CS Paper Radar

How Much Feedback Is Needed to Break Template Protection? The Geometric Vulnerability of Biometric Authentication

Eliron Rahimi, Margarita Osadchy, Orr Dunkelman

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-10-18 08:47 UTC · v1

Abstract

Biometric authentication systems increasingly use privacy-preserving mechanisms to protect sensitive templates. However, the authentication interface itself may still leak information that enables reconstruction attacks. Prior attacks exploit released similarity scores, whereas more advanced systems reveal only the binary accept/reject decision. This binary feedback provides substantially less information, making template reconstruction far more challenging. In this work, we introduce query-efficient reconstruction attacks under extremely limited feedback, addressing two key limitations of prior attacks. First, we introduce the first attack that reconstructs protected biometric templates using only authentication success/failure feedback by exploiting the geometric constraints of biometric authentication. Second, we introduce distribution-aware query-efficient reconstruction methods for score-releasing systems, achieving a more realistic threat model by reducing the number of required queries by a factor of $5\times$ compared to recent prior score-based attacks. Finally, we combine these two insights by incorporating a pretrained facial diffusion prior into our geometric binary attack, reducing the number of required queries by a factor of $5\times$. Our findings reveal a fundamental security limitation of biometric authentication: independently of the template protection mechanism, the authentication process itself exposes geometric information that can enable perfect template reconstruction up to numerical precision. Moreover, the distribution of biometric templates can be leveraged to make significantly more effective reconstruction attacks.

Comment
preprint

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Flexibility Has a Price: Quantifying Modality Policies in Maliciously Secure Multi-Biometric Authentication

cs.CR ·2026-11-17 ·Fuyi Wang, Wang Zhang, Neo Xu, Chao Chen, Kok-Leong Ong +1 more
similarity 0.70
Abstract

Multi-biometric authentication improves robustness and accessibility by combining information from multiple biometric modalities. Existing research has primarily focused on secure multimodal authentication, feature fusion, and recognition performance, while paying comparatively little attention to the security implications of modality-flexible authentication policies. At the same time, most systems provide limited cryptographic protection for biometric data during authentication. This paper addresses both challenges. We first study modality flexibility as a security decision rather than merely a usability feature. Each accepted modality subset creates an authentication entry point, and the resulting risk depends on the joint behavior of all accepted subsets and the attempt budget. We introduce a framework for quantifying this security cost and develop a policy-selection procedure that identifies policies satisfying a target risk level while supporting users who can present only a subset of modalities. We then present SUPERMBA, a two-server privacy-preserving authentication system that enforces the selected policy without revealing biometric templates or the modality subset used in an authentication attempt. The protocol provides verifiable policy enforcement even when one server is malicious and executes the same computation irrespective of the chosen policy or modality subset. Experiments on the three-modality MULB+ dataset show that allowing all modality subsets increases impostor risk from 1.21% for the weakest entry to 4.42% for the union of entries. On VidTIMIT, the increase is substantially smaller and is not statistically resolved with the available identities. SUPERMBA completes an authentication attempt in only 6.42 ms on MULB+ and 6.03 ms on VidTIMIT.

0.24

BioBind: Binding Biometric Deduplication to Zero-Knowledge Authentication

cs.CR ·2026-11-09 ·Taotao Wang, Xiaoxiao Wu, Shengli Zhang
code/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · 29 pages, 7 figures, 19 tables. Supplementary material included as Appendices A-H. Code and artifact: https://github.com/plan-lab-szu/biobin…

Biometric identity systems for decentralized applications need credentials that resist repeated enrollment and support private, publicly verifiable authentication. Capture and large-scale private deduplication run off chain while smart contracts authorize issuance and use; these stages span distinct trust domains, and a correct verdict covers only the checked inputs and gallery snapshot. Without binding and state checks, concurrent enrollments can issue duplicate credentials from correct verdicts, while substituted inputs can authorize unrelated credentials. We present BioBind, a protocol whose four backend interface conditions bind the deduplication query, gallery insertion and issued commitment to one captured vector, authenticate gallery transitions, and require a sound uniqueness verdict valid at finalization. Its encrypted instance uses bound requests, stale-session rejection and committee-confirmed migration. Capture-bound zero-knowledge authentication links credential use to the enrolled template and a fresh device-originated probe bound to the challenge. We give a conditional multi-session composition argument under explicit capture, backend and cryptographic assumptions. A prototype using LFW face features rejects the tested composition attacks; its unlinkable authentication circuit uses 31,445 constraints and about 305,000 gas. An equal-public-field baseline quantifies the cost of verifiable matching: witness-plus-proving medians are 1.989 s versus 1.119 s with device-trusted matching. Separate tests of encrypted enrollment complete three histories of 16,384 registrations without decoding errors at the tested checkpoints. Biometric accuracy bounds person-level uniqueness: on the Bosphorus database, cooperative subjects who change appearance evade deduplication in 1.8% of re-enrollment attempts at the operating threshold. Full backend integration remains open.

0.55

Breaking High Confidence: Practical Face Impersonation under High-Security Thresholds

cs.CV ·2026-08-21 ·Changjin Kim, Seunghun Paik, Dongsoo Kim, Jae Hong Seo
top venuebenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.61
Abstract

Face recognition systems (FRSs) are increasingly deployed in critical real-world services for authentication, such as banking applications and airport identity checks, necessitating stringent security configurations. Consequently, the security vulnerabilities of FRSs have garnered significant attention. While existing studies have extensively explored FRS security, prior analyses have primarily focused on medium-security threshold settings, which are not directly applicable to FRSs operating under high-security constraints. In this paper, we propose the first successful impersonation attack against FRSs under high-security threshold settings. Among various threat models, we focus on a practical and challenging scenario: score-based impersonation attacks under strict rate limits. To precisely evaluate the feasibility of such attacks, we provide a principled mathematical analysis characterizing the gaps in each stage of the attack pipeline. Our method significantly enhances impersonation capabilities in score-based attacks, even under elevated decision thresholds. On the LFW benchmark, with a budget of only 100 confidence score queries per identity, our attack achieves an impersonation success rate exceeding 92\% against Amazon Rekognition at a confidence score threshold of 99-recommended setting for law enforcement scenarios. We further observe consistently robust performance across multiple open-source FRSs evaluated at similarly stringent decision thresholds.

0.67

Ghost Attack: Using 19th-Century Illusions to Fool 21st-Century Biometrics

cs.CV ·2026-10-16 ·Tyler Fitzsimmons, Adam Czajka
publishedbenchmarkhot direction similarity 0.61
Abstract · Accepted to WACV (Winter Conference on Applications for Computer Vision) 2027

While the Pepper's Ghost illusion is a 19th-century optical technique, we found that this forgotten gimmick exposes vulnerabilities in modern face recognition systems. This paper introduces the 'Ghost Attack': a physical attack that repurposes this classic illusion using low-cost, free-space hardware and a transparent medium to project high-resolution facial data into physical 3D space. We show in the paper that despite relying on centuries-old optical principles, this new attack type simultaneously breaks three components of modern facial recognition systems (FRS): (a) the face matcher, (b) the presentation attack detection module, and (c) the morphing attack detection component, resulting in high impersonation success rates against state-of-the-art algorithms without triggering presentation or morphing defenses. These findings reveal a significant blind spot in current biometric systems, which fail to account for transparent projections and evolving physical attack vectors. To support further research, we are offering the dataset of face images of 100 identities, re-captured with and without 'ghost' projections as a new benchmark representing a novel attack for face recognition.

0.44

Identity by Design, Demographics by Accident: Demographic Leakage and Suppression in Behavioral Biometric Embeddings

cs.CR ·2026-08-28 ·Iyadh Khan, Patrick Nilackshan, Mohamed Aathif, Mohamed Theesan, Sandareka Wickramanayake +1 more
benchmark similarity 0.60
Abstract

Behavioral biometric authentication (BBA) systems use deep learning models to transform biometric signals, such as eye movements, voice, keystroke/touchstroke dynamics, and gait, into identity embeddings for user authentication. While designed to encode identity, these embeddings may inadvertently reveal sensitive demographic attributes, including gender, age, and height. Consequently, an adversary with access to the authentication model can infer demographic information from biometric signals, including those of users unseen during training or enrollment. In this paper, we present the first systematic audit of demographic leakage in BBA systems, evaluating 11 models across 9 datasets spanning four biometric modalities. We further benchmark four post-hoc suppression methods-Incremental Variable Elimination (IVE), Hilbert-Schmidt Independence Criterion (HSIC), Adversarial Encoder-Decoder (AED), and Protected Attribute Suppression System (PASS) to assess their ability to mitigate demographic leakage while preserving authentication utility. Our analysis reveals substantial variation in leakage and suppressibility across modalities, model architectures, and learning objectives. While voice embeddings exhibit high leakage that can be effectively suppressed, keystroke/touchstroke embeddings exhibit lower leakage but are considerably more difficult to sanitize. These findings highlight a fundamental privacy risk in behavioral biometric authentication and provide insights into the factors governing demographic information suppressibility.

0.29

GhostFaceMPC: Privacy-Preserving Face Recognition with Multi-Party Computation

cs.CR ·2026-10-21 ·Davide Carnemolla, Dario Catalano, Mario Di Raimondo
code/data similarity 0.59
Abstract

Facial recognition has become central to modern authentication systems, security frameworks, and personalized services. However, its widespread adoption is hindered by severe privacy risks, particularly surrounding unauthorized access to sensitive biometric data. To address these challenges, this paper presents GhostFaceMPC, the first end-to-end, privacy-preserving face recognition system to evaluate a deep convolutional neural network extractor and matching under secure multi-party computation. GhostFaceMPC enables secure processing of facial data across all stages of a face recognition process, from feature extraction and storage to matching, without exposing raw images or biometric embeddings at any stage. We introduce a multi-party computation-friendly quantization of the GhostFaceNet model and circuit optimizations that make face recognition under multi-party computation practical. The code is available at https://github.com/crypto-unict/GhostFaceMPC.

0.25

FIDA: Feature Instability-Driven Attack on Self-Supervised Facial Representation

cs.CV cs.CR ·2026-08-27 ·Zhiyang Chen, Changchun Yin, Huiqin Yang, Liming Fang
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Self-supervised learning (SSL) models are vulnerable to backdoor attacks. However, the systemic risks they pose in face representation have received little attention. The entanglement of identity features in self-supervised face learning presents unique challenges for attack stealthiness. To address this gap, we propose FIDA (Feature Instability-Driven Attack), a novel backdoor attack framework. FIDA uses subtle semantic triggers for injection, but its key innovation is a novel objective called Feature Instability Loss. It trains the encoder to increase the sensitivity of triggered features along perturbation directions sampled during attack optimization . By preventing the backdoor from exhibiting the rigid feature patterns typical of previous attacks, FIDA effectively evades the evaluated perturbation-based defenses. Experiments show that FIDA achieves a high attack success rate and generally preserves benign utility across the evaluated settings , posing a significant threat to real-world multimedia applications relying on facial analysis.

0.18

Anti-Persona: Disrupting Unauthorized Identity Binding and Recognition in Personalized Vision--Language Models

cs.CV ·2026-10-01 ·Abhishek Basu, Fahad Shamshad, Karthik Nandakumar
code/data similarity 0.58
Abstract · Code available at https://github.com/iabh1shekbasu/anti-persona

Few-shot personalization enables large vision--language models (LVLMs) to learn user-specific visual concepts for applications such as personalized retrieval and subject-aware querying. However, it also creates a privacy risk: an adversary can bind a target identity from a few reference images and subsequently detect that identity in new images through natural-language queries. We introduce Anti-Persona, an image-level defense against unauthorized identity binding and recognition in personalized LVLMs. Our key insight is that identity personalization relies on visual features shared across multiple reference images. We aggregate these features into an identity prototype and optimize visually subtle perturbations that disrupt prototype alignment in the vision-encoder space. Spatial smoothing and low-frequency preservation further promote visual fidelity and practical resilience to image compression. The resulting protection does not depend on a specific prompt and supports both proactive anti-personalization and reactive image protection. Experiments on two representative personalized LVLMs demonstrate protection rates of up to $95.0\%$ while preserving visual fidelity. The method remains stable across prompt variations and evaluated identity-query tasks, and improves black-box transfer under encoder mismatch.

0.36