CS Paper Radar

What We Keep of What We Forget: Replacement Operators and Routing Semantics in Training-Free MoE Expert Pruning

Ezza Ali, Sehrish Bibi, Momina Moetesum, Faisal Shafait

cs.LG cs.CL ·submitted 2026-10-30 07:31 UTC · v1

Abstract

Training-free expert pruning makes two decisions: which experts to remove, and what the layer computes when its router still selects a removed expert. Published methods change both at once. Holding the mask fixed, we compare replacement operators from three families on OLMoE, DeepSeek-V2-Lite and Moonlight, with Granite as a fourth router, using paired, multiplicity-corrected tests. The largest effect is a choice usually left implicit: the survivors' gate scale. On routers trained without top-k renormalization, renormalizing the survivors' gates, a common implementation choice, costs 0.8-8.5 points and reverses whether rerouting beats MoNE's mean-output replacement; on two routers trained with renormalization, the trained scale wins at 50% pruning. We introduce the tilted novice, a closed-form low-rank map of the pruned expert's input whose rank-0 case is MoNE's constant. At 50% pruning it adds 1.2-1.8% parameters and gains 3.45 and 1.37 points over the constant on OLMoE and Moonlight, stable across calibration draws and largely unchanged by 4- and 3-bit quantization. No operator dominates: trained-scale rerouting is best on DeepSeek-V2-Lite, and a partial copy of each pruned expert is statistically indistinguishable from the tilted novice on two models. Evaluation can change conclusions: at 25% pruning MoNE's constant keeps 92-97% of dense multiple-choice accuracy but only 5-65% of GSM8K and 0-17% of code scores, and the calibration domain moves the mask 4-9 times more than resampling. We propose a five-item reporting checklist.

Comment
56 pages, 8 figures, 76 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

RAZOR: Pruning Replaceable Experts in LLMs

cs.LG cs.CL ·2026-09-24 ·Mingyang Song, Mao Zheng
similarity 0.72
Abstract

Mixture-of-experts (MoE) models activate only a few experts per token but store the entire expert pool. Pruning this pool requires identifying experts whose removal preserves model behavior. Routing frequency and output magnitude do not fully describe deletion damage, which also depends on how the surviving and replacement experts compensate for the removed output. We introduce RAZOR, a training-free pruning method based on consensus residuals, the deviations of expert outputs from their original weighted mixture. At a fixed layer input, these residuals give the exact output change for a single deletion under survivor renormalization and router refill. RAZOR aggregates this damage by conditional root mean square and selects experts under a layerwise budget using forward computation alone, without gradients, subset search, or recovery training. Against frequency, activation-norm, and REAP baselines on GLM-4.7-Flash and Qwen3.6-35B-A3B at 25% and 50% expert removal, it attains the highest macro average over nine reasoning-intensive tasks in all four model-budget settings, gaining 2.12-5.59 points over REAP and lowering reverse KL in all four. On DeepSeek-V4-Flash-0731 and Hy3, it also achieves the highest macro average among the three residual criteria. Local exactness does not guarantee better joint pruning. Generation analyses show changes in diversity, formatting, and termination despite higher task scores.

0.43

Matching the Training-Time Weight Rule in Inference-Time Expert Deactivation

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-11-04 ·Hao Cheng, Zhiyu Yang, Bo Ma, Hanzhang Jia
similarity 0.70
Abstract · Corresponding authors: Hanzhang Jia (lead corresponding) and Bo Ma

Expert deactivation at inference time changes both token routing and expert weights, and its effect on performance depends on how these changes are implemented. We compare removal, freezing, remaining-expert renormalization, and unnormalized re-routing on identical disabled sets across five instruction-tuned checkpoints from four model families, with a base OLMoE checkpoint as an additional comparison. We develop a weight-sum model that relates the loss of expert contributions and changes in branch scale to the weight rule used during training. With half of the experts deactivated according to activation-based rankings, remaining-expert renormalization yields the highest perplexity in models trained with raw router probabilities, whereas unnormalized re-routing yields the highest perplexity in models trained with normalized weights. Perplexity ranges from 1.4 to 73 times the intact baseline when the training rule is retained, and from 14 to 28,740 times the baseline under a rule mismatch. Task outcomes vary across evaluation types: on OLMoE, GSM8K strict-match accuracy falls to zero under all four implementations. Extending the model to changes in the number of active experts yields a further prediction, supported by the OLMoE experiments: the perplexity penalty from additional renormalization increases as fewer experts are activated.

0.12

Launch-Bound and Substitutable: Why Three Inference Optimizations Fail to Pay Off in Mixture-of-Experts Models

cs.PF ·2026-08-27 ·Gokulakannan Sakthivel, Jerry Wu, Amogh Rajendra, Giriprasad Radhakrishnan
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) models route each token to a few of many expert networks, and that routing is data-dependent in a way standard inference optimizations do not expect. This paper measures what three of them actually deliver on OLMoE-1B-7B, DeepSeek-V2-Lite, and Qwen3-30B-A3B. Fused Triton kernels reach 5.6x to 9.0x in isolation but 0.999x end to end against a measured 1.07x ceiling, because the model spends its time waiting on roughly a thousand kernel launches per forward pass rather than on the arithmetic those kernels improve. INT4 quantization changes on average 0.53 of the eight selected experts per token position, yet replaying exactly those changed routes through full-precision weights reproduces only 2.7% of the quality loss, which makes the experts substitutable rather than specialized. Removing all 23 graph breaks from PyTorch's compiler, the step prior work treats as the structural fix, makes the model three times slower. A fourth result ties the three together: leaving the routers in FP16 lowers drift by 20% while raising loss, so routing fidelity and output quality are separable objectives. Every number recomputes from committed per-token route dumps.

0.37

MoRA: MoE Pruning via Router Bias Learning and Expert Approximation

cs.LG ·2026-09-30 ·Yushuai Sun, Zikun Zhou, Lin Gao, Jun Yu, Wenjie Pei
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 13 pages, 3 figures

Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) models enable parameter scaling with limited per-token computation by activating only a small subset of experts for each token, but deploying them still requires loading the complete expert pool into memory. Structured expert pruning can effectively reduce the memory usage by removing experts. However, existing pruning methods either use expert ranking criteria that are not well aligned with model performance or rely on effective expert subset searching that is computationally expensive. Moreover, these methods typically overlook the routing-behavior redundancy among the retained experts. In this paper, we propose MoE Pruning via Router Bias Learning and Expert Approximation (MoRA), a framework for structured MoE expert pruning. We introduce a learnable router bias for each expert and optimize these biases by minimizing the language-modeling loss and a routing-diversity regularizer. The learned router biases sharpen the routing probability distributions to identify experts critical to model performance while encouraging the selection of experts with diverse routing preferences. In addition, we introduce an expert approximation mechanism as a post-pruning enhancement. It leverages the remaining experts to approximate the outputs of pruned experts by affine transformation, further improving the performance of the pruned model. We evaluate MoRA on Qwen3-30B-A3B, DeepSeek-V2-Lite, and Moonlight-16B-A3B, removing 25\% and 50\% of the routed experts in each MoE layer. Extensive experiments on nine zero-shot benchmarks show that MoRA outperforms state-of-the-art pruning algorithms. Our code will be released.

0.27

GaP-MoE : Explicit Expert Specialization in Mixture-of-Experts via Orthogonal Gradient Accumulation and Projection

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-10-21 ·Donghyun Jeong, Yoon-Yeong Kim
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Sparse Mixture-of-Experts (SMoE) models improve scalability by routing input tokens to only a subset of expert networks, but they often suffer from representation collapse, in which multiple experts converge toward similar functions and lose their intended diversity. Prior work has addressed this limitation either by improving router architectures or by introducing auxiliary loss terms that implicitly penalize similarity among experts. However, router-based approaches remain vulnerable to routing collapses, and loss-based approaches can conflict with the task's original objective during optimization. In this work, we propose GaP-MoE (Gradient Accumulation and Projection in MoE), which induces expert specialization by directly manipulating expert output gradients rather than modifying the loss function. At each training step, GaP-MoE stochastically selects one of the $TopK$ routed experts as a leader based on normalized routing scores, and projects the gradients of the remaining follower experts onto the orthogonal complement of the subspace spanned by the leader's recent gradients. This removes directional overlap between expert gradients without altering the task loss, allowing specialization to emerge as a direct consequence of the optimization dynamics rather than an externally imposed constraint. We evaluate GaP-MoE in both fine-tuning settings (BERT-based, on GLUE) and from-scratch pretraining settings (GPT-2-based, on WikiText-103, enwik8, and text8), and further confirm its compatibility as a drop-in module for existing SMoE architectures. Experimental results show that GaP-MoE achieves performance comparable to or better than standard SMoE.

0.14

When Load-Balancing Goes Too Far: Expert Pruning in Over-Dispersed Mixture-of-Experts Models

cs.LG cs.AIcs.CL ·2026-09-03 ·Berkcan Kapusuzoglu, Connor Pryor, Sangwoo Cho, Supriyo Chakraborty, Shi-Xiong Zhang +2 more
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 22 pages, 7 figures. Preprint

Expert pruning reduces the memory and serving cost of Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) models by removing low-importance experts identified by the router, assuming router probabilities provide a reliable importance signal. We observe that this assumption breaks down under over-dispersed routing, a regime associated with aggressive load-balancing during training, in which tokens are distributed nearly uniformly across experts and importance signals collapse. In this regime, perplexity does not predict downstream task accuracy: on gpt-oss-20B, the lowest-perplexity pruning configuration yields the worst mathematical reasoning, while the highest-perplexity configuration preserves it. This does not occur under standard routing (e.g., Mixtral-8x7B-Instruct), where perplexity and accuracy degrade together. Pruning under over-dispersed routing also exposes a capability trade-off in which no single scoring metric dominates: activation-aware scoring preserves mathematical reasoning but severely degrades knowledge-intensive science (an 18-point gap on GPQA), whereas frequency-based scoring exhibits the reverse. We propose Minimax Expert Score Allocation (MESA), a domain-aware method that iteratively boosts importance scores for experts serving whichever domain is currently worst-affected, minimizing worst-case domain degradation rather than average accuracy. At 25% expert pruning MESA achieves the smallest worst-case degradation across domains, outperforming activation-aware baselines on 7 of 11 benchmarks at a correspondingly reduced memory footprint, and it generalizes to gpt-oss-120B, Gemma-4-26B-A4B, and OLMoE-1B-7B. Our results indicate that over-dispersed routing is a qualitatively distinct pruning regime in which standard assumptions fail, and that recognizing it is a prerequisite for principled expert pruning of load-balanced MoE models.

0.29

SPARE: Sparsity Allocation via Routing Entropy for Efficient MoEs

cs.LG cs.CL ·2026-10-21 ·Yifan Yang, Hanling Yi, Dongquan Yang, Feng Lin, Rong Xiao +2 more
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) architectures scale model capacity efficiently, yet their substantial memory footprint poses a major barrier to deployment. Expert pruning reduces this footprint, but most methods focus on which experts to remove and prune every layer equally. We propose SPARE (Sparsity Allocation via Routing Entropy), a training-free, selector-agnostic method that decides how many experts to remove from each layer using routing entropy, the entropy of tokens' normalized Top-K gate weights on calibration data. When a token's gate weight is spread evenly, removing one active expert discards little of it, so SPARE prunes layers with more diffuse routing more aggressively. A perturbation bound under random pruning formalizes this intuition, and controlled interventions with a fixed selector link concentrated routing to larger output changes. With the same selector and budget, SPARE improves average accuracy over uniform allocation on Mixtral, Qwen3, and DeepSeek models, especially at high pruning ratios. At 50% expert pruning, it raises the eight-task average of Qwen3-30B-A3B from 57.2% to 63.8%, and the math, code, and science average of DeepSeek-R1 from 80.1 to 82.8.

0.25

Router Prior Bias: Preserving Base Routing Structure in MoE Post-Training

cs.AI ·2026-09-08 ·Jaedeok Lee, Keonwoo Kim, Dongyoon Han, Sangdoo Yun, Yera Choi +1 more
top venuecode/data similarity 0.65
Abstract

Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) pretraining relies on an auxiliary load-balancing loss (LBL) to drive per-expert utilization toward uniformity. Post-training inherits a different situation: the base router already encodes non-uniform expert co-activation structure, which a re-imposed uniformity objective flattens away. We show that downstream performance depends instead on holding this inherited routing softly, a principle we term soft router anchoring, and instantiate it as Router Prior Bias (RPB), a training-time bias that pulls the router logits toward a prior read off the frozen base router while leaving the router itself trainable. On math post-training of Moonlight-16B-A3B, RPB attains 45.77 in-domain accuracy against 31.91 under re-applied LBL and 29.44 under unanchored fine-tuning, and retains more out-of-domain capability than either. The ordering against LBL reproduces on a second model family (Qwen3-30B-A3B-Base), and the advantage over LBL is resolvable on an independently sourced corpus. Anchors defined on the router weights, on its logits, or on its output distribution perform comparably with no consistent ordering, which places the effect in the softness of the constraint rather than in the particular prior RPB supplies. Retained community structure in the expert co-activation graph tracks these gains wherever the base router is non-uniform enough for communities to form, yet enforcing the same prior as a hard assignment preserves that structure while performance falls sharply. Community structure is therefore a footprint of soft anchoring rather than its source, and the practical lesson is that inherited routing should be held softly during post-training, since both flattening it toward uniformity and enforcing it absolutely carry a downstream cost. Our code will be released at https://github.com/naver-ai/rpb.

0.42