CS Paper Radar

Characterizing Post-Incident Software Evolution

Matt Pope, Jonathan Sillito

cs.SE ·submitted 2026-10-19 23:06 UTC · v1

Abstract

BACKGROUND: After a software incident, organizations attempt to improve the reliability of their software systems by conducting post-incident analysis and identifying actions to prevent or mitigate similar future incidents. Despite the importance of this activity, there is a limited understanding of the nature and characteristics of the software evolution triggered by the analysis process. AIMS: This study seeks to bridge this gap by providing the first empirical characterization of post-incident software evolution. We aim to establish an understanding of how these changes manifest, specifically focusing on how their characteristics (such as effort, location, and timing) differ from standard maintenance and evolutionary changes. METHOD: We conducted a mixed-methods analysis of a 10-year longitudinal dataset from Wikimedia, examining 1,302 tasks and 2,203 code reviews. We categorized these changes across five dimensions: target, effort, abandonment rate, prioritization, and time-to-resolve. RESULTS: Our results show that the post-incident evolution is distinct from other change types. Post-incident changes are more time-consuming, with a median completion time over twice that of other changes and are disproportionately concentrated in a server configuration repository. CONCLUSION: By identifying a few of the characteristics of post-incident evolution, this work provides a foundation for future research into reliability engineering and learning from failure. We highlight further avenues for exploration necessary to fully understand post-incident evolution. Lastly, our work enables researchers to move beyond high-level analysis and begin developing specialized methods and tooling tailored to the nature of post-incident evolution.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Documentation Drift in AI-Generated Pull Requests

cs.SE ·2026-10-19 ·Will De Michele, Kla Tantithamthavorn
published similarity 0.63
Abstract · Accepted at APSEC 2026 (Early Research Achievements)

AI coding agents now contribute to software repositories at scale, yet their documentation practices remain uncharacterised. We analyse 29,669 AI-generated pull requests from 2,585 repositories in the AIDev dataset, measuring documentation co-change: whether code-file modifications are accompanied by a documentation-file update in the same PR. We find that 63.2% of AI PRs change code without updating any documentation. This varies sharply by task type: 55.2% for features and 77.5% for refactoring. Undocumented code files are followed by a fix to the same file 8.6 to 11.7% more often than documented files across 30 to 90-day windows. A raw PR-level comparison shows the opposite because documented PRs are 3.9 times larger and therefore attract more fixes. Controlling for size exposure reverses this result. Documented changes also merge faster despite their larger size (median: 40 seconds versus 184 seconds), although merging is largely automated in this dataset. Documentation drift also compounds: within 90 days, a file changed without documentation is later re-documented at roughly half the rate of a file changed with documentation (24% versus 48%). This suggests that documentation debt tends to accumulate rather than be revisited.

0.23

The Construction of an Empirical Dataset of Incomplete Software Changes from Open Source Projects

cs.SE ·2026-09-28 ·Savira Ramadhanty, Profir-Petru Pârţachi, Yoshiya Ishida, Takashi Kobayashi
datasetcode/data similarity 0.62
Abstract

During software development, a modification to a software component may propagate across the system, requiring precise identification and correct revision of all affected components. This is a complex task, and developers often (45.7%) miss related changes. To address this, several methods have been developed to extract co-change rules from files that are frequently changed together in the revision history. However, previous research evaluated the methods using artificially created incomplete changes, which may not be representative of real-world data. To solve this problem, we construct a dataset by mining incomplete changes from a collection of open-source software, using information about induced bugs and their respective fixes from an issue tracking platform. We also analyze the characteristics of incomplete changes using this constructed dataset and found that 89.4% of missed changes involved five or fewer files. Finally, we re-evaluate LCExtractor, an existing co-change rule extraction method, on our constructed dataset, and we identify the optimal sorting criterion and the impact of the number of used commits.

0.19

TraceVIC: Causal Reasoning over Code Evolution for Identifying Vulnerability-Inducing Commits

cs.SE cs.AI ·2026-09-22 ·Fnu Tanish, Samiha Shimmi, Samikshya Chapagain, Hamed Okhravi, Mona Rahimi +1 more
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Software vulnerabilities are often discovered long after they are introduced, making it difficult to identify the vulnerability-inducing commit (VIC) responsible for introducing the underlying vulnerable condition. Existing VIC identification techniques largely rely on git blame to trace vulnerable code through revision history and use positional heuristics, such as selecting its earliest or most recent modification. However, the true VIC may occur anywhere within this history, and vulnerable behavior may depend on code that evolves across multiple revisions. We therefore argue that VIC identification requires reasoning about how vulnerability-relevant code evolves, rather than simply where a candidate commit appears in the revision history. We present TraceVIC, a temporal graph-based approach for identifying and ranking VICs by reasoning over code evolution. TraceVIC first localizes likely root-cause lines and traces their histories across revisions, constructing graph representations that capture program structure within each revision and the evolution of vulnerability-relevant code across the history. It reasons over the resulting revision history, using temporal edges to preserve correspondences between program elements across consecutive revisions, and directly ranks candidate commits according to their contribution to the vulnerable condition. Ablation results show that modeling the full revision history improves F2 from 0.637 to 0.814. TraceVIC improves F2 by up to 28.7% over state-of-the-art methods and identifies a valid VIC for 78 of 79 vulnerabilities across four unseen C/C++ projects.

0.08

Spotlights: Discovering Improvement Opportunities in Software Repositories

cs.SE ·2026-09-17 ·Udi Barzelay, Ophir Azulai, Idan Friedman, Inbar Shapira, Foad Abo Dahood +7 more
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Coding agents and evolutionary code-search systems can improve implementations once a target and evaluation criterion have been specified. Applying these methods to an existing software repository raises an earlier question: which implementation choices are worth investigating for a high-level engineering objective? We introduce \emph{optimization-opportunity discovery}, the repository-level task of identifying candidate source regions, explaining how they relate to the objective, and proposing possible changes. The task takes as input a repository, an engineering objective, and optional runtime evidence such as offline telemetry observations or profiles. It does not require the user to specify a defect, bottleneck, or code location. We present \emph{Spotlights}, a system that performs this task through logical repository mapping, successive agent reviews, and optional research linking candidates to relevant techniques. We evaluate Spotlights across model serving, document retrieval, blockchain ordering, and document processing. Across three cases, it recovers seven of nine expert-selected targets. In the reliability study, 70\% of the top ten candidates meet the stated correctness and severity thresholds. Across five repeated retrieval runs, 73.6\% of candidate occurrences have a matching source region in all five runs. Spotlights also rediscovers the target of a withheld retrieval optimization and connects it to a relevant tiling technique. In an implementation study, a discovered change reduces end-to-end page-processing runtime by 10.6\% while preserving measured output quality. These results establish optimization-opportunity discovery as a distinct and empirically evaluable step between a broad engineering objective and subsequent implementation and validation.

0.08

Architectural Degradation: How to Measure and to Remediate

cs.SE ·2026-10-01 ·Noman Ahmad, Ruoyu Su, Matteo Esposito, Andrea Janes, Valentina Lenarduzzi +1 more
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Context. Architectural degradation undermines software maintainability, evolvability, and quality. However, existing research remains fragmented across measurement approaches, metrics, tools, and remediation strategies, limiting our understanding of how these elements relate across the degradation lifecycle. Aim. We consolidate the state of the art on architectural degradation by examining how researchers measure it, which metrics and tools support its assessment, and how existing approaches address remediation. Method. We conducted a Multivocal Literature Review of 284 peer-reviewed and grey-literature studies. We supported screening, data extraction, and classification with a locally executed LLM-assisted pipeline combining Retrieval-Augmented Generation, multi-model validation, and human adjudication. We then analyzed the resulting taxonomies and their cross-dimensional relationships. Results and Conclusions. We identified 277 measurement approaches, 357 metrics, 238 tools, and 395 remediation approaches. Research strongly concentrates on static and structural analysis, structural metrics, and detection-oriented tools. In contrast, remediation spans heterogeneous code-level, architectural, and organizational interventions and shows substantially less consolidation. Overall, the field has developed a mature diagnostic apparatus but has made less progress in connecting degradation detection with effective remediation. Our results provide a structured view of the available techniques and identify the diagnosis-remediation gap as a key direction for future research.

0.16

An Empirical Study on the Impact of Change Granularity in Refactoring Detection

cs.SE ·2026-09-07 ·Lei Chen, Shinpei Hayashi
publishedcode/data similarity 0.59
Abstract · 24 pages, 17 figures

Detecting refactorings in commit history is essential to improve comprehension to code changes on code reviews, and to provide valuable information for empirical studies on software evolution. Techniques have been proposed to accurately detect refactorings on the granularity of a single commit. However, refactorings can be made over multiple commits because of their complexity or other practical development problems, which cause detecting on only the granularity of a single commit not enough. We observe that some refactorings can only be detected in coarser granularity, i.e., changes conducted over multiple commits, or in the granularity of a single commit but not in coarse-grained. We call these types of refactorings as coarse-grained refactorings (CGRs) and ephemeral refactorings (EPRs). We investigated the features and causes of CGRs and EPRs through an empirical study of 32 open-source Java projects and found that both commonly occur during development. In addition, we found that refactoring types related to splitting or merging classes and packages, as well as those involving modifications to the inheritance structure, tend to be CGRs, and types targeting small objects such as variables and attributes, and refactorings with context-sensitive detection criteria tend to be EPRs. The causes of CGRs and EPRs are analyzed and categorized, and the relationships between the commit messages of CGRs and themselves are also assessed. We found that about 20% of commit messages explicitly suggest the existence of CGRs. We suggest that CGRs and EPRs be valued in refactoring research and that detectors be extended to identify CGRs.

0.47

Orchestrating AI-Assisted Code Remediation: Socio-Technical Bottlenecks in a Large Industrial Repository

cs.SE ·2026-09-24 ·Andreas Bexell, Lo Gullstrand Heander, Emma söderberg
similarity 0.59
Abstract · Submitted

Background: Code degradation in large, long-lived codebases is costly to remediate through manual refactoring and opportunistic clean-ups. LLM-based coding assistants can perform mechanical remediation at scale, but their impact on industrial workflows is underexplored. Objective: We investigate how massive AI-assisted code remediation affects build-on-commit continuous integration (CI), code review, and team coordination in a large industrial repository, and which socio-technical bottlenecks constrain such remediation when source editing becomes cheap through AI assistance. Method: We report on a 15-day exploratory single-case field study in which an experienced developer used a command-line AI coding buddy to remediate widespread issues in a closed-source industrial C++ repository. We triangulate Gerrit metadata with a developer diary and team chat, analyzed through descriptive statistics and qualitative coding. Results: AI-assisted remediation rapidly generated hundreds of commits touching thousands of lines, saturating CI and reviewer attention. Naïve per-file commits overloaded build-on-commit CI; Switching to directory-based batching and capping the number of files per change restored throughput, but still required explicit review solicitation, negotiation of acceptable commit granularity, and iterative follow-up to resolve build and static-analysis failures. Conclusion: When mechanical editing is cheap, CI capacity, review effort, and change orchestration become primary bottlenecks. Sustainable AI-assisted remediation in very large repositories requires deliberate control of commit, review, and CI batch granularity and treating semantic change sets, such as ``fix all instances of warning X'', as first-class units of work that can be sliced differently for developers, reviewers, and CI.

0.16

Methodological Harness in Agentic Software Engineering: An Empirical Study on Mining Software Repositories

cs.SE ·2026-09-25 ·Jessica Díaz, Jorge Pérez, Sergio Gil-Borrás
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Context. Agentic software engineering requires mechanisms to coordinate and govern agents' work. The framework motivating this study proposes a methodological harness with eight mechanisms: context engineering, persistent shared knowledge, executable specifications, N-version mindset and parallel agents, normative specifications, structured consultation, evidence-based acceptance, and graduated autonomy. These are realized through artifacts such as rule or context files, specifications, and architectural decision records, but the framework had not been empirically validated at repository scale. Objective. We analyze to what extent and how this harness is observable in repositories with agentic activity. RQ1 characterizes adoption through artifact prevalence, breadth, co-occurrence, and temporal evolution; RQ2 examines rule files - a key observable artifact and persistent source of agent instructions - to assess how their content reflects the proposed mechanisms. Method. From the AIDev dataset of 116,211 GitHub repositories, we analyzed 5,435 using a design stratified by visibility, measured through stars as an indicator of popularity and/or reputation. For RQ1, we detected and quantified artifacts and introduction dates for the seven observable mechanisms. For RQ2, we qualitatively coded rule files from 150 repositories. Results. Population prevalence of at least one mechanism is 21.7%, versus 65.3% among the most visible repositories. Multi-mechanism configurations are rare. Where rule files exist, they almost always guide the agent and state norms, while persistent shared knowledge, executable specifications, structured consultation, and graduated autonomy appear only in a minority. Conclusions. The harness is empirically observable, but mainly through isolated mechanisms rather than the integrated system proposed by the framework.

0.43