CS Paper Radar

Order-selection Prophet Inequality (Almost) Goes I.I.D

Bo Peng, Zhihao Gavin Tang

cs.DS cs.GT ·submitted 2026-10-26 06:12 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

We study the order-selection prophet inequality. A gambler knows the distributions of independent nonnegative random values, chooses the order in which to inspect them, and may irrevocably accept at most one value, at the time it is revealed. Since the order is irrelevant when the values are i.i.d., no algorithm can guarantee more than the optimal i.i.d.\ ratio $Γ_\star\approx0.74544$ of the expected maximum. We give an algorithm with competitive ratio $0.74500001$, less than $4.5\times10^{-4}$ below this bound. The algorithm samples independent arrival times and uses item-dependent thresholds. It is designed so that, conditional on its value, every item is selected with probability equal to a fixed fraction of its probability of being the maximum. We show that the constructions of this form that apply one local rule to every item are exactly those given by an allocation kernel, that is, by a coupling of two uniform random variables. Requiring every rarely winning item to follow the optimal i.i.d.\ threshold path singles out a baseline kernel, for which we prove analytically a ratio $Γ_0\approx0.7389$, defined through a one-dimensional control problem. Our final kernel perturbs this baseline, and its guarantee combines analytic estimates with a rigorous computer-assisted certificate.

Comment
75 pages

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Mean-only Prophet Inequalities

cs.DS ·2026-10-17 ·Yilong Feng, Yaonan Jin, Xiaowei Wu, Xinyue Xiang
theory similarity 0.73
Abstract · 50 pages

We study mean-based algorithms for single-choice prophet inequalities: the algorithm knows the number of variables and the mean of their maximum, but not their distributions. For arbitrary independent variables in a fixed order, we can already achieve the optimal $1/2$ competitive ratio using only this mean. For i.i.d. variables and prophet secretary, however, we previously knew only a $1-1/e$ guarantee, which is far away from the ratios with full distribution information. We improve the guarantees in both settings using a simple and natural algorithm: we fix a continuous decreasing threshold function that depends only on the mean and accept the first variable exceeding its threshold. For i.i.d. variables, we prove a $0.7419$ competitive ratio. For the prophet secretary, we prove a $0.6902$ competitive ratio.

0.10

Prophet Inequalities and Online Contention Resolution for Matchoids

cs.DS ·2026-09-17 ·Calum MacRury, Pranav Nuti, Jan Vondrák
similarity 0.72
Abstract

In the classical prophet inequality, an algorithm observes a sequence of random variables with known distributions in an online fashion, and it must select one of the random variables with the goal of maximizing the expected value of its selection. The performance of the algorithm is compared to an \textit{omniscient prophet} who observes all of the random variables before having to make its selection. Combinatorial extensions of the classical prophet inequality in which the algorithm gets to pick a subset of the random variables (constrained to belong to some family of feasible sets) have been studied extensively. We study prophet inequalities with a $k$-matchoid constraint (a common generalization of a $k$-matroid intersection constraint and a $k$-bounded hypergraph matching constraint) in two common online arrival models. We give guarantees with respect to the \textit{ex-ante} fractional relaxation of the omniscient prophet, obtaining an ex-ante competitive ratio of $\frac{1}{k+1}$ in the adversarial order case, and $\frac{1-e^{-k}}{k}$ in the random order case. Using the duality framework of Lee and Singla \cite{Lee2018}, this also yields online contention resolution schemes in these settings. Our adversarial-order prophet inequality can be viewed as a generalization of a recent $\frac12$-competitive matroid prophet inequality by Kalantarzadeh and Pashkovich, 2026. This generalization introduces a new framework: coordinated weighted principal partitions across multiple matroids. Our random-order prophet inequality is a generalization of the $k=1$ matroid case of Lee and Singla, 2018. The two results improve previously known competitive ratios for $k$-matroid intersection, which were $\frac{1}{(e+o(1))k}$ and $\frac{1}{k+1}$, respectively.

0.24

Optimal Prophet Inequalities for Gain from Trade

cs.DS math.OC ·2026-09-25 ·Xujin Chen, Xiaodong Hu, Changjun Wang, Qingjie Ye
benchmark similarity 0.71
Abstract

We initiate the study of prophet trading, an online trading model in which a trader interacts with sellers and buyers who arrive in a uniformly random order and whose prices are drawn independently from a common known distribution. The trader aims to maximize the expected gain from trade (GFT), with performance measured against an omniscient prophet that knows the realized arrival order and all prices in advance. Unlike the classical prophet inequality problem, the trader must make both purchasing and selling decisions while managing the inventory, which makes both the prophet benchmark and the analysis of online algorithms substantially more intricate. For arbitrary numbers of buyers and sellers, we propose a simple threshold-based algorithm and prove a distribution-free competitive ratio of~2, which is the best possible. Our main technical contribution is an exact characterization of the inventory process induced by threshold trading. By expressing the algorithm's expected GFT in terms of the cumulative holding probability at buyer arrivals, we derive an exact formula for this inventory term, which serves as the foundation of our analysis and yields sharper guarantees in several important special cases. For balanced trading (with $n$ sellers and $n$ buyers), we improve the competitive ratio to $(2n^2-n)/((n+4^{-n}-1)(n+1))$, which is strictly less than 2 for every $n>1$. For the single-seller case, we sharpen the analysis of the fixed-threshold algorithm to obtain an asymptotic competitive ratio of $2e^2/(e^2+1)\approx1.76$. Furthermore, by exploiting the additional structure of this setting, we design an adaptive-threshold algorithm whose competitive ratio approaches $e/(e-1)\approx 1.58$. Due to a symmetry property of our general algorithmic idea, the same $1.76$-competitive guarantee also holds for the single-buyer case.

0.25

A Nearly Tight Lower Bound for Matroid Intersection Prophet Inequalities

cs.GT ·2026-09-17 ·Dimitris Fotakis, Charalampos Platanos, Thanos Tolias
theory similarity 0.69
Abstract

We study prophet inequalities under intersections of $q$ partition matroids, where an online algorithm irrevocably selects elements with independent nonnegative values drawn from known distributions and revealed in an adversarial order. We prove an $Ω(q/\log q)$ lower bound on the competitive ratio. Together with the known $O(q)$ upper bounds, this resolves, up to a logarithmic factor, the optimal dependence on $q$, an open question posed by Correa, Cristi, Fielbaum, Pollner, and Weinberg (IPCO 2022) and Saxena, Velusamy, and Weinberg (ITCS 2023). Our construction also yields an $Ω(d/\log d)$ lower bound for $d$-single-minded auctions, where buyers request fixed bundles of at most $d$ unit-capacity items. Our construction and analysis build on the big-decisions-first framework of Rubinstein and Singla (STOC 2026). Previous lower bounds for this problem hold even for i.i.d. Bernoulli values, whereas our instance uses nonidentical distributions. For i.i.d. Bernoulli values, we prove a $q^{1-o(1)}$ lower bound, improving the previous $q^{1/2+Ω(1/\log\log q)}$ of Saxena, Velusamy, and Weinber (ITCS 2023). To this end, we construct $p^p$ pairwise qualitatively independent partitions into $p$ blocks on a ground set of only $p^{2+o(1)}$ points.

0.25

Minimization Prophet Inequality with Bounded Costs

cs.DS ·2026-09-06 ·Haolong Li, Xiaowei Wu
similarity 0.69
Abstract

We study the cost-minimization prophet inequality problem, in which a decision-maker sequentially observes $n$ independent and identically distributed (IID) random variables. After each observation, the decision-maker must either accept the current realization and stop, or reject it and continue with the next variable. The goal is to minimize the selected value. Unlike the classical maximization setting, if none of the first $n-1$ values is accepted, the final realization must be selected. Esfandiari et al. (SIDMA 2017) showed that this problem does not admit constant-competitive online algorithms in general, which motivates subsequent work on restricted distribution classes, such as entire distributions (Livanos and Mehta, SODA 2024) and distributions with bounded extreme values (Livanos and Mehta, EC 2025). In this work, we focus on distributions with bounded support. For distributions supported on $[1,b]$, we characterize the competitive ratio of online algorithms as a function of both $b$ and $n$. We consider both distribution-aware and distribution-oblivious settings. In the distribution-aware case, we provide a nearly tight characterization of the optimal online algorithm, showing that its competitive ratio is at most $b^{(1-1/n)^n}$ for all $n\geq 2$. More significantly, we design a distribution-oblivious algorithm that achieves the same guarantee, with a sequence of predetermined thresholds that depend only on $b$ and $n$. Furthermore, we extend our analysis to the non-IID setting, where we show that a simple single-threshold algorithm attains an asymptotically optimal competitive ratio of $Θ(\sqrt{b})$.

0.27

Optimal Rank Lotteries for Truthful Unit-Interval Covering

cs.GT ·2026-08-25 ·Alexandros A. Voudouris
theory similarity 0.68
Abstract

In truthful interval covering, each agent has a private interval of unit length, and the goal is to decide where to place a public unit interval so as to minimize the total uncovered length while incentivizing the agents to be truthful. Previous work proposed a universally strategyproof lottery over order-statistic mechanisms with approximation ratio at most $5/3$, and established a lower bound of $3/2-o(1)$ for this class of mechanisms. We close this gap by characterizing the approximation ratio of every report-independent lottery over order-statistics. In particular, we show that, for every $n\ge2$, the optimal approximation ratio for this class is $\frac32-\frac{1}{2\lfloor n/2\rfloor}$. Beyond rank lotteries, we show that every universally strategyproof randomized mechanism has approximation ratio at least $9/8$.

0.07

Sample-Based Prophet Inequalities for Random Walks

cs.DS math.OC ·2026-09-22 ·Pieter Kleer, Johan van Leeuwaarden, Daan Noordenbos
publishedtheory similarity 0.68
Abstract · Accepted at the 22nd Conference on Web and Internet Economics (WINE 2026)

We study prophet inequalities for a random walk reward stopping problem with sample-based information. The goal is to stop as close as possible to the maximum of a random walk with i.i.d. increments, measuring performance by the ratio between the expected reward when stopping and the expected true maximum. We consider a sample-based model in which the increment distribution is unknown and the decision maker has access to $K$ independent sample paths of the reward process. For the infinite-horizon setting, we establish a sharp prophet inequality with constant $(K/(K+1))^{K+1}$. The guarantee is attained by a randomised stopping rule based on the ladder height decomposition of random walks. As $K\to\infty$, this recovers the classical $1/e$ prophet inequality from the full-information setting. For the finite-horizon setting, where the process terminates after $n$ steps, we first prove a tight no-information prophet inequality with constant $1/H_n$, where $H_n$ is the $n$-th harmonic number. For $K\ge1$ samples, we show that a prophet constant of $1/4$ is attainable. Finally, we prove that, with $K$ samples, the prophet constant is at most $(K/(K+1))^{K+1}+(6+6H_K)/H_n$ for $n\ge 2K^2$, implying convergence to the infinite-horizon constant as $n\to\infty$. Our approach combines random walk theory, including ladder heights and Spitzer's identity, with linear programming duality. Our results contribute to random walk stopping theory and to sample-based prophet inequalities for correlated rewards, an area that remains largely unexplored. To the best of our knowledge, our tight sample-based prophet inequalities are the first whose performance is parameterised exactly, rather than only up to constants, by the number of available samples.

0.20

Beyond Worst-Case Online Algorithms via Input Subsampling

cs.DS cs.GT ·2026-11-11 ·Siddhartha Banerjee, Tianle Jiang, Kamesh Munagala
published similarity 0.68
Abstract · Accepted to ITCS 2027

We study whether classical competitive ratios survive input subsampling, when both the online algorithm and the offline optimum are evaluated on the same subsampled input. We consider the canonical problems of prophet inequalities and ski-rental. In these settings, for any single subsampling rate, the classical worst-case ratios remain unchanged. We ask a stronger question: can one adversarial input remain worst-case at two distinct rates $p>q$? For prophet inequalities, in the model where the policy knows the sampling rate and learns item survival online, every instance has competitive ratio strictly below $2$ at one of the two rates, and we determine the tight simultaneous guarantee. For ski rental, in the fluid model where sampling scales the horizon, the answer depends on $q/p$. Against adversarial distributions over horizons, one unrestricted randomized algorithm achieves a strict simultaneous improvement over $e/(e-1)$ for every distribution exactly when $q/p$ is below approximately $0.34$. Requiring the algorithm to buy by the breakeven time lowers this threshold to approximately $0.31$, showing that unlike classical ski-rental algorithms, buying later can provably help in this setting. Our results therefore reveal a new form of beyond-worst-case fragility under input subsampling: instances that are worst-case at one rate need not remain hard at two rates simultaneously.

0.20