CS Paper Radar

Through the Looking Glass: Analyzing Geolocation Providers Using Looking Glasses and Active Measurements

William Leung, Oliver Gasser

cs.NI ·submitted 2026-10-21 12:39 UTC · v1

Abstract

Looking Glass servers (LGs) allow users and network operators to debug issues or measure performance to/from arbitrary, external IP addresses, making LGs a valuable tool in a variety of analyses. To assess the reliability of LGs as an independent and free set of vantage points, we perform an analysis of 4487 LG servers across 144 countries. We analyze LGs by comparing them to six different geolocation databases from four providers, and by conducting active measurements on LGs. In our RTT measurements we find 9 of 18 LG providers have at least one server with an RTT-disconfirmed location. We also find substantial differences between geolocation databases' ability to locate LGs, with IPinfo showing the closest distance to LGs.

Journal ref
New Directions in IP Geolocation Workshop 2026 (NewGeo'26)

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

RIPE Atlas Measurements and Geolocation Providers: A Longitudinal Consistency Evaluation

cs.NI ·2026-10-19 ·Jonatas Marques, Oliver Gasser
similarity 0.75
Abstract · New Directions in IP Geolocation (NewGeo) Workshop, Monday, October 12, 2026 - Karlsruhe, Germany

IP geolocation supports many Internet services and operations, including but not limited to content delivery, fraud detection, content localization, and regulatory compliance. However, assessing the reliability and accuracy of IP geolocation providers is challenging and only partially explored. In this paper, we present a longitudinal study evaluating the consistency between RIPE Atlas latency measurements and location estimates from four popular geoproviders as a proxy for geolocation quality. Analyzing six months of data we observe mostly stable consistency levels through time, with fluctuations largely related to changes to the mix of targets being measured by RIPE Atlas each day. We also observe that consistency levels can differ greatly between geoproviders, with IPinfo leading DB-IP (the next best) by 5.4 percentage points for IPv4 and 11.5 percentage points for IPv6. Finally, the analysis reveals distinct degradation patterns across providers for different subsets of IP addresses. For example, for IPv4 router addresses, MaxMind consistency is 10.7 percentage points worse than in the general case while IPinfo is only 1.6 percentage points worse; for IPv6, the pattern flips and routers are geolocated more consistently than non-routers by all providers.

0.32

Reactive Constraint-Based Geolocation of Internet Hosts

cs.NI ·2026-10-04 ·Spencer Ye, Chase Kanipe, Peter Ryan, Erik Rye
published similarity 0.70
Abstract · Accepted to NewGeo '26

Active IP geolocation techniques rely on the responsiveness of Internet hosts, while passive techniques depend on data sources that are unevenly adopted and prone to staleness and error. In this work, we invert the active IP geolocation problem by listening at a geographically distributed set of vantage points for unsolicited Internet scans. By reactively completing connections with these scanners, we obtain round-trip time (RTT) measurements from hosts that may otherwise be unresponsive and use those measurements for geolocation. Over the course of 20 days in August 2026, we recorded 46.8 million scans from 289,746 distinct scanners, with a reactive RTT for each scan. We show that reactive RTTs align with those obtained by sending active probes, with more than three-quarters of 990,204 measurement pairs differing by at most 10 ms. Over half of the scanners that yielded a reactive RTT did not answer our active probes, highlighting the value of our approach. We demonstrate the feasibility of multilateration using purely reactive RTTs for 56,112 distinct IP addresses. Finally, using speed-of-light constraints, we refute commercial geolocation claims for 6,852 addresses.

0.31

Locating and Enumerating Anycast: a Comparison of Two Approaches

cs.NI ·2026-09-18 ·Remi Hendriks, Tim Betzer, Ben Du, Raffaele Sommese, Mattijs Jonker +1 more
similarity 0.58
Abstract · 7 pages, 4 figures, 3 tables, ANRW'25

Anycast allows for providing services from multiple, geographically distant Points of Presence (PoPs), using a single IP address, to, e.g., improve resilience. Due to its opaqueness, it is often unknown which addresses are provisioned using anycast and, if so, where the PoPs are located. As anycast is widely used for critical Internet infrastructures (e.g., the DNS) efforts have been made to map anycast deployments. The current state-of-the-art mapping technique, iGreedy, relies on latency-based measurements, and is adversely affected by noise caused by, e.g., network processing delays. Previous work has shown that traceroute can alternatively be used to detect anycast. As traceroute reveals the hops a packet traverses, it may also be used to locate sites using geolocation data for hops near the anycast PoPs. This paper is the first to assess the performance of the traceroute-based approach at scale, by targeting 14k prefixes from an anycast census. Using ground truth we show traceroute achieves a slight increase in enumeration and geolocation precision over iGreedy. However, it suffers from overestimating the number of PoPs and incurs a 4 times increase in probing cost, making it unattractive for anycast censuses.

0.58

StarLoc: A Practical Approach to Encoding Geographic Locators in IPv6 for Starlink

cs.NI ·2026-11-05 ·Vanya Singla, Mostafa Abdollahi, Jinwei Zhao, Jianping Pan
similarity 0.58
Abstract

LEO satellite networks such as Starlink provide Internet connectivity across continents, oceans, and airspace. IP geolocation providers map Starlink's IPv6 prefixes to locations mainly through its self-published GeoFeed. However, users may be far away from their assigned Points of Presence (PoPs), one label covers an entire prefix, and labels and PoP mappings can change while addresses stay the same. We characterize Starlink's IPv6 addressing using 925 historical GeoFeed snapshots (2024--2026), one year of PoP mappings, and over 7.9 million observed IPv6 addresses. Our findings reveal that customer prefixes lack clear geographic structure, prefix labels lie a median of 540km from their PoPs, and relabeling a single /40 can affect the reported locations of up to 65,536 possible /56 delegations. To address these challenges, we propose StarLoc, a geographic Locator--Identifier separation scheme that embeds terminal location into IPv6 addresses using a resolution-adaptive H3 Locator while preserving existing Starlink prefixes, /56 delegations, and stable Endpoint Identifiers. To balance accuracy and privacy, StarLoc reveals only cells with at least a certain number of terminals, and operators can cap resolution in sensitive regions or withhold location entirely. Unlike topology-based schemes, StarLoc encodes physical location and lets Locators follow moving users.

0.24

A First Look at Starlink Maritime on Cruise Ships

cs.NI ·2026-11-04 ·Jinwei Zhao, Kousar Malekinasab, Jianping Pan
similarity 0.55
Abstract · 6 pages, 7 figures

Low-Earth-Orbit (LEO) satellite networks are reshaping maritime connectivity, offering much lower latency and higher capacity than traditional geostationary (GEO) links. As a single user terminal (UT) cannot serve hundreds to thousands of passengers, a cruise ship often deploys several UTs behind an onboard multi-WAN router for aggregated capacity and load balancing. Consequently, passenger connectivity depends not only on the satellite links but also on how the router distributes sessions among UTs. In this paper, we measure Starlink maritime connectivity on two cruise ships of different scales, Utopia of the Seas near the Bahamas in December 2025 and Silver Muse in the Adriatic Sea in July 2026, combining UT telemetry, inside-out measurements from a passenger device, and outside-in measurements from cloud servers near Starlink Points of Presence (PoPs). We find that the onboard network, rather than the satellite links, largely determines the passenger experience, as cruise lines rate limit each passenger device. Moreover, the public IP address of a passenger device changes not only at PoP handovers but also within the same PoP. Furthermore, while the country code reported by the UT reflects the maritime jurisdiction of the ship, the serving PoP follows neither this jurisdiction nor geographic proximity alone, suggesting factors beyond the distance-based PoP boundaries observed in Starlink aviation. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first systematic study of Starlink on commercial cruise ships, complementing prior land mobile and in-flight measurements.

0.28

How Global Is Anycast?: Evaluating Performance Gaps

cs.NI ·2026-10-29 ·Mohammad Shaikh Sadid Khan, Karishma Setya, ASM Rizvi
similarity 0.54
Abstract · 9 pages, 9 figures, 1 table

Anycast networks aim to reduce latency by directing users to nearby service sites. However, users can still experience high latency even when accessing services via anycast. Some anycast deployments are localized and intended to serve a specific geographic region, while others are globally distributed to support users worldwide, with the expectation of consistently low latency across locations. In practice, latency can remain poor for certain users due to factors such as routing inefficiencies and peering relationships. These inefficiencies are often more pronounced in regions such as Africa, Asia or South America, where Internet connectivity is generally less mature than in North America or Europe. Despite this, there has been no in-depth analysis of anycast performance in these continents. In this paper, we examine the latency experienced by users in these regions when accessing anycast networks. We analyze more than 10,000 anycast prefixes, quantify the severity of latency problems, and show that clients in Africa, Asia, and South America experience substantially higher latency than those in North America. We also investigate the underlying causes of this performance gap.

0.15

GeoContext: One Context Ladder, Two Failure Modes in Vision-Language Geolocation: Flat Reliance on User-Provided Location Context and False Confirmation of Location Claims

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-09-04 ·Yifan Zhang, Kai Wang
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.52
Abstract · Code and data: https://github.com/Yifan1209/geocontext

Visual geolocation benchmarks typically ask a model where an image was captured without accounting for the location context that users often provide. We introduce GeoContext, a resource supporting two complementary tasks: GeoHint, open-ended localization given a true but coarse location hint, and GeoVerify, binary verification of whether an image was taken within 150 m of a claimed place. GeoContext constructs a context ladder by stratifying nearby reference points according to distance and referenceability, allowing the image to remain fixed while the supplied context varies. The benchmark covers 109 sites in 30 cities and evaluates five vision-language models using 21,933 GeoHint responses and 6,270 GeoVerify responses. Our evaluation reveals three main patterns. First, hint repetition varies by only 1.5 percentage points across referenceability tiers and by less than 3 points across distance bands, while the resulting localization error increases steadily with hint distance. Second, behavior depends strongly on no-context performance: at sites with low no-context accuracy, the median ratio between localization error and hint distance is approximately 1.00, whereas at higher-accuracy sites it ranges from 0.24 to 0.69. After correcting for bias introduced by the site grouping procedure, only one of the five models retains a negative accuracy estimate when given a nearby hint. Third, in GeoVerify, no model reaches d' = 1 for decoys immediately beyond the 150 m tolerance. Model rankings also change when sensitivity is separated from response bias, and 83.8% of false acceptances are reported with confidence of at least 0.8. We release the benchmark, construction pipeline, audit decisions, and scoring code.

0.30

Split Skies: Operational Experiences Extending a Multi-Cloud Network Telescope into the Asia-Pacific

cs.NI ·2026-10-06 ·Nils Kempen, Benjamin Schumann, Ralph Holz
similarity 0.52
Abstract · 7 pages, 5 figures. Accepted at RE-NET '26, First International Workshop on a Resilient, Renewable, and Responsible Internet (co-located wit…

Comprehensive visibility into Internet Background Radiation (IBR) requires diverse measurement infrastructure. Recent work showed that cloud IBR depends on the provider making single-provider telescopes systematically biased. These studies relied entirely on Western providers and left the Asia-Pacific region as a blind spot. In this report we extend a multi-cloud network telescope onto Tencent Cloud inside mainland China. We detail how Internet fragmentation, geo-politics, and provider rules complicate global measurement through strict onboarding barriers and an unreliable management plane. Once deployed, our nodes captured high-volume regional scanning invisible to our Western vantage points. We conclude by connecting our findings to the Responsible Internet framework. This framework relies on independent global observation to build a transparent Network Inspection Plane. We show that building this plane is bottlenecked by sovereign ecosystems and requires a collaborative community effort.

0.17