CS Paper Radar

When Stable and Preferred Semantics Agree: A Path-Based Approach

Yan Zhang, Kehan Liu

cs.AI ·submitted 2026-10-19 05:23 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

We investigate structural conditions under which preferred and stable semantics agree in abstract argumentation frameworks. Our approach is based on suitably chosen sets of paths in the attack graph and binary relations induced by them. We establish a general path-based criterion for semantic agreement and instantiate it with several classes of paths, obtaining sufficient conditions expressed in terms of well-foundedness of the corresponding relations. The resulting conditions strictly generalize two principal structural criteria for preferred and stable agreement in the literature: Dung's limited controversiality condition and the SCC-symmetry condition. In particular, Dung's result is recovered as a special case by taking the relevant path set to be the set of even paths. We further introduce two infinite sequences of path sets, each yielding a family of agreement conditions. For the first sequence, a Collapse Theorem reduces the infinitely many associated well-foundedness conditions to three essentially distinct ones, whereas the second sequence gives rise to genuinely distinct conditions with no analogous collapse. Our results apply to both finite and infinite argumentation frameworks, admit simplified formulations in the finite case, and also yield sufficient conditions for the existence of stable extensions.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Evidential-Based Higher-Order Set Argumentation Framework

cs.AI math.LO ·2026-08-28 ·Shuai Tang
similarity 0.68
Abstract

Evidential argumentation extends Dung's abstract argumentation by requiring arguments and interactions to be backed by chains of evidence rooted in prima-facie elements. However, existing formalisms lack a unified treatment of evidential support, higher-order relations (attacks and supports targeting arbitrary elements), and collective interactions (sources as sets). In this paper, we introduce the Evidential-Based Higher-Order Set Argumentation Framework (EHSAF), which conservatively generalises several existing frameworks within a single expressive setting. We develop two complete semantics for EHSAFs: an \emph{adjacent complete labelling semantics} that admits multiple truth values (true, false, undecided) for arguments in support cycles, reflecting an open epistemic attitude toward future evidence; and an \emph{extension-based complete semantics} that follows a strict evidentialist stance, accepting only arguments with well-founded support chains. We show that these two semantics diverge in the presence of support cycles, and prove their equivalence under support-acyclicity. To enable computational reasoning, we provide a normal propositional encoding of EHSAFs and prove that, in three-valued Łukasiewicz logic, its models correspond precisely to the adjacent complete labellings. We further extend this encoding to continuous fuzzy logics (G{ö}del, Product, and Łukasiewicz), defining a continuous fuzzy normal encoded semantics. We establish that this fuzzy semantics satisfies key properties---continuity, monotonicity, boundary conditions, and solution existence---and that its ternarisation recovers the adjacent complete labellings under natural t-norm conditions. Our framework thus unifies expressive argumentation with principled three-valued and fuzzy semantics, bridging the gap between qualitative and quantitative reasoning about evidence.

0.20

Structural Morphisms for Nested Conditions - Full Version

cs.LO ·2026-08-12 ·Arend Rensink, Andrea Corradini
published similarity 0.55
Abstract · This is the full version (including proofs) of the paper published in GCM 2026

Nested conditions are used, among other things, as a graphical way to express first order formulas ruling the applicability of a graph transformation rule to a given match. In this paper, we first introduce several operators on conditions mimicking logical connectives. Next we propose an original notion of structural morphism among nested conditions, and we identify circumstances under which morphisms are consistent with the entailment of the corresponding conditions. Finally we frame the results in a categorical context, proving functoriality and universality properties of the various operations.

0.19

From Contexts to Values: Context-Dependent Defeat in Abstract Argumentation

cs.AI cs.LO ·2026-08-16 ·Albert Sadowski, Jarosław A. Chudziak
similarity 0.54
Abstract · Accepted to SAFA workshop at COMMA 2026

In value-based argumentation, an audience's ordering of values decides which attacks succeed as defeats. In many settings the deciding factor is not the audience but the circumstances: the same attack may succeed at one procedural stage, or under one regulation, and fail at another. Context-dependent argumentation frameworks (CDAFs), a model we recently introduced, capture this directly: one attack relation and a defeat function that switches each attack on or off per context, so every context induces an ordinary Dung framework. This raises a reduction question: can one value assignment with per-context orderings reproduce the defeat function, collapsing the CDAF into a VAF? We present a polynomial-time decision procedure for this question and map the harder neighbouring problems, with upper bounds from NP to $Σ^p_3$. We also present a validated reference implementation and a measurement: representability is rare and falls fast with the number of contexts.

0.11

Minimum-Cost Robust Evidence Certificates for Horn Reasoning under Correlated Source Failures

cs.AI ·2026-10-19 ·Yukun Yang
theory similarity 0.54
Abstract · 9 pages, 2 figures

A small justification for a rule-based conclusion may disappear when a source is withdrawn, and multiple derivations need not provide independent evidence. We study minimum-cost certificates that preserve a Horn conclusion under every withdrawal of at most k source domains. Evidence records remain distinct from asserted facts, supporting replicated attestations and overlapping failure dependencies. Transversals of minimal-support footprints characterize robustness and explain why disjoint-proof requirements can reject valid certificates. An exact procedure alternates weighted evidence selection with a source-failure oracle. A rule-closed counterinterpretation yields a globally valid selection cut without enumerating supports or failure scenarios. We prove correctness, finite termination, and cost optimality, establish coNP-completeness of unrestricted verification and NP-completeness of synthesis for every fixed budget, and identify a tractable reachability restriction. Experiments on controlled benchmarks, reachability graphs, and ontology-derived instances demonstrate that our counterinterpretation-guided synthesis achieves up to 92% optimum coverage within practical resource bounds, outperforming scenario expansion and general abduction while confirming the necessity of transversal-based reasoning over proof-packing heuristics.

0.22

Scenario Proofs for Verification of Distributed Protocols

cs.PL ·2026-10-11 ·Zhendong Ang, George Pîrlea, Umang Mathur
similarity 0.54
Abstract

Formal verification of distributed protocols is still dominated by inductive-invariant proofs, whose central challenge is discovering strengthening assertions that rule out unreachable states. This burden is often misaligned with how protocol designers reason: they explain correctness by following representative executions, causal histories, and phase-structured interactions among nodes. This paper introduces scenario proofs, a verification methodology that makes such execution-oriented reasoning formal. A scenario is a structured expression describing representative protocol executions, enriched with ghost variables. Rather than enumerate all possible interleavings, a scenario describes canonical executions and uses a sound semi-commutation relation to account for reorderings that preserve feasibility and final states. Verification then factors into two main obligations. Coverage shows that every feasible protocol execution is equivalent, up to semi-commutation, to one described by the scenario; this obligation is independent of the safety property and serves as a reusable behavioral characterization of the protocol. Correctness proves the desired safety property only over the representative executions, using Hoare-style weakest-precondition reasoning along the scenario structure. We formalize the scenario language, its layered semantics, and proof rules for coverage and correctness. Through case studies of ring leader election, two-phase commit, a decentralized lock, two variants of multi-signature payment, and single-decree Paxos, we show how scenario proofs capture the causal and phase-based arguments used informally by protocol designers. These examples illustrate that scenario proofs can replace monolithic invariant discovery with structured reasoning over representative executions, while retaining a rigorous connection to all feasible protocol behaviors.

0.24

Notation3: Graph Terms for RDF

cs.LO cs.AI ·2026-10-22 ·Dörthe Arndt, Pierre-Antoine Champin
similarity 0.54
Abstract · Submitted to TGDK

Notation3 Logic was introduced as an extension of RDF allowing the user to express rules on top of triples and to make statements about graphs. The original proposal of the logic only came with an informal specification of its semantics which has been refined later on. While this refinement clarified the meaning of rules and implicitly quantified variables, it left the meaning of graphs used as terms - so-called graph terms - open. In this paper we aim to close this gap. We discuss in detail, how graph terms are used in Notation3, which formal requirements they need to meet, and provide examples to illustrate the difficulties when defining their semantics. We then introduce an abstract syntax for the logic and define its semantics in two steps: similarly to RDF's simple interpretations, we define interpretations and basic entailment for Notation3 which covers plain RDF triples but also triples containing graph terms. N3-entailment is then an extension of basic entailment which assigns meaning to the different special predicates of the logic like for example the implication symbol. N3-entailment is defined in a way that it can be extended whenever a new predicate is added to the logic. As Notation3 Logic is currently under development, we expect many predicates to be added. Our research provides and important step towards the full standardisation of the logic.

0.24

Two-Variable Logic with Arbitrarily Many Successor Relations

cs.LO ·2026-10-07 ·Jakub Michaliszyn, Piotr Witkowski
theory similarity 0.54
Abstract

We study two-variable first-order logic with a finite, input-dependent number of distinguished successor relations and arbitrary additional unary and binary predicates. Each distinguished relation must be the exact immediate-successor relation of some linear order on the common domain; the orders themselves are not available in the language and may have arbitrary order types. We prove that satisfiability belongs to 2NEXPTIME, uniformly in the number of successors. The proof gives finite certificates for possibly infinite models. A closure operation separates local neighbourhood descriptions, called star types, into those of bounded multiplicity and those that can be realized infinitely often. The bounded part is represented explicitly. Outside it, integer height vectors allow overlapping successor requirements to be matched without creating cycles or unintended identifications. Ordering the resulting path components densely then recovers exact successor relations. Consistent assignments of the additional binary predicates handle witnesses involving the bounded part. The same certificates decide infinite satisfiability in 2NEXPTIME and give a doubly exponential threshold above which a finite model guarantees an infinite model. A doubly exponentially large finite core can be forced with only two successors and unary predicates. For finite models, we prove that satisfiability subject to a bound on the total number of reference adjacencies lost by the other orders is NEXPTIME-complete, even when the budget is encoded in binary and the number of successors is part of the input.

0.49

Multi-Winner Voting with Argumentative Ballots

cs.GT cs.AI ·2026-08-24 ·Ryuta Arisaka, Hirotaka Ono
similarity 0.53
Abstract · Corrected Example 1, reflected the update to page 6's counts of winner sets proving axioms for the robust h. No definitions, propositions, l…

We introduce multi-winner voting with argumentative ballots (MVArg) and investigate theoretical properties. As our conceptual contribution, we generalise approval ballots to argumentative ballots, thereby allowing voters to express defeasible preferences over candidates. We accordingly generalise voter cohesion and justified representation axioms JR, PJR and EJR. As our theoretical contribution, we establish several key results. First, MVArg is strictly more expressive than multi-winner voting with approval ballots (MV). Second, our notions of cohesion and justified representation are conservative generalisations of their counterparts in MV. Third, the MVArg counterpart of JR can always be satisfied, whereas the counterparts of PJR and EJR cannot always be. Fourth, although verifying whether a winner set satisfies the MVArg counterpart of JR is already coNP-hard, such a winner set can be constructed in polynomial time. All definitions, propositions, auxiliary lemmas and theorems have been formalised and mechanically checked in Lean 4.

0.24