CS Paper Radar

Virtual Placebo: a scoping review of control conditions in randomized controlled trials of psychological immersive virtual reality interventions

Madis Vasser, Mary-Ann Kubre, Kadi Tulver, Jaan Aru

cs.HC q-bio.NC ·submitted 2026-10-23 06:43 UTC · v1

Abstract

Research on immersive virtual reality (IVR) as a therapeutic tool is growing rapidly, with randomized controlled trials (RCTs) now commonplace. Yet the control conditions in many of these studies that claim strong specific IVR effects vary from usual care to active immersive experiences, making it difficult to draw clinically meaningful conclusions. We conducted a scoping review of recent literature on psychological IVR interventions to assess the main forms of control conditions used and their relations to study outcomes. In this paper, we make the case that most of the recent RCTs studying the effects of specific IVR interventions compare active immersive VR to usual care with no multimedia component. This can lead to strong yet potentially misleading study outcomes and can potentially inflate the IVR interventions' effect. Namely, the lack of an appropriate immersive control condition may risk misattributing general effects of VR devices to the specific content of the intervention. In this review, we discuss the implications of these design choices and propose strategies for including a suitable "virtual placebo" condition to improve the methodological rigor and interpretability of results.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Beyond the Lab: Large-Scale Remote Cybersickness Research in Virtual Reality Using the VERA Platform

cs.HC ·2026-09-04 ·Matt Gottsacker, Gerd Bruder, Daniel Zielasko, Alexander Giovannelli, Ali Haskins +11 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract · This is a preprint of a publication currently under review at IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics (TVCG)

Cybersickness remains a major barrier for the adoption of virtual reality (VR), yet most existing knowledge is derived from laboratory-based studies with relatively small and homogeneous participant samples. In this paper, we investigate whether remote VR studies can produce cybersickness findings comparable to traditional in-lab experiments while enabling larger and more diverse participant populations. Using the Virtual Experience Research Accelerator (VERA), we deployed a remote adaptation of the standardized Cybersicker testbed for cybersickness research and collected data from N=263 participants using their own consumer VR headsets. We compared these results against a previously published in-lab dataset and a demographically matched subset of the remote sample. Across cohorts, cybersickness outcomes were consistent in direction and temporal pattern, including symptom onset trajectories, Fast Motion Sickness Scale (FMS) ratings, and Simulator Sickness Questionnaire (SSQ) responses, supporting the validity of remote cybersickness human-subjects research. Leveraging the larger remote dataset, we additionally examined demographic and individual-difference factors associated with cybersickness. These analyses confirm at scale the effects of sex, sickness susceptibility, and sickness expectation reported in smaller laboratory samples, and they add well-powered evidence on the contested relationship between age and cybersickness. These findings demonstrate that the VERA platform provides a viable means of remotely replicating laboratory-based studies and highlight its ability to support large, demographically diverse participant samples. This work establishes a validated methodological foundation for future large-scale remote studies of cybersickness and other VR research topics.

0.20

On Edge in the Dental Chair: Designing VR Support for Moments of Dental Anxiety

cs.HC ·2026-09-14 ·Zhu Guo, Junjie Zhao, Haofan He, Jiaming Zhang, Mingshi Deng +11 more
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 44 pages, 9 figures, including appendices and references

Dental anxiety can change as a procedure unfolds, yet dental virtual reality (VR) commonly provides continuous distraction or relaxation. We investigate how support can be coordinated with specific simulated dental events. Stakeholder interviews (N=36), participatory design with three returning dentists, and patient walkthroughs of a no-intervention prototype (N=12) informed five Anxiety Events and an intervention-module framework. Drawing on cognitive vulnerability and emotion regulation, we implemented a standardized event-contingent VR system with predefined event-module assignments and shared agency and safety controls. A randomized study (N=24) compared the intervention package with no-intervention VR. The adjusted intervention-minus-control difference averaged -12.83 VAS-A points across events (95% CI [-24.42, -1.70]). Physiological, behavioural, and qualitative measures contextualized participants' experiences. The findings inform timely, comprehensible support and reassuring social presence in simulated dental VR; they concern the complete package rather than individual modules or clinical effectiveness.

0.28

Slide to Report: Continuous Reporting Symptom-Specific Cybersickness in VR

cs.HC ·2026-11-05 ·Purnata Saha, Rifatul Islam, Qiliang He, John Quarles
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Cybersickness is often assessed during VR exposure through discrete overall sickness, which cannot capture specific symptoms or their changes over time. Post-exposure questionnaires such as the Simulator Sickness Questionnaire provide symptom-specific measures but cannot be collected during immersion. We investigate whether separating cybersickness into three symptom-specific dimensions -- nausea, oculomotor discomfort, and disorientation -- during immersion provides more informative continuous measurements. We conducted a between-subjects study with 52 participants in a VR-rollercoaster, comparing a three-slider interface with a single-slider interface. Concurrently, participants also completed an auditory Simon task to measure attention. We additionally collected multimodal set of physiological signals, including GSR, ECG, PPG, eye and head tracking. Results show that each slider correlated most strongly with its corresponding SSQ subscale, whereas the single slider correlated with all SSQ subscales. Using three sliders did not significantly affect usability, workload, or attention. We publicly release the multimodal dataset to support future cybersickness research.

0.20

Unpacking the process of watching a 360-degree video: How physiological responses and head rotation relate to affective and cognitive outcomes

cs.HC ·2026-10-30 ·Portia Wang, Yujie Tao, Monique Santoso, Jeremy Bailenson
similarity 0.62
Abstract

A defining feature of 360-degree video is that the perceptual experience is actively constructed. As viewers turn their heads, shift their gaze, and encounter changing visuals, their perceptual experience is not predetermined, but rather emerges through ongoing exploration. Yet, it is unclear how the process of watching immersive videos unfolds, and how it is related to psychological and physiological outcomes. We present a large-scale study (N=200) in which participants experienced one of 10 pieces of 360-degree videos in virtual reality. Results showed that greater head rotation was associated with greater valence, higher attention focus, longer length of subjective review, and lower simulator sickness; greater pupil dilation was associated with lower valence, lower review ratings, and greater use of negative tone in written reviews. A mediation analysis revealed that participants who rotated their heads more experienced greater frame-to-frame pixel-level perceptual changes in their field of view, which in turn resulted in greater valence and lower simulator sickness. Moreover, participants tended to rotate their heads toward field of view regions with greater perceptual movement, while directing their eye gaze toward less perceptually dynamic areas within that view. We outline theoretical and practical contributions for designing 360-degree content and predicting experiential outcomes.

0.14

Beyond Harassment: Exploring the Harm Experienced by People with Disabilities in Social Virtual Reality

cs.HC ·2026-08-27 ·Xinran Adeline Li, Kexin Zhang, Yuhang Zhao, Yaxing Yao
top venue similarity 0.60
Abstract · Accepted to the 28th International ACM SIGACCESS Conference on Computers and Accessibility (ASSETS 2026)

People with disabilities (PWD) are increasingly engaging in social virtual reality (VR) platforms, where immersive and embodied interactions can intensify negative experiences. While prior work has examined harassment in VR, little is known about the harms experienced by PWD and the perceived severity associated with different harassment and disability types. Unlike harassment, which represents behaviors, harm is more critical to designing effective protections, as it reflects the consequences and impact; the realism of VR and the vulnerability resulting from disability identity can further amplify such impact. To characterize and model harms for PWD, we conducted a literature review, followed by an online survey with 67 PWD to understand participants' harassment experiences and resulting harms in social VR. We identified 19 types of harm in 5 categories, and reported the severity perception of each type of harm. Finally, we analyzed our results from the critical disability theory perspective, summarized the uniqueness of harm in social VR, and discussed design implications for specialized safety mechanisms that mitigate harm for PWD.

0.26

Usability, User Experience, and Acceptability of the Trail Making Test in Virtual Reality in Younger and Older Adults

cs.HC cs.CY ·2026-10-16 ·Panagiotis Kourtesis, Dante O'Connor, Sarah E. MacPherson
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 20 pages, 3 figures, 4 tables, supplementary material are included

Immersive virtual reality (VR) adaptations of neuropsychological tests change how a test operates. Before their scores are interpreted, the individuals they are intended to assess should find them usable, acceptable and tolerable, and for older adults this evidence is usually missing. This study evaluated the experience of the Trail Making Test in Virtual Reality (TMT-VR), a head-gaze adaptation of the Trail Making Test that requires no hand-held controller, in 47 younger (20-38 years) and 44 older adults (64-81 years). After the task, participants rated usability, pragmatic and hedonic user experience, acceptability, and cybersickness. The study had three aims: to compare the two age groups on these ratings; to examine whether the ratings were associated with age group, gaming and technology experience, and whether cybersickness was associated with motion sickness susceptibility; and to examine whether the ratings were related to TMT-VR completion and error-adjusted times. Both groups rated the TMT-VR as highly usable, acceptable and pleasant to use. Older adults gave slightly lower usability and pragmatic ratings, but neither the age-group differences nor the associations with age group or previous experience were statistically significant after correction. Cybersickness was low, with 38 of the 91 participants reporting no symptoms; it did not differ between the age groups and was not associated with motion sickness susceptibility. No correlation between the ratings and TMT-VR performance survived correction. The TMT-VR with head-gaze selection is therefore usable, acceptable and well tolerated by older as well as younger adults. Because the ratings were favourable across the whole range of TMT-VR scores, slower or less accurate performance is unlikely to reflect difficulty with the interface.

0.37

Moving Beyond the Flat Screen: Opportunities and Challenges of Extended Reality for Studying Human Brain and Behavior

cs.HC ·2026-10-13 ·Tom Bullock, Radha Kumaran, You-Jin Kim, Emily Machniak, Tobias Höllerer +1 more
published similarity 0.58
Abstract · 4 pages, 1 figure. Workshop paper presented at the NeuroXR 2026 Workshop at IEEE ISMAR 2026 (ISMAR-Adjunct)

Much of what we know about human perception and cognition comes from austere experimental settings: static stimuli presented to sedentary observers on flat monitors, complex responses reduced to simple button presses, and brain activity recorded from immobilized heads using EEG or fMRI. These highly controlled paradigms have provided remarkable insights, but capture a small and often unusual slice of behavior, raising questions about how well the findings generalize to the real world. Extended reality (XR), spanning both immersive virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) that overlays digital content on the real world, offers a way beyond these constraints, supporting controlled, reproducible experiments in which participants actively engage with three-dimensional tasks. Drawing on a growing body of VR and AR studies of attention, memory, and language -- our own and others', some involving EEG -- we outline what XR makes newly possible for cognitive neuroscience and reflect on the practical and conceptual obstacles that remain. The opportunities are substantial, but realizing them requires solving practical problems of hardware, timing, and measurement, and being realistic about what a virtual or augmented world can and cannot stand in for.

0.40

Gaze Under Strain: How Oculomotor Behavior Tracks Cybersickness Progression in VR

cs.HC ·2026-10-23 ·Nevzat Umut Demirseren, Mehedi Hasan Raju, Oleg Komogortsev, Isayas Berhe Adhanom
published similarity 0.58
Abstract · Accepted for publication at ACM VRST 2026. 10 pages, 4 figures

Cybersickness remains a major barrier to comfortable, accessible virtual reality (VR). Arising from mismatches between visual and vestibular signals, it places sustained demands on gaze stabilization and visual processing. Because gaze is the mechanism through which users actively sample the virtual environment, cybersickness-induced disruptions may alter both what users perceive and how discomfort itself emerges. Yet, how eye-movement behavior evolves alongside discomfort during prolonged VR exposure remains poorly understood. We present a behavioral analysis of eye-tracking data from 19 participants navigating a realistic virtual environment over a 20-minute session, with discomfort rated repeatedly throughout the experiment. Linear mixed-effects models examined gaze constructs spanning fixation stability, visual exploration, and gaze allocation as functions of discomfort, exposure duration, and their interaction. Our results show that fixation stability degraded progressively with increasing discomfort, with the effect strengthening over time. Visual exploration showed no marginal discomfort effect but exhibited significant discomfort-by-time interactions, indicating that saccadic behavior adapts dynamically rather than responding uniformly to discomfort. Gaze allocation was not associated with discomfort but shifted systematically with time. These findings show that cybersickness does not uniformly disrupt gaze. Instead, different aspects of eye-movement behavior respond differently and change in ways that only become visible when discomfort is tracked repeatedly over time. Understanding how gaze evolves during cybersickness progression provides the behavioral grounding needed to better interpret how discomfort shapes the user's visual experience of immersive environments and to design more sensitive detection approaches.

0.31