CS Paper Radar

Extending Higher-Order Critical Pairs

Johannes Niederhauser, Aart Middeldorp

cs.LO ·submitted 2026-10-28 10:08 UTC · v1

Abstract

Confluence is a fundamental property of computation which implies that the nondeterminism of a system does not affect its outcomes. A key concept of confluence research in rewriting theory is the notion of critical pairs which captures the potential local sources of non-confluence. In this paper, we lift the definition of higher-order critical pairs to a more expressive class of higher-order rewrite systems. Thereby, we facilitate confluence analysis of rewrite systems which can express complex one-step computations as well as program transformations from functional programming.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

A new method for proving confluence on abstract reduction systems --- Confluence of non-E-overlapping weakly-shallow TRSs ---

cs.LO ·2026-10-07 ·Masahiko Sakai, Mizuhito Ogawa, Michio Oyamaguchi
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 68 pages, 17 figures

This paper proposes a new method for proving the confluence of an abstract reduction system (ARS) by clarifying the sufficient conditions, called compatibility and edge commutativity, for expanding a given finite sub-ARS into a confluent one by adding rewrite edges. This method can be regarded as an extension of our earlier work, which showed that a weakly non-overlapping, shallow, and non-collapsing term rewriting system (TRS) is confluent. Furthermore, we apply our method to demonstrate that a non-$E$-overlapping and weakly shallow TRS is confluent. Here, a term is weakly shallow if each defined function symbol occurs either at the root or in the ground subterms, and a TRS is weakly shallow if both sides of all its rewrite rules are weakly shallow. This drops the non-collapsing condition assumed in our previous work on weakly shallow TRSs. Moreover, since a weakly shallow TRS is non-$E$-overlapping whenever it is non-$ω$-overlapping, and the latter property is decidable, we also obtain a decidable sufficient condition for confluence: non-$ω$-overlapping and weakly shallow TRSs are confluent.

0.34

Decreasing Diagrams are Complete for Confluence

cs.LO ·2026-10-05 ·Jörg Endrullis, Ievgen Ivanov, Femke van Raamsdonk
theory similarity 0.65
Abstract

Confluence is a fundamental property of nondeterministic computations, arising from parallelism, concurrency, or freedom in the evaluation order. It guarantees that such a computation always yields the same result, regardless of the order in which steps are taken. The decreasing diagrams technique of van Oostrom is one of the most versatile methods for establishing confluence of transition systems (abstract rewriting systems). It reduces global confluence to local confluence: a system is confluent whenever its transitions admit a locally decreasing labeling. Essentially all classical confluence criteria arise as corollaries. A central question, posed by van Oostrom in 1993, asks whether the decreasing diagrams technique is complete: Does every confluent transition system admit a locally decreasing labeling? This is Problem 56 of the RTA List of Open Problems. A positive answer was known only for countable systems, and recently up to the first uncountable cardinal $\aleph_1$. The general case remained open. We settle this thirty-three-year-old problem in full. We prove that every confluent transition system admits a locally decreasing labeling using only three labels. This bound is optimal, as two labels do not suffice even at the first uncountable cardinality. It follows that this single criterion can, in principle, certify the confluence of every confluent system, and hence of every confluent program. The entire development is machine-checked in the Isabelle/HOL and Lean proof assistants and relies only on classical logic and the axiom of choice.

0.23

Augmenting Rewrite Rule Sets via Knuth-Bendix Completion

cs.PL ·2026-10-01 ·Michael Schifferer, Marcel Ullrich, Sebastian Hack
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Equality Saturation (EqSat) is a powerful technique for program optimization, systematically exploring the search space of candidate programs to overcome the phase ordering problem. However, the feasibility and performance of EqSat rely heavily on the specific rewrite rules used to derive equivalent programs. These rule sets are typically handcrafted, requiring extensive domain expertise and carrying the risk of missing valuable transformations. In this work, we evaluate Knuth-Bendix Completion (KBC) as a method for automatically generating and augmenting rewrite rules for EqSat. Our experiments show faster optimization as well as reaching better terms with previously missed optimizations.

0.21

On Eliminating the Impossible with Dependent Types: Choreographic Libraries with Proof-Carrying Located Values

cs.PL ·2026-08-20 ·Simon Daniel, Timon Böhler, David Richter, Pascal Weisenburger, Mira Mezini
similarity 0.59
Abstract

With growing complexity, distributed software systems become increasingly challenging to maintain and reason about. When implementing a distributed protocol, developers must ensure manually that the different components fit together. Choreographic programming addresses this challenge by specifying global protocols in a single program and projecting them into communicating processes, so-called endpoints. Recent choreographic approaches are designed as programming libraries that embed this paradigm into a host language like Haskell or Rust. In these designs, we observe common cases of partiality: unreachable branches in endpoint projection (EPP) and located-value access can trigger runtime errors or undefined behavior, relying on manual discipline of library maintainers rather than being statically type-checked. Also, some programs require users to write down dummy branches that should not be reachable, for example when branching on sum types. To close this gap, we use the dependently typed Lean programming language to implement a similar choreographic library. We show how we are able to move from a partial EPP to a total EPP function, and also eliminate cases of partiality in user-written code with pattern matching on sum types. ChorLean ensures total EPP and safe value access via proof-carrying located values, passing Lean's totality checker without undefined cases, while supporting the same feature set as libraries like MultiChor.

0.25

Linking as Evaluation: Correct Separate Compilation via First-Class Environments

cs.PL ·2026-11-03 ·Jam Kabeer Ali Khan, Jinhao Tan, Bruno C. d. S. Oliveira
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 36 pages, including references and appendices

Separate compilation is central to modular software: components are compiled independently and linked into an executable. Separate compilation is correct when a linked program behaves like the program formed by merging its sources. This property is less routine to prove than type soundness because it requires a formal account of linking. We present $λ_{\mathsf{SCE}}$, a simply typed calculus in which linking, modules, and environments are all first-class. Programmers control module linking through a link operator, which a type-directed elaboration translates into ordinary terms of a core calculus of first-class environments. The core calculus's existing evaluation rules then perform the linking: linking as evaluation. Linking independently compiled modules yields the same core term as elaborating their source link. Therefore, compilation and linking commute by construction. As a result, separate compilation correctness follows directly from the semantics preservation for both static and dynamic linking. All meta-theory is mechanized in Lean 4, and we implement a compiler to WebAssembly in OCaml.

0.25

CIRT: Calculus of Inductive Refinement Types

cs.PL cs.LO ·2026-11-16 ·Alessio Ferrarini, Niki Vazou, G. A. Kavvos
published similarity 0.58
Abstract · Extended version of the POPL 2027 paper

Refinement types are a powerful mechanism for statically verifying properties of programs. They have been successfully integrated into practical languages such as Haskell, Scala, and Rust. However, their metatheory is not yet fully understood. In this paper we present the first semantic model for a refinement type system that supports the full feature combination of subtyping, SMT-style equality, impredicative polymorphism, and (stratified) inductive types. Interactions between these features have led to inconsistencies in the past, and existing formalizations of refinement type systems omit at least one of them. We present a realizability model based on partial equivalence relations (PERs) over a Scott domain, which overcomes these obstacles. We use our model to prove the consistency of a core refinement type system and to give a semantic account of the annotation-independence property of refinement types. Our semantics uses two interpretations: a refined one, which interprets types and their refinements as PERs; and an unrefined one, consisting of complete uniform PERs with a bottom element (CUPERs), which models computational behaviour independently of refinements. We extend the model to positive and stratified inductive types, showing that both are consistent in the presence of impredicativity.

0.42

Unifying Function- and Argument-First Bidirectional Type Systems

cs.PL ·2026-09-02 ·Takuma Yoshioka, Taro Sekiyama, Atsushi Igarashi
publishedtheory similarity 0.58
Abstract · Accepted as a short version at APLAS 2026 (Springer LNCS). This extended version includes substantial new material and results

Bidirectional typing mixes type synthesis and type checking into a single process. Existing bidirectional type systems can be classified into two styles based on whether, given a function application, a bidirectional typing algorithm synthesizes the function's type first and typechecks the argument against the synthesized argument type, or it synthesizes the arguments' types first and typechecks the function against the synthesized arguments' types. We call the former _function-first_ and the latter _argument-first_. Not only do the two styles significantly differ in how the type systems and typing algorithms are formalized, but also they lead to incompatible typeabilities, forcing a language designer to select one style and to give up the other's typeabilities. In this paper, we unify the two styles and develop \lang with a new bidirectional type system for higher-rank polymorphism. Key ideas of the unification are twofold. Each function application is annotated with a bit of information to represent whether function- or argument-first typing is used, to allow a language designer (or even a programmer) to switch between the two styles at their discretion. We reformulate the function- and argument-first type systems by using ideas from colored types and boxy types, which can specify which part of a type should be synthesized or used for checking in a flexible manner. We also develop a typing algorithm based on the worklist approach by Zhao et al. The (declarative) type system of $λ^{BH}$ is shown to be sound and to subsume two representative function- and argument-first systems. Our typing algorithm is shown to be sound with respect to the type system of $λ^{BH}$ and complete with respect to representative function- and argument-first systems. We mechanically prove the metatheorems using the Abella theorem prover.

0.29

Garlene: Guarded Recursion in Lean

cs.LO cs.PL ·2026-09-21 ·Sergei Stepanenko, Patrick Bahr, Rasmus Ejlers Møgelberg
theoryhot direction similarity 0.58
Abstract

Extending the recursion principles of a formal system is an enticing but dangerous endeavour with a well-documented history of leading to consistency bugs. Nakano's guarded recursion is an elegant, type-based approach to soundly extend type theory with a powerful recursion principle. This makes guarded recursion useful for many applications, from programming with infinite structures such as streams to reasoning about advanced programming language features using synthetic guarded domain theory. Sadly, guarded recursion is not directly supported by any major interactive theorem prover, which leaves users of guarded recursion with unmechanised pen-and-paper proofs or mechanisations that depend on unmaintained theorem provers. In this paper, we present an implementation of guarded recursion as an embedded language in Lean consisting of a simply-typed lambda calculus for definitions and a higher-order logic for reasoning. Using Lean's excellent support for metaprogramming, our language allows users to write guarded recursive definitions in an intuitive syntax and to prove properties about them using a dedicated proof mode. We give our language a presheaf model, which we use to prove the soundness of our language and to allow users to export guarded recursive definitions and their theorems into standard Lean developments. To demonstrate the usefulness of our language, we present several case studies for programming and reasoning with guarded recursion.

0.24