CS Paper Radar

Characterizing Maximum Nash Welfare: Envy-Freeness and Proportionality

Karen Frilya Celine, Warut Suksompong, Nicholas Teh

cs.GT econ.TH ·submitted 2026-10-27 06:27 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

When allocating indivisible goods, the maximum Nash welfare rule is known to be the unique welfarist rule satisfying envy-freeness up to one good. We strengthen this characterization by showing that envy-freeness up to one good can be replaced by substantially weaker fairness requirements: envy-freeness up to $k$ goods or proportionality up to $k$ goods, for any fixed $k$. Our characterization holds even for profiles with identical goods.

Journal ref
Economics Letters, 269:113310 (2026)
DOI
10.1016/j.econlet.2026.113310

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Envy-Free Allocation of Indivisible Goods under Leontief Preferences

cs.GT cs.CC ·2026-09-23 ·Tanmay Inamdar, Pallavi Jain, Pranjal Pandey
theory similarity 0.78
Abstract

Envy-freeness is a fundamental notion of fairness in the allocation of indivisible goods. In this paper, we study envy-free allocation under Leontief preferences, which model perfect complements. Although Leontief preferences have been extensively studied in the context of allocating divisible goods and market equilibria, they have received comparatively little attention for the allocation of indivisible goods. We show that, unlike additive valuations in cardinal preferences, an envy-free allocation always exists for Leontief preferences when there are at least two goods. In contrast, envy-free allocations may fail to exist when there is a single good, however it can be decided in polynomial time. We next study the problem of computing a welfare-maximizing envy-free allocation. We prove that this problem is NP-hard in general, whereas it is polynomial-time solvable when there is only a single good or agents have identical demands. Finally, we investigate the parameterized complexity of this problem.

0.03

Reaching Fairness by Reallocating Goods

cs.GT ·2026-08-31 ·Robert Bredereck, Eva Deltl, Tanmay Inamdar, Pallavi Jain, Pranjal Pandey +1 more
similarity 0.77
Abstract

Fair allocation of indivisible goods has largely been studied under the assumption that no prior allocation exists. Motivated by practical settings with pre-existing (and possibly unfair) allocations, we study how to achieve fairness through limited reallocations. Building on recent work on reformability/reallocations, we consider three fairness notions---envy-freeness (EF), envy-freeness up to one good (EF1), and envy-freeness up to any good (EFX)---and optimize the number of goods reallocated. We analyze both the classical and parameterized complexity of these problems, providing a comprehensive analysis across multiple fairness notions.

0.37

Best-of-Both-Worlds Fair Division via Subsidies

cs.GT ·2026-10-10 ·Surya Panchapakesan, Rohit Vaish
theory similarity 0.76
Abstract · 16 pages in main body, 1 page appendix

We study the relationship between fair division with $\textit{subsidies}$ and $\textit{best-of-both-worlds}$ (BoBW) fairness for indivisible items. We prove a general reduction of BoBW existence to envy-freeability. Specifically, for any scale-free ex-post property $P$ (e.g., EF1, EFX, PO) and any scale-free valuation class $\mathcal{V}$ (e.g, additive, submodular, subadditive, monotone), if every instance in $\mathcal{V}$ admits a $P$-allocation that can be made envy-free using subsidies, then every such instance admits an ex-ante envy-free lottery supported on $P$-allocations. The proof uses linear programming duality. As applications, the reduction gives alternative proofs of BoBW existence results for additive goods, chores, and mixtures of goods and chores. The converse of our general reduction holds for two agents but fails for three: We provide a four-good counterexample with monotone submodular valuations where an ex-ante envy-free and ex-post EF1 lottery exists, but no allocation is simultaneously EF1 and envy-freeable. For lexicographic valuations, we prove simultaneous EFX, Pareto optimality, and envy-freeability (and hence BoBW guarantees for EFX+PO) for three agents, and show that even EFX and envy-freeability can be incompatible for four agents.

0.16

Fair Division Under Boolean Valuations: Beyond Normalization

cs.GT ·2026-08-30 ·Nisarg Shah, Paritosh Verma
similarity 0.74
Abstract

We study fair division of indivisible items when agents have arbitrary two-level preferences: the value of each agent for any set of items is Boolean, which need not be monotone or additive. Notably, we do not impose the standard assumption of normalization, i.e., different agents may value the empty set at different Boolean levels. Since the preferences are nonmonotone, envy-freeness up to one item (EF1) and envy-freeness up to any item (EFX) each admit several variants, depending on which items are tested for removal and whether they are removed from the envious agent's bundle or the envied agent's bundle. This paper investigates the existence of these variants of EF1 and EFX, on their own and together with economic efficiency, incentive compatibility, feasibility constraints, and lottery-based randomization. Our results highlight that the existence landscape depends crucially on the number of normalized agents, who value the empty bundle at the lower Boolean level. The authors used significant assistance from GPT-5.6-Sol for deriving theoretical results, verified any AI-generated proofs for correctness, and expanded on the exposition and simplified arguments, with the aid of GPT-5.6-Sol and Claude Opus 5.

0.17

Envy-Free Chore Allocation with Unit Subsidies under Negative Dichotomous Valuations

cs.GT ·2026-09-13 ·Mainak Sarkar, Soumyarup Sadhukhan
theory similarity 0.73
Abstract · Revised version: Added a unit-subsidy guarantee for objective mixed instances with signed binary marginals, along with additional results on…

We study the allocation of indivisible chores with subsidies under negative dichotomous valuations, where the marginal disutility of every chore is either zero or one. This is the chore analogue of the dichotomous goods model of Barman et al. (2022), for which a subsidy of at most one unit per agent is known to suffice for envy-freeness. Our main contribution is to show that the same optimal guarantee holds for chores under no structural assumption beyond binary marginals. For every instance with negative dichotomous valuations, there exists a complete allocation $\mathcal{A}$ and a subsidy vector $p\in\{0,1\}^n$ with $\sum_{i\in N} p_i\le n-1$ such that $(\mathcal{A},p)$ is envy-free. Moreover, $\mathcal{A}$ is EF1 even before subsidies are paid. The subsidy bound is tight, and both the allocation and the subsidies can be computed in polynomial time in the value-oracle model. Unlike in the corresponding goods setting, a natural incremental extension approach does not work for chores. Our proof instead exploits key properties of an envy-free partial allocation and its associated equality graph to complete the allocation and determine which agents require subsidies. As a further extension of the main theorem, we establish the same optimal unit-subsidy guarantee for objective mixed instances with signed binary marginals, where every item is a good for all agents or a chore for all agents; these valuations need not be additive. The key step is to prove that the goods-side extension argument of Barman et al.~\cite{BKNS22} remains valid even when the previously allocated bundles contain chores. Finally, even for negative dichotomous chore valuations, we show that the unit-subsidy guarantee cannot, in general, be maintained if Pareto optimality is also required.

0.14

On the Incompatibility of Weighted PROPX and Pareto Optimality for Indivisible Chores

cs.GT ·2026-08-17 ·Haris Aziz, Bo Li
theory similarity 0.73
Abstract

Proportionality (PROP) is one of the simplest fairness criteria for allocating items among agents with additive preferences. With indivisible chores, however, PROP is not always satisfiable. We study proportionality up to any item (PROPX), which requires every agent to satisfy proportionality after any chore is removed from her bundle. Under strictly positive costs, we settle the weighted compatibility question negatively: weighted PROPX and Pareto optimality are incompatible already for two agents and four chores. Moreover, for every $n\geq3$, we give an $n$-agent, $(n+1)$-chore counterexample whose shares can be arbitrarily close to equal. These counterexamples are item-minimal: under strictly positive costs, weighted PROPX and Pareto optimality are always compatible when the number of chores is at most the number of agents, and they are compatible for two agents with at most three chores. Our impossibility result contrasts with the compatibility theorem of Mahara (2026) for weighted envy-freeness up to one item (EF1) and Pareto optimality .

0.04

Multilevel Fair Allocation under Additive Preferences

cs.GT cs.AIcs.MA ·2026-08-25 ·Maxime Lucet, Nawal Benabbou, Aurélie Beynier, Nicolas Maudet
publishedtheory similarity 0.72
Abstract · Accepted at the 9th International conference on Algorithmic Decision Theory

We study multilevel fair resource allocation with tree-structured hierarchical relations among agents. At each level, the problem can be viewed locally as allocating an agent's bundle to its children, the overall allocation being a trace of this process iterated down to the leaves. Assuming that internal nodes' utilities are the utilitarian welfare of their children, and the leaves have classical additive utilities over items, we first propose multilevel adaptations of usual envy-based fairness notions (e.g., WEF1). We present three adaptations and show that the choice among them is not neutral. We prove that, under identical preferences, the three adapted envy-based notions coincide, and that the Multilevel extension of Weighted Round Robin (Chakraborty et al., 2021) (MWRR) guarantees them. We then show that under general preferences, MWRR may guarantee some notions while failing others. Finally, through experiments, we show that MWRR may still perform well even for adaptations it does not formally guarantee.

0.26

Subquadratic Subsidies for Nonnegative or Nonpositive Valuations

cs.GT ·2026-09-08 ·Max Dupré la Tour, Mashbat Suzuki
theory similarity 0.72
Abstract

We study envy-freeness with subsidies for indivisible items beyond additive valuations. Assuming that every single-item marginal value lies in $[-1,1]$, we prove that a total subsidy of $O(n^{3/2}\sqrt{\log n})$ suffices to achieve envy-freeness among $n$ agents whenever all agents assign nonnegative values to every bundle or all assign nonpositive values to every bundle. These valuation classes include monotone goods and monotone chores, respectively, but do not require monotonicity. Our result establishes the first subquadratic total-subsidy bound for general monotone valuations that holds for every number of agents.

0.37