CS Paper Radar

Adversarial Robustness Is Not Zero-Day Generalization: A Controlled Evaluation of Flow-Based Intrusion Detectors on Corrected CIC-IDS2017

Abdulhamid Zaro

cs.CR cs.LG ·submitted 2026-10-31 07:11 UTC · v1
code/data

Abstract

Synthetic variants of known attacks, including feature-space adversarial perturbations, are sometimes used as stand-ins for unseen ("zero-day") attacks when evaluating machine-learning network intrusion detection systems (NIDS). We test whether this proxy holds. On the corrected CIC-IDS2017 release we train Random Forest, XGBoost, a 1D-CNN and an FT-Transformer and compare, at a fixed 1% false-positive rate over five seeds, detection under constrained perturbations of known attacks (gradient-based and black-box attacks on 42 attacker-controllable features) with leave-one-attack-family-out (LOAO) detection, where an entire family is absent from training. Detection under the strongest perturbation we tested, with budgets of at most 0.2, stays between 90.9% and 99.7%, yet mean detection of held-out families falls to 76.2% (RF), 40.2% (XGBoost), 25.8% (1D-CNN) and 22.8% (FT-Transformer). Robustness exceeds LOAO detection for every model (gaps of 24 to 72 percentage points, 23 to 66 when robustness is also averaged over families; Holm-adjusted p $\le$ 0.00096), and the two measures agree at most on a coarse ranking of the models. An exact mixed-integer evasion search confirms the tree ensembles' scores. Benign-only anomaly detectors and a simple multi-class open-set baseline do not close the gap. A temporal split on 5 seeds (3 of the 4 models) leaves the gap in place. On CSE-CIC-IDS2018 the gap recurs for every model (16 to 68 points). On these benchmarks and under this threat model, a robustness score should not be read as a zero-day score, and the two should be reported separately. Code and per-seed results are publicly available.

Comment
10 pages, 10 tables. Code and per-seed results: https://github.com/abdulhamid-zaro/robustness-vs-zeroday-nids

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Multi-Class, Multi-Tier Network Intrusion Detection: A Comprehensive and Reproducible Benchmark

cs.CR cs.LG ·2026-09-28 ·Yufeng Xin, Bryant Goseland, Mohamed Rahouti
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.74
Abstract

Machine learning (ML) and deep learning (DL) have dominated Intrusion Detection System (IDS) research in recent years. Unfortunately, many existing studies have produced inflated results and unreliable benchmarks due to critical oversights and mistakes in the ML and DL pipeline, from data collection and labeling to feature engineering and model training and evaluation. CIC-IDS2017 is a standard benchmark for network intrusion detection. Still, many published results on this dataset are difficult to compare due to labeling errors, inconsistent flow extraction, potential leakage, and performance evaluation metrics dominated by benign traffic. In this paper, we present a comprehensive benchmark with corrected PCAP-level labeling and a complete evaluation pipeline with diverse ML models. We evaluate eleven tabular classifiers at three nested levels: binary attack detection, nine-class attack-family attribution, and fifteen-class fine-grained classification. A soft-voting ensemble of Random Forest, XGBoost, and LightGBM obtains the best fine-tier macro-F1 of 0.955, with coarse and binary macro-F1 scores of 0.980 and 0.999, respectively. We further conducted a feature selection study based on an analysis of feature importance. This comprehensive benchmark pipeline is configurable and open-source, enabling new feature extraction and model plugins for new datasets. Future work should use this pipeline as a reference point for richer features, rare-class analysis, and model generalization towards new datasets and attack classes.

0.18

Defending Network Intrusion Detection Systems Based on Graph Neural Networks Against Structural Adversarial Attacks

cs.CR ·2026-08-25 ·Dimitri Galli, Andrea Venturi, Dario Stabili, Mauro Andreolini, Mirco Marchetti
published similarity 0.73
Abstract · In Proceedings of 2025 23rd International Symposium on Network Computing and Applications (NCA), Lisbon, Portugal, 2025

Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) represent a promising solution for Machine Learning (ML) based Network Intrusion Detection Systems (NIDS), thanks to their ability to leverage both network flow features and topological patterns. While GNN classifiers demonstrate superior robustness against feature-based adversarial attacks compared to other ML detectors, they remain vulnerable to structural adversarial attacks, where an attacker perturbs the underlying network graph topology by injecting edges or inserting nodes. Such attacks pose a realistic and severe threat, undermining the reliability of GNN-based NIDS in practical deployments. While countermeasures have been proposed in the literature, they often rely on assumptions that are unrealistic in real-world cybersecurity scenarios. In this paper, we propose a defense framework based on adversarial training to strengthen GNN-based NIDS against structural attacks. We generate adversarial samples by strategically replacing the source and destination nodes in benign network flows, thereby efficiently mimicking edge injection attacks. We evaluate our approach on two widely used datasets (CTU-13 and TON-IoT) using E-GraphSAGE as the base GNN classifier. Experimental results show that our approach produces hardened detectors with superior detection performance on clean graphs and enhanced robustness against structural adversarial attacks.

0.50

Jev-IDS: System One Models for Network Intrusion Detection

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-10-01 ·Paulo Severo, Silvio E. Quincozes, Amanda Dias
similarity 0.72
Abstract

Machine-learning Network Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS) depend on substantial labeled datasets and task-specific training, whereas Large Language Models (LLMs) detection can analyze flow records directly but incurs higher inference cost and latency, with less constrained outputs. This paper presents JEV-IDS, an open experimental general NIDS based on the Jev System One Model (SOM) to detect zero day intrusions Under label scarcity. JEV-IDS serializes one flow per request and asks JEV two questions: a binary attack probability and a finite-choice traffic category. Our results show that, at k=1, JEV was 4.8 times faster and 3.8 times cheaper than GPT-5.6 Luna, with 1.5 times higher novel-attack recall; it also produced 15 times fewer false alarms than a low-data Random Forest. Across 5,400 decisions on a 300-flow NSL-KDD pilot split, JEV achieved F1-Score 0.859, precision 0.941, recall 0.790, and novel-attack recall 0.838. Increasing k to 2 reduced its F1-Score to 0.839.

0.22

Robustness Evaluation and Detection of Transferable Adversarial Attacks in ML-Based NIDS

cs.CR ·2026-09-05 ·Huda Ali Alatawi
similarity 0.72
Abstract

Machine learning-based network intrusion detection systems (ML-based NIDS) are vulnerable to adversarial evasion, where malicious samples are perturbed to evade detection and be misclassified as benign. Despite growing research on adversarial attacks and defenses for ML-based NIDS, comparative evaluations of multiple attack types, detection models, and defense strategies under a common setting remain limited. In this paper, we evaluate eight adversarial evasion attacks, fifteen detection models, and three representative defense strategies using the NF-UQ-NIDS dataset, which includes recent traditional and IoT network traffic with twenty distinct attack categories. The evaluation compares model performance on clean test data and on robustness evaluation sets that include adversarial samples, analyzes attack success consistency across models, and examines the effect of defense strategies on adversarial robustness. To support model comparison, we introduce the Robustness Index (RI), a compact comparative metric that rewards high balanced accuracy and macro-F1 score computed on the robustness evaluation set while penalizing high attack success rate (ASR). We further present AR-NIDS, a two-stage framework that uses an adversarially trained ensemble to distinguish normal, attack, and adversarial samples, followed by an adversarial attack classifier to identify the attack type. Under the evaluated transfer-based setting, the proposed adversarially trained ensemble achieves the strongest overall trade-off between classification performance on the robustness evaluation set and evasion resistance, reducing the average ASR from 0.41 to 0.03 and achieving an RI of 0.98.

0.08

Learning to Verify: Signature-Guided Training for Adaptive Adversarial Detection

cs.LG ·2026-11-18 ·Arash Vashagh, Roozbeh Razavi-Far
similarity 0.70
Abstract

Adversarial example detectors often fail when attackers explicitly attempt to bypass them. We propose a dual-model approach that keeps the original classifier fixed and trains a separate verifier to assess its predictions. During training, we identify patterns of internal neural network activations that distinguish genuine examples of each class from adversarial examples targeting that class. These patterns, called activation signatures, guide the generation of challenging adversarial examples that mislead the classifier, challenge the verifier, and internally resemble the target class. The verifier learns to recognize these examples while preserving its performance on clean inputs through knowledge distillation. At inference, the verifier evaluates the classifier's prediction without requiring activation signatures. We evaluate the approach on publicly available datasets against several adaptive attacks, including attacks unseen during training. The proposed verifier substantially outperforms directly attacked confidence-based and feature-based detectors under the evaluated L-infinity attacks. Ablation studies show that adaptive verifier training is the main source of this improvement, while signature guidance primarily benefits clean accuracy. Additional L2 evaluations reveal limitations in robustness across perturbation types.

0.17

Evaluating ML-based Intrusion Detection Systems: The Illusion of Model Efficacy

cs.CR ·2026-09-02 ·Achilleas Spanos, Ioanna Kantzavelou
similarity 0.69
Abstract · 19 pages, 6 figures, 3 tables

Intrusion Detection has been revolutionized due to the integration of Machine Learning. Improved detection rates, reduced false alarms, and optimized algorithms contribute to the perception of improved systems with optimal accuracy and near-perfect performance, the illusion of model efficacy. However, the value of this effectiveness diminishes when confronted with unseen attacks. In this paper, we go beyond solely algorithmic enhancements and metric adjustments in ML-based Network Intrusion Detection Systems. We design an experiment to test the generalization capabilities of certain classifiers on unseen attacks. Our approach examines the dimensionality parameter's impact through two experimental methodologies, which are applied in two distinct settings. The experimental findings reveal how effectively the models could identify even a fraction of unseen attacks and underscore structural weaknesses in ML-based IDS research and evaluation techniques. Finally, seven evaluation criteria are outlined to address these challenges.

0.29

A Three-Axis Stress Test of LLM vs Classical ML for Network Intrusion Detection under Distribution Shift and Adversarial Evasion

cs.LG cs.AIcs.CR ·2026-09-11 ·Muhammad Ebad Atif, Muhammad Haider Ali
similarity 0.69
Abstract · 11 Pages, 5 figures

Large language models are increasingly benchmarked against classical machine learning for network intrusion detection (NIDS), almost always using same-dataset evaluation, and that protocol turns out to be incomplete. Evaluating XGBoost and RoBERTa-LoRA on two independently collected NetFlow v2 networks across three axes (same-dataset performance, cross-dataset transfer, and adversarial evasion) reveals no universal winner. The two models are statistically tied same-dataset. XGBoost wins decisively under cross-dataset distribution shift, by 15 points of F1 and 25 points of balanced accuracy; on the target network RoBERTa-LoRA's false positive rate reaches 0.78, leaving it barely above chance despite a superficially moderate F1. RoBERTa-LoRA wins decisively under adversarial evasion, by roughly 17 points of F1 at a representative mid-range perturbation strength, while both models hold false positive rates below 0.01 throughout. The model an evaluator would recommend therefore depends entirely on which axis is tested, not on same-dataset accuracy alone. A staged feature-leakage ablation improves cross-dataset transfer non-monotonically, indicating the leakage signal is distributed across the feature representation rather than confined to a few columns, and cross-dataset transfer between our two networks is strongly directional. These results argue for evaluating NIDS models along multiple independent robustness axes, and with more than one metric per axis.

0.31

MIG-COW: Transferable Adversarial Attacks on Deepfake Detectors via Gradient Decomposition

cs.CR cs.AIcs.LG ·2026-10-22 ·Wonjune Seo, Joonhyuk Baek, Yeseong Jung, Saerom Park
top venuehighly cited similarity 0.69
Abstract · 7 pages, 3 figures, ACM MM '25

Despite recent advances, deepfake detectors remain vulnerable to adversarial examples, particularly in diverse, real-world settings. We propose MIG-COW, a novel adversarial attack framework that generates highly generalizable and visually imperceptible adversarial examples. By combining momentum-integrated gradients with a consensus-orthogonal decomposition, MIG-COW captures both shared and model-specific vulnerabilities across heterogeneous CNN and ViT detectors. On the AADD-2025 Challenge benchmarks, MIG-COW achieves a 99.96% white-box attack success rate (ASR) with high perceptual similarity (SSIM), significantly outperforming existing baselines. However, its limited 7.16% ASR against official black-box targets - despite achieving the best overall score - highlights the ongoing challenge of transferability. We also demonstrate that incorporating low-performing but diverse models in the ensemble can degrade attack effectiveness, underscoring the need for careful surrogate model selection in real-world adversarial settings.

0.64