CS Paper Radar

The Capability Transfer: Cohort Reversal, Codified Expertise, and the Adaptability Tax of AI Transformation

Ina Catrinescu

cs.CY econ.GN ·submitted 2026-10-22 15:08 UTC · v1

Abstract

Most analyses of AI and employment ask which jobs are exposed. This paper asks what happens to the pipeline that produces experts. It extends the model of Caosun and Aral (2026) from a single worker to a firm with two cohorts, juniors and seniors, and studies how expertise formation changes when codified work is automated. Because junior work is the most codified, demand for juniors falls first; the stock of seniors falls later but further, as the pipeline stops replacing the experts who retire. In the baseline calibration, junior demand bottoms out about a fifth below its 2022 level before recovering most of that ground, while the senior stock falls by a quarter and later halves. Because expertise forms through unassisted practice on work that AI cannot do, the time needed to develop an expert from within rises from about five years to nine. The costs fall on a different party from the one that decides on adoption: a manager with a three-year horizon sets AI use to maximise near-term output, cutting the wage bill by 21 percent while the capacity of the firm on work AI cannot do falls by two-fifths and its output on that work goes unserved once the pipeline runs thin. Two key parameters are not yet measured, so the results are scenarios rather than forecasts. The paper proposes three indicators organisations can track: the unaided practice juniors get on work AI cannot do, senior time spent on such work, and the years it takes to develop an expert.

Comment
29 pages, 6 tables, 6 figures. Working paper. Also available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=7445098. JEL: J24, O33, M54

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Cheap, Fallible Cognition and the Political Economy of Expertise

cs.CY ·2026-08-11 ·Christophe Kolb, Jim Caron
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 18 pages

The question of whether artificial intelligence will "destroy jobs" is too coarse to guide economic analysis or institutional design. A job is not an indivisible object, and machine cognition is not a uniform substitute for human labor. This paper develops a task-based and institutionally grounded framework for analyzing generative AI as cheap, scalable, and fallible cognition. The relevant margins are exposure, adoption, verification, question selection, workflow redesign, demand elasticity, apprenticeship, and rent allocation. We distinguish the technical reach of large language models from equilibrium labor-market displacement by introducing a task vulnerability index and an adoption condition that makes verification, liability, trust, and governance explicit. We then model occupations as governance bundles rather than task lists, firms as architectures of distributed intelligence, and labor-market effects as a balance among task compression, scale expansion, new human work, and institutional bargaining. A further implication is that when answer generation becomes abundant, the scarce human capital shifts upstream and downstream: toward asking economically meaningful questions, framing problems, generating hypotheses, interpreting results, and bearing responsibility for consequential use. The central dynamic concern is expertise formation: Junior tasks jointly produce current output, question sense, and future judgment, so their automation can raise short-run productivity while weakening the pipeline into accountable expertise unless AI is designed to teach rather than merely bypass. The paper concludes that AI's labor-market destiny is neither mechanical unemployment nor automatic abundance. It is an institutional equilibrium shaped by workflow design, apprenticeship systems, liability rules, competition policy, worker voice, and the distribution of rents from cheap cognition.

0.10

Practice Makes Perfect: Tacit Knowledge, Generative AI, and Returns to Schooling and Experience

cs.CY econ.GN ·2026-10-26 ·Eduardo Levy Yeyati, Darío Judzik, Juan Ignacio Barbiero
similarity 0.57
Abstract · 64 pages, 13 figures, 19 tables. JEL codes: J24, J31, O33, I26. Also circulated as Universidad Torcuato Di Tella, Escuela de Gobierno, Docum…

Generative AI changes the scarcity of different forms of human capital. It makes codified knowledge cheaply available at the point of production, while judgment acquired through practice remains tied more closely to the worker. We ask what this does to two familiar prices in the wage structure: the return to schooling and the return to experience. In a short-run framework, machine-supplied codified knowledge substitutes directly for the codified component of worker human capital, lowering the schooling gradient. If codified and practice-based knowledge are complements, the return to experience rises where learning through practice is fastest; technology-specific experience can also become obsolete, rotating the experience profile rather than shifting it uniformly. Using US Current Population Survey earnings data from 2018 through June 2026, we compare occupations in the top and bottom quartiles of the pre-ChatGPT Felten-Raj-Seamans exposure index. After the public release of ChatGPT, the return to a year of schooling falls by 0.55 log points in exposed occupations. The return to a year of experience rises by 0.26 log points at three years of potential experience, is unchanged at fifteen, and falls by 0.12 log points at twenty-five; under the baseline quadratic, the effect crosses zero at 18.1 years. These breaks appear with the release, disappear under a pandemic placebo, survive a common censoring rule across the full sample, and remain when each occupation is allowed its own pre-shock schooling and experience gradients. The pattern is a repricing of human capital inside exposed occupations: codifiable knowledge becomes less scarce, while the value of experience depends increasingly on whether it transfers to the new technology.

0.29

"To Boldly Go Where No One Has Gone Before" What Has AI Let Developers Unlock?

cs.HC ·2026-10-16 ·Rudrajit Choudhuri, Jenna L. Butler, Christian Bird, Carmen Badea, Brian Houck +1 more
similarity 0.55
Abstract

Measuring AI by how much faster developers work is like judging electricity by how much faster it spun a steam-era factory. A fuller measure asks what new work becomes possible. We surveyed 331 software developers at Microsoft about what AI lets them do that they could not do before and analyzed their answers using reflexive thematic analysis with a human-in-the-loop, multi-model AI council. Developers described doing familiar work faster (Faster, 45%), undertaking work previously beyond their reach (Further, 36.9%), and taking on new kinds of work centered on building for and directing AI agents (Afresh, 12.4%). Across these accounts, learning and scaffolding ran in both directions: developers learned new skills with AI while externalizing their tacit knowledge as the context and standards that guide AI's work. Drawing on Vygotsky's zone of proximal development, we frame developers and AI as joint learners whose zones meet at the skill-judgment nexus: AI can supply skill faster than it can reliably judge its own work, and developers must continuously bridge that gap. Whether they do sets them on one of two paths. On one, developers' judgment grows alongside AI's skill, and they codify what they learn so the loop keeps turning. On the other, they become hollow orchestrators, approving work they can no longer judge and losing the identity and meaning they once drew from it. Based on our findings, we offer a two-way scaffolding playbook to help developers, teams, and tool builders take the first path.

0.12

Expertise capture in workplace AI

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-11-16 ·Andreas Ekelhart, Ahmad Mohsin, Iqbal H. Sarker, Helge Janicke
similarity 0.53
Abstract

AI assistants are becoming part of how knowledge workers think and perform, accumulating the prompts, exemplars, memory and interaction histories that encode a worker's professional judgment. This infrastructure typically runs under employer or platform control. We name the resulting process expertise capture, the absorption of worker-applied knowledge and judgment into AI resources under organizational control. We develop a framework of contribution forms, technical residences and transformation families, and show that how far a contribution can be attributed, separated and revoked depends on where it resides and how it has been transformed, properties fixed by system design long before any dispute arises. When a worker departs, the organization retains a capability shaped by their judgment while the worker loses access to it, and the asymmetry compounds as contributions move from inspectable artifacts into derivatives, learned components and successor systems. We outline three measures, write-time provenance, extraction of separable contributions and an executable exit procedure, that make an agreed allocation technically performable, and make explicit what cannot be separated at all.

0.25

Modelling lock-in of AI adoption through skill erosion

cs.AI physics.soc-ph ·2026-11-03 ·Renaud Lambiotte
similarity 0.53
Abstract · 10 pages, 4 figures

Generative AI can improve immediate performance but may erode the human skills required for future work. We study a model in which individuals tend to imitate successful peers, while their independent skills grow with practice and erode with reliance on AI. Because each agent's skill reflects their history, non-users and AI users develop different skill distributions, which we derive exactly. Skill erosion can produce bistability and hysteresis between a low-adoption, high-skill state and a high-adoption, low-skill state. When agents rarely change behaviour at random, the two transitions are asymmetric. A single AI user spreads through a population of experts only if AI-assisted work earns more than expert work, whatever the timescale of skill adaptation. A single non-user, by contrast, can lead an AI-dependent population back to independent work only if they regain enough skill before returning to AI, which becomes easier the more persistent behaviours are. As AI improves, adoption can jump abruptly, and a sufficiently long increase in its benefit, such as a period of low prices, can leave a population relying on AI after the benefit has returned to its initial value. Skill erosion thus creates a history-dependent switching cost that can make widespread AI adoption difficult to reverse.

0.33

Governing Delegation to Generative Artificial Intelligence: Human Direction, Work-Related Orientation, and Modes of Use

cs.CY econ.GN ·2026-08-18 ·Jorge Fábrega
similarity 0.53
Abstract · 19 pages, 4 figures

Delegating cognitive operations to generative artificial intelligence redistributes execution and raises a governance problem: where human direction of the task remains. We distinguish two routes. Specified delegation places that direction before execution, through instructions, constraints, or criteria that delimit the task. Iterative coproduction places it during production, through interventions that correct or redirect provisional outputs. To examine both routes, we use aggregate monthly cells from the Anthropic Economic Index for April and May 2026. The AEI distinguishes two modes of use: 1P API, which corresponds to direct traffic through Anthropic's API, and Claude.ai, which combines activity from Chat and Cowork. On this basis, we test whether a stronger work-related orientation of human-AI interaction is associated with more specified delegation within each mode and whether the increase in the iterative profile is greater in Claude.ai than in 1P API. The main analysis uses level-0 O*NET tasks and estimates how both profiles change when an eligible record reallocates ten percentage points from personal use to work-related use. The iterative comparison is restricted to 1,411 node-month pairs observed and eligible in both modes. Specified delegation increases by 2.76 points in 1P API (95% CI: [2.30, 3.22]) and by 1.45 in Claude.ai (95% CI: [0.93, 1.97]). On the common support, iterative coproduction changes by-0.30 points in 1P API and by 0.15 in Claude.ai, yielding a between-mode difference of 0.45 points (95% CI: [0.15, 0.75]). These findings show that work-related orien tation is associated with stronger traces of prior human direction and that the observable iterative response varies across modes of use. The article shifts attention from how much the AI executes to when human direction leaves observable traces.

0.27

Impact of Expertise and Trust on AI-assisted Work

cs.HC ·2026-10-10 ·Qianou Ma, Pranav Khape, Rock Pang, Ken Koedinger, Tongshuang Wu +2 more
similarity 0.52
Abstract

Artificial intelligence (AI) agents promise to extend what users can accomplish beyond their existing expertise, but they also raise the risk of producing plausible-looking work that users may struggle to evaluate. We ask how task-relevant expertise and trust in AI shape agent-assisted work. To isolate these factors, we conduct a think-aloud study in which 20 professionals with varying data-science expertise use the same agentic tool to complete the same data-science hiring assessment, used at a major U.S. company. We find that surface productivity can come at the expense of understanding: participants who delegated more completed more of the task, but were also more likely to produce invalid solutions. Experts more often resisted this tradeoff, sacrificing completion to decompose the task and scrutinize agent outputs. Our findings call for evaluating agentic assistance not only by how much it accomplishes, but by whether users remain able to evaluate the work they produce.

0.48

Artificial Intelligence and Job Design: A Dynamic Framework

cs.CY cs.HC ·2026-10-20 ·Amin Shirangi, Todd L. Pittinsky
similarity 0.52
Abstract · 27 pages, 1 figure

This study aims to deepen the understanding of artificial intelligence's (AI) impact on work by introducing and describing the AI-Job Dynamics Framework. Drawing from sociotechnical systems theory, complexity theory, and organizational learning theories, we conceptualize AI integration as a dynamic, non-linear process with three key phases. The framework, supported by theoretical propositions, identifies how this process affects organizational decision-making structures and key job characteristics over time, emphasizing the balance between centralization and decentralization of decision-making power. AI integration initially reduces job autonomy but may lead to greater autonomy in later phases as AI becomes more embedded. Throughout this process, AI reshapes skill requirements from routine to complex cognitive and adaptive skills. In the advanced phase of AI integration, we introduce the alternative paths and varied trajectories through which AI, organizational structures, and individual work experiences evolve. We conclude by discussing the implications of this framework for future research on AI and job design.

0.26