CS Paper Radar

A Failure Mode Taxonomy and Severity Model for Ethereum Smart Contracts

Fernando Richter Vidal, Naghmeh Ivaki, Nuno Laranjeiro

cs.SE ·submitted 2026-10-30 12:50 UTC · v1
survey

Abstract

Smart contracts are a core component of blockchain systems, but their immutability makes failures in deployed code catastrophic and irreversible. Existing work classifies vulnerabilities, defects, and attacks, yet the observable failures of smart contracts, the deviations from intended behavior or the expected ledger state seen once a contract is deployed, have been largely disregarded. In this paper, we design and validate a failure mode taxonomy for Ethereum smart contracts, together with a severity model that ranks failures by their observable impact. Using a literature review as input, we follow the taxonomy development method of Nickerson et al. to derive the failure modes and their dimensions, and we subject the resulting taxonomy to a saturation exercise over a systematic literature review, the OpenSCV vulnerability catalog, and smart contract incidents reported after the search cutoff. Each failure mode is characterized along five dimensions, namely root cause, violated security property, impact (recorded as primary, secondary, and other), affected component, and nature, and is given a standardized name targeting the observable malfunction rather than the underlying vulnerability. From the taxonomy, we derive CIPER, a five-level severity model that groups failure modes by their observable impact. The saturation exercise produced no new failure modes or dimensions. The taxonomy offers a shared vocabulary for describing what smart contracts do wrong when they fail, and CIPER links that vocabulary to the severity of each observable outcome.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Understanding Verification Vulnerabilities in Cross-chain Bridges: An Empirical Study

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-10-09 ·Yuying Wang, Yi Guo, Jiachi Chen, Hanwen Zhang, Yi Sun
dataset similarity 0.63
Abstract · 22 pages, 12 figures, 10 tables

With the rapid development of blockchain technology, numerous heterogeneous blockchains have emerged, each featuring distinct architectures, consensus mechanisms, and application ecosystems. Cross-chain bridges have consequently become a critical infrastructure component, typically relying on smart contracts to facilitate message passing and asset transfers across heterogeneous blockchains. Unlike single-chain contracts, bridge contracts introduce additional verification logic to validate external-chain data, such as state proofs, message sender identities, and signatures. However, correctly implementing such logic is challenging. We refer to vulnerabilities that violate the security guarantees of cross-chain verification as Cross-chain Verification Vulnerabilities (CVVs). To characterize CVVs, we conduct the first systematic empirical study of this vulnerability class. By analyzing 588 security audit reports from 36 real-world cross-chain bridge projects, we derive 11 CVV patterns and organize them into 5 high-level categories according to the affected verification properties. Following this taxonomy, we construct a CVV dataset containing 830 vulnerability instances across 786 contract files. The dataset establishes mappings among audit reports, audited source-code versions, affected source files, and CVV-pattern labels. We then assess existing detection approaches. Current tools provide limited documented coverage of CVV patterns, while only two of four evaluated LLMs outperform an all-pattern constant baseline of 29.3% Macro-F1; the best reaches 51.2%. Together, the limited tool coverage and inconsistent LLM gains motivate detection methods tailored to cross-chain verification semantics.

0.15

Enhancing Reliability of Symbolic Execution Tools for Smart Contract Analysis through Rule-Based False Positive Reduction

cs.SE ·2026-08-10 ·Muhammad Ali Hassan Ahmad, Muhammad Hashim Ali, Muhammad Ali Amer, Muhammad Naiman Jalil, Muhammad Hassan +1 more
similarity 0.63
Abstract

A blockchain is a decentralized, secure ledger system that enables transparent and immutable record-keeping, essential for trust and security in digital transactions. Smart contracts are self-executing agreements encoded on a blockchain, enabling different parties to fulfill the terms of the agreement automatically. These contracts trigger corresponding actions when conditions are met, ensuring decentralized and transparent transactions. Writing reliable smart contracts is challenging due to the lack of standardization. To find security vulnerabilities, tools based on various approaches, including symbolic execution, are used. However, these tools often report a large number of false positives, raising concerns about their reliability. The time and effort spent investigating false positives diverts resources from addressing actual vulnerabilities. Therefore, such tools must also be evaluated according to the rate of false positives they exhibit. More importantly, the algorithms and heuristics used by the tools must be enhanced to distinguish between true vulnerabilities and false alarms. In this paper, we first demonstrate the prevalence of false positives in vulnerability reports generated by Mythril, a symbolic execution-based analysis tool for Ethereum smart contracts. We analyze the root causes of these inaccuracies and devise a rule-based approach based on the gained insight to reduce false positives. We implement our rules for the most impactful vulnerabilities in Mythril and assess the effectiveness of our approach. Our results show a significant reduction in false positives without compromising the detection of true vulnerabilities, thus enhancing the tool's reliability.

0.04

EventSpec: Defining and Detecting Event-Semantic Issues in Blockchain Ecosystems

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-09-07 ·Yixuan Liu, Yuxin Dong, Ye Liu, Yin Wu, Chengxuan Zhang +2 more
top venue similarity 0.63
Abstract

In recent years, smart contracts have become the backbone of decentralized applications (DApps), and off-chain systems such as bridges, wallets, and indexers rely heavily on event logs to track contract execution and state changes. However, the Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM) does not validate or enforce event semantics, so logs can diverge from on-chain state, misleading off-chain systems into accepting incorrect state transitions. Existing smart contract vulnerability detection tools focus on logic bugs, with limited support for detecting event-semantic defects. To address this gap, we collect audit reports and incident cases and apply open card sorting to define five classes of event-semantic defects: event collision, state-event mismatch, unauthorized event emission, event emission mismatch, and event parameter mismatch. We propose EventSpec, which infers event specifications from a contract corpus via behavior inference and semantic-constraint extraction and applies differential checking to identify event-semantic defects in target contracts. We run EventSpec on 6,617 real-world contracts and evaluate detection effectiveness based on manually labeled results; EventSpec achieves an overall comprehensive precision of 90.17%. We further provide an off-chain evaluation harness that reproduces two off-chain attack vectors on any EVM-compatible chain: event origin confusion caused by unintended emitters and event-state desynchronization where events lack matching state updates. Using this harness, we demonstrate the feasibility of these attacks on bridge relayers, blockchain explorers, and NFT marketplaces, and report six wallet issues, four of which were confirmed (including a $600 bounty), with two remaining pending.

0.47

Mitigating Error Propagation in Chain-of-Thought: A Tree-of-Thought Framework for Smart Contract Repair

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-08-23 ·Jingping Zhu, Hongping Wang, Xiaoqi Li
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Smart contracts power blockchain applications such as DeFi and NFTs. However, once deployed, they cannot be modified. Even minor bugs can result in significant financial losses. Current AI-based repair methods rely on linear reasoning, which leads to the accumulation of errors and unreliable patches. Our method combines document parsing, static analysis, and Tree of Thoughts reasoning. We first convert audit reports into structured data. Then we use Slither to locate the exact vulnerable code. Our three-step framework explores multiple repair paths simultaneously, evaluates options, and eliminates poor choices. Finally, we verify patches through compilation and manual checks. We test our method on 50 real vulnerabilities from Code4Rena. Our method achieves a 62% single success rate and an 84% top-3 success rate, outperforming ContractTinker by 12 and 6 percentage points, respectively. We also increase the proportion of fully effective patches to 44%, while reducing defective patches from 38% to 22% and invalid patches from 10% to 4%. This approach overcomes the limitations of linear reasoning and makes smart contract repair more accurate and practical.

0.19

SoK: Failure Modes in Common Criteria Product Evaluation - A Taxonomy and Design-for-Evaluability Guidance

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-10-07 ·Punit Suketu Patel
publishedsurvey similarity 0.61
Abstract · 25 pages, 1 figure, 1 table. Accepted at the Security Standardisation Research (SSR) Conference 2026; to appear in Springer LNCS. Author's s…

The Common Criteria (CC; ISO/IEC 15408) is the principal international framework for evaluating the security of IT products, and its certificates gate procurement across government, defense, and regulated industry. Yet evaluations routinely stall, fail, or yield certificates whose assurances do not survive real-world deployment. Prior work has approached this from two directions: economic critiques of misaligned incentives and "security theatre"; and recent data-driven studies that quantify vulnerabilities in already-certified products. Comparatively little systematizes the problem from the evaluator's operational vantage - recurring, cross-vendor failures against the Common Criteria work units themselves. This paper presents a systematization of knowledge (SoK) of failure modes in Common Criteria product evaluation. Drawing on the standard, the Common Evaluation Methodology (ISO/IEC 18045), public NIAP Protection Profiles, and published Security Targets and Certification Reports, we organize recurring failures into a lifecycle taxonomy spanning Security Target scoping, Protection Profile conformance, assurance evidence, cryptographic requirements, functional testing, vulnerability analysis, operational guidance, and post-certification configuration drift. We analyze their root causes, derive a design-for-evaluability framework that product teams can apply before evaluation begins, and identify open problems for cloud, continuous-delivery, and AI-enabled systems.

0.50

SmartMemory: Detecting On-chain-off-chain Communication Inconsistency for Smart Contract via Memory-based Agent

cs.SE cs.CR ·2026-09-28 ·Zeqin Liao, Yuhong Nan, Henglong Liang, Zixu Gao, Lianyu Hu +5 more
dataset similarity 0.60
Abstract · Nil

Smart contracts underpin decentralized finance, where growing demand for on-chain/off-chain communication(OFC) has driven diverse applications such as cross-chain bridges, real-world asset tokenization, and fiat-backed stablecoins. TheOFC-related security incidents in these applications are increasingly frequent, but prior studies address separate vulnerability categories within OFC applications rather than providing a unified view, causing vulnerabilities outside known patterns to be missed.In this paper, we identify OFC inconsistency (OFCI) as a root cause of OFC vulnerabilities, which arises from business-logic flaw and ultimately breaks the equivalence between the on-chain and off-chain asset representations to induce inconsistency.Automatically detecting OFCIs faces two challenges including (1)locating heterogeneous business logic, and (2) transferring existing vulnerability knowledge to identify unseen OFCI instances. To this end, we propose SmartMemory, the first framework to leverage a memory-based agent for OFCI detection. To address heterogeneity, SmartMemory maps diverse implementations ofOFC contracts into a canonical business-semantic representation to locate the business logic for OFCI inspection. For knowledge reuse, SmartMemory integrates a memory-based agent to distill vulnerability knowledge from features into patterns and detection rules, enabling knowledge transfer across cases to identify unseenOFCIs. Lastly, SmartMemory performs taint analysis to verify the reachability, type, and impact of each candidate OFCI. We construct the first real-world OFCI dataset comprising 48 DApps with 81 OFCIs for evaluation, on which SmartMemory achieves80.68% precision and 87.65% recall. In addition, through an analysis of 325 real-world OFC applications, SmartMemory detects 36 previously unknown OFCIs, all of which have been confirmed and fixed by corresponding parties.

0.13

When Agents Act on Web3: An Attack-Surface Survey of MCP, Skills, and Tool Calling

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-08-18 ·Rabimba Karanjai, Yang Lu, Nour Diallo, Wujie Xiong, Lei Xu +2 more
survey similarity 0.59
Abstract

AI agents increasingly act rather than merely read: across the Model Context Protocol (MCP) ecosystem, the share of deployed tools that modify external state has risen from 27% to 65% of tool use. When agents exercise this authority on public blockchains through MCP, skills, and tool calling, the consequences of an attack are governed by the blockchain execution layer rather than by conventional software assumptions. This survey argues that four properties of that layer (irreversibility, signing authority, continuous autonomy, and sequence-level composition) qualitatively change the threat model, turning the recoverable failures of generic agent security into a standing, irreversible loss. We organize the fragmented MCP-security literature into an attack-surface taxonomy, then contribute a Web3 risk-mapping matrix that ties each attack class to its amplified impact, the responsible amplifiers, a representative mitigation, and the residual gap. We synthesize defenses, including emerging blockchain-based mechanisms, and find them improving but insufficient: measured protections stop fewer than 30% of attacks, and model-level safety refuses fewer than 3%. We close by positioning the work against adjacent surveys and deriving a research agenda from the matrix's open cells.

0.43

Smart Contracts Claimed Vulnerable by the CVE Database, with Labels and Source Locations

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-09-01 ·Monika di Angelo, Gernot Salzer
dataset similarity 0.59
Abstract

The Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVE) database catalogs vulnerability claims in hard- and software, among them those pertaining to blockchain programs a.k.a. smart contracts. We present CVE-Smart-Contracts, a curated dataset of CVE records up to July 2026 referring to Ethereum smart contracts. The dataset contains the vulnerable artifacts (source code and runtime bytecode), labels according to three taxonomies, and function-level locations. The retrieval of CVE records, collection of additional evidence, validation of the correspondence between records and artifacts, label assignment, and vulnerability localization are automated, leaving 15% to manual analysis. The dataset does not validate the original vulnerability claims, but marks a few records obviously wrong as `refuted'. For the sake of reproducibility, all external inputs are retained, so that rerunning the pipelines results in the same outputs. The dataset comprises 491 records linked to deployed contracts, 26 referring to projects (mostly libraries), 45 without validated artifacts, and six records with refuted claims. The dataset supports empirical security research, in particular the evaluation of code analysis and repair techniques.

0.19