CS Paper Radar

Optimality and Impossibility in Multidimensional Strategyproof Facility Location

Jianan Lin

cs.GT ·submitted 2026-10-27 04:17 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

We study facility location in multidimensional normed spaces with the objective of minimizing social cost, the sum of agents' distances to their nearest facility. A deterministic mechanism selects $k$ facility locations based on the reports of $n$ agents and is strategyproof (SP) if no agent can reduce her distance by misreporting her location. We establish optimal approximation ratios and impossibility results. For a single facility in the Euclidean plane, we prove that the optimal approximation ratios among deterministic SP mechanisms are exactly those obtained by Goel and Hann-Caruthers [SCW 2023] for the coordinate-wise median (CM): $\frac{\sqrt{2(n^2+1)}}{n+1}$ for odd $n\ge3$ and $\sqrt{2}$ for even $n\ge4$. We remove the anonymity assumption from their optimality result. However, CM is not always optimal in non-Euclidean spaces: we give an SP mechanism that minimizes social cost exactly in $\ell_\infty^d$, whereas CM has a tight uniform approximation ratio of $2$ already in the plane. We then consider two facilities in $\ell_p$ spaces with $1<p<\infty$ and prove two impossibility results for every $n>2$. In the plane, no deterministic SP mechanism has a finite approximation ratio. In higher dimensions, the same impossibility holds for anonymous deterministic SP mechanisms. Finally, a reduction using distant agents and a limiting argument extends both impossibility results to every $k>2$ with $n>k$.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Strategic Facility Location in Euclidean Spaces

cs.GT cs.DS ·2026-09-04 ·Kim Thang Nguyen, Lucas Perotin, Bertrand Simon
similarity 0.81
Abstract

The strategic facility location problem is defined as follows: $n$ agents report their location in a metric space, and the objective is to design a \emph{mechanism} deciding the (possibly randomized) location of a facility such that agents have no incentive to lie about their position. We focus on the egalitarian cost, which means that the goal of the mechanism is to minimize the expected maximal facility-agent distance. Meanwhile, mechanisms must be \emph{truthful} (or \emph{strategyproof}): no agent may decrease their expected distance to the facility via lying on their location. Designing truthful mechanisms minimizing the approximation ratio is a well-studied problem, and the optimal solution is known for the real line. We focus in this paper on higher dimension Euclidean spaces, for which gaps remain between the best known lower and upper bounds. We first show that, maybe counter-intuitively, the problem is easier for two agents on the plane rather than on the line: the mechanism can exploit the additional dimension to prevent more efficiently agent lies. Based on this intuition, we devise lower bounds for $\mathbb R^d$ asymptotically matching the best known approximation factor of $2$ for large $d$. We also provide novel mechanism ideas, improving over the best known algorithms on the plane, and when the agents belong to $\mathbb R^d$ but the facility may use an additional dimension.

0.03

Mechanism Design for Facility Location Games Under a Prelocated Facility

cs.GT ·2026-08-31 ·Genjie Qin, Qizhi Fang, Wenjing Liu
publishedtheory similarity 0.78
Abstract

We study the problem of locating a new homogeneous facility under a prelocated facility. Here, a set of $n$ agents is located on a real line or a circle, each of whom has her location as private information, and her cost is the (expected) distance from her location to the nearest facility. Our goal is to design mechanisms which can approximately minimize the maximum cost or the social cost while eliciting agents' private information truthfully (i.e., strategy-proof). Based on real-life scenarios, we consider the problem in two settings: the general setting where each agent can be located at both sides of the prelocated facility, and the special setting where all the agents are located at the same side of the prelocated facility. For agents on a line, in the general setting, we design the best possible deterministic strategy-proof mechanism with $2$-approximation and provide a lower bound of $1.5-ε\textbf{ }(ε>0)$ for any randomized strategy-proof mechanism under the maximum cost objective. For the social cost, we obtain an upper bound of $n$ for deterministic strategy-proof mechanisms and lower bounds of $1.5$ and $1.0425$ for any deterministic strategy-proof mechanism and any randomized strategy-proof mechanism, respectively. In the special setting, we further provide a randomized strategy-proof $5/3$-approximation mechanism for the maximum cost and a deterministic strategy-proof $(n-1)$-approximation mechanism for the social cost. For agents on a circle, we provide a deterministic strategy-proof 2-approximation mechanism under the maximum cost objective.

0.39

Breaking the 4-Approximation Barrier in Strategyproof Two-Facility Location

cs.GT ·2026-08-10 ·Mengfan Ma, Bo Peng
theoryhighly cited similarity 0.77
Abstract · 23 pages, 1 figure

We study strategyproof mechanism design without transfers for the two-facility location problem in metric spaces. A mechanism selects two facility locations based on agents' reported locations; each agent incurs her distance to the nearer facility, and the objective is to minimize the expected social cost. A mechanism is strategyproof if no agent ever benefits from misreporting her location. The best approximation ratio achieved by a randomized strategyproof mechanism has been $4$, attained by the Proportional mechanism of Lu, Sun, Wang, and Zhu (EC 2010), and the best lower bound has been $1.045$, due to Lu, Wang, and Zhou (WINE 2009). Neither bound has moved since then, even on the line $\mathbb{R}$. We improve both bounds. Our main result is a randomized strategyproof mechanism with approximation ratio $11/3 \approx 3.667$ on every Ptolemaic metric space, a rich class containing all Euclidean spaces. The mechanism randomizes between the Proportional mechanism and a new mechanism that we call Global Pair. Global Pair draws an unordered pair of agents with probability proportional to their distance and opens facilities at their reported locations. Although Global Pair and Proportional each have approximation ratio $4$, the two mechanisms attain their worst-case approximation ratios on complementary instances. Randomizing between them balances these complementary weaknesses and breaks the $4$-approximation barrier. On the lower-bound side, we construct a new two-profile instance that yields a lower bound of $(1+\sqrt{2})/2 \approx 1.207$, improving upon the previous lower bound of $1.045$.

0.50

Truthful Two-Facility Location with Candidate Locations in Metric Spaces

cs.GT ·2026-10-13 ·Panagiotis Kanellopoulos, Alexandros A. Voudouris
theory similarity 0.77
Abstract

We study a truthful facility location problem in which agents have private positions in a metric space and known approval preferences over two distinct facilities. Each agent incurs a cost equal to her total distance from the facilities she approves. The goal is to locate the facilities at a given set of candidate locations so as to approximately minimize either the social cost or the max cost, while incentivizing the agents to report their positions truthfully. This problem was previously studied for line metrics and deterministic mechanisms. We first settle the approximation ratio of deterministic mechanisms for the social cost on the line by establishing a lower bound of $7$, matching the upper bound from previous work, and show that randomization leads to a strict improvement. For the max cost, we show that the previously known optimal deterministic guarantee of $3$ remains tight even for universally strategyproof mechanisms. We then turn to general metric spaces. For deterministic strategyproof mechanisms, we obtain tight approximation ratios of $2n-1$ for the social cost and $5$ for the max cost. We also show that randomization yields substantial improvements for both objectives: for the social cost, we obtain a tight characterization, while for the max cost we establish nearly matching upper and lower

0.04

Strategyproof Aggregation in Euclidean Spaces: Rigidity and Median Optimality

cs.GT ·2026-09-16 ·Jianhao Jia
theory similarity 0.77
Abstract

We study deterministic strategyproof mechanisms for facility location in finite-dimensional Euclidean spaces. For every population of at least three agents and every finite dimension, the coordinate-wise median minimizes the worst-case approximation ratio among anonymous mechanisms. Agent identities can improve the ratio at a fixed population size, and we give an explicit four-agent separation. Nevertheless, for every fixed dimension, the optimal ratio over all deterministic strategyproof mechanisms converges, as the population grows, to the supremum of the median's ratios over finite populations. Combined with the sharp bound for the median, this gives the optimal guarantee $\sqrt{6\sqrt3-8}$ uniform over populations and dimensions. The main structural ingredient is a rigidity theorem for strategyproof aggregation. We characterize unanimous, anonymous, translation-equivariant strategyproof mechanisms with bounded individual influence as fixed coordinate-wise order-statistic rules in a single orthonormal frame. We also prove that, for strategyproof mechanisms, continuity is equivalent to convexity of the full range in every finite dimension. An approximation-preserving normalization and a reflection argument yield the fixed-population anonymous comparison. To remove anonymity in the large-population limit, we develop an extraction theorem that converts a common guarantee on arbitrarily large populations into an anonymous deterministic mechanism on any prescribed finite population.

0.28

Randomized Strategyproof Facility Location: Two Facilities and Beyond

cs.GT ·2026-08-23 ·Hau Chan, Jianan Lin, Chenhao Wang
benchmark similarity 0.74
Abstract

We design and analyze randomized strategyproof mechanisms for multi-facility location under the utilitarian social-cost objective, the sum of the agents' distances to their nearest facilities. For two facilities, the Pairwise-Distance mechanism locates facilities at a pair of reported locations sampled with probability proportional to their distance. It is strategyproof on Ptolemaic spaces, including Euclidean and Hilbert spaces as special cases, and has an approximation ratio of \(4\). The resulting Hybrid-Distance mechanism is a fixed-probability mixture: it selects the classical Proportional mechanism [Lu et al., EC'10] with probability \(λ^*=\frac{5+4\sqrt3}{23}\) and Pairwise-Distance with probability $1-λ^*$. It is strategyproof on Ptolemaic spaces and has a tight approximation ratio of \(\frac{74+4\sqrt3}{23}\approx3.5186\), breaking the long-standing factor-\(4\) benchmark of [Lu et al., EC'10]. We complement the two-facility results by studying more facilities. First, for \(n\) agents and \(k=n-1\) facilities, we introduce the Inverse-Square mechanism, which omits one report with probability proportional to the inverse square of its nearest-neighbor distance and locates facilities at all remaining reports. It is strategyproof on any metric space and has an approximation ratio of \(Θ(\sqrt{n})\), improving the previous best-known ratio of \(\frac{n}{2}\) [Escoffier et al., ADT'11]. Second, for $k$ facilities on the line, we introduce the Gap-Product mechanism, which locates facilities at \(k\) reports and weights each set by the product of the gaps between consecutive selected reports. When \(k=3\), it is strategyproof and has a \(6\)-approximation, replacing the previous \(n\)-dependent guarantee [Fotakis and Tzamos, EC'13] by a constant, whereas it is not strategyproof for any \(k\ge4\).

0.43

Maximum-Cost Strategic Facility Location: The Limits of Randomization

cs.GT ·2026-08-17 ·Jabari Hastings, Misha Ivkov
similarity 0.73
Abstract · 15 pages

We consider strategic facility location in Euclidean space $\mathbb R^d$, where a mechanism selects a single facility based on the reported locations of $n$ agents and seeks to minimize the maximum distance from any agent to the facility. The optimal approximation ratio of deterministic strategyproof mechanisms is $2$. Whether randomization can yield a universal constant improvement over this factor has remained a major open question. We show that for $d \geq 2$, every strategyproof-in-expectation mechanism has approximation ratio at least \[ α(\mathcal M) \ge 2 - e^{-Θ(\sqrt d)} - O\left(n^{-2/(d-1)}\right). \] Therefore, no strategyproof-in-expectation mechanism can guarantee a $(2-\varepsilon)$-approximation uniformly over all $n$ and $d$, for any universal constant $\varepsilon>0$.

0.38

A Randomized $\frac32$-Approximation for Strategic Facility Location on a Circle

cs.GT ·2026-09-11 ·Hau Chan, Jianan Lin, Chenhao Wang
theory similarity 0.71
Abstract · v1 is finished in June 2026, and v2 is revised with the assistance of GPT Astra-6

We study strategyproof mechanisms for locating a single facility on a circle so as to serve a set of strategic agents under the utilitarian social cost objective. We analyze a simple parity-dependent mechanism that randomizes between the Random Dictator (RD) mechanism and the Proportional Circle Distance (PCD) mechanism. For an odd number \(n\) of agents, this mechanism mixes RD and PCD with equal probability, as originally proposed by Rogowski and Dziubi{ń}ski (IJCAI 2025). For even \(n\), it mixes RD with a random-deletion extension of PCD, in which one agent is removed uniformly at random before PCD is applied to the remaining agents. Our main result shows that this mechanism is strategyproof and achieves an approximation ratio of \(\frac32\) for every \(n\ge 3\). This improves the \(\frac74\) upper bound of Rogowski and Dziubi{ń}ski, which applied only to odd \(n\), and extends the guarantee to even numbers of agents. Finally, we establish a computer-assisted lower bound of \(1.088187\ldots\) on the approximation ratio of any randomized strategyproof mechanism, improving on the previous lower bound of \(1.0456\) due to Meir (SAGT 2019).

0.34