CS Paper Radar

A Large-Scale Evaluation of Cookie Notice Privacy and Accessibility for Blind and Low Vision Users

James M. Clarke, Maryam Mehrnezhad

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-10-31 19:12 UTC · v1

Abstract

We present the first large-scale privacy and accessibility evaluation of cookie notices across 2,061 domains for blind and low vision (BLV) users. Using a Playwright-based crawler, a custom NVDA screen reader add-on, and the Lighthouse and WAVE accessibility tools, we measure UK GDPR/PECR compliance, tracker activity across pre-interaction, post-accept, and post-reject phases, and cookie notice accessibility for screen reader users. We find that 51 % of sites display a cookie notice, of which (at least) 50 % violate UK GDPR/PECR requirements. Accepting a notice produces a mean five-fold increase in tracker activity, and degrades page landmark structure on one in five sites. While 95 % of notices are readable by a screen reader, only 37 % carry a meaningful title, 39 % are announced immediately on page load, and 42 % use descriptive button labels. We reveal a systemic correlation: cookie notices failing legal privacy requirements disproportionately exhibit the weakest screen reader accessibility. This compounding privacy burden on BLV users demands urgent intervention from developers, regulators, and standards bodies.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Senseful Consense: Towards Simplified Cookie Banners using Plain Language

cs.CY cs.HC ·2026-09-09 ·Minela Bećirović, Ha Dao, Mannat Kaur, Martin Johns, Alexandra Dirksen
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 14 pages, 3 figures

While the GDPR and ePrivacy Directive mandate that consent information must be clear and accessible, most modern cookie banners remain obscured by technical jargon, vague phrasing, and frequent content overload or underload. This feasibility study investigates the impact of applying plain language (Einfache Sprache) to cookie banners within the IAB Transparency & Consent Framework (TCF). In our study, we analysed cookie banner texts from 200 websites, using AI-based mapping to categorise extracted content into standardised processing purposes. By substituting complex legal terms with simplified descriptions, we successfully demonstrated that the comprehension barrier can be lowered from a college-graduate level to a 7th-grade level. However, the effectiveness of plain language is inherently constrained by the informativeness of the original content; it cannot compensate for banners that omit legally required details. We conclude that while plain language is a vital tool for digital accessibility, it must be paired with standardised implementation guidelines to ensure that cookie banners are both readable and informative.

0.36

PrivAudit: A Dual-Lens Auditing Framework for Website Privacy Practices under the CCPA

cs.CR ·2026-09-09 ·Mohamed Moustafa Dawoud, Riya Aggarwal, Likith Rahul Krishnamurthy, Ram Sundara Raman
top venuecode/datahot direction similarity 0.66
Abstract · Extended version of a paper accepted to the 2026 ACM SIGSAC Conference on Computer and Communications Security (CCS '26)

Five years after the enforcement of the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), understanding how website privacy practices evolve at scale in response to regulation remains a key challenge for both researchers and regulators. Prior work and regulatory efforts have focused on manual and case-specific enforcement, but there remain no scalable approaches to systematically audit two key user-facing facets of websites that are crucial signals for the CCPA: privacy disclosures and front-end user tracking behavior. In this paper, we present PrivAudit, an automated auditing framework that adopts a dual-lens approach to capture: (1) privacy disclosures through large language model-based analysis of privacy policies grounded in CCPA provisions, and (2) user-observable data collection behavior through automated browser measurements of cookie writes under diverse privacy configurations. We apply PrivAudit to 998 websites and report two broad findings. The law is associated with stronger privacy disclosures: CCPA-subject policies are more likely to disclose opt-out mechanisms, data-sharing practices, and user rights. On the other hand, cookie-based tracking remains pervasive, with both CCPA-subject and not-subject websites setting a total of 6,392 targeting cookies, 49% of which are third-party writes. Moreover, cookies show limited-to-moderate responsiveness to privacy signals and consent choices, even when websites claim to honor them in their disclosures. Our results highlight the need for multi-layered and scalable auditing approaches that combine policy analysis with behavioral evidence. PrivAudit can support these auditing workflows at scale by generating actionable signals and patterns for further manual review. We open-source PrivAudit and are engaging with regulators to support auditing in practice.

0.62

Beyond the Landing Page: Website Blocking, Tracker Visibility, and Human Alignment in Automated Web Crawls

cs.CR ·2026-11-04 ·A H M Nazmus Sakib, Mahsin Bin Akram, Raveen Wijewickrama, Igor Bilogrevic, Murtuza Jadliwala
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Web tracking studies largely rely on automated crawlers, yet their measurements can differ from what people encounter while browsing. Conventional crawlers follow predefined navigation rules, whereas LLM-driven agents decide how to navigate and interact with websites, potentially changing the tracking they encounter. We compare agentic and non-agentic crawlers to examine how websites respond to them, what tracking they record, and how closely their observations match human browsing. Across 2,000 popular websites, we evaluate different navigation strategies, automation frameworks, and stealth configurations, alongside browsing data from 26 participants. We find that website denials increase beyond landing pages for standard browser automation, while a detection-resistant automation framework largely prevents this escalation without increasing recorded tracking. On the same URLs, agentic crawlers record tracking activity from 1.5-1.7 times as many third-party organizations, particularly on consent-managed pages. Agentic crawlers recover 82-87% of tracker organizations observed by participants, compared with 58-68% for non-agentic crawlers, yet roughly half of their own observations are absent from human participant visits. These findings show that avoiding website interventions, increasing tracking visibility, and achieving closer agreement with human observations do not necessarily go hand in hand, highlighting the need to select and validate crawlers according to the measurement objective.

0.17

One String to Rule Them All: Measuring Consent Under the IAB Global Privacy Platform

cs.CR ·2026-11-01 ·Muhammad Abu Bakar Aziz, Christo Wilson
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 11 pages, 8 figures, 3 tables

Many privacy regulations, including the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), require websites to honor users' opt-out choices. To facilitate this process, industry has introduced technical standards such as the IAB Global Privacy Platform (GPP), which aims to standardize collection and transmission of user consent information across multiple jurisdictions. However, it remains unclear whether these standards consistently and correctly transmit user opt-out choices, or whether opt-out choices are respected by advertisers. In this study, we conduct an in-depth analysis of consent propagation under the GPP framework. We collect data from four web crawls across four experimental settings to analyze how widely the standard is adopted, the extent to which opt-out signals propagate from publishers to third parties, and whether these signals reach and alter third-party advertiser behavior. Our analysis reveals several inconsistencies in the implementation and adoption of the standard that result in user consent signals being lost and user opt-out choices not being respected by the advertisers.

0.28

A11yLTLNav: Automatic Detection of Accessibility Navigation Failures

cs.HC cs.SE ·2026-09-16 ·Chenming Ge, Kewen Peng, Chengyang Shi, Ben Greenman, Yue Jiang
similarity 0.60
Abstract

For blind and low-vision (BLV) screen-reader users, a website that appears accessible in a static snapshot can become difficult or impossible to navigate once interaction begins. Yet, most automated accessibility checkers miss failures involving focus, interface state, and accessible feedback across interactions. We present A11yLTLNav, a property-based approach for automatically detecting accessibility navigation failures. Through a structured review of prior research, we organize accessibility navigation failures into a failure taxonomy and formalize a browser-observable subset as executable Linear Temporal Logic properties over action-state traces. A11yLTLNav combines random keyboard exploration with runtime property monitoring to detect these failures during interactions. We evaluate A11yLTLNav on 31 generated websites based on real-world websites and tasks. It reported 309 accessibility failures, of which 274 were confirmed, achieving 88.7% precision and identifying more confirmed failures than the comparison checkers. Our results show that A11yLTLNav transforms accessibility knowledge into reusable checks of interface behavior over time.

0.20

Bridging the Gap: A Longitudinal Analysis of Extended Identifiers in the Post-Cookie Era

cs.NI ·2026-09-02 ·Michael Smith, Riley Grossman, Krzysztof Franaszek, Antonio Torres-Agüero, Pritam Sen +2 more
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 10 pages

As third-party cookies fade because of browser restrictions, the online advertising ecosystem is turning to extended identifiers (EIDs) as an alternative. EIDs are persistent user identifiers, such as hashed email addresses, that are employed to link users across domains and devices. This paper presents a 41-month longitudinal study examining EID usage in over 145 million HTTP header bidding requests sent to six major supply-side platforms (SSPs) from 616,539 websites. Our findings show that EIDs are widely used and are becoming increasingly prevalent in the digital advertising ecosystem, reaching 83.76% of studied websites by May 2025. Our analysis of the 18 popular EID providers that account for 99.42% of all transmitted EIDs in our dataset raises concerns about the readiness of EIDs as an alternative to third-party cookie tracking. In terms of accuracy, only one identity provider consistently recognizes and identifies that the visitor is a self-identified bot crawler, and many providers regularly transmit multiple EIDs for the same visitor. We also identify privacy concerns with EIDs, as 12 of the providers create persistent EIDs that can identify the same user across visits, websites, devices, and months. Finally, we found that 16 providers transmit EIDs on EU websites without user consent.

0.28

Agentic Web Accessibility Auditing: A Criterion-Specific Framework for Translating WCAG Requirements into Assessments

cs.HC ·2026-09-08 ·Arjun Mishra, Pranav Karthik, Byungjun Bae, Dongwook Yoon
dataset similarity 0.59
Abstract · Preprint. 26 pages, 7 figures. Revised title, abstract, conclusion, and exposition; clarified methods, dataset construction, and interpretat…

Web accessibility auditing requires interpreting diverse requirements and examining interface behavior. Rule-based checks and noninteractive model assessments can miss barriers requiring contextual or interactive evidence. We present an agentic framework that assigns a vision-language agent to each accessibility requirement. Guided by tailored instructions, agents inspect webpages, operate controls, and record evidence supporting their findings. We implement the framework for 40 requirements from the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG). To compare detection and cost, we construct a dataset of 250 page-criterion records derived from expert audits across 11 scholarly platforms. Agents recover 67 of 78 reported positive cases (86% recall), compared with 36% for axe-core, a rule-based checker, and 67% for an uncued, noninteractive vision-language model, at lower precision (56%). They recover nine of ten Keyboard and No Keyboard Trap cases missed by both baselines. Together, the framework, implementations, and dataset support automated accessibility auditing grounded in inspectable evidence.

0.16

InterA11y: Interactive Web Accessibility Error Detection with LLM Agents

cs.HC ·2026-10-29 ·Mingyuan Zhong, Mengqi Shi, Davin Win Kyi, Ajit Mallavarapu, Xia Chen +2 more
code/data similarity 0.58
Abstract · We release our code and data at https://github.com/jszh/InterA11y

Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown potential to expand the coverage of web accessibility evaluation. However, current LLM-based checkers neglect much of the interactive and dynamic web contexts, resulting in limited coverage, high false discovery rates, and inconsistent performance across models. We present InterA11y, an agentic accessibility evaluation system that combines rubrics and interactive tools to support LLM agents in evaluating accessibility effectively. The rubrics decompose WCAG success criteria (SC) into testable aspects and guide agents in collecting and interpreting evidence. The interactive tools inspect or operate a webpage deterministically to collect evidence, such as focus appearances and error messages. We developed these rubrics and tools on 682 curated test cases grounded in established accessibility guidelines that target 10 commonly violated SC. We evaluated InterA11y on 197 expert-annotated cases sampled from 54 real webpages. Results show InterA11y achieves higher recall than the strongest evaluated LLM-driven baseline (79.0% vs. 44.4%), while maintaining comparable precision to best rule-based checkers (93.1% vs. 90.3-97.6%), with little variability between models. Further, when equipped with our interactive tools, general-purpose web agents detect more accessibility errors with fewer false positives and less token usage than without these tools.

0.33