CS Paper Radar

Beyond Behavioral Accuracy: Evaluating Individual-Level Fidelity in LLM Investor Simulation

Jiajie He, Yuanhong Jiang, Xintong Chen, Dongling Ni, Wenjin Liu

cs.AI cs.HCcs.IR ·submitted 2026-10-19 14:54 UTC · v2

Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used as user simulators, but can they faithfully reproduce an individual's behavior and decision logic over time? We investigate this question in a longitudinal paper-trading study with 80 participants. Using rolling next-day predictions, we evaluate trading activity, buy-sell structure, asset selection, and portfolio outcomes, complemented by controlled input ablations and participant-rated explanation alignment. No evaluated LLM reliably outperforms a simple recent-activity persistence baseline for predicting trade occurrence, while buy-sell structure and asset selection remain difficult to reproduce. Similar activity-level performance can also yield substantially different portfolio trajectories. Ablations show that activity predictions depend primarily on recent trades, whereas asset choices are sensitive to multiple evidence sources. Participants rate explanations as more aligned with their recurring strategies than with their decision-specific rationales. These findings reveal a gap between coarse behavioral agreement and individual-level fidelity, motivating separate evaluation of behavioral accuracy, explanation alignment, and evidence dependence in personalized user simulation.

Comment
This paper is under review in ARR

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Are LLMs Good Financial User Simulators? Multi-view Investor Logic Alignment (MILA)

cs.AI cs.CYcs.HC ·2026-09-14 ·Jiajie He, Jiangyuan Hong, Xintong Chen, Dongling Ni, Wenjin Liu
similarity 0.89
Abstract · The complete version will be open and the paper is under review in AAAI

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used as user simulators, yet it remains unclear whether their predictions faithfully reproduce the evolving decisions of individual users. We investigate this question in a controlled longitudinal paper-trading study with 80 participants, where user interactions, simulated transactions, virtual portfolio states, and point-in-time market information are aligned under a rolling next-day prediction protocol. We evaluate behavioral fidelity hierarchically, from trade occurrence to action structure, asset selection, and downstream portfolio consequences. Across 1,239 aligned user-days, no evaluated LLM reliably outperforms a simple recent-activity persistence baseline for predicting whether a user trades. Fidelity further deteriorates at finer levels: models struggle to recover buy--sell structure and traded assets, and similar activity-level predictions can lead to substantially different portfolio trajectories. Controlled evidence ablations show that recent trading history strongly governs activity prediction, whereas asset selection is substantially more sensitive to the available evidence. An observational analysis further finds that intensified ticker-specific research predicts imminent trading, but diagnostic tests do not support a causal interpretation. These findings suggest that current LLMs capture useful short-term behavioral regularities without yet recovering a stable individual decision mechanism.

0.36

EvolveTrade: Experience-Driven Policy Refinement for Self-Evolving LLM Trading Agents

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-09-15 ·Sehee Kim, Yumin Choi, Minki Kang, Sung Ju Hwang
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Large language model (LLM) trading agents can combine market data, news, and executable analysis, but their behavior is often controlled by static hand-written tool-use policies that are fixed before deployment. This limits their ability to adapt how they gather evidence, invoke tools, verify signals, and manage risk under changing market regimes. We introduce EvolveTrade, a self-evolving framework that treats the system prompt of a tool-using trading agent as a text-parameterized policy. After each update interval, a Policy Agent revises this policy using accumulated decision traces and realized portfolio feedback, while keeping the backbone LLM fixed. The updated policy is then used for the next batch of trading decisions, enabling the agent to refine its information-acquisition and portfolio-construction procedure over time. Experiments across multiple market regimes and two LLM backbones show that EvolveTrade often improves Sharpe Ratio and Cumulative Return over fixed-policy LLM baselines, achieving the improved SR and CR in most evaluated settings. Behavioral analyses further show that self-evolved policies increase code-mediated analysis and activate regime-relevant computations; case-level policy-to-return attributions trace how policy-induced allocation changes contribute to realized return differences. These results suggest that adapting the reusable procedure governing tool use is a key direction for building more robust LLM trading agents.

0.28

The Price of Thought: Does Test-Time Reasoning Pay in LLM Trading?

cs.AI ·2026-09-25 ·Jiayi Chen, Guiling Wang
similarity 0.66
Abstract

While inference-time reasoning in large language models (LLMs) promises better decision making, its higher computational cost may not yield better economic outcomes. Yet reasoning controls are rarely evaluated as economic interventions, where changes in model outputs must translate into better portfolios after trading costs. We conduct a controlled study of representative LLMs from the DeepSeek, GPT, and Gemini families. We vary reasoning effort while holding information available at each formation date, prompts, output formats, and portfolio construction fixed. Our evaluation covers a full year of U.S. equities under three input conditions: numerical, identifiable news, and masked news. It includes more than 800,000 asset predictions and repeated model generations. Across all three model families, additional reasoning does not produce a reliable improvement in net portfolio returns. For DeepSeek, where we examine the full progression from no reasoning to maximum reasoning, performance is nonmonotonic. Repeated generations also produce unstable treatment effects and portfolio selections, even when overall scores remain similar. These findings show that additional reasoning can change financial decisions without reliably improving their economic value, motivating validation for each task before deployment.

0.18

RetailAgent: Structured Adverse Timing in Self-Conditioned Multimodal LLM Trading Agents

cs.AI q-fin.TR ·2026-08-28 ·Yupeng Zhang, Liuyuan Jiang, Hongyi Huang, Bingheng Li, Lisha Chen
similarity 0.64
Abstract

In financial markets, a sequential policy that reacts systematically to price movements may become predictable to other market participants. This paper studies whether large language model (LLM) agents exhibit such directional structure through RetailAgent, an experimental framework in which an LLM observes anonymized intraday equity price histories and permitted state, then repeatedly chooses long (hold the stock) or flat (stay out) before the subsequent interval return is revealed. We compare returns during long and flat intervals along the same stock's intraday path after removing the overall fraction of long decisions. This exposure-matched measure reveals persistent negative timing across modality, horizon, state, and model family. Shuffling saved action sequences substantially attenuates the effect, showing that alignment between actions and subsequent returns drives the negative score. Feeding self-authored memories into decisions further increases policy persistence, while timing becomes more negative among stock-days on which the agent uses both actions. These results reveal stable, recoverable directional structure in sequential LLM financial decisions and a behavioral signal for studying how another participant could respond to a predictable policy.

0.34

The Analyst in the Prompt: Role, Retrieval, and Memory Biases in LLM Financial Analysis

cs.CL cs.CEq-fin.PM ·2026-09-02 ·Ahmed Asaad, Amr Mohamed, Yang Zhang, Omneya Abdelsalam
top venue similarity 0.63
Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) increasingly use user context such as memory, profiles, and role prompts to personalize their responses. This personalization can affect evidence-based judgment: the same evidence may lead to different conclusions under different user contexts. Finance provides a high-stakes setting to study this problem because decisions often depend on interpreting long and complex documents. We test this using 3,575 SEC filings across twelve LLMs. We compare persona-conditioned retrieval, neutral retrieval, and memory-framed context to separate the effect of evidence selection from the effect of interpretation. We find that most user-context spillover comes from how models interpret the same evidence under different roles, rather than from retrieving different evidence. We then test two simple mitigation strategies: expressing the same investor mindset as a user profile instead of an assistant role, and separating evidence-based and personalized outputs. Both reduce spillover, but neither removes it completely, and their effectiveness varies substantially across models.

0.58

Beyond Profit Rankings: Identifying, Understanding, and Evaluating Smart Money in Prediction Markets

cs.CE ·2026-10-26 ·Huaiyu Jia, Shuo Sun
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Prediction markets have emerged as an important mechanism for aggregating information and trading beliefs about future events. The transparency of on-chain transactions has enabled investors to identify historically profitable wallets, commonly referred to as smart money, and replicate their trading activities through copy trading. However, despite the growing popularity of smart-money tracking, systematic research on these wallets' trading behavior, profitability persistence, and the economic feasibility of following their trades remains limited. To address this gap, we conduct a comprehensive empirical study of Polymarket, the most popular decentralized prediction market, by reconstructing wallet-level trading activities from on-chain transactions, position changes, market histories, and settlement outcomes. We first examine the distribution and persistence of historical profitability using statistical analysis and logistic regression, and further characterize heterogeneous trading strategies through multidimensional behavioral profiling and unsupervised clustering. Building on these findings, we develop an evidence-grounded multi-agent research framework that integrates wallet behavior, market conditions, and real-world information to generate interpretable and verifiable explanations of individual trades. Finally, we implement a real-time copy-trading system and evaluate its practical feasibility through order-book-aware paper trading and live on-chain execution. Our findings reveal substantial behavioral heterogeneity among historically profitable wallets and highlight the challenges of translating observed trading performance into replicable economic returns.

0.29

Foresee to Trade: Forecast-Augmented Policy Optimization for Portfolio Management

cs.LG ·2026-11-05 ·Zeyu Liu, Xuanzhi Feng, Haoran Xu, Lai Sing Kwong, Yang Li +5 more
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Online investment services must translate asset opportunities into investment outcomes for users' accounts, yet the same market opportunity can warrant different account actions. We study how supervision from future asset opportunities can strengthen account-level trading decisions and propose Forecast-Augmented Relative Policy Optimization (FRPO). FRPO separately supervises asset opportunities and account decisions through a jointly learned representation: a Financial State Head (FSH) learns future relative-return targets to provide asset-level opportunity supervision, while Same-Path Group-Relative Optimization compares trading trajectories under the same market path and initial account to provide account-level relative-outcome supervision. An Adaptive Gate coordinates auxiliary supervision using predictive variance and gradient alignment. FSH is used only during training; inference uses the encoder and policy for trading. Across DJIA30, TOPIX Core30, and three investment-style portfolios, ten-seed evaluations show that FRPO achieves the highest mean cumulative and annualized returns among the compared methods in all five settings. These results support strengthening investment agents' trading decisions through joint supervision from asset opportunities and trading outcomes.

0.22

When News Gets Old: Portfolio Allocation with Reinforcement Learning and Large Language Models

cs.LG q-fin.PM ·2026-10-22 ·Bolin Song, Surui Xiang
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Financial news can influence investment decisions long after publication. Timely news may reach an investor before prices fully adjust, whereas older news may already be reflected in prices. We examine two ways to handle aging signals: retain them and give a portfolio policy timing information, or filter them out before portfolio selection. A fixed large language model (LLM) extracts signals from public SEC disclosures. We compare these treatments in reinforcement learning (RL) policies and LLMs that choose portfolios directly. We evaluate returns after trading costs in historical tests over 2023-2025. RL choices respond to timing information in a controlled test, but historical returns show no consistent benefit from adding it. For the LLM, filtering old news produced the highest average net return, reaching 18.43% per year when news delivery was delayed by four weeks. This exceeded the returns of all RL strategies that used news.

0.24