CS Paper Radar

Self-Consistency of Entity Sets and Citations in a Deep Research System under Repeated Prompting

Lauri Pykälä, Kimmo K. Kaski

cs.CL ·submitted 2026-10-19 13:50 UTC · v1

Abstract

Deep research agents (DRA) are commonly used for open-ended synthesis tasks where closed-world QA benchmarks are poorly suited to characterize relevant aspects of performance. We study the self-consistency of one commercial deep research system under repeated identical prompting, representing each report with the set of named entities it mentions, categorised by a custom schema, and the set of citations it retrieves. Across repeated runs of a single open-ended cybersecurity related prompt, we quantify pairwise overlap to characterize how stable the retrieved and synthesized output structure is under repeated identical prompts. In ten runs, the pairwise entity Jaccard results in a median of 0.12 and the pairwise citation Jaccard is below 0.02, with discovery curves that do not visibly saturate. The magnitude and structure of (dis)agreement between entity sets varies by entity class, which suggests that self-consistency in a DRA is better understood as a function of the underlying entity space than as a stable property of the system.

Comment
6 pages, 3 figures

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Who is the Agent to Blame? Localizing Faithfulness and Citation Mistakes in Agentic Deep Research

cs.CL ·2026-08-25 ·Eran Hirsch, David Wan, Han Wang, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Mohit Bansal +1 more
top venuecode/data similarity 0.71
Abstract · Accepted to EMNLP 2026 (Main Conference). Code: https://github.com/eranhirs/who-is-the-agent-to-blame

Deep research (DR) systems produce long-form cited reports by orchestrating multiple agents that search and synthesize information from the web. Citations are the primary mechanism for evaluating the faithfulness of these reports, yet current DR systems exhibit poor citation recall. Moreover, improving citation recall is challenging because DR systems are complex multi-agent architectures where information passes through agents like a telephone game, and both content and citations can get corrupted along the way. We propose an evaluation method that pinpoints which agent introduced each error by locally testing agent invocations for faithfulness and verifiability relative to their own inputs. Furthermore, we propose a four-type taxonomy to categorize the discovered errors: hallucination, uncited input reliance, uncited output, or insufficient citations. Applying our method to three top-ranked open-source DR systems, we obtain actionable diagnostics. Almost every agent makes a lot of mistakes with the exception being those that summarize a single document. We find that the dominant error type varies systematically across agents, where the orchestrator mistakes are mostly citation-related. We find that 84.7% of final-report errors in AI-Q originate at the orchestrator, roughly 31% of them hallucinations and the rest citation mistakes. Guided by these insights, we demonstrate that two simple interventions raise citation recall by 5% without degrading output quality.

0.64

Ingest-Time Fact Compilation for Cost-Efficient and Reliable Question Answering over Revised Corpora

cs.AI cs.DBcs.IR ·2026-08-29 ·Kyle Wild, Yusuke Takahashi, Asako Uraki
publishedcode/data similarity 0.65
Abstract · 6 pages, 5 tables, 1 figure. Accepted for presentation at the 2026 International Conference on Applied Science and Technology - Engineering …

Most agentic question answering (QA) systems do an important part of their semantic work at the worst possible time: every time someone asks a question. When a corpus contains revisions, drafts, revocations, deletions, and sources with different levels of authority, the model must reconstruct the governed current state on every read - then throw that work away and repeat it on the next query. This is a bit like a database that rebuilds a materialized view every time someone reads from it. We present ingest-time fact compilation, an architecture that performs this work when corpus data is ingested or changed. Raw passages are rephrased into self-contained facts; rules governing revisions, deletions, effective dates, and source trust are resolved once; and the resulting state is stored as typed records carrying source and revision provenance. At query time, an inexpensive model reads the compiled record instead of reconstructing it from noisy candidates. In a controlled synthetic experiment across five seeds, the same low-cost model produced the correct value, source, and revision in only one of 30 trials under query-time reconstruction, but in all 30 trials from the compiled substrate, at 12.89 times lower mean read cost per question. On simpler revision questions both architectures were exact, but the compiled path used 21.6 times fewer tokens. A separate test found that fact rephrasing roughly halved verbose Federal Reserve dialogue while preserving high source entailment, but left concise Wikipedia prose essentially unchanged. These results support a narrow but practical claim: resolving a corpus state once can make subsequent QA cheaper and more reliable for inexpensive models. We release the open source, MIT-licensed implementation and experimental artifacts.

0.40

Optimist Deep Research: An Iterative, State-Centric Agent for Autonomous Literature Research

cs.AI ·2026-10-16 ·Gihan Panapitiya
code/data similarity 0.64
Abstract

Most retrieval-augmented systems treat literature search as a single retrieval step followed by summarization. Real literature research works differently: the investigator's understanding of the question changes as they read, new subquestions appear, and evidence is weighed, not just collected. We present Optimist Deep Research, an open-source agent that runs literature research as an iterative evidence-acquisition process over an explicit, mutable research state. A research question is broken into a tree of subquestions, each served by search intents that are translated into source-specific queries over arXiv, OpenAlex, Crossref, PubMed, Semantic Scholar and the web. Results are merged into a canonical, provenance-preserving document registry through a conservative four-tier deduplication hierarchy. The registry is expanded by citation snowballing until a saturation criterion is met, and then screened, ranked and allocated to subquestions round-robin. Documents are read in parallel into a structured evidence store of claims with support, location, type and strength. A critic reviews the state along eight dimensions and returns research actions rather than a binary verdict: it can add, split, rephrase, deprioritize or close subquestions, so the research plan is an output of the investigation as well as an input. The final report is written section by section from the evidence store, and every citation resolves to a retrieved document. We describe the design, the deterministic machinery that keeps a language-model pipeline auditable, and a case study that read 28 of 237 retrieved documents in about three and a half minutes. We also report weaknesses the case study exposed.

0.21

ArcticSwarm: Deferring Early Consensus in Long-Horizon Multi-Agent Research

cs.MA ·2026-09-01 ·Soyoung Yoon, Boyi Liu, Yite Wang, Ruofan Wu, Canwen Xu +4 more
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Multi-agent systems have shown strong performance in domains with reliable verifiers such as coding, where multi-parallel candidate generation selected by a verifier is effective. However, such pipelines would not generalize to open-ended, long-horizon research tasks without a verifier. While majority voting or self-consistency is often used to reach consensus as a proxy verifier, parallel agents repeatedly explore the same evidence, while access to peers' partial findings cause search to converge on an early candidate before alternatives are tested. We present ArcticSwarm, a multi-agent research architecture that separates evidence gathering from evidence integration. Subagents publish findings to a shared bulletin board, while gated isolation lets selected search tasks maintain their own prior, preventing early consensus. Structured review at three commitment boundaries enforce only confident candidates to be propagated. As a result, ArcticSwarm reaches 82.6% on the full BrowseComp-Plus set with the open-weight Qwen 3.5-27B model, compared with 78.8% without gated isolation and 74.5% additionally with structured review disabled, outperforming aligned baseline MiroFlow runs (70.6%). Extending to live-web BrowseComp, ArcticSwarm reaches 73.6% with GPT-5, which is well above the reported provider system (54.9%) and MiroFlow (63.4%). Overall, the results show that restricting peer reads during evidence gathering and strengthening commitment boundaries before a hypothesis is shared can broaden search and improve long-horizon multi-agent deep research.

0.26

Security of Deep Research Agents: Attack Surface, Defenses, Benchmarks, and Agenda Seeding against Research Planning

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-11-15 ·Yang Luo, Guangpu Chen, Yichen Liu, Zhaoyu Chen, Yifeng Gao +3 more
survey similarity 0.64
Abstract · 31 pages, 5 figures

Deep research and agentic search agents autonomously retrieve content from the open web and generate reports with citations, and their outputs are often taken directly as research conclusions. This paper systematizes security research in this area along four stages, namely retrieval, planning, evidence integration, and report generation. We present a unified threat model, a taxonomy of attacks and defenses, and a review of evaluation benchmarks, and we align the area dimension by dimension with retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) poisoning, prompt injection, and generative engine optimization (GEO). Coding 34 primary studies shows that only 26.5% of them involve the planning stage, and none performs an end-to-end poisoning evaluation on commercial products. To address this gap, we propose the agenda seeding attack, in which the attacker writes no instructions and only introduces a fictitious evaluation metric. Across 3,520 sandboxed research runs under the same budget, GEO and prompt injection are nearly ineffective, whereas agenda seeding makes the attacker's target the top pick in 16% to 28% of reports. Injection detection and query anchoring fail against it, verification prompting hurts utility, and our proposed provenance tagging preserves utility but can be bypassed by multi-site bait. Finally, we propose eight research directions.

0.16

JevGPT: Thinking Fast and Slow in Autonomous Research

cs.CL cs.AIcs.IR ·2026-10-13 ·Yasheng Sun, Yanning Dai, Yimeng Chen, Nanbo Li, Firas Laakom +7 more
code/datacommunity pick similarity 0.64
Abstract · 26 pages, 6 figures, 8 tables. Added CMASS experiments. Project page: https://sunyasheng.github.io/projects/JevGPT

Autonomous research agents must acquire and reason over evidence within a limited budget. Yet relevant sources can remain uninspected or unused, leaving a gap between retrieval coverage and the evidence that informs research. The challenge is to align fast local judgments with changing evidence needs and feed their findings back into research decisions. We introduce JevGPT, a dual-system architecture for autonomous research that couples fast evidence processing with deliberative research planning. System Two sets evidence objectives and integrates findings, while System One locates support, assesses relevance, and guides further inspection. Independent source judgments run in parallel; selected original passages inform the next research step. Experiments on fixed-corpus question answering and document ranking show that JevGPT achieves leading task performance, with faster completion and lower cost than comparably effective research agents. Evidence analysis shows broader source inspection and greater coverage of supporting documents in the research loop, highlighting efficient evidence processing as a route to more capable autonomous research.

0.46

AgentHop: A Diagnostic Benchmark for Agentic Multi-Hop Question Answering over Scientific Citation Graphs

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-09-28 ·Chanhee Park, Jeongho Yoon, Sungbin Han, Hyeonseok Moon, Heuiseok Lim
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract · Accepted to NeurIPS 2026 Evaluations and Datasets Track

Agentic tasks require a large language model to interact with the world, navigating information and gathering evidence across multiple steps with restricted resources. Due to this complexity, agentic task failures arise from various sources, and pinpointing these failure causes is essential to diagnose and improve agentic systems. Existing benchmarks, however, tend to focus on a single leaderboard score, leaving the underlying failure modes opaque. To fill this gap, we introduce AgentHop, a diagnostic benchmark of 1,011 multiple-choice questions paired with a controlled seven-tool sandbox under fixed token, turn, and tool-call constraints. AgentHop reveals model vulnerabilities by dissecting a single accuracy score along four axes of agent operation: retrieval, synthesis, tool-call, and resource management. Across 19 models, we find that behavior clusters by model family, with tool-call signatures revealing distinct family fingerprints: GPT models commit early, Anthropic and GLM checkpoints verify before committing, DeepSeek and Kimi over-search, and Gemini-3 Pro stays balanced. Decomposed axes further expose within-family structure: Claude Opus 4.6 and Sonnet 4.6 land within one accuracy point yet diverge on retrieval-versus-synthesis emphasis, with Opus retrieving more and Sonnet synthesizing better. We release the full benchmark set and the harness to support diagnostic agent benchmarking.

0.36

AutoKD: Autonomous Knowledge Discovery

cs.AI ·2026-09-06 ·Qinwen Ge, Bo Ni, Haowei Fu, Ngoc N. Tran, Erik Blasch +1 more
code/data similarity 0.63
Abstract

Scientific discovery in data-rich domains is currently constrained by human bandwidth: the growth in the volume and complexity of real-world data far outpaces the rate at which researchers can read, reason, and synthesize. Recent LLM-based multi-agent systems have begun to automate portions of the research cycle, but they target hypothesis generation in settings where validation cannot itself be automated, and each run is one-shot, with no mechanism for findings to accumulate or steer subsequent inquiry. This paper introduces AutoKD, a multi-agent framework for autonomous knowledge discovery that is both computational and cumulative, allowing validated findings to persist and inform subsequent inquiry. Six coordinated LLM agents collaborate in an open-ended discovery loop, where accepted findings are stored in a persistent insight graph that serves as both long-term memory and an exploration-steering mechanism. We evaluate AutoKD on three diverse datasets from two perspectives: Open-ended Quality against published findings, and Conditioned Quality via literature-derived queries. Across both evaluation perspectives, AutoKD covers known findings and surfaces substantive discoveries that complement human-driven research. Our code is available at https://github.com/GeQinwen/AutoKD.

0.30