CS Paper Radar

Extending the W3C Data Privacy Vocabulary to Cover the German Health Data Use Act - Lessons Learned

Julian Flake, Christian Henke, Alessandra S. Kuntz, Matthias Löbe, Harshvardhan J. Pandit, Christian Draeger

cs.CY ·submitted 2026-10-27 16:48 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

Finding, sharing, and reusing data requires common interoperable vocabularies to adequately describe machine-actionable data policies. Semantic Web standards are a proven way to express such information describing data access and reuse. Narrative descriptions get a stable and agreed meaning by formal definitions of terms that have a globally unique identifier. The Data Privacy Vocabulary (DPV) represents a community standard for privacy, data protection, and related topics. DPV uses modular namespaces to define jurisdictions, such as "EU", and to represent concepts from laws within that jurisdiction, such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the European Health Data Space (EHDS). In this work, we present the creation of a DPV extension representing the German Health Data Use Act (Gesundheitsdatennutzungsgesetz (GDNG)) that has been set into force in March 2024. The GDNG regulates sharing and using health data for secondary use, such as research purposes and policymaking. It builds the German legal foundation for the future EHDS as the European initiative and regulation providing rules for sharing of health data within Europe. The parallel development of the EHDS and GDNG extensions resulted in many shared concepts, which contributed to an overarching extension: the DPV sector health extension. It sets the foundation of aligned privacy terms for future EHDS member states looking to build a national vocabulary aligned with the EHDS. All extensions were released as draft extensions with the latest DPV version 2.3, released 25th of February 2026.

DOI
10.3233/SHTI261013

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Usage Control in Public Data Exchange Infrastructures for Future Digital Governance

cs.SE ·2026-09-11 ·Oleksandr Kosenkov, Fathiyeh Faghih, Eric Jackson, Theo Dimitrakos
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Public data exchange infrastructures, such as X-Road, are essential to data-intensive digital public services and the EU digital economy. Their next generation requires advanced data usage control (DUC) mechanisms that address emerging requirements, including privacy by design, to mitigate privacy threats inherent in large-scale automated data exchange. Although research within the individual disciplines already addresses many of the emerging requirements, significant practical challenges arise at the intersection of the disciplines. This paper analytically examines the practical challenges and requirements of data usage control in public data exchange infrastructures. We examine the Estonian X-Road system and emerging use cases through an interdisciplinary lens that integrates formal verification and monitoring of usage control, requirements engineering, and digital governance research. We formulate key requirements and propose a conceptual vision for developing usage control in public data-exchange infrastructures to enable future digital-governance systems to comply with privacy requirements by design.

0.19

PrivDev: Mapping Static-Analysis Data Types to DPV

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-10-02 ·Simon Bernbeck, Ricardo Ramalho, Matheus Amendoeira, Juliana Alves Pereira
published similarity 0.60
Abstract · 7 pages, 1 figure, 4 tables. Published at the 14th Workshop on Software Visualization, Maintenance and Evolution (VEM 2026), part of CBSoft …

Static-analysis scanners can identify personal-data types in source code, but they lack mechanisms to connect these findings to standardized privacy vocabularies. PrivDev maps 122 Bearer CLI data types to Data Privacy Vocabulary Personal Data (DPV-PD) categories and links them to potentially relevant GDPR provisions. Our approach combines deterministic mapping for 43 exact-label matches with a retrieval-grounded Large Language Model (LLM) to resolve the remaining 79 non-trivial mappings. The resulting RDF knowledge graph contains 118 ODRL policy resources that were structurally validated using SHACL. The artifact passed five complementary validation gates that cover structural correctness, query consistency, retrieval quality, LLM-based assessment, and human evaluation. In human evaluation, nine annotators produced 711 judgments, yielding a raw agreement of 0.72, Gwet's AC1 of 0.68, and Gwet's AC2 of 0.88. Our results indicate that the proposed mappings are plausible and reproducible, while also revealing ambiguities in scanner-defined data-type labels and coverage gaps in DPV-PD.

0.34

Extracting Semantics from Cattle Reporting Categories for Data Interoperability and Findability

cs.IR ·2026-09-08 ·Kassy Raymond, Andrew Hamilton-Wright, Deborah Stacey
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Livestock population data disaggregated by age, sex, and production are important inputs to calculations and models that inform our understanding of global health, yet these data are fragmented across disparate sources. Bridging data siloes to improve the findability of data requires interoperability. Conventional approaches to improving the findability and interoperability of data include indexing standardized metadata. However, creating metadata is time and resource-intensive and is often difficult in domains such as livestock, which lack standards that address the needs of broad user groups. When metadata exist, they typically need to be standardized against a pre-existing vocabulary, ontology, or thesaurus, requiring a technique known as `crosswalking'. To overcome issues in the absence of metadata, the lack of standards, and the resource-intensive solutions that currently exist, this study uses a bottom-up approach. By leveraging real-world reporting categories in datasets, the composition and semantics of terms already present in the data were extracted and analyzed. Using cattle data as a pilot, we find the age, sex, and production modifiers present across cattle terms from five datasets from four data sources capture granularity not present in AGROVOC, the largest agricultural vocabulary in the world. We discuss how the composition and semantics of these terms can be used to improve the interoperability and findability of data without first requiring metadata to be generated or standards to be created. Rather than forcing datasets to conform to an existing vocabulary, this approach uses the semantics embedded in terms already present in datasets, allowing systems to make data more discoverable and interoperable while maintaining culturally and dataset-specific terminology.

0.26

A Reusable Semantic Web Framework for Evidence-Grounded Fundamental Rights Impact Assessments under the EU AI Act

cs.CY cs.AI ·2026-09-30 ·Faith Olopade, Delaram Golpayegani, David Lewis
top venue similarity 0.59
Abstract · Presented at the Fifth European Conference on Algorithmic Fairness (ECAF '26), Ghent, Belgium, 2-4 September 2026. Proceedings forthcoming i…

The EU AI Act (Art. 27) requires deployers of high-risk AI systems to conduct Fundamental Rights Impact Assessments (FRIAs) before deployment, yet the evidence needed for credible assessments is fragmented across incompatible incident repositories, risk vocabularies, and legal texts. We present a reusable Semantic Web-based framework that consolidates this evidence for two high-risk public sector categories: employment and worker management (Annex III(4)) and access to essential public services (Annex III(5)(a)). A curated 150-record corpus is annotated along four axes using keyword, LLM, and hybrid methods and serialised as a SPARQL-queryable knowledge graph of 1,351 RDF triples. Five FRIA demonstration scenarios surface 103 records (68.7% coverage). Evaluation against a 69-record gold standard reveals that LLM-assisted classification of the employment domain achieves only $κ= 0.045$, a cautionary result for automated fairness-related evidence retrieval in this domain. All artefacts are released openly to support adoption by regulators, national authorities, and SMEs.

0.39

Decoding the Legalese: A Scalable and Quantitative Framework for Analyzing Corporate Privacy Policies

cs.CR cs.CY ·2026-09-22 ·Jiaming Tang, Chenlan Wang, Mingyan Liu, Armin Sarabi
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Even though privacy policies are the primary mechanism organizations use to disclose how they collect, process, and share personal data, they are difficult for average users to interpret, perhaps by design, due to their verbosity and dense legal language. Importantly, there is a lack of standardized metrics that characterize key qualities of a privacy policy beyond regulatory requirements. Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) make it feasible to automatically structure and analyze these documents at scale. In this study, we develop and evaluate an end-to-end, LLM-enabled system that converts raw privacy policies into fine-grained structured representations and a set of quantitative measures. Our pipeline applies a detailed taxonomy to extract specific data elements and governing practices, capturing relational links that connect each practice to the data elements it references. We apply our framework to a diverse corpus of 10,000 website privacy policies, yielding, to the best of our knowledge, the most comprehensive dataset of its kind to date. Building on our structured representations, we introduce the first standardized and repeatable quantitative metrics for evaluating privacy policies along four dimensions: completeness, transparency, commitment to user protection, and emphasis on business-driven data practices. This allows us to compare policies within and across industry sectors, and to assess the tension between user protection and business interests.

0.32

Taxonomizing Synthetic Data for Law

cs.CY cs.CRcs.LG ·2026-11-11 ·Ignacio Cofone, Katherine J. Strandburg, Nicholas Tilmes
publishedposition similarity 0.56
Abstract · 29 pages

Synthetic data is increasingly important in data usage and AI design, creating novel legal and policy dilemmas. All too often, discussions of synthetic data treat it as entirely distinct from "real," collected data, overlooking the risks posed by different kinds and uses of synthetic data. We build on Michal Gal and Orla Lynskey's argument that synthetic data will transform information privacy, market competition, and data quality. While the risks posed by synthetic data depend on its connection to collected data, we argue that background knowledge and assumptions about ground truth used to create it are at least as important. We bring that focus to Gal and Lynskey's taxonomy of synthetic data, arguing that this focus is essential to grasp synthetic data's legal and policy implications. As such, we divide synthetic data into (1) transformed data, which modifies collected data to preserve certain statistical properties for an end use; (2) augmented data, which relies on assumptions to bolster a collected dataset's fidelity to the ground truth; and (3) simulated data, which relies almost entirely on background knowledge and ground-truth assumptions. Applying this taxonomy, we show that no category of synthetic data prevents privacy harms from group-based inferences, that augmented and simulated data can amplify bias while making a dataset look more complete, and that synthetic data rarely lets smaller competitors overcome incumbents' data advantages. As policymakers weigh whether to incentivize, mandate, or discourage the use of synthetic data, they should consider the validity of the ground-truth assumptions used in producing that data.

0.35

AI Risk Ontologies for the EU AI Act Compliance: AIRO, VAIR, and their Integration with DPV

cs.CY cs.AI ·2026-10-22 ·Delaram Golpayegani, Harshvardhan J. Pandit, Declan O'Sullivan, Dave Lewis
similarity 0.56
Abstract

As the use of AI, and consequently its harms, becomes more prevalent, the global discourse around AI has become increasingly risk-aware. With new risks emerging more frequently than ever, a key challenge is how to represent, document, and catalogue AI risks in an effective, interoperable, and queryable manner. Additionally, the European Union (EU) AI Act's requirements for "high-risk" AI systems to manage and document the risks creates the need for open and interoperable tools, methods, and standards that facilitate AI risk management in an ever-changing environment. In this paper, we present ontologies and taxonomies developed to assist with risk management and documentation, in line with the requirements of the EU the AI Act. We developed the AI Risk Ontology (AIRO) to specify AI use cases and their associated risks, complemented by the Vocabulary of AI Risks (VAIR), which populates AIRO with taxonomies of concepts. Key international standards on AI and risk, namely ISO/IEC 23894 on AI risk management and ISO/IEC 22989 on AI terminology informed the development of the ontologies. To promote reuse and enable multi-regulatory compliance, AIRO and VAIR have been integrated in the Data Privacy Vocabulary (DPV) through a consensus-building process, expanding DPV's scope from data to AI.

0.09

From Regulation to Implementation: A Critical Evaluation of LLM-Assisted Regulatory Compliance in Industry

cs.AI ·2026-08-21 ·Adriana Watson, Marco Bücheler, Grant Richards
similarity 0.56
Abstract · 10 pages, 4 figures

The European Union (EU) has emerged as a leading regulatory body in the development of sustainability and privacy regulations. While new regulation requirements vary, many include a documentation artifact to ensure compliance. Notably, the Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation (ESPR) introduces Digital Product Passports (DPPs) for life cycle transparency, while the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) mandates Data Protection Impact Assessments (DPIAs) to mitigate privacy risks. Creating these compliance artifacts, however, is challenging. Industrial data, which often exists in heterogeneous formats and is scattered across company and supplier systems, is required for DPPs and can be difficult to extract into compliant DPP formatting. Furthermore, DPIA documents require interdisciplinary expertise and follow no standardized format, making development difficult for novel systems. To address the particular complexity of compliance artifact creation for both regulations, researchers have proposed the use of LLMs in the generation process; however, the impact of the aforementioned problems on the output of these systems is largely unaddressed. This work investigates the existing research gap by exploring how data extraction instructions and regulatory vagueness impact the quality and consistency of LLM-produced compliance artifacts. The resulting artifacts are evaluated by benchmarking different models against manually created ground-truth schemas. The results reveal that less strict guidelines, such as DPIA formatting, require higher context prompts to maintain consistency and completeness. Stricter guidelines, such as formatting for Digital Battery Passports (DBP), result in consistent results regardless of prompt context, but may lead to more hallucinations in the output

0.20