CS Paper Radar

Model Collapse Is Avoidable Even as Real Data Vanishes: A Sharp Criterion for Iterative Gaussian Estimation

Roy Turgeman, Tom Tirer

cs.LG stat.MLmath.ST ·submitted 2026-10-30 18:39 UTC · v1

Abstract

Large generative models are commonly trained on data collected from the open web, which may contain data produced by previous generations of the same model. Previous work has shown that recursively training on model-generated data can progressively degrade model performance, a phenomenon known as model collapse. Yet, generative models continue to improve dramatically over time. Existing theory suggests that this is enabled by the availability of new real data at each iteration, kept separate from generated data. However, exact separation is not realistic, and uncurated data is still commonly used. We bridge this gap by considering a more realistic setup in which real and generated data are not handled differently during training. Specifically, we present a comprehensive theoretical study of iterative estimation of the mean and covariance of a multivariate Gaussian distribution. At each iteration, samples are drawn from a mixture of the real data distribution and the estimated distribution from the previous iteration, but are used indistinguishably. We provide a single equivalent condition for consistency of the mean and covariance estimators in Euclidean norms, and convergence to zero of the expected squared 2-Wasserstein distance between the estimated and true distributions. Using this result, we show that consistency holds, i.e., model collapse is avoided, for any fixed real data fraction above zero, and even for a fraction that vanishes across iterations, provided it does not vanish too quickly. However, more real data (or data curation) remains important at practical finite times: the convergence rate of the mean estimator deteriorates as the real data fraction approaches zero. We support our results with an empirical investigation of the theoretical setup, and with experiments on iterative training of a diffusion model on CIFAR-10 that correlate with our theory.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Preventing Model Collapse: A Fisher-Rao Perspective on the Dynamics of Training with Synthetic Data

cs.LG eess.SY ·2026-09-16 ·Matteo Marchi, João Pedro Silvestre, Bahman Gharesifard, Paulo Tabuada
publishedtheory similarity 0.66
Abstract · 8 pages. Extended version of the paper accepted for presentation at the 2026 65th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control (CDC). This versio…

Large Language Models (LLMs) are now routinely trained using synthetic data, since high-quality human data has been exhausted by the ever increasing needs of larger and larger models. However, recursive training on synthetic data frequently induces model collapse, a degenerative feedback loop where models progressively forget the true underlying data distribution. Training on a mixture of synthetic and fresh human data is a logical countermeasure and can prevent model collapse. However, it is an open question as to what is the exact minimum required ratio of human-to-synthetic data to maintain training stability. In this paper, we establish rigorous theoretical guarantees on the minimum rate of human data required to prevent model collapse. Although previous work established a formal lower bound for this ratio, such bound can be vacuous for very high dimensions, as the analysis relies on the usual Euclidean metric in R^n and is not adapted to the space of categorical probability distributions. Instead, in this paper we explicitly leverage the information-geometric structure of the probability simplex by analyzing the dynamics of the process under the Fisher-Rao metric. We derive quantitative contraction and invariance bounds that are stable and do not become trivial as the dimensions increase. Thus, we show that the effective required data ratio to prevent model collapse is different than previously implied.

0.30

Sample-Optimal Estimation of the Fréchet Inception Distance

cs.LG cs.CVcs.DSmath.ST+1 ·2026-10-05 ·Ziyun Chen, Jerry Li, Kevin Tian, Yusong Zhu
code/datahot direction similarity 0.60
Abstract · Our code is available at https://github.com/zys996/sample-optimal-fid-estimation

The Fréchet Inception Distance (FID) is widely used to evaluate generative models, but its empirical plug-in estimator suffers from finite-sample bias [BSAG18, CF20]. We study the sample complexity $n$ of estimating FID to error $ε$ between $d$-dimensional Gaussians with bounded mean distance and covariances, when one distribution is known. Our contributions are threefold. (1) We establish tight finite-sample $Θ(\frac{d^2}{n})$ bias and $Θ(\frac{d}{n} + \frac {d^2} {n^2})$ variance bounds for the empirical plug-in estimator, establishing a $\gtrsim d^2$ sample complexity. (2) To debias the empirical plug-in estimator, we generalize the ${\rm FID}_\infty$ estimator of [CF20] to extrapolation methods of arbitrary order $k$. We further prove tight bias and variance bounds of $Θ(\frac{d^{k + 2}}{n^{k + 1}})$ and $Θ(\frac d n + \frac{d^2}{n^2})$ for any order-$k$ extrapolation under our framework. (3) We introduce Relative Taylor Debiasing (RTD), a new, computationally efficient FID estimation algorithm using debiasing techniques inspired by U-statistics. We show that RTD achieves an $O(\frac d {ε^2})$ sample complexity, and prove that this is optimal. We provide a complementary empirical evaluation of our new estimators. Our experiments on synthetic Gaussians validate the predicted residual bias and support the tightness of our bounds. On ImageNet with Inception embeddings, RTD achieves the lowest mean estimation error at the standard 50K sample budget, while our second-order variance-aware extrapolation estimator (VALE$_2$) uses only 10K samples to achieve accuracy comparable to FID$_\infty$ at 50K samples.

0.46

Variational Outlier-Robust Gaussian Process Regression with Generative Modeling

cs.LG ·2026-08-17 ·Arslan Majal, Aamir Hussain Chughtai
similarity 0.60
Abstract · 5 pages, 1 figure

Outliers can substantially distort Gaussian process regression (GPR) due to its conventional Gaussian observation likelihood, leading to inaccurate model learning and prediction. To address this limitation, this article introduces a generative GPR model that captures observation-specific contamination and adaptively mitigates the influence of outliers. Subsequently, a variational generalized expectation-maximization procedure is used to learn the latent variables and GPR model parameters. Experiments on synthetic and real datasets under different contamination settings demonstrate that the proposed method remains competitive with-and in several cases outperforms-robust GPR baselines in prediction accuracy. Moreover, the proposed method shares the cubic computational scaling of the compared GPR methods.

0.23

Calibrating your confidence requires thinking of all the ways you could be wrong

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-11-06 ·Marco Miani
similarity 0.60
Abstract · PhD Thesis, Technical University of Denmark (DTU), 2026

A primary limitation of modern deep learning is the miscalibration of model confidence; traditional architectures fundamentally lack a mechanism to quantify their own uncertainty. Larger models and larger datasets mitigate this issue, but they do not resolve the underlying structural deficiency. Bayesian methods offer a principled uncertainty-aware learning framework through stochastic parameters. Yet, despite the established benefits, the inherent computational overhead often compromises either scalability or quality. This trade-off currently prevents the widespread adoption of Bayesian methods. This Thesis bridges the gap between high-quality and low-complexity by introducing a novel distribution on parameter space: a degenerate Gaussian whose covariance is a projection matrix aligned with the null space of the Fisher information matrix. We demonstrate the scalability of this Bayesian posterior through two numerically efficient algorithms: one for posterior sampling and another for the direct computation of predictive confidence. Empirically, we show State-Of-The-Art confidence calibration and out-of-distribution detection for large models. We provide theoretical grounding for this approach. We study the degeneracies inherent in Amari's information geometry and highlight its most relevant component: the split of parameter's perturbations into two orthogonal subspaces. From this perspective, our posterior naturally emerges as the simplest choice that captures this split, assigning unitary variance to one subspace and zero variance to the other. Moreover, through the tools of differential geometry, we utilize this split to identify and rectify a critical misalignment issue of the non-linearized Laplace Approximation. Finally, with a focus on PAC-Bayes generalization bounds, we pave the way for a deeper understanding of the learning capabilities of overparametrized models.

0.12

Source Distribution Estimation by Posterior Averaging

cs.LG ·2026-09-02 ·Trung-Dung Hoang, Lisa M. Koch
benchmark similarity 0.59
Abstract

Simulation-based science often requires a distribution over simulator parameters whose push-forward reproduces a set of real observations: this is the source distribution estimation (SDE) problem. Existing methods fit the source against a likelihood surrogate trained once from a fixed proposal prior. Their objective is therefore stated only in terms of the surrogate instead of the true simulator, which may fail for inaccurate areas in parameter space where the surrogate was never trained. We instead solve SDE by expectation maximization: an E-step trains an amortized posterior on fresh simulations from the current source estimate, and an M-step refits the source to the average of that posterior over the observed data. We give two parameterizations, (1) separate source and posterior flows and (2) a single shared conditional flow. We evaluate our method on three benchmark tasks under both broad and misspecified initial priors. Both improve on existing fixed surrogate approaches and on iterated variants of each, most clearly on Lotka--Volterra, where no baseline falls below 0.96 data-space C2ST while our methods reach 0.64-0.68 in three of four initial-prior settings.

0.10

Adaptive Mean Estimation by In-Context Learning: A Gradient-Flow Analysis

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-10-06 ·Martin Eppert, Krishna Balasubramanian, Subhro Ghosh, Jason Klusowski, Yan Shuo Tan
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Prior Fitted Networks (PFNs) such as TabPFN now rival established statistical procedures across prediction and estimation tasks. A natural explanation is that PFNs have the property of statistical adaptivity, that is, they perform nearly as well as a method tailored to the true data-generating model for a heterogeneous set of models, while not being told which model the data comes from. We study how such adaptivity is learned in a controlled location-estimation problem. Each task is an unlabeled sample whose family is hidden: Gaussian data call for averaging, with error of order $n^{-1}$, whereas uniform data are best estimated from their extremes, at the faster rate $n^{-2}$. We also provide the example of a symmetric Gaussian mixture, for which a rate of $σ^2_n/n$ can be attained. On scalar inputs, softmax attention computes the derivative of the empirical cumulant-generating function. A single primitive therefore both supplies features that distinguish the families and forms estimators interpolating between the sample mean and the mid-range. We combine attention experts through either a softmax mixture of experts or a gated linear unit (GLU), and analyze stagewise gradient flow. With $\widetildeΩ(n^{1+ε})$ pretraining tasks, the learned estimator is asymptotically efficient on Gaussian tasks, within a factor $n^ε$ of the minimax rate on uniform tasks, and order-optimal on mixtures in a shrinking-variance regime. These guarantees extend to new locations and longer contexts. A risk decomposition separates expert error, routing error and normalization error, which clarifies the architectural contrast. Softmax gating enforces normalization and exact translation equivariance, whereas the GLU must learn it: its dynamics separate into fast bias removal followed by slow expert selection. End-to-end experiments recover the predicted specialization.

0.33

Sufficiently Reduced Distributional Regression

cs.LG stat.MEstat.ML ·2026-09-24 ·Alexander Henzi, Tiange Liu, Xinwei Shen
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract

We propose Sufficiently Reduced Distributional Regression (SRDR), a generative method that combines conditional distribution estimation with nonlinear sufficient dimension reduction (SDR). It builds on a characterization of sufficiency through strictly proper scoring rules: a dimension reduction is sufficient if and only if predicting the response from the reduced covariates incurs no loss in expected score relative to the full covariates. Sufficient dimension reduction thus becomes a risk minimization problem. SRDR jointly trains a dimension reduction map and a generative prediction model by minimizing the energy score, which can be estimated by sampling without density evaluation or adversarial training. The framework extends to multi-environment data and to classification. We prove that the estimated conditional distributions converge in energy distance to the true ones, which implies that the learned representation is asymptotically sufficient. In simulations and applications to CT slice localization, superconductivity, and digit classification, SRDR recovers low-dimensional sufficient structure and matches or outperforms state-of-the-art nonlinear SDR methods in representation quality and predictive performance.

0.04

Livin' on a Prior: Likelihood Score Approximation for Inverse Problems

cs.LG ·2026-09-28 ·Rostislav Makarov, Tal Peer, Danilo de Oliveira, Timo Gerkmann
benchmarkhot direction similarity 0.59
Abstract

Generative models have found great success as data-driven methods of solving inverse problems. Two popular approaches work either by combining a pretrained generative prior with a known degradation model, or by training a conditional generative model directly from paired data. We target a setting that spans both regimes: unknown degradations can be learned from few paired examples, while known degradations can be learned from self-generated samples. We introduce Likelihood Score Approximation (LSA), a generative framework that keeps a pretrained unconditional model fixed and learns an observation-conditioned model that approximates the likelihood score from paired samples. Within a conditional stochastic-interpolant framework, LSA can be trained in either score or velocity coordinates, independently of the unconditional model's native parameterization, and supports both deterministic and stochastic sampling. We further show empirically that the prior model can be swapped post-training while keeping the same LSA model. Across speech and image inverse problems, LSA operates effectively even at roughly 0.01% of the full training dataset. On the ImageNet-256 benchmark it achieves competitive or better restoration quality than strong posterior-sampling baselines while requiring up to several orders of magnitude fewer network evaluations.

0.29