CS Paper Radar

Birthday Estimators Are Uniformly Optimal for Renyi Entropy

Maciej Skórski

cs.IT cs.DSmath.PRmath.ST ·submitted 2026-10-20 17:37 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

Collisions are a basic probe of unknown distributions, used for testing and for counting substructures in graphs, and they underlie Rényi entropy, a fundamental measure of uncertainty with applications in cryptography, machine learning, physics, and biology. Motivated by this, we study the natural birthday estimator. We prove Bernstein-type concentration for it and show that it is minimax optimal, uniformly and jointly in alphabet size, order, accuracy, and confidence, with no sample splitting, clipping, or median aggregation. This, in particular, settles the sample complexity of integer-order Rényi entropy estimation up to absolute constants in all regimes, closing the gap between the best known upper and lower bounds. Our concentration bound rests on a sensitivity analysis of collision count, and the matching lower bound on a sharp analysis of detecting a hidden spike in a plateau distribution.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Settling the Sample Complexity of Rényi Entropy Estimation

cs.IT cs.DSmath.ST ·2026-10-07 ·Qisheng Wang
theory similarity 0.65
Abstract · 23 pages, 1 table

Rényi entropy estimation has been comprehensively investigated by Acharya, Orlitsky, Suresh and Tyagi (SODA 2015; IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 2017) and consequent works, whereas only the sample complexity of Rényi entropy estimation of integer order has been settled. In this paper, we settle the sample complexity of Rényi entropy estimation of noninteger order, thereby completing the complexity picture of Rényi entropy estimation. Specifically, we show that for any noninteger $α> 0$, it is sufficient and necessary to use \[ Θ\!\left(\frac{d^{\max\{1/α,1\}}}{\varepsilon^{1/α}\log(d)} + \frac{d^{|1-1/α|}}{\varepsilon^2}\right) \] samples to estimate the Rényi entropy of order $α$ of an unknown discrete distribution over an alphabet of size $d$ to within additive error $\varepsilon$. For the upper bound, we reduce the bias using a refined polynomial approximation estimator for large probabilities. For the lower bound, we employ a different hard instance equipped with a new moment matching construction. The constructive moment matching has constant bounded high-order moments, while attaining a fixed ratio between the $α$-th moments, which is of independent interest.

0.20

Optimal Rényi and Logarithmic Additive Functional Entropy Estimation

cs.IT cs.CCeess.SPmath.ST ·2026-10-20 ·Arman Adibi, Piotr Krysta
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract

We characterize the minimax sample complexity of estimating Rényi entropy from independent samples on an alphabet of size at most $k$, when the known order $α>1$ may vary with $k$. For every fixed additive accuracy $\varepsilon\in(0,1/2)$ and success probability $2/3$, we prove matching bounds with constants independent of $k$ and $α$. For $1<α<\log k$, the rate is $Θ_\varepsilon(αk^{1-1/α}X_α(k,\varepsilon))$, where a monotone scalar inequality defines $X_α$ at noninteger orders. The bounds remain uniform as the order approaches one or an integer, or grows with the alphabet. Integer orders below $\log k$ have rate $Θ_\varepsilon(αk^{1-1/α})$; orders at least $\log k$ and min-entropy have rate $Θ_\varepsilon(k\log k)$. We extend the analysis to logarithms of positive additive functionals. For every fixed continuous $f$ satisfying $f(0)=0$, $f(x)>0$ for $x>0$, and $f(x)\sim ax^r$ at zero, with $a>0$ and $r>1$, estimating $-β^{-1}\log\sum_i f(p_i)$ at fixed accuracy, for fixed $β>0$, has sample complexity $Θ(k^{1-1/r})$ for integer $r$ and $Θ(k/\log k)$ otherwise. A replication reduction preserves the sampling experiment and transfers the rates for powers. Smooth flat functions show that regularity alone does not determine the complexity. The upper bound combines polynomial approximation, Gamma count statistics, and an independent pilot, with a global affine correction near order one. The lower bound uses interpolation to construct positive mean-one priors and controls their distinguishability and entropy separation after normalization. Exact count-variance identities and weighted approximation duality connect the two arguments.

0.17

Optimal Min-Entropy Estimation with High Probability

cs.IT math.STquant-ph ·2026-11-17 ·Qisheng Wang
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 9 pages

Min-entropy plays a fundamental role in assessing the unpredictability of randomness sources. In particular, NIST SP 800-90B specifies min-entropy estimation as a key procedure for entropy sources used in cryptographic random bit generators, illustrating the practical importance of reliable min-entropy estimation. In this paper, we settle the sample complexity of min-entropy estimation with high probability in both the classical and quantum cases. Specifically, for min-entropy estimation with additive error $\varepsilon$ and probability at least $1-δ$, the sample complexity is $Θ(d\log(d/δ)/\varepsilon^2)$ for classical distributions on $d$ symbols and $Θ((d^2+d\log(1/δ))/\varepsilon^2)$ for quantum states on a $d$-dimensional Hilbert space. Our results admit short and simple proofs.

0.25

Learning Finite-Memory Binary Sources

cs.IT math.PR ·2026-10-29 ·Maciej Skorski
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Estimating biased finite-memory sources from a single trajectory is a fundamental problem with practical impact, for example in estimating entropy for cryptography. We study order-$d$ binary sources whose conditional probabilities have bias at most $ε$, and establish *sharp* sample complexity bounds: relative accuracy $γ$ with confidence $1-δ$ needs $γ^{-2}\,(\tfrac12-ε)^{-d}\,(\log d+\log\tfrac1δ)$ samples up to constants depending on $ε$, with matching upper and lower bounds and no dependence on mixing time or spectral gap. The proof rests on a sharp bound on expected hitting times of the sliding-window (de Bruijn) chain, which stay of order $1/π(w)$ uniformly in $d$ exactly when $ε<\tfrac3{10}$, and on majorization of the window masses by those of independent biased coins. Applied to published entropy-source validations, the bounds show that their trace lengths may be underpowered: $10^6$ bits cannot resolve all transitions of an $8$-bit model to better than about $4.5\%$ relative error.

0.17

Minimax Estimation of Discrete Distributions under Hockey-stick Divergence

cs.LG stat.MLmath.ST ·2026-11-15 ·Manaka Ueno, Geoffrey Wolfer
theory similarity 0.55
Abstract

We initiate the study of estimating a discrete distribution with respect to the hockey-stick divergence from independent samples. We provide non-asymptotic upper and lower bounds on the minimax expected loss in terms of the alphabet size, the number of samples, and the divergence parameter. The upper bounds are achieved by add-constant estimators, while the lower bound is derived via a Bayes risk argument. Both upper bounds and lower bounds reveal a transition between polynomial and exponential regimes as the parameters of the problem vary.

0.33

A positive resolution of the gap-entropy conjecture

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-09-09 ·P. M. Aronow, Nathan Kallus, Patrick Lopatto
theory similarity 0.55
Abstract

We prove the gap-entropy conjecture for fixed-confidence best-arm identification with independent unit-variance Gaussian arms, means in $[0,1]$, and a unique optimal arm. For each suboptimal arm $i$, let $Δ_i=μ_*-μ_i$ be its gap from the optimal mean, and write $H=\sum_{i\ne *}Δ_i^{-2}$. Let $p_r$ be the fraction of $H$ contributed by arms with $2^{-(r+1)}<Δ_i\le2^{-r}$, and let $\mathrm{Ent}(I)=\sum_{r:p_r>0} p_r\log(1/p_r)$. Among all algorithms that identify the optimal arm with probability at least $1-δ$ on every Gaussian instance, the optimal expected number of samples on a given instance, averaged over all permutations of the arm labels, is within absolute constant factors of $H(\log(1/δ)+\mathrm{Ent}(I))$. Moreover, there is an algorithm, independent of the instance, whose expected number of samples is bounded by a constant multiple of this quantity plus $g^{-2}\log\log(e^e/g)$, where $g=\min_{i\ne *}Δ_i$ is the gap to the closest competitor.

0.51

Algorithms, Complexity, and Entropy of the Bernard-Letac Fair-Sampling Construction

cs.IT math.PR ·2026-08-20 ·Claude Gravel
theory similarity 0.55
Abstract · 42 pages, 1 figure

Bernard and Letac (1971) introduced a method for uniform random sampling among $m$ outcomes from an unknown biased source of independent and identically distributed symbols. The process terminates when the multinomial coefficient of the cumulative symbol counts equals zero modulo $m$. This study extends the computational and information-theoretic analysis of their construction by presenting five algorithms with formal correctness guarantees and comprehensive complexity analyses. For prime $m=p$, the Bernard-Letac framework is analyzed in greater detail. The Rényi entropies of the source yield an exact product formula for the expected number of draws. A first-order approximation consistently overestimates this value, and the entropy lower bound is never attained. As $p$, treated as a continuous parameter, approaches 1, the expected cost converges to a constant greater than 1, determined by the entire source distribution. Furthermore, for every prime modulus $p$ and every finite alphabet $I$, an explicit automaton with $p + |I| + 3$ states computes the mod-$p$ first-passage kernel of the walk from the base-$p$ digits of its arguments, reducing the fair assignment cost from quadratic to nearly linear.

0.34

Low-degree polynomials lower bounds for clustering in small dimension

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-10-27 ·Alexandra Carpentier, Nicolas Verzelen
theory similarity 0.54
Abstract

We study the computational limits of clustering $n$ observations drawn from a mixture of $K$ isotropic distributions in $\mathbb R^d$, in the regime where the number $K$ of groups is much larger than the dimension $d$. In this regime, tensor-based procedures recover the partition with a polylogarithmic separation between the centers, but they require a sample size that is a large and non-explicit polynomial of $dK$, whereas the existing low-degree lower bounds only show that $n$ must be larger than $dK^2$. We introduce a mixture of $2K$ product Bernoulli distributions on $\{0,1\}^d$, with $K=(d+1)^m$, whose centers are built from a dual BCH code. This construction ensures that the moment tensors of the observations coincide with those of the uniform distribution on $\{-1,1\}^d$ up to the order $2m+1$. For any fixed $m$, we establish a low-degree polynomial lower bound showing that clustering is hard as long as the separation $Δ$ satisfies $Δ^2\ll(K^2d^{3/2}/n)^{1/(2m+2)}\wedge\sqrt d$, up to polylogarithmic factors. In particular, with a polylogarithmic separation, low-degree polynomials require $n\gtrsim K^2d^{3/2}$ observations, up to polylogarithmic factors. Through a Gaussianization argument, this hardness carries over, in the sense of reductions, to isotropic Gaussian mixtures. Our proof relies on a family of polynomials of the observations, indexed by bipartite graphs, which is almost orthonormal. The moments of these polynomials are governed by the number of solutions of polynomial systems over the finite field $\mathbb F\_{d+1}$ that are induced by the BCH code, and the crux of our analysis is to connect the combinatorial structure of the bipartite graphs with the structure of the solution sets of these systems.

0.19