CS Paper Radar

A Counterexample to KL1 Completeness and a Complete Disjunctive Calculus

Damiano Presa, Fabio Aurelio D'Asaro, Massimiliano Badino

cs.LO ·submitted 2026-10-27 12:06 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

The logic KL$_1$ of Evans, Sergot and Stephenson formalizes Kant's rules as conditional imperatives $B \square\to C$ and permissives $B \diamond\to C$ over acts. Its consequence relation is operational: a rule follows from a set of rules when adjoining it leaves the set of outcomes unchanged for every input. The authors proved their calculus sound and conjectured that it is complete. We show that the conjecture fails: for distinct atoms $b,c,d$ the rules $\top \diamond\to b \lor d$, $b \diamond\to c$, $d \diamond\to c$ and $c \square\to b \lor d$ entail $\top \diamond\to c$, which is not derivable. Non-derivability is proved by an invariant that holds at every derivation depth and for arbitrary intermediate atoms. The obstruction is the side condition of may-trans, which requires each new act to bring with it a single intermediary act. Replacing it by a disjunctive side condition yields may-trans-disj, a strict generalization from which the original rule is derivable. Using a local characterization of entailment, we prove the repaired calculus sound for arbitrary sets of rules and complete for finite ones, and we show that, with finite inputs, completeness cannot be extended to infinite sets. The main results on KL$_1$ are formalized in Agda. For KL$_2$ we observe that the published reduction to KL$_1$ passes through infinite rule sets; re-establishing the decomposition for finite rule sets, we prove that KL$_2$ with the disjunctive rule is sound and complete for finite sets of rules. We close with remarks on KL$_3$ and on the significance of completeness for the relation between the operational and the inferential questions of Kant's logic.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Restricted Peirce's Law and Natural Deduction

cs.LO ·2026-10-29 ·Satoru Niki
publishedtheoryhot direction similarity 0.62
Abstract · In Proceedings NCL'26, arXiv:2610.34489

The constructive logic JP' is known to be the weakest logic between intuitionistic and minimal logic that satisfies Glivenko's theorem. In spite of this natural and desirable formal property, the motivation for its notion of negation remains rather elusive: it can be characterised by a restriction of Peirce's law or by the double negation of ex falso quodlibet, neither of which is very intuitive. In order to have an alternative perspective on this negation, we study in this paper a couple of natural deduction systems for JP'. We first present a system that is normalisable and satisfies a restricted form of the subformula property. Then a modification of this system is introduced, whose rules satisfy the separation of connectives and the full subformula property. Afterwards we turn our attention to a typed lambda-calculus, with respect to which our natural deduction enjoys the Curry-Howard correspondence, followed by a concluding discussion.

0.40

Natural Deduction Derivations as Directed Acyclic Proof Graphs

cs.LO ·2026-10-19 ·Jonathan Chan, Aaron Stump
similarity 0.60
Abstract

In conventional natural deduction, a proof of a proposition is a derivation tree constructed out of inference rules with some number of premises and a conclusion judgement. For propositional logic, in contrast to the other connectives, the rule for disjunction elimination of $A \vee B$ involves concluding with an auxiliary formula C from $A \vdash C$ and $B \vdash C$. Not only is this asymmetry unsightly, it also introduces the need for commuting conversions across disjunction eliminations to transform between proof derivations that are morally equivalent but not $βη$-equivalent. To resolve the asymmetry, Jean-Yves Girard suggests a disjunction elimination rule with multiple conclusions A and B, but claims that "we have no way of bringing them back together". In this work, we pursue Girard's proposal using the key insight that proof derivations need not be trees, but may be directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) in general. Derivation rules are represented as nodes, premises as incoming edges, and conclusions as outgoing edges. Treating derivations as DAGs permits using the alternate rule by ensuring that the subderivations pointed at by each conclusion eventually join up at a new concluding node. Commuting conversions can then be formulated in terms of interactions with this join node. We explore ways to design a proof graph language with reduction and commutation rules such that proof simplification retains its concluding judgements, i.e. type preservation. In particular, we examine two styles of reduction rules: a local style, which only requires looking at the relevant subgraph of a whole proof but necessitates a number of extraneous constructs to satisfy type preservation; and a global style, which doesn't require all the extraneous constructs but necessitates looking at the entire proof graph as a whole.

0.23

New Proofs of Weak Normalization for Propositional Logic

cs.LO ·2026-09-13 ·S P Suresh
similarity 0.58
Abstract

We present new proofs of weak normalization for intuitionistic and classical propositional logics (with the full set of operators -- falsum, implication, conjunction and disjunction). These proofs work with cuts rather than cut segments, and they provide explicit ``local'' rules for determining whether to contract a whole proof or reduce one of its subproofs, and in the latter case, which subproof to reduce. Interestingly, much of the complication in the case of intuitionistic logic is due to the disjunction elimination rule, while our version of the same rule for classical logic has falsum as conclusion always, and so is much easier to handle. All the complication in the case of classical logic shifts to cuts involving the reductio ad absurdum rule. We also discuss a formalization of the entire proof in Lean, and present a deterministic algorithm for weak normalization.

0.20

An Exponential Succinctness Gap between Three-Variable Logic and the Calculus of Relations

cs.LO cs.CC ·2026-09-22 ·Yuya Uezato, Yoshiki Nakamura
theory similarity 0.57
Abstract · v2: Simplified the construction, streamlined the exposition, and added a subexponential circuit upper bound for fixed vocabularies and expon…

Three-variable first-order logic ($\mathrm{FO}^3$) and the calculus of relations (CoR) define the same binary queries, an equivalence that goes back to Tarski's work in the 1940s. The classical translation from $\mathrm{FO}^3$ to CoR is single-exponential, but it has remained open whether this blowup is necessary. We prove that it is, even over finite structures and even for circuits that share subterms. Our proof introduces a new technique: we modify a single finite structure in exponentially many local ways, each changing the answer of a short $\mathrm{FO}^3$ formula $\varphi$. In any CoR circuit $C$ equivalent to $\varphi$, only compositions of binary relations can notice these modifications, and each composition can notice at most two; thus, $C$ requires exponentially many compositions. The same technique gives an exponential succinctness gap between $\mathrm{FO}^3$ and $\mathrm{FO}^2$, and exponential lower bounds for matrix query languages over the Boolean and tropical semirings, where the analogous question was also open.

0.22

Tracking relevance syntactically: A nested approach to weak relevant logic

cs.LO ·2026-11-12 ·Fabio De Martin Polo, Han Gao
theory similarity 0.57
Abstract

The variable-sharing property (VSP) is regarded as a key feature of relevant logics, while the Craig interpolation property (CIP), formulated with respect to relevant implication, implies the VSP in constant-free propositional languages. However, to the best of our knowledge, no constant-free distributive relevant logic has previously been shown to enjoy the CIP. This absence of positive results has contributed to a widespread impression among relevant logicians that relevance and Craig interpolation are incompatible. In this work, we address this tension by proving that the negation-free fragment of base relevant logic B, denoted B+, enjoys both properties. Our proof is purely syntactic and is based on a novel nested sequent calculus featuring binary relevant blocks as primitive structural constructs. Unlike conventional nested sequent calculi, where unary nesting reflects the binary accessibility relation of Kripke semantics, our calculus employs a binary nesting operator that directly reflects the ternary relational structure of Routley-Meyer semantics for relevant logics. After establishing soundness and cut-free completeness of the calculus, we prove several meta-logical properties for the logic. Most notably, we provide the first syntactic proof of the VSP (along with a variety of its stronger variants) and the first proof of the CIP for B+, both derived directly from the cut-free system using a structural notion internalized within nested sequents.

0.26

Completeness and incompleteness of basic matching logic

cs.LO ·2026-08-13 ·Xiaohong Chen, Grigore Rosu
theory similarity 0.55
Abstract

Basic matching logic is matching logic without definedness. Symbols are interpreted as set-valued operations, element variables denote singletons and are bound by $\exists$, and no connective uniformly internalizes totality. For basic matching logic without fixpoints over an arbitrary one-sorted finitary signature, we prove \emph{global completeness} ($Γ\vDash\varphi$ iff $Γ\vdash\varphi$, for arbitrary, possibly infinite $Γ$) and, as a corollary, conservativity of the definedness extension. The proof localizes $Γ$ to a theory $Δ_Γ$ and reduces semantic consequence and derivability to the same local relation: $Γ\vDash\varphi$ iff $Δ_Γ\vDash_\text{loc}\varphi$ iff $Γ\vdash\varphi$. A double-cover construction establishes the semantic equivalence. Least fixpoints destroy effective axiomatizability. Over a signature with one unary and two binary symbols and no constants, validity is not recursively enumerable; hence no sound calculus with a recursively enumerable proof relation is even weakly complete, already for the empty theory and without definedness. The positive result is also sharp in the number of sorts. Global completeness fails with three sorts for a satisfiable $Γ$. Thus the completeness conjecture holds for one sort and fails in general. The negative results arise from sort flow, fixpoint effectivity, and, for hybrid logic, an obstruction to every well-founded calculus whose leaves are hypotheses or valid patterns and whose rules respect localization. This yields a matching-logic-independent dichotomy: the language with state variables bound by $\exists$ and $\forall$ over modalities of arbitrary arity is globally complete without nominals, while no calculus in that well-founded class is globally complete once nominals are added.

0.04

Self-extensional logics of formal inconsistency: Decidability and limits for paraconsistency

cs.LO ·2026-08-28 ·Marcelo E. Coniglio, Héctor Federico Mallea
theory similarity 0.54
Abstract · Revised and expanded version. coNP-completeness was proved for the principal extensions containing at least one of the six minimal explosive…

RmbC is a self-extensional paraconsistent logic in the family of Logics of Formal Inconsistency (LFIs). This system is obtained from mbC (the basic LFI) by adding the replacement property via two global inference rules. RmbC is characterized by a non-explosive negation $\neg$ and a consistency operator $\circ$, which recovers the principle of explosion in a controlled way. Together with its principal axiomatic extensions, RmbC admits a standard Lindenbaum-Tarski algebraization, with Boolean algebras with LFI operators (BALFIs) as its algebraic semantics. In this paper, we study how far this self-extensional paraconsistent behavior can be extended axiomatically, starting from RmbC. We classify pairs of very natural consistency axioms according to whether they preserve paraconsistency or force classical collapse; identify six minimal explosive combinations that collapse to a single algebraic core; and isolate a separate structural obstruction for the combination of excluded middle for $\neg$ with an involutive negation. We also investigate, for the first time, the decidability of this family of self-extensional LFIs. As a first result, we prove the finite model property for RmbC with respect to BALFI semantics via an algebraic filtration, which yields decidability, and transfer this result to several paraconsistent axiomatic extensions of RmbC. Finally, we establish a coNEXPTIME upper bound for the validity problem of RmbC and a coNP-hardness lower bound, and prove coNP-completeness for the principal extensions containing one of the six minimal explosive pairs.

0.18

Decidability of Elementary Modal Logics is Undecidable

cs.LO ·2026-11-08 ·Jakub Michaliszyn
theory similarity 0.54
Abstract

We study the decidability of modal satisfiability over classes of Kripke frames defined by universal first-order sentences. Although some such classes yield undecidable satisfiability problems, decidability is guaranteed for wide families of frame conditions, including universal Horn sentences and universal sentences implying transitivity. A more than decade-old open problem asks a natural question: can decidable and undecidable cases be distinguished algorithmically? We prove that this is impossible, already for equality-free universal frame conditions over a single binary relation. More precisely, there is no algorithm that, given such a condition, decides whether its associated local modal satisfiability problem is decidable. We first establish the result for conditions with equality and then eliminate equality by passing to quotients of worlds with identical incoming and outgoing edges.

0.16