CS Paper Radar

Controllability of polynomial systems is undecidable and not recursively enumerable

Jun Liu, Ivan O. Shevchenko

cs.CC math.OCeess.SY ·submitted 2026-10-19 17:56 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

Sontag conjectured in 1988 that global controllability of polynomial control systems with rational coefficients is undecidable, but that the controllable systems form a recursively enumerable set. We prove the first part of the conjecture and disprove the second. For every homogeneous polynomial vector field $F$ of odd degree with rational coefficients, we construct an explicit polynomial control system $Σ_F$, with one more state than $F$, that is globally controllable if and only if the origin is \emph{not} globally asymptotically stable for $\dot x=F(x)$. By a recent result, the homogeneous polynomial vector fields with a globally asymptotically stable origin form a set that is recursively enumerable but not decidable. Consequently, global controllability of polynomial systems is undecidable, and the controllable polynomial systems are not recursively enumerable. The same conclusions hold for systems of the form $\dotξ=f(ξ)+Bu$ with a polynomial drift and a constant input matrix.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Discrete-time polynomial systems with inputs and outputs: structure, reachability, observability, and minimal realizations

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-09-29 ·Eduardo D. Sontag
similarity 0.64
Abstract

We study the realization problem for discrete-time input/output polynomial systems. These are formalized using tools from commutative algebra and algebraic geometry as systems whose state spaces are algebraic varieties, or more abstractly the set of k-points of an affine k-scheme, where k is an arbitrary infinite field. The input/output behaviors of such systems are described by "polynomial response maps" in which outputs are polynomial functions of past inputs. The main results show that every polynomial response map admits a canonical (quasi-reachable and algebraically observable) realization, which is unique up to isomorphism. The key to the approach is to linearize dynamics by considering a "dual" system in which states are functions defined on states. Finite dimensionality of the canonical realization, and its polynomiality, are characterized in terms of the space, algebra, and field of observables of the map, as well as in terms of algebraic input/output difference equations, and by a Jacobian rank criterion. A particular subclass consists of the maps that we call "bounded," defined by the property that their degree in the past inputs is uniformly bounded. Bounded maps are shown to be finitely realizable if and only if they are realizable by finite-dimensional state-affine systems, whose theory in turn reduces to that of rational formal power series. We also study the lattice of quasi-reachable realizations of a given map, including normal realizations. This work is an update of the PhD thesis written by the author in 1976; connections to recent work are briefly discussed in the last section.

0.38

The existence of polyhedral invariants is undecidable for linear systems

cs.LO ·2026-09-25 ·David Monniaux
similarity 0.60
Abstract

The existence of polyhedral inductive invariants suitable for proving that a given control location is unreachable is undecidable for programs using only linear arithmetic over Z or Q, by reduction from 2-counter machines.

0.30

New bounds for the support of input-output equations in differential-algebraic systems

cs.SC math.AG ·2026-09-03 ·Gabriela Jeronimo, Leonardo Lanciano
theory similarity 0.58
Abstract · 26 pages

Given a polynomial dynamical system $\mathbf{x}'=\mathbf{f}(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{u})$ together with an observation function $y=g(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{u})$, where $\mathbf{x}=(x_1,\ldots,x_n)$, $\mathbf{u}=(u_1,\ldots,u_m)$ and $y$ are differential variables, and $\mathbf{f}=(f_1,\ldots,f_n)$, $g$ are polynomials with coefficients in a differential field, we study the problem of determining a minimal polynomial differential equation satisfied by the inputs $\mathbf{u}$ and the output $y$ which follows as a differential consequence of the system. We provide a characterization of a finite superset of the set of monomials appearing with non-zero coefficients in this input-output equation. Specifically, we establish an upper bound for the degree of the minimal polynomial and a family of inequalities that define a polytope containing its Newton polytope. These results extend recent work by Mukhina and Pogudin for systems with constant parameters, and enable the use of evaluation-interpolation techniques for the efficient computation of such eliminant polynomials.

0.30

Rational polynomial solvability reduces to stratifiability of semilinear sets

cs.FL cs.LO ·2026-10-20 ·Michaël Cadilhac
similarity 0.56
Abstract · 13 pages plus 10 pages of appendix

A semilinear set is stratifiable if it is a finite union of linear sets whose periods have at most two nonzero coordinates, with no two periods in one component connecting alternating pairs of coordinates. We give a computable many-one reduction from the existence of a rational zero of an integer polynomial to deciding stratifiability. After the classical reduction to quadratic systems, we reduce rational solvability of these systems to a problem we call finite separation by Cartesian products of rational linear forms. Its input consists of rational subspaces $D_1,\ldots,D_k\le\mathbb Q^r\times\mathbb Q^r$. A separator is a map $(\boldsymbol x,\boldsymbol y)\mapsto(u(\boldsymbol x),v(\boldsymbol y))$, where $u,v\colon\mathbb Q^r\to\mathbb Q$ are nonzero rational linear forms. The problem asks whether finitely many separators suffice so that every pair outside $\bigcup_iD_i$ receives, from some separator, a value attained at no pair in that union. We then reduce this problem to stratifiability. Ginsburg and Spanier's characterization of letter-bounded context-free languages} also induces a reduction from rational polynomial solvability to context-freeness of letter-bounded languages specified by semilinear exponent sets. An OpenAI preprint claims undecidability of rational polynomial solvability; if correct, our result settles the decidability of general stratifiability, a problem open since 1966.

0.33

Tensor-Algebraic Framework for Nonlinear Control: Spectral Stability Analysis and Controller Design of Polynomial Systems

eess.SY ·2026-11-16 ·Shaoxuan Cui, Guofeng Zhang, Hildeberto Jardon-Kojakhmetov, Ming Cao
similarity 0.56
Abstract

Matrices provide an algebraic foundation for systems and control, whereas an analogous tensor-based framework for general nonhomogeneous polynomial dynamics is still lacking. This paper addresses this gap by developing a tensor-algebraic framework that connects tensor structure, spectral properties, Lyapunov stability, and controller synthesis. We first establish stability conditions based on positive-definite, copositive, and P-tensors for homogeneous and nonhomogeneous polynomial systems. We then introduce an extended tensor-eigenvalue problem (ETEP) for general multivariate polynomials, yielding a spectral-variational characterization of positivity through one interior and two boundary spectral quantities, and consequently a stability test for polynomial vector fields. For controller synthesis, we develop an unfolding-based U-eigenvalue relaxation that combines a positive-definite anchor with a near-positive-semidefinite higher-order part, leading to a convex semidefinite program. The conservatism of the relaxation is explicitly characterized, and an explicit guaranteed domain-of-attraction bound is derived. Numerical examples demonstrate positivity certification beyond direct SOS representations and substantially lower computation time than SOS-based synthesis in the considered example. These results establish a systematic tensor-spectral methodology for the analysis and control of polynomial systems with higher-order interactions.

0.20

Elementwise Positivity of the Solution to Lyapunov Equation for Hurwitz Companion Matrices

eess.SY ·2026-09-10 ·Miaomiao Wang, Patrizio Colaneri, Jie Chen
theory similarity 0.55
Abstract · 7 pages

We prove, with the aid of AI, that for every real symmetric forcing matrix $Q\succeq0$, the unique solution of a continuous-time Lyapunov equation is entrywise nonnegative whenever the state matrix is a real Hurwitz companion matrix. This proves an earlier conjecture. The proof makes no assumption on the spectrum of the state matrix, and is made possible by means of using Horner polynomial matrices. We also show that discrete-time counterpart of the conjecture is false: Counterexamples can be readily constructed to show that Schur companion matrices, including one generated by a polynomial with all positive coefficients, yield solutions with negative off-diagonal entries even with identity forcing.

0.22

The De Cock--De Moor Conjecture: Proof, Normal Form, and Indefinite Angles

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-08-30 ·Jeffrey Humpherys
theory similarity 0.54
Abstract

De Cock and De Moor conjectured that two matrices built from the solutions of three coupled Lyapunov equations always share their eigenvalues, an identity linking principal angles between model subspaces with the canonical correlations between the past and future of a stochastic process. The conjecture was recorded as Problem 9.1 of \emph{Unsolved Problems in Mathematical Systems and Control Theory}. We prove it under the natural nonresonance condition, without stability or diagonalizability, and show that the two matrices are similar. The proof exposes a Cauchy-matrix structure created by the rank-one perturbation and reduces the problem to rational interpolation, and the main theorem has also been verified in the Lean~4 proof assistant. The same structure gives a normal form that depends only on the poles and zeros of the model. Off the stable set the eigenvalues become squared cosines of angles in an indefinite metric. We prove an inertia theorem for them and show that reflecting a pole or a zero across the unit circle acts on the angles by a principal pivot transform. For several inputs and outputs, where the conjecture fails, we identify the subspaces whose angles do give the canonical correlations. We also relate our approach to the independent proof of Gillberg and Löfberg.

0.21

The Global Asymptotic Stability Problem for Linear MPC Is Undecidable

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-09-09 ·Johan Löfberg
theory similarity 0.54
Abstract · Submitted to IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control

We prove that deciding global asymptotic stability for constrained finite-horizon linear model predictive control is undecidable. This holds at horizon one with identity state, input, and terminal weights, unique optimizers, and global feasibility. Separate reductions cover predicted-state boxes, hard input boxes, and quadratically softened input boxes. A fourth reduction fixes the state and input dimensions to three and six. Hence undecidability is not caused by long horizons, growing dimensions, failures of recursive feasibility, or nonuniqueness.

0.26