CS Paper Radar

Attracting Rotations Obstruct Almost-Global Consensus on Spheres over Strongly Connected Graphs

Galina Sidorenko, Johan Thunberg

eess.SY math.OC ·submitted 2026-10-20 15:07 UTC · v1

Abstract

We study discrete-time consensus on the Euclidean unit sphere, where weighted combinations of neighboring states are normalized to unit length. For symmetric weights on connected undirected graphs and ambient dimension $d\ge3$, earlier results establish instability of non-consensus fixed points under suitable weight conditions. For directed graphs on the unit circle, earlier results show that fixed points other than consensus and antipodal configurations occur only for a measure-zero set of weights. We show that these conclusions do not extend directly to general strongly connected directed graphs in higher dimensions. First, we construct full-rank non-consensus fixed points whose tangent eigenvalues all equal one, showing that strict linear instability need not hold. In a separate construction, for every $d\ge3$, we present a sparse strongly connected graph admitting full-rank fixed points on an open set of its permitted weights. Our main result establishes robust counterexamples to almost-global consensus: attracting rotating motions exist for $d=2$ with every $n\ge3$ and for $d=3$ with every $n\ge6$. These motions are locally asymptotically stable modulo common rotations and have asymptotic phase. They persist on open sets of strictly positive weight matrices. For each such matrix, an open set of initial configurations approaches neither consensus nor any fixed configuration. Thus the absence of full-rank non-consensus fixed points does not ensure almost-global convergence to consensus.

Comment
21 pages including appendices, 2 figures

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

New Contraction Bounds for Multidimensional Asymptotic Consensus in Dynamic Networks

cs.DC ·2026-10-08 ·Zeremonienmeister Berber Aab, Darya Melnyk, Stefan Schmid
theory similarity 0.57
Abstract · 21 pages, 2 figures

This work studies the multidimensional asymptotic agreement problem in dynamic networks. We assume that nodes have $d$-dimensional inputs and need to converge arbitrarily close to each other's inputs while their vectors stay inside the convex hull of all inputs. We present a new upper bound of $\sqrt{2d/(3d+1)}$ on the contraction rate of asymptotic agreement in the non-split network model, where $d$ is the dimension of the input and $\sqrt{2d/(3d+1)}\rightarrow \sqrt{2/3}\approx 0.816$ for $d\rightarrow\infty$. To this end, we adapt the BallMidpoint algorithm (Melnyk, 2026) recently introduced for the all-to-all communication model. This algorithm lets the nodes choose the midpoint of the smallest enclosing ball of the received vectors. This bound is strictly worse than the $\sqrt{1/2}\approx 0.707$ contraction rate for fault-tolerant approximate agreement in all-to-all communication networks because the convex hulls of the nodes do not have a common intersection, and only intersect pairwise. Our bound improves over the previously best-known contraction rate of $\sqrt{7/8}\approx 0.935$ for dynamic networks via the MidExtremes algorithm (Függer and Nowak, 2018). We present the first multi-dimensional lower bound of $2/3$ for the contraction of coordinate-free memoryless anonymous deterministic algorithms in non-split networks, for $d\ge 8$. This result shows that the previously best-known lower bound of $1/2$ on the contraction rate for $n\ge 3$ and $d=1$ is not tight in higher dimensions. If $n$ is infinite, we extend this lower bound to $\sqrt{1/2\cdot d/(d+1)}$, which converges to $\sqrt{1/2}$ for $d\rightarrow \infty$. We further show that for a single round, the one-round contraction is at least $\sqrt{\frac{2d-2}{3d+7}}$, which converges to $\sqrt{2/3}$ for $d\rightarrow\infty$, showing that the BallMidpoint strategy is asymptotically optimal for one round.

0.17

Analysis and Consensus Control of Emergent Dynamic Polarization in Minimally-Nonlinear Opinion Dynamics

eess.SY cs.SI ·2026-08-10 ·Rajul Kumar, Ningshi Yao
theory similarity 0.57
Abstract

Collective opinions in social networks evolve through local interaction rules, yet how such local updates give rise to dynamic polarization--persistent oscillatory disagreement between opposing opinion clusters at the network level--remains unexplained. This paper proposes a Minimally-Nonlinear Opinion Dynamics (or M-NOD) framework that analytically characterizes dynamic polarization as a truly emergent collective behavior arising solely from local, agent-level opinion-update rules without externally imposed mechanisms. By introducing a minimal cubic nonlinearity, we rigorously prove that, as the reactivity rate exceeds a critical threshold, the network's consensus equilibrium loses stability via a supercritical flip bifurcation. In the post-bifurcation regime, this instability gives rise to a unique, locally asymptotically stable periodic orbit, thereby characterizing symmetric dynamic polarization with balanced bipartite opinion clusters. We further establish the structural robustness of this behavior by proving the existence and local asymptotic stability of asymmetric dynamic polarization under directed graphs with nonuniform influence weights. Finally, to resolve this undesirable cyclic deadlock, we develop local agent-level control strategies. We prove that anchoring the opinion of only a single agent is sufficient to eliminate network-wide oscillatory disagreement and restore asymptotically stable consensus. Numerical simulations substantiate the theoretical analysis, including the emergence of symmetric and asymmetric dynamic polarization, and demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed control interventions.

0.04

On the Discernibility of Topology Changes in Networked LTI Systems

eess.SY ·2026-10-23 ·Giulio Fattore, Maria Elena Valcher
similarity 0.55
Abstract · Submitted as an invited paper to the Bicentennial Special Issue of the Journal of the Franklin Institute. Under review

This article investigates the discernibility of topology changes in networked linear time-invariant systems, with particular focus on edge disconnection. We introduce a new notion of discernibility motivated by a limitation of the definition commonly adopted in the literature. In consensus networks, topology changes are inherently indiscernible for all initial conditions belonging to the synchronization subspace. To overcome this issue, we first introduce the notion of dynamical discernibility of a topology change for elementary consensus networks. This notion explicitly disregards the intrinsic indiscernibility associated with states in the consensus subspace. We characterize this property for directed communication graphs and then specialize the resulting conditions to topology changes arising from either the disconnection of an edge or a variation in its weight. We then extend the analysis to networks of homogeneous agents by introducing discernibility modulo synchronization, which factors out the unavoidable indiscernibility associated with synchronized trajectories. We derive a general characterization showing how discernibility depends jointly on the topology change and on the dynamics of the individual agents. Finally, we specialize the analysis to undirected communication graphs and show that, under mild additional assumptions, discernibility modulo synchronization is equivalent to the dynamical discernibility of the corresponding topology change. This establishes a direct connection between the two notions and extends existing results on the discernibility of topology variations in dynamical networks. The resulting characterizations are then further specialized to the case of edge disconnection.

0.20

Flip-packability: uniform characterisations of tame graph classes

cs.LO cs.DMmath.COmath.LO ·2026-09-27 ·Ioannis Eleftheriadis
theory similarity 0.55
Abstract · 32 pages; added funding information

A class of graphs is monadically dependent if one cannot encode all graphs in coloured graphs from the class using a fixed first-order formula, and monadically stable if one cannot even encode arbitrarily long linear orders. Bonnet et al. (ICALP 2025) characterised monadic dependence by flip-separability: for every vertex weighting, boundedly many flips - complementations of the adjacency relation within a vertex subset - make every ball of radius $r$ carry at most an $\varepsilon$-fraction of the weight, so that every set carrying an $\varepsilon$-fraction has two elements pulled apart. We introduce flip-packability: boundedly many graphs, each obtained from the input by boundedly many flips and all determined by the weighting before any set is presented, such that every set carrying an $\varepsilon$-fraction of the weight has $m$ elements pairwise far apart in one of them. The number of flips producing each graph depends on the radius alone; only the number of graphs depends on $\varepsilon$ and $m$. We prove that a class of graphs is flip-packable if and only if it is monadically stable, and $2$-flip-packable, that is, flip-packable with $m=2$, if and only if it is monadically dependent. The passage from two scattered elements to $m$ is thus exactly what separates the two notions. For monadically stable classes we show that the flipped graphs can be computed from the weighting in cubic time. Varying the three parameters of the definition - the sparsifying operation, the radius, and the number $m$ of elements scattered - produces eight known characterisations of sparse and dense graph classes from the same template. In each case $m$ separates a depth-like notion from its width-like relaxation: treedepth from treewidth, shrubdepth from cliquewidth, and monadic stability from monadic dependence.

0.24

On Maximum Clique and Maximum Consensus Formulations in Point Cloud Registration

cs.RO cs.CV ·2026-10-19 ·Abolfazl Babanazari, Kaveh Fathian
theory similarity 0.55
Abstract · 8 pages, 7 figures. Interactive examples and Lean proof verification: https://ariarobotics.github.io/mc-vs-mc-registration/

Maximum clique and maximum consensus are widely used formulations for robust point cloud registration in robotics. Maximum consensus seeks one transformation that aligns as many matches as possible, while maximum clique selects matches through pairwise distance tests. Maximum clique is often used as a substitute for or an approximation to maximum consensus, with empirical evidence suggesting a close relationship. However, how closely the two formulations agree is not fully understood. We study this relationship theoretically. We show that a maximum clique can have arbitrarily large alignment error and be arbitrarily larger than the maximum consensus set at any fixed positive tolerance, and derive geometric conditions that bound this error. When rotation is fixed, we derive sharp error bounds and tests that exactly characterize maximum consensus for the translation subproblem. Finally, we study group-$k$ consistency, which tests groups of $k$ matches, and determine the smallest group sizes that guarantee alignment error bounds independent of point cloud scale and geometry. These are $d+1$ for rotations and translations and $d+2$ when reflections are allowed, in dimensions $d\ge 2$. Interactive examples and proof verification using the Lean theorem prover are available at https://ariarobotics.github.io/mc-vs-mc-registration/.

0.30

Destroying Rigidity in the Plane

cs.DM ·2026-10-28 ·Yu Cong, Chao Xu, Yajie Zhao
theory similarity 0.55
Abstract

Rigidity and global rigidity are fundamental graph properties in discrete geometry, with applications to structural engineering and network localization. In two dimensions, both admit combinatorial characterizations in terms of the rigidity matroid and graph connectivity. We study the computational complexity of finding minimum-cost sets of edges or vertices whose deletion destroys either property in a finite simple graph. With unit costs, we give deterministic polynomial-time algorithms for edge deletion destroying global rigidity and vertex deletion destroying either property. We prove that edge deletion destroying rigidity is NP-hard and that, with positive integer costs, all four problems are NP-hard. These results resolve, in dimension two, the open questions on recognizing robustness under edge and vertex deletions posed by Jordán and Whiteley (2017), as well as the minimum edge-deletion problem for rigidity recorded in EGRES Open.

0.42

Equilibria and Consensus in Mixed Weighted-Average and Weighted-Median Opinion Dynamics: The Consensus-Promoting Role of Weighted-Average Individuals

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-10-12 ·Junkai Cheng, Wenjun Mei
similarity 0.55
Abstract · 29 pages, 10 figures, including supplementary material

How individuals respond to their neighbors' opinions shapes whether a networked group reaches consensus. This paper analyzes synchronous discrete-time opinion dynamics on a fixed influence network, where individuals use either weighted-average (WA) or weighted-median (WM) opinion-aggregation mechanisms with individual-specific inertia coefficients. We characterize equilibria through graph-theoretic conditions on opinion level sets and WA balance equations, proving that every solution converges to a Lyapunov-stable equilibrium. We define type-dependent cohesive sets, whose WA members assign all their influence weight to the set and WM members assign at least half. The absence of two disjoint such sets gives a necessary and sufficient graph-theoretic criterion for consensus from any initial condition. Otherwise, an open set of initial conditions leads to persistent dissensus. Converting WM individuals to WA cannot create type-dependent cohesive sets and preserves existing guarantees of consensus from any initial condition. If the conversion eliminates every disjoint pair of these sets, the converted system also guarantees consensus from any initial condition. Four numerical studies examine the locations and proportion of weighted-average individuals, as well as the influence weights, while comparing the consensus criterion with finite-horizon simulation outcomes. In the four network ensembles with 100 individuals, the observed frequency of reaching a prescribed consensus tolerance is nondecreasing with WA proportion at each tested simulation horizon. This trend supports the consensus-promoting role of WA individuals, although individual realizations need not follow it.

0.23

On Real Eventual Exponential Positive property of complex-valued Laplacians and their pseudoinverses

eess.SY ·2026-11-07 ·Aditi Saxena, Twinkle Tripathy, Rajasekhar Anguluri
similarity 0.53
Abstract

The property of real eventual exponential positivity guarantees the state trajectories of a linear time-invariant system to evolve asymptotically to right half of the complex-plane [1]. It has applications in the characterization of herdability and reachability of states in networked systems. Networks with complex-valued edge-weights arise in AC power systems and opinion dynamics. Recent work has introduced real eventual exponential positive (rEEP) Laplacians, for which the trajectories of the associated network flow eventually converge to consensus. We establish further properties of rEEP Laplacians and their pseudoinverses. Firstly, we show that the rEEP property for complex-valued matrices exhibits invariance under specific rotational transformations. Secondly, we establish that the property of rEEP is preserved under the MoorePenrose pseudoinverse operation, highlighting its robustness under algebraic manipulations. These results apply to effective impedance computation in AC networks and to consensus in multi-agent systems. Finally, we provide numerical examples to validate our theoretical results.

0.27