exactly one policy succeeds. This ordering holds in every task, every policy pair, and nine sampling and band-limited representations; however, the ratio varies severalfold across representations, so we report the direction rather than a fixed multiple. Both-failure pairs are more separated again but rest on thin, uneven support, so we report them as exploratory. Within successful executions, partner replacements separate more across tasks than across initial states. A matched baseline still reveals measurable, heterogeneous residual policy differences, so a low cross-policy distance does not imply interchangeability. Successful executions sit about as far from same-task demonstrations as those demonstrations sit from each other, compatible with task-associated geometry without separating training-data overlap from task constraints. A common 72-action window preserves the ordering but reduces its magnitude; endpoint and duration adjustment likewise leaves a positive mixed-outcome coefficient relative to both-success pairs, though its magnitude is specification-dependent. Under composite visual stress, policy rankings and pair composition change together.

0.21