CS Paper Radar

Tableaux Rules for Theories of Definite Descriptions in Positive Free Logic with Some Philosophical Remarks

Nils Kürbis

cs.LO ·submitted 2026-10-29 18:12 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

While Russell's theory of definite descriptions, expressions of the form 'the F', is almost incontrovertible in classical logic, in free logic matters stand differently. Several alternatives have been proposed. In Lambert's hierarchy, the weakest theory is his minimal free theory of definite descriptions (MFD), which only says that anything is the F iff it is the unique existing F, the strongest one is a chosen object theory in which all improper definite descriptions refer to the same object (FD2). Intermediate is Lambert's FD1, which adds ix(x = t) = t as an axiom to MFD. MFD is very weak. FD2 is very strong. One might hope to find intermediate systems in which ix(x = t) = t is provable from more fundamental principles. The present paper considers one avenue where one might hope to find them and closes it. Two theories, FDA and FDH, will be considered that are motivated by considerations from proof-theoretic semantics. The former turns out to be equivalent to FD2, the latter to have unreasonable consequences. A third theory, similarly motivated, is also not viable. The philosophical upshot of this is briefly discussed.

Comment
In Proceedings NCL'26, arXiv:2610.34489
Journal ref
EPTCS 455, 2026, pp. 77-90
DOI
10.4204/EPTCS.455.7

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Completeness and incompleteness of basic matching logic

cs.LO ·2026-08-13 ·Xiaohong Chen, Grigore Rosu
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract

Basic matching logic is matching logic without definedness. Symbols are interpreted as set-valued operations, element variables denote singletons and are bound by $\exists$, and no connective uniformly internalizes totality. For basic matching logic without fixpoints over an arbitrary one-sorted finitary signature, we prove \emph{global completeness} ($Γ\vDash\varphi$ iff $Γ\vdash\varphi$, for arbitrary, possibly infinite $Γ$) and, as a corollary, conservativity of the definedness extension. The proof localizes $Γ$ to a theory $Δ_Γ$ and reduces semantic consequence and derivability to the same local relation: $Γ\vDash\varphi$ iff $Δ_Γ\vDash_\text{loc}\varphi$ iff $Γ\vdash\varphi$. A double-cover construction establishes the semantic equivalence. Least fixpoints destroy effective axiomatizability. Over a signature with one unary and two binary symbols and no constants, validity is not recursively enumerable; hence no sound calculus with a recursively enumerable proof relation is even weakly complete, already for the empty theory and without definedness. The positive result is also sharp in the number of sorts. Global completeness fails with three sorts for a satisfiable $Γ$. Thus the completeness conjecture holds for one sort and fails in general. The negative results arise from sort flow, fixpoint effectivity, and, for hybrid logic, an obstruction to every well-founded calculus whose leaves are hypotheses or valid patterns and whose rules respect localization. This yields a matching-logic-independent dichotomy: the language with state variables bound by $\exists$ and $\forall$ over modalities of arbitrary arity is globally complete without nominals, while no calculus in that well-founded class is globally complete once nominals are added.

0.04

Restricted Peirce's Law and Natural Deduction

cs.LO ·2026-10-29 ·Satoru Niki
publishedtheoryhot direction similarity 0.59
Abstract · In Proceedings NCL'26, arXiv:2610.34489

The constructive logic JP' is known to be the weakest logic between intuitionistic and minimal logic that satisfies Glivenko's theorem. In spite of this natural and desirable formal property, the motivation for its notion of negation remains rather elusive: it can be characterised by a restriction of Peirce's law or by the double negation of ex falso quodlibet, neither of which is very intuitive. In order to have an alternative perspective on this negation, we study in this paper a couple of natural deduction systems for JP'. We first present a system that is normalisable and satisfies a restricted form of the subformula property. Then a modification of this system is introduced, whose rules satisfy the separation of connectives and the full subformula property. Afterwards we turn our attention to a typed lambda-calculus, with respect to which our natural deduction enjoys the Curry-Howard correspondence, followed by a concluding discussion.

0.40

Typed Knowledge over Constructive Institutions

cs.LO cs.AIcs.DB ·2026-11-05 ·Hans-Martin Will
publishedtheory similarity 0.58
Abstract

Type theories designed for mathematics or program verification need only that a proposition holds; proof irrelevance in conversion erases, at the kernel level, how a claim was established. A persistent knowledge store, by contrast, must retain that record: who established a claim, by which derivation or external tool, and under which assumptions. This volume presents the theory of Eigenius---a store of typed knowledge over constructive institutions---and develops its metatheory from that requirement. The kernel theory is a dependent type theory with cumulative universes, an impredicative universe of propositions, inductive families, and an intensional identity type. Proof irrelevance is an axiom with an explicit witness rather than a conversion rule, so proofs of a proposition are provably equal yet remain distinct terms. Definitional equality is joinability under an orthogonal rewriting system---confluent, injective on type formers, and decidable by a type-free test---while a separate subsumption judgment covers universe cumulativity, codomain-covariant function types, and declared class inclusions. We prove consistency via a set-theoretic model; develop a justification logic over the kernel's propositions to track evidence and support; organize environments as an institution so that store extensions are signature morphisms and external verdicts enter via comorphisms; formulate a typed knowledge-graph theory with records, classes, and refinements; and prove the correctness of conversion, normalization by evaluation, and bidirectional type checking relative to termination. A Lean 4 formalization accompanies the volume.

0.45

Proofs Without Nominals: Gödel's Ontological Argument, its Shallow Embedding, and the Open Questions of the Monatshefte Notes

cs.LO cs.AImath.LO ·2026-09-28 ·Christoph Benzmüller
theory similarity 0.58
Abstract · 51 pages. New in v5: the witness criterion and the whole-term condition come apart (a proof with the nominal in a context alone); three open…

The shallow embedding of higher-order modal logic in classical higher-order logic, used in Benzmüller and Scott's Notes on Gödel's and Scott's variants of the ontological argument, reaches beyond the modal object language: its quantifiers range over domains containing the nominals and satisfaction operators of hybrid logic. A proof using one proves a theorem of the embedding, not necessarily of the modal logic. Whether a result is one of the modal logic can be settled by replaying it in an explicit calculus, or, more cheaply and for all results at once, by analysing what the embedding's proofs substitute. Every statement the Notes prove has a proof in the embedding substituting nothing outside the object language, 294 of them explicit. The Notes' own proofs substitute none either; what it flags are terms a prover introduced. A soundness theorem over general models closed under the object language, and a sentence of that language the embedding proves but which fails in such a model, fix what the certificate says. The Notes' three open questions are settled too, without nominals, but by the empty instance of the conjunction axiom, too cheaply to convince. Generalised to Gödel's "any number of summands", the axiom covers the empty conjunction and the singleton. This article restricts it to at least two different conjuncts, a non-degenerate reading of Gödel's footnote, and settles them again without nominals. In effect only the empty conjunction is excluded; the singleton comes back with the other axioms. In one variant the restriction refutes the possible existence of a God-like being; the answers return, with no side condition, once the Notes' non-emptiness clause is confined to Gödel's essence. Every theorem here is verified in Isabelle/HOL and independently in Lean 4, the separating model in its propositional part; the countermodels are Nitpick's, checked by the build.

0.45

CIC + EM $\vdash$ Con(ZF): the consistency of ZF in type theory with excluded middle and no choice

cs.LO math.LO ·2026-09-19 ·Mario Carneiro
theorycode/data similarity 0.58
Abstract · 13 pages. Lean 4 formalization at https://github.com/digama0/ConZF

The sets-as-trees interpretation of set theory in a dependent type theory with an impredicative universe of propositions validates Zermelo set theory, and it validates Replacement if the type theory has a choice or description operator, which turns a functional relation into a function. It has been natural to expect that without such an operator the strength of the type theory drops well below that of $\mathrm{ZF}$. We show that it does not. In the type theory of Lean with two predicative universes, from excluded middle as the only assumption and with no axiom (no choice, no propositional extensionality, no quotients), we prove the consistency of $\mathrm{ZF}$, stated outright for a first-order proof system. The proof is formalized. The mechanism is the large elimination of the accessibility predicate over a type as large as the type of sets: a recursion on accessibility whose recursive calls are guarded by propositions, and whose later calls are indexed by the value of an earlier call, computes as a term any ordinal that is specified by a proposition through a well-founded tree of a certain shape. We give a rule that produces such a tree for every ordinal, unless some $V_ρ$ is already a model of $\mathrm{ZF}$; the rule does not choose a cofinal map into a limit ordinal but takes all definable ones at once. In the first case the sets-as-trees satisfy Replacement for arbitrary propositional relations. Either way $\mathrm{ZF}$ has a model. Finally, the double negation of excluded middle suffices, and what remains of it is exactly that membership is not not well-founded in the stable reading of sets; this in turn implies the double negation of Markov's principle.

0.46

Towards an Operational Proof-theoretic Semantics

cs.LO ·2026-10-05 ·Alexander V. Gheorghiu
hot direction similarity 0.58
Abstract

Model-theoretic semantics comes with a computational counterpart: to check validity is to search for a countermodel, and tableaux, resolution, and satisfiability solvers make the semantics something one can run. Proof-theoretic semantics -- the younger paradigm in which meaning is given by inferential role rather than by denotation -- has no established counterpart. This paper proposes one: logic programming. We show that Sandqvist's base-extension semantics for intuitionistic propositional logic is executable in a precise sense. Bases are logic programs, and to each formula $\varphi$ we assign a goal $[\![\varphi]\!]$ of a second-order hereditary Harrop language such that $\varphi$ is supported in a base $\mathcal{B}$ exactly when $[\![\varphi]\!]$ is operationally derivable from $\mathcal{B}$ read as a program. The encoding is the Russell-Prawitz translation of the connectives with quantification restricted to atoms, and this restriction is not a limitation but the point: it is what the support clauses themselves demand. The correspondence is exact base by base, not merely at the level of validity, so that intuitionistic validity becomes the success of a single query against the empty program. Logic programming stands to proof-theoretic semantics as tableaux and satisfiability solvers stand to model-theoretic semantics.

0.33

Tracking relevance syntactically: A nested approach to weak relevant logic

cs.LO ·2026-11-12 ·Fabio De Martin Polo, Han Gao
theory similarity 0.57
Abstract

The variable-sharing property (VSP) is regarded as a key feature of relevant logics, while the Craig interpolation property (CIP), formulated with respect to relevant implication, implies the VSP in constant-free propositional languages. However, to the best of our knowledge, no constant-free distributive relevant logic has previously been shown to enjoy the CIP. This absence of positive results has contributed to a widespread impression among relevant logicians that relevance and Craig interpolation are incompatible. In this work, we address this tension by proving that the negation-free fragment of base relevant logic B, denoted B+, enjoys both properties. Our proof is purely syntactic and is based on a novel nested sequent calculus featuring binary relevant blocks as primitive structural constructs. Unlike conventional nested sequent calculi, where unary nesting reflects the binary accessibility relation of Kripke semantics, our calculus employs a binary nesting operator that directly reflects the ternary relational structure of Routley-Meyer semantics for relevant logics. After establishing soundness and cut-free completeness of the calculus, we prove several meta-logical properties for the logic. Most notably, we provide the first syntactic proof of the VSP (along with a variety of its stronger variants) and the first proof of the CIP for B+, both derived directly from the cut-free system using a structural notion internalized within nested sequents.

0.26

Iris on Indirection Theory: Lightweight Higher-order Ghost State

cs.PL ·2026-10-30 ·Darius Foo, Viet-Anh Nguyen, Wei-Ngan Chin
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Today, semantic models of languages with concurrency and higher-order state are constructed using step-indexed predicates over resources and higher-order ghost state. There are two main lines of work for constructing such models. On the one hand, Iris provides these in full generality, at the cost of a large body of mechanised domain theory that is difficult to learn and port to new proof assistants. On the other hand, Indirection Theory is much simpler through the use of ordinary dependent types, but its foundation in separation algebra limits the expressiveness of its resource model compared to Iris-style higher-order ghost state. We resolve this conundrum by showing that Indirection Theory can be as expressive as Iris. To that end, we give a lightweight mechanisation of Indirection Theory in Lean, generalised so knots contain resources from an Iris-style resource algebra functor. We then reconstruct the Iris base logic on top of it. The advantage of this approach is in the elementary metatheory: a user can follow the whole construction without domain theory. We conduct two case studies to show that the base logic is expressive and faithful to Iris: a biorthogonal logical relation for higher-order state, and an Iris-style program logic with invariants and user-definable ghost state, complete enough to verify concurrent and higher-order programs.

0.36