CS Paper Radar

Learn the Interface, Not the Implementation: Output Representation Dominates Training Regime in LLM-Based RTL Generation

Siddharth Patel, Vikram Singh, Siddharth Savyasachi Malu, Rohit Singh

cs.LG cs.AR ·submitted 2026-10-19 06:38 UTC · v1
publishedposition

Abstract

Large-language-model register-transfer-level (RTL) generation has concentrated on how to train the model: fine-tuning, continued pre-training, and reinforcement learning from a verifier. We argue this is the second-order question. On a bounded, formally specifiable task of generating single-error-correcting, double-error-detecting (SECDED) ECC memory wrappers, we hold the task, data, and correctness oracle fixed and vary two axes independently: the training regime (seven settings) and the output representation (four levels, from fully expanded flat Verilog to an eight-field configuration expanded by a deterministic generator). Because a reference generator exists, correctness is decided by formal equivalence over a design space of approximately ten million points, rather than sampled from a hand-written testbench. Two results follow. First, representation dominates: every representation close to raw RTL reaches a pass rate of at most 0.17, while the configuration reaches 0.83 with no training at all. Once the model emits the configuration, every training regime achieves a pass rate between 0.89 and 1.00. Second, raw RTL hits a hard output-length limit: a 512-bit design requires 44,237 tokens of flat Verilog compared with just 69 tokens for the configuration. Consequently, raw generation becomes infeasible above 32-bit data words rather than merely inaccurate. A model trained from scratch with fewer than 50 million parameters, combined with the verified generator, achieves 0.89 formal equivalence, compared with 1.00 for a 32-billion-parameter fine-tuned model, while using approximately 1600 times less inference energy per correct design. Inference energy also dominates amortized training energy. The lesson is to learn the interface, not the implementation.

Comment
6 pages, 3 figures. Accepted for presentation at VLSID 2027

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

NoTB: Oracle-Free Triage of LLM-Generated RTL via Cross-Model Formal Consensus

cs.AR cs.AI ·2026-08-22 ·Elisavet Lydia Alvanaki, Je Yang, Biruk Seyoum, Luca P. Carloni
similarity 0.72
Abstract · MLCAD 2026

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used to generate register-transfer-level (RTL) designs from natural-language specifications. However, assessing functional correctness at early stages remains a fundamental challenge. Existing oracle-free approaches rely either on simulation-based agreement, which depends on LLM-generated testbenches that can fail or vary across models, or on LLM-as-a-judge heuristics, which produce inconsistent predictions. We introduce NoTB, an oracle-free triage framework that infers correctness from cross-model formal consensus. NoTB generates RTL implementations from multiple independently trained LLM families and applies Sequential Equivalence Checking (SEC) to identify designs that are provably equivalent. We show that the diversity of model families within an SEC-equivalent cluster induces a calibrated correctness signal, enabling risk-coverage tradeoffs without requiring testbenches. On 78 CVDP RTL-generation tasks, four-family formal consensus achieves 94.7% precision at 27% coverage; three-family consensus achieves 87% precision at 33% coverage. These operating points give designers a tunable accept/defer rule before a trusted testbench or golden RTL is available. Overall, NoTB demonstrates that formal cross-model agreement provides a reliable basis for high-confidence triage without model-dependent oracles

0.30

AutoC2V: Synthesis-Guided LLM Training for QoR-Optimized C++-to-Verilog Generation

cs.AR cs.LG ·2026-11-07 ·Guanqi Lyu, Fei Zhao, Zhaojun Lu, Jiaji He, Yongqiang Lyu
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 14 pages, 7 figures, 4 tables

High-level synthesis (HLS) can translate C/C++ kernels into register-transfer level (RTL) designs, yet generating high-quality hardware still relies heavily on manual pragma tuning and repeated synthesis evaluation. We propose AutoC2V, a C++-to-Verilog generation framework driven by real synthesis feedback that enables large language models (LLMs) to directly generate RTL with improved quality of results (QoR) from synthesizable C++ kernels. We construct training data from real synthesis results, including synthesizable C++ source code, the corresponding Verilog RTL, QoR metrics, and optimization objectives. Using this dataset, we align the model toward synthesis-aware RTL generation through Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) and Group Relative Policy Optimization (GRPO). To reduce the high cost of repeatedly invoking real synthesis during GRPO, we design the QoR Prediction Reward Model (QoR RM), which predicts latency and resource metrics by encoding RTL into long-context semantic representations, thereby providing low-cost and continuous QoR reward signals for policy optimization. Experimental results demonstrate that AutoC2V not only substantially improves RTL functional pass rates, but also achieves superior latency and resource optimization compared to the unfine-tuned base model, representative HLS optimization approaches (HLSPilot, LLM-DSE, and AutoDSE), and advanced general-purpose commercial models (Claude Opus 4.8, GPT-5.5, Gemini 3.1 Pro, DeepSeek v4 Pro, and GLM-5.2). These results indicate that combining real synthesis data with efficient QoR reward modeling can further improve the ability of LLMs to generate high-quality RTL.

0.24

SpecLens: LLM-Based Verilog Generation with Specification-Derived Constraints via Behavioral Divergence

cs.AR ·2026-09-15 ·Wen Bing, Bing Li
publishedbenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.66
Abstract · Accepted at the 32nd Asia and South Pacific Design Automation Conference (ASP-DAC 2027)

Large language models (LLMs) have recently shown promise in Verilog generation, but producing functionally correct RTL directly from natural-language specifications remains a highly challenging task. Existing approaches improve LLM-based Verilog generation mainly with retrieval-augmented generation (RAG), self-planning, or few-shot prompting. However, these methods focus primarily on external or generic forms of enhancement rather than strengthening the specification with task-specific constraints. In this work, we propose SpecLens, an automated framework for LLM-based Verilog generation that derives specification-driven constraints by analyzing behavioral divergence among multiple candidate implementations, using the original specification as the only external semantic source during generation. On the VerilogEval v2.0 spec-to-RTL benchmark, SpecLens achieves a functional pass@1 ratio of 86.2\% with o3-mini-medium and 89.4\% with o3-mini-high. This corresponds to a 3.6 percentage-point gain over the SOTA prompting method with o3-mini-medium and a 3.8 percentage-point gain over the SOTA behavioral divergence method with o3-mini-high. In addition, on RTLLM v1.1 and v2.0, analysis shows that SpecLens is more specification-faithful and less prone to benchmark-aligned priors. SpecLens achieves 100\% syntactic correctness on VerilogEval v2.0, 86.2\% on RTLLM v1.1, and 88\% on RTLLM v2.0, even without using costly compile-repair loops to revise generated code iteratively. The code is open source and available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/SpecLens-4632/readme.md.

0.31

BUSTA: Teaching Small Language Models to Reason About Binary Execution

cs.CR cs.AIcs.LGcs.PL ·2026-10-26 ·Ritika Poddar, Aidan Fennelly, Deirdre Murphy, Eric Wolos, Corre L. Steele +1 more
dataset similarity 0.65
Abstract

Large Language Models (LLM) are increasingly applied to Reverse Engineering (RE) workflows. RE, however, differs from common LLM coding tasks as it requires models to reason about low-level program behavior. Furthermore, the deployment of tooling in resource-constrained sandboxed RE environments limits the ability to use frontier-scale solutions. We examine whether a targeted LLM training approach can transfer distinct RE skills to open models via inverse basic-block execution: given an x86-64 basic block and a desired output register state, the model predicts the input register values that produce it. Fine-tuning \texttt{Qwen3-1.7B} and \texttt{Nemotron-3-Nano} with Group Relative Policy Optimization (GRPO) raises knowable-register prediction accuracy from 73.2\% to 85.3\% and from 63.3\% to 95.2\%, respectively. Frontier models still score highest (up to 99.2\%), but our fine-tuned \texttt{Nemotron-3-Nano} comes within four points at a fraction of the parameter count. We release both fine-tuned models and the training dataset.

0.15

GRADE-RTL: Evaluating LLM-Generated RTL Beyond Compilation

cs.AR cs.PL ·2026-09-21 ·Hepziba Susan, Shivaranjani G. R., Malik Imran, Muhammad Rashid, Sumathi Gokulanathan +1 more
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) can generate register-transfer-level (RTL) code from natural-language specifications, but compilation alone does not establish structural completeness, functional correctness, or implementation efficiency. This paper presents a framework for evaluating LLM-generated RTL beyond compilation, which we named GRADE-RTL. Using fixed prompts and validation settings, GRADE-RTL applies five checks, such as Port Signature, Compilation, Elaboration, Module Completeness, and Functional Equivalence against trusted reference RTL. With the help of compact metrics, we identify where candidates fail and distinguish end-to-end success from eligibility for downstream synthesis. We evaluate nine general-purpose and RTL-specialized LLMs on ten edge-relevant intellectual property designs under a budget of three generation attempts with failure-directed feedback. End-to-end success ranges from 0% to 70% across the evaluated models, with failures extending beyond compilation to hierarchy resolution, incomplete logic, and behavioral mismatch. FPGA implementation and 65 nm ASIC synthesis results further show that functionally equivalent RTL can differ substantially in resource use, timing, area, and power. A PID-controller place-and-route case study illustrates the physical-design consequences of different RTL implementations. GRADE-RTL provides a practical basis for comparing LLM-generated hardware descriptions by separating structural validity, behavioral correctness, and implementation quality.

0.44

ChipMEM: Verification-Grounded Memory for EDA Agents

cs.LG cs.CL ·2026-09-22 ·Abdulrahman AlRabah, Joshua Mabry, Dilek Hakkani-Tür, Abdussalam Alawini, Hamid Shojaei +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.64
Abstract

Large language model (LLM)-based agents use Electronic Design Automation (EDA) tools to generate and revise register-transfer-level (RTL) designs under synthesis and verification feedback. Recent methods learn from this feedback by distilling reusable skills from execution traces or by training on rewards derived from EDA-tools. Both methods are typically evaluated on the tasks that produced the experience. Repeated access to benchmark feedback on the same task can reward task-specific revision rather than creating reusable knowledge that transfers. We introduce ChipMEM, a verification-grounded memory layer for EDA agents. It combines cross-task procedural memory with within-trajectory statistical guidance. Its procedural component distills and stores a skill only after it passes synthesis, simulation, or formal checks, rather than relying on model self-assessments. A Bayesian component maintains hierarchical Beta estimates over tool-call outcomes and ranks recovery strategies that succeeded under comparable errors. A common adapter applies the same memory interface to RTL optimization and testbench-generation agents while preserving each domain's tools and acceptance criteria. We measure performance on training tasks and evaluate whether learned skills transfer to unseen tasks. On RTLRewriter-Bench, under matched model and tool settings, ChipMEM produces equivalence-passing outputs on 39/54 scored designs versus 35/54 without memory; on the 49-design short suite, mean area improvement is 8.69% versus 5.66%. On held-out CVDP tasks, ChipMEM with a frozen procedural library achieves 20/20 accepted outcomes versus 18/20 without memory in a single evaluation per setting.

0.21

CorrectRTL: Boost RTL Generation Quality Through Automated Self-Correction with Instruction Decomposition

cs.AI ·2026-10-18 ·Jing Wang, Shang Liu, Hangan Zhou, Wenji Fang, Yuchao Wu +2 more
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.64
Abstract · This paper is accepted by ICCAD'26

Large language models (LLMs) have shown strong promise in specification-to-RTL generation. Among the explorations, the self-correction paradigm has significantly advanced LLM-based RTL generation. However, two challenges limit further progress. Existing benchmarks are saturated by advanced LLMs, leaving little room to evaluate the agentic self-correction framework. The monolithic self-correction paradigm rewrites the entire design at once, where LLMs are susceptible to error confusion and corruption of originally correct code. To address the benchmark challenge, we contribute ScaleBench, a more challenging benchmark of 200 complex RTL designs. To address the challenge in methodology, we propose CorrectRTL, an agentic framework that realizes a new decompose-then-correct paradigm, in which the LLM agent explicitly decouples scaffold construction from detailed implementation. CorrectRTL contributes three core techniques: (1)~\emph{Structure-oriented decomposition}, (2)~\emph{Snippet-based RAG}, and (3)~\emph{SVA-based self-correction}. On ScaleBench, CorrectRTL improves Pass@1 from 20.5% to 49.0% (+28.5%). On VerilogEval, CorrectRTL achieves up to 96.1% Pass@1, demonstrating consistent improvements across both simple and complex designs.

0.44

Inject a Turn, Not a Token: Learning Where to Redirect LLM Reasoning for Self-Correction

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-10-09 ·Jiwon Jeon, Myungsik Cho, Jeonghye Kim, Youngchul Sung
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Large language models struggle to reliably identify and correct errors in their own reasoning. Unlike prior training-based approaches that fine-tune an LLM to generate revisions or feedback, we learn where to intervene in failed rollouts and determine how to redirect them. To choose where to intervene, we train a 130K-parameter MLP head on a frozen encoder using only final-answer correctness. For redirection, we find that under a fixed generation budget, the tested inline injections fail to reliably redirect reasoning, whereas presenting the same instruction in a new user turn changes the model's course. The resulting correction framework, UPTURN (User-Prompt TURN injection at a learned position), requires no LLM fine-tuning: it retains a selected prefix, injects an instruction as a new user turn, and regenerates the suffix. Across four reasoners and six math benchmarks, UPTURN improves average accuracy in every setting over a 32-rollout baseline. It outperforms self-correction and reflection-token injection baselines under matched correction budgets, transfers across reasoners and to GPQA-Diamond without retraining, and complements GRPO and self-correction methods.

0.18