CS Paper Radar

Optimal Correction Sets for Provable Redress of Contestable Causal Discovery

Fabrizio Russo, Giuseppe Mazzotta, Carmine Dodaro, Francesco Ricca, Francesca Toni

cs.AI ·submitted 2026-10-23 16:01 UTC · v1
position

Abstract

Constraint-based causal discovery relies on conditional-independence (CI) tests that may conflict in finite samples, leaving no causal graph that satisfies them all. Causal Assumption-based Argumentation (ABA) makes these tests explicit as defeasible commitments, and offers correspondence guarantees with a subset of them, but its existing repair procedure releases facts heuristically and offers no formal response to a user's contestation of a release. We argue that contestable causal discovery requires an inspectable repair object, a justification for it, and a predictable revision procedure for such contestations. We therefore formulate CI-fact repair as a minimum-cost correction problem and implement it in Answer Set Programming (ASP). Building on Causal ABA, we provide a compact and efficient ASP encoding of causal consistency, with soundness and completeness guarantees, and a two-way projection correspondence between optimal stable models and minimum-cost correction sets. These results establish fidelity to retained facts, subset-minimality and cost optimality of the repair, conflict-based justifications for released facts, and formally guaranteed redress under user contestations. An empirical evaluation supports the formal account: OptABA-PC retains more correct facts, reduces ambiguity in the compatible outputs, and improves graph reconstruction over Causal ABA on common benchmarks.

Comment
41 pages including appendix

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Causal Explanations for Stratified Datalog

cs.DB ·2026-08-21 ·Ratan Bahadur Thapa, Steffen Staab
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract

Rule-based reasoning with exceptions requires causal explanations that account for both present and absent facts. For positive Datalog, monotonicity allows minimal supports to determine deletion causality. Stratified negation removes that property because inserting or deleting a fact may create or destroy an answer. We study actual causes, responsibility, and robustness for safe and stratified Datalog under perfect-model semantics and interventions over a finite set of mutable extensional facts. We prove that minimal supports and inclusion-minimal outcome-changing interventions do not determine causality, while robustness radius one may coexist with unbounded minimum contingencies. Our main result characterizes the minimum contingency size of a candidate fact by compatible prime implicants for the observed and opposite outcomes. The characterization conservatively recovers support-based causality for positive Datalog and yields path--cut characterizations for blocked recursive reachability. For fixed nonrecursive stratified programs, we establish data-complexity NP-completeness for cause recognition, robustness, and responsibility, and coNP-completeness for intervention-response equivalence between two such programs.

0.51

Causal discovery needs explicit epistemic standards

cs.LG stat.MLstat.ME ·2026-11-02 ·Harald Kugler, Leonard Henckel, Sebastian Weichwald
top venueposition similarity 0.64
Abstract · This paper was accepted to the position paper track of NeurIPS 2026

There are many causal discovery algorithms, but few guiding principles for choosing between them. Methods are usually compared through three lenses: identifiability, consistency, and benchmarks. Each introduces assumptions about the data-generating process that are often untestable. We argue that there are no shared standards for comparing, prioritizing, or even discussing those assumptions. We support this claim by showing that (i) identifiability assumptions are often preferred by convention rather than by principle, (ii) uniform consistency requires further untestable assumptions, while the weaker pointwise consistency has arguably narrowed algorithm design, and (iii) benchmarks are not neutral tests but carry an epistemic role of their own: they quietly fix which regimes matter, which guarantees come into play, and what counts as success. In doing so, they shape what algorithm comparisons are taken to show and thus perform some of the same epistemic work as theory, but less transparently. In this position paper we argue for a more transparent, integrated practice: Make the epistemic standards for discussing identifiability and consistency assumptions explicit, especially their failure modes and scope conditions; design benchmarks to operationalize those standards, by stress-testing and ablating both. Then, theoretical and empirical results jointly clarify when, why, and how algorithms may work rather than accumulate as disconnected advances.

0.30

Minimum-Cost Robust Evidence Certificates for Horn Reasoning under Correlated Source Failures

cs.AI ·2026-10-19 ·Yukun Yang
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract · 9 pages, 2 figures

A small justification for a rule-based conclusion may disappear when a source is withdrawn, and multiple derivations need not provide independent evidence. We study minimum-cost certificates that preserve a Horn conclusion under every withdrawal of at most k source domains. Evidence records remain distinct from asserted facts, supporting replicated attestations and overlapping failure dependencies. Transversals of minimal-support footprints characterize robustness and explain why disjoint-proof requirements can reject valid certificates. An exact procedure alternates weighted evidence selection with a source-failure oracle. A rule-closed counterinterpretation yields a globally valid selection cut without enumerating supports or failure scenarios. We prove correctness, finite termination, and cost optimality, establish coNP-completeness of unrestricted verification and NP-completeness of synthesis for every fixed budget, and identify a tractable reachability restriction. Experiments on controlled benchmarks, reachability graphs, and ontology-derived instances demonstrate that our counterinterpretation-guided synthesis achieves up to 92% optimum coverage within practical resource bounds, outperforming scenario expansion and general abduction while confirming the necessity of transversal-based reasoning over proof-packing heuristics.

0.22

AgentCBO: Causal Belief Routing for Bayesian Optimization under Unknown Graphs

cs.LG ·2026-10-31 ·Qiyu Wei, Xin Zhang, Richard Allmendinger, Mauricio A Álvarez
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Causal Bayesian optimization (CBO) typically relies on the unrealistic assumption of a perfectly known causal graph. Recent methods relax this constraint by coupling optimization with structure learning, but they often waste sample budgets on structural uncertainties that are irrelevant to the optimizer. In this paper, we formalize routing-equivalence to shift the objective from full causal-graph recovery to causal belief routing, where structural differences only matter when they alter optimizer-facing objects such as admissible exploration sets and do-priors. Furthermore, we propose agentcbo, a graph-belief routing framework that incorporates LLM causal priors through guarded proposal and commit mechanisms. Specifically, a Language-Prior Agent combines LLM beliefs with constraint-based discovery to extract a protected causal backbone alongside residual uncertain edges. A Calibration Agent and a Residual Repair Agent then refine only these uncertain structures through score-gated bounded local edits. Finally, a deterministic commit gate evaluates candidate updates using routing-proxy checks before allowing them to influence intervention selection. Across ten benchmarks, agentcbo performs comparably to known-graph CBO, demonstrating that guarded LLM priors can improve fixed-budget CBO performance.

0.26

Optimal Probabilistic Answer Set Programming: Complexity and Implementations

cs.LO cs.AI ·2026-11-06 ·Damiano Azzolini, Giuseppe Mazzotta, Francesco Ricca, Fabrizio Riguzzi
published similarity 0.61
Abstract · Accepted for publication in Theory and Practice of Logic Programming

Probabilistic Answer Set Programming (PASP) extends Answer Set Programming with the possibility of representing uncertain data. Among the possible available semantics, we focus here on the credal semantics. In this setting, prior work has focused exclusively on plain ASP programs, i.e., programs without optimization constructs. However, many real world tasks define optimality criteria over the possible solutions, which cannot be conveniently modeled with existing probabilistic ASP frameworks. In this paper, we close this gap and propose optimal Probabilistic Answer Set Programming, which extends PASP by also allowing weak constraints, which are the standard optimization construct of ASP. We define the semantics of such programs, study the computational complexity of the inference and most probable explanation tasks, and propose practical implementations based on Algebraic Model Counting and Answer Set Programming with Quantifiers. An empirical evaluation of the proposed approach on three real world tasks confirms the applicability of our framework.

0.38

Partial Identification under Causal Orders by Linear Programming

cs.AI ·2026-08-25 ·Eric Rossetto, Alessandro Antonucci
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 15 pages, 3 figures, 3 tables, 3 appendices

Non-parametric (partial) identification of counterfactual queries typically relies on a fully specified causal graph. Motivated by settings with incomplete domain knowledge, we challenge this requirement by leveraging structural assumptions that are inherently implied by the query itself. We show that any counterfactual inquiry induces a, mostly partial, topological ordering over relevant variables, which, in turn, enables an explicit query parametrisation reducing the identification task to a linear program. This allows bounding arbitrary counterfactual and nested counterfactual queries. Our work can be viewed as a generalisation of the classical bounding framework of Tian and Pearl (2000), originally developed for probabilities of causation. We also prove the \emph{tightness} of our bounds by constructing structural causal models that attain the bounds whilst being compatible with both the observed data and the query-implied order. To assess both the generality and practical utility of the proposed bounding procedure, we revisit several case studies from the literature, demonstrating how the derived bounds can be used to yield informative insights even in the absence of an input causal graph.

0.19

Certifiable Near-Optimality: A Simple Framework for Unifying Search and Refutation for (Semi)random CSPs

cs.DS ·2026-09-29 ·Prashanti Anderson, Peter Manohar, Jeff Xu
similarity 0.60
Abstract · 21 pages

A classical problem in average-case complexity is the study of random constraint satisfaction problems (CSPs). Random CSPs are traditionally studied in two different settings: refutation, where the instances are uniformly random and thus unsatisfiable with high probability, and search, where the instances are drawn from a planted model so that they are satisfiable. While there is no formal relationship between the refutation and search variants of random CSPs, known algorithms are strikingly similar with near-identical computational thresholds. In this work, we establish a formal relationship between the known algorithms for refutation and search by showing that in either case they achieve a stronger guarantee: they output an assignment $x$ along with a certificate $π$ that the fraction of constraints satisfied by $x$ is within some small $\varepsilon$ of the optimal assignment. We call this guarantee certifiable $\varepsilon$-optimality. As an application, we design new algorithms for a model of semirandom CSPs where the instance hypergraph (or scopes) is random, but the literal negation patterns are adversarially chosen and may depend on the hypergraph. For such CSPs, we give a family of algorithms that output certifiably $\varepsilon$-optimal solutions. We additionally study such semirandom CSPs in the "strong contamination model", where an adversary is allowed to corrupt an $O(δ)$-fraction of constraints after seeing the initial CSP. For such CSPs, we give an algorithm to output a certifiably $O(δ)$-optimal solution.

0.48

Guide, Not Bind: Why Defeasible Priors Fail in Augmented Lagrangian Causal Discovery

cs.LG ·2026-09-03 ·Sairam Sundararaman, Sara Girdhar, Manit Narasimha Murthy, Samrudh N, Bhaskarjyoti Das
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract · 29 pages, 6 figures

Differentiable causal discovery methods increasingly encode expert priors as forbidden-edge constraints enforced by an Augmented Lagrangian (ALM) penalty, on the assumption that a data-adaptive relaxation mechanism will discount and eventually override a rule the data consistently contradicts. We show this design, which we call \emph{guide, not bind}, fails for two independent, precisely characterized reasons, and that directly repairing both restores it only partially. First, sequential penalty-ramping ALM suppresses a wrongly-forbidden true edge before any counterfactual check can detect it: we give three necessary conditions any adaptive relaxation must satisfy to avoid this (Proposition~\ref{prop:conditions}), prove that DADU---the natural relaxation rule this paper introduces as the object of study---violates all three (Corollary~\ref{cor:dadu_failure}), and confirm the failure across 3{,}072 training runs spanning graphs from 4 to 32 nodes, where a single wrong prior suppresses a true edge in 87--97\% of trials under DADU. Second, and independent of any fix to the mechanism, we prove in closed form that the standard correlation-matching objective ties a true edge and its reverse to an identical cost of exactly $2r^2$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:tie}), not because the underlying equal-variance model is unidentifiable, but because normalizing to correlation discards exactly the variance information that would make it identifiable; covariance matching instead separates the two directions by a provable margin of at least $w_0^4$ (Lemma~\ref{lem:separation}).

0.16