CS Paper Radar

The Testability Gap: A Pre-Registered Census of Naming versus Implementation in 59 Cognitive-Architecture LLM Systems

Jia Chen, Ying Xu, Ni Zhang, Siyuan Zhang

cs.SE ·submitted 2026-10-31 05:27 UTC · v1

Abstract

A companion line of work audited individual cognitive-architecture LLM systems in depth and found that module names and module computations are empirically independent claims. This paper asks how far that gap extends across the system class. We pre-registered a census protocol (sample frame, metrics, and acceptance criteria frozen before any sample was downloaded) and surveyed the 59 most-starred Python repositories declaring cognitive architecture on GitHub, plus five classic architectures as a historical control. We measure a testability gap. First, an auditability gap: 22% of repositories document no code reference whatsoever. Second, an integrity gap: 42% of repositories have at least one dangling reference, and within that subgroup the median fraction is 8%, the top quartile 19.6%, and the maximum 79.5%; one 148-star system documents paths of which a majority do not exist. Three of four pre-registered hypotheses were falsified: the integrity gap is not universal (58% of repositories either offer no checkable references or offer references that all resolve); claim density does not predict dangling rate (rho = -0.10); and the classical-architecture control does not significantly outperform (p = 0.059 with five controls, all at zero dangling). Exactly one repository in 59 (1.7%) ships executable falsification criteria for its own claims. A second pre-registered round classified every dangling path by git lifetime: 85.5% of dangling references (159 of 186) are ghosts - paths that never existed at any commit - against 14.5% that were once real and later removed.

Comment
21 pages. Pre-registered census of the 59 most-starred GitHub repositories declaring cognitive architecture, plus five classic architectures as control: 22% document no code reference, 42% have dangling references (median 8.0%, max 79.5%); 3 of 4 pre-registered hypotheses falsified. Artifact archive: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23433898

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

The Code of Theseus: Can Agents Rebuild Software from Recovered Design Documents?

cs.SE ·2026-10-14 ·Cezar Sas, Sandra Mitrović, Fabio Barth, Georg Rehm, Matteo Salani
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 12 pages, 3 figures, 7 tables

LLM agents increasingly design a system before implementing it, yet the data to train and evaluate them centres on implementation and testing: requirements and design artefacts are often missing, outdated or private. Source code, in contrast, is abundant. Prior work recovers architecture documentation by feeding LLMs the source code or letting agents explore it, which saturates the context, does not scale to many repositories, and yields a single artefact rather than aligned ones. We present a framework that recovers aligned stakeholder intent, requirements and architecture from a compact repository representation, a static dependency graph and key contextual files, and release the artefacts of 10,764 Java, Python, C/C++ and C# repositories as a dataset. An LLM judge rates the artefacts of three generators as clear and internally consistent, but less reliably correct and at the right level of abstraction. To test whether the artefacts carry the design, we pose a software Ship of Theseus: a coding agent rebuilds 29 Commit0 libraries from the intent alone or with the recovered requirements and architecture, given only an interface contract and part of the tests. The artefacts do not significantly change the held-out pass rate (33.7% vs. 35.8%), but bring the rebuilt module structure significantly closer to the original (module F1 from 0.54 to 0.63), with either generator and even with concise artefacts. Recovered artefacts thus convey design that tests do not capture, offering a scalable source of design-level data for agents that design before they implement, and the round trip measures this without human references.

0.22

Real Computation or Merely Naming? A Pre-Registered Mechanism Audit of 25 Cognitive-Architecture Modules in an LLM-Based Agent System

cs.AI ·2026-10-30 ·Peter Chen, Ni Zhang, Ying Xu, Siyuan Zhang
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 40 pages. Static audit of 25 cognitive-architecture modules (18 carry no computed value to any production output), pre-registered interventi…

Agent systems built on local large language models are increasingly marketed through the vocabulary of cognitive architecture: modules named global workspace, theory of mind, causal reasoning, or active inference are listed as features, and the presence of the name is taken as the presence of the mechanism. We ask the prior question -- does the named computation actually happen -- and contribute a transferable verification method for the claim-implementation gap: a four-question static audit protocol with line-number evidence and call-chain tracing, demonstrated on two systems. We audit a system claiming 25 cognitive mechanisms, pre-register falsifiable predictions for 11 modules and execute the interventions, replicate the protocol on the IIT-phi core of a second, independent system with its own pre-committed falsification criteria, and run two repair experiments as positive controls. In 18 of 25 modules the computed value never reaches any production output; three idle-wiring shapes new to the dead-code and code-smell literatures emerge (connected-but-never-called, called-but-inert, called-but-content-blind). Of 61 frozen criteria across 12 interventions, 53 were confirmed, two partially adjudicated, five falsified, one adjudication-ambiguous. Repairs raised planner task success from 0.028 to 1.000 and cut state-controller error by 52%. Module names and module computations must be audited as independent claims; the protocol and the five-class failure taxonomy are reusable for the claim-implementation gap at two-system, case-level depth.

0.57

PonyEval: Evaluating LLM-Based Program Repair for Capability-Safe and Actor-Oriented Pony Software

cs.SE ·2026-08-20 ·Bang Xie, Hao Liu, Zhenyu Shi, Zhiyuan Peng, Xin Yin +6 more
benchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract · 9 pages, 1 figure, 5 tables

Repository-level issue-resolution benchmarks have made executable evaluation central to software-engineering agents, but their language coverage remains concentrated in mainstream ecosystems. Pony presents a different regime: it combines actors, reference capabilities, ahead-of-time compilation, and a rapidly evolving historical toolchain, making both patch generation and faithful replay difficult. We introduce PonyEval, a SWE-bench-style benchmark of 291 real GitHub issue-pull-request pairs from 15 Pony repositories. Every instance binds an issue statement, a historical base commit, a developer gold patch, a black-box test patch, and a reproducible runtime mapping. The frozen release passes an offline audit requiring the issue-specific test to fail on the base state and pass after the gold patch; it contains no duplicate instance identifiers or canonical repository-PR pairs. In a separate full-set semantic selection audit, three isolated machine reviewers label all 291 instances as include or exclude; their Fleiss' kappa is 0.8968, with 249 unanimous inclusions and 32 unanimous exclusions. To replay eleven years of repository history, we reconstruct 72 runtime images covering 289 unique base commits and verify their availability on five heterogeneous compute nodes. We define a matched evaluation with mini-SWE-agent 2.4.6 for GPT-5.6-sol, DeepSeek-V4-Pro, GLM-5.2, MiniMax-M3, and Kimi-K3, followed by strict patch application, compilation, and hidden-test validation. Across the patches actually produced by each model, conditional resolution rates range from 10.21% to 24.68%. These rates characterize the quality of generated patches rather than success over all 291 benchmark tasks.

0.23

From Traceability to Justifiability: Accountability Structures in Agentic Software Engineering

cs.SE ·2026-08-21 ·Rashid Azarang
surveycode/data similarity 0.62
Abstract · 18 pages, 2 figures. Primary-data measurement study: a 47-platform two-pass graded documentation survey and a 30-repository depth measuremen…

A pipeline promoting an AI system publishes records claiming the thing evaluated is the thing deployed and that the evidence licensed the transition. We measure, from public material only, whether those records can express that claim and whether it holds where declared. First, a two-class documentation survey of 47 delivery platforms (20 CI/CD, 27 model-serving/agent) under one fixed three-label protocol, graded twice (second pass blind), every consulted page pinned by content hash and date. Across 188 double-graded cells we found no platform whose default record emits a content-addressed identity of the behavioral tuple (model version, instructions, tool definitions, retrieval and runtime configuration); the blind pass grades that column default on zero of 47. Immutable nominal versioning is meanwhile arriving as the agent platforms' default answer (16 of 27): version integers behind mutable pointers, a layer the artifact supply chain already found insufficient. Second, an instrument computes realized assurance depth from a pipeline's published exhaust alone and compares it with the declared depth. Applied to a frozen two-stratum frame of 30 public repositories graded twice from a hashed archive (second pass blind; cell-level agreement 23 and 19 of 30, both passes independently finding the same five full realizations), the sharpest result is a verifiability hole: seven of the 15 repositories chosen for adopting attestation tooling publish source-only releases, so the binding their workflows declare cannot be checked where declared. Where checkable it mostly checks out: five of seven measurable adopters realize the binding end to end; both shortfalls fall at identity binding. Together the results locate the field's records structurally short of justifiability, the one rung that can refuse a transition. The survey carries an expiry clock; we state what would falsify each finding.

0.39

An Empirical Analysis of Cross-OS Portability Issues in Python Projects

cs.SE ·2026-09-22 ·Denini Silva, MohamadAli Farahat, Marcelo d'Amorim
top venuecode/data similarity 0.61
Abstract

While Python is designed as a cross-platform language, real-world applications encounter portability failures when deployed across different operating systems. We present the first large-scale empirical study of cross-OS portability issues in Python, analyzing 2,042 open-source repositories using two complementary approaches: systematic cross-OS test reexecution and manual analysis of GitHub issues. Our cross-platform testing of 500 projects reveals that 11.2% exhibit OS-dependent test failures. Through systematic analysis of 240 GitHub issues, we confirm 102 genuine portability problems spanning 95 additional projects. We develop a comprehensive taxonomy identifying 7 primary failure categories - with file/directory operations, process management, and library dependencies being most prevalent - along with 24 distinct sub-categories, 15 diagnostic signatures, and 4 systematic repair patterns. Our evaluation reveals that existing static analysis tools provide minimal support for portability detection, while large language models achieve 40-79% accuracy in identifying issues and 50-77% success in generating fixes when provided with structured guidance. Through 33 contributed pull requests, we demonstrate practical applicability and developer acceptance (17 merged, zero rejected) of our findings. This work establishes the first comprehensive baseline for understanding and addressing cross-OS portability issues in Python, providing actionable insights for developers, tool designers, and the broader research community.

0.77

PROBE: Frontier Coding Agents Find Different Bugs Than Maintainers Fix

cs.SE cs.AIcs.LG ·2026-10-26 ·Marco Paina, Mark Niklas Müller, Niels Mündler-Sasahara, Martin Vechev
benchmark similarity 0.61
Abstract

Proactive bug discovery is an important software-engineering problem. Even though coding agents are already widely deployed in this domain, their capabilities remain understudied. In particular, the challenging task of finding all bugs that human maintainers would repair across an entire repository has not been studied yet. To close this gap, we introduce PROBE, a benchmark consisting of all 2,457 bugs fixed over the course of 18 months across 20 diverse GitHub repositories, together with a method for matching candidate findings to this partial reference set. We evaluate coding agents across frontier models and find they all achieve a recall of below $21\%$ and a precision of less than $9\%$ with respect to the reference set. While stronger models increase recall substantially from $8\%$ to $17\%$, they do not improve precision. Surprisingly, despite the low precision, LLM and human evaluators still judge $85\%$ of findings valid. Crucially, we find that found bug distributions are similar across agents but differ substantially from those of bugs fixed by maintainers. The practical relevance of bug discovery and the low recall of frontier models make this benchmark a valuable resource for both model users and developers.

0.19

Repository-Grounded Rubrics for Execution-Free Evaluation of Coding Agents

cs.SE cs.AI ·2026-11-11 ·Matej Gerek, Danylo Zahorulko, Samuel Budai, Chris Rupley, Thierry Donneau-Golencer
code/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · 31 pages, 6 figures, 15 tables. Code and data: https://github.com/faros-ai/repository-grounded-rubrics

Coding agents are usually evaluated by running task-specific tests, but tests may be missing or incomplete, and running them requires a working environment for each repository. We adapt agentic rubrics, introduced for selecting among candidate patches, into an execution-free measure of how far a patch satisfies a task's requirements. An agent explores the repository before the change and writes weighted binary criteria, and a judge without tools scores a diff by the weighted share of criteria it satisfies. We validate the ordering this score produces against test outcomes on SWE-bench Verified, using 7,291 labeled patches from fifteen systems. Within the 400 tasks that have both resolved and unresolved patches, the mean per-task AUROC is 0.826 (0.838 on tasks not used to tune the rubric-generation prompt), and ranking systems by their failing patches closely agrees with ranking them by resolve rate (Spearman 0.968). Case analyses trace disagreements to tests that do not match the task, execution-blocking defects that the textual assessment misses, and errors in criteria or verdicts. The validation does not establish absolute score magnitudes or requirement satisfaction beyond agreement with tests, but rubric scores could complement tests where tests or execution environments cannot be assumed.

0.43

A Multi-Domain Study on the Effectiveness of LLMs at Writing Property-Based Tests

cs.SE ·2026-10-25 ·M M Abid Naziri, Feiran Qin, Khush Patel, Marcelo d'Amorim
similarity 0.60
Abstract

A property-based test (PBT) checks a property of a program on many generated inputs, but writing one takes a property, a generator of valid inputs, and an oracle. LLM-based PBT writers produce all three, yet they have been evaluated only on Python libraries. We study how two of them, Proptest-AI and Agentic-PBT, generalize to ten programs in five domains: deep learning libraries, databases, system software, compilers, and LLM serving engines. Most of these programs take text in their own language, such as queries, configurations, and programs. Agentic-PBT covers more branches than Proptest-AI on seven of the ten programs with Opus 5 and on all ten with GLM-5.3-Flash. Domain-specific fuzzers cover more of the compilers and of PostgreSQL and less of PyTorch than Agentic-PBT. We filed 180 bug reports, 44 of which duplicate reports that others filed after the models' knowledge cutoffs; maintainers have confirmed 65 of the others, in all five domains, and fixed 23. We draw lessons for building and evaluating such writers: low observability hurts them, and mature fuzzers paired with LLM-written properties could check that each feature behaves as documented.

0.28