CS Paper Radar

Submodularity Is Barely Testable

Diptaksho Palit, Yuichi Yoshida

cs.DS ·submitted 2026-11-02 01:39 UTC · v1

Abstract

In 2010, Seshadhri and Vondrák asked: is submodularity testable? For functions $f : \{ 0, 1 \}^n \to \mathbb{R}$, they gave a tester that makes $2^{O(\sqrt{n} \log n)}$ queries. We show that every tester, even an adaptive one with two-sided error, must make $2^{Ω(\sqrt{n})}$ queries, thereby concluding: submodularity is barely testable.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Optimal universal sets for submodular functions

cs.DS ·2026-11-18 ·Marek Adamczyk, Richard Ueltzen, Jan Vondrak
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract · Results obtained with the assistance of GPT-6 Astra

We resolve the question of deterministic non-adaptive algorithms for nonnegative submodular maximization: We prove that for every $n \geq 2$ and $ε\in (0,\frac{1}{4})$, there is a polynomial-size family ${F}_{n,ε}$, $|{F}_{n,ε}| = n^{O(1/ε^2 \log (1/ε))}$, such that for every nonnegative submodular function $f:2^{[n]} \to {\bf R}$, $\max_{S \in {F}_{n,ε}} f(S) \geq (1/4 - ε) \max_{S \subseteq [n]} f(S)$. It is also easy to show that a factor better than $1/4$ cannot be achieved by any fixed polynomial-size family. A related result that we prove is that there is a distribution ${D}_{n,ε}$ supported on polynomially many subsets of $[n]$ such that $(1 - ε) {\bf E}_{R \sim {U}_n}[f(R)] \leq {\bf E}_{R \sim {D}_{n,ε}}[f(R)] \leq {\bf E}_{R \sim {U}_n}[f(R)]$, where ${U}_n$ is the uniform distribution on $2^{[n]}$, and $f$ is any nonnegative submodular function. This is interesting in light of the fact that uniform convergence does not hold for submodular functions: Sampling polynomially many sets from ${U}_n$ and taking the empirical mean does not converge to the true expectation uniformly for all submodular functions. The construction of ${F}_{n,ε}$ and ${D}_{n,ε}$ is based on a new semidefinite extension of submodular functions: We show that the Goemans-Williamson rounding technique for a near-orthogonal arrangement of vectors gives a value close to the uniform expectation, and this rounding can be derandomized, since near-orthogonal vectors can be constructed in logarithmic dimension.

0.09

A Tight Scale-Locality Bound for Partial Detection in Non-Adaptive Group Testing

cs.DS ·2026-08-12 ·Nader H. Bshouty
publishedtheory similarity 0.59
Abstract

We give a lower bound for randomized non-adaptive group testing when the goal is to find any $\ell$ defective items but the total number $d$ of defectives is unknown. Bshouty and Haddad-Zaknoon proved an upper bound of $O(\ell\log^2 n)$ tests and a lower bound of $$Ω\!\left(\frac{\ell\log^2 n}{\log \ell+\log\log n}\right).$$ We prove the matching lower bound. More generally, we show that every randomized non-adaptive algorithm that succeeds with constant probability for every defective set must use $$Ω\!\left(\ell\log^2(n/\ell)\right)$$ tests. The proof is as follows. At a fixed value of $d$, finding $\ell$ defectives requires about $\ell\log(n/d)$ bits of information. On the other hand, one fixed group test is informative only when its size is tuned to the scale of $d$; across all logarithmic scales of $d$, a single test contributes only $O(1)$ bits. Summing over all scales gives the lower bound. We also record the matching upper bound $$O\!\left(\ell\log^2(n/\ell)\right),$$ obtained by running the known-$d$ algorithm in parallel over dyadic guesses for $d$. Thus the randomized non-adaptive complexity of unknown-$d$ partial detection is $Θ\!\left(\ell\log^2(n/\ell)\right)$ for constant success probability.

0.22

A Tight Oracle Threshold for \(k\)-Submodular Maximization

cs.DS ·2026-10-19 ·Siyuan Chen
theory similarity 0.55
Abstract · 5 pages

We prove that, for every \(\varepsilon>0\), a \((\frac{k}{2k-1}+\varepsilon)\)-approximation algorithm for maximizing monotone \(k\)-submodular functions requires exponentially many value-oracle queries. This improves the \(\frac{k+1}{2k}\) oracle bound of Iwata, Tanigawa, and Yoshida. Their \(\frac{k}{2k-1}\)-approximation algorithm therefore gives the exact threshold in the monotone setting. For \(k\ge5\), our bound also matches, up to an arbitrarily small loss, Aggarwal's recent approximation guarantee for non-monotone \(k\)-submodular maximization.

0.10

A Sharp Barrier of Consistent Submodular Maximization: Any Improvement over $2-\sqrt{2}$ Entails Exponential Queries or Linear Recourse

cs.DS cs.LG ·2026-09-09 ·Shi Fu, Qixin Zhang, Dacheng Tao
theory similarity 0.55
Abstract

Consistent submodular maximization aims to maintain a high-utility subset of size at most $k$ as new elements arrive one by one, while changing only a limited number of elements per update. Previously, [DFL+25](STOC '25) established an information-theoretic bound of $2/3$ and gave the first polynomial-time randomized algorithm with a $0.51$-approximation guarantee. However, a fundamental question remained open: Is it possible to design an efficient algorithm for consistent submodular maximization that matches the classical offline $(1-1/e)$-approximation? In this paper, we answer this question in the negative by proving that the sharp approximation threshold achievable with polynomially many value queries and worst-case constant recourse is \[β:=2-\sqrt{2}\approx0.5858<1-1/e.\] Specifically, we develop an improved poly-time randomized algorithm, which can attain a $(β-\varepsilon)$-approximation in expectation at each fixed time with $O(\varepsilon^{-2})$ worst-case recourse. The cornerstone of this algorithm is a novel anchored sampling scheme, which uses only value queries on subsets of the elements seen so far to construct a solution that remains competitive under unknown future arrivals. Conversely, we establish a matching lower bound by showing that any fixed improvement over $β$ requires either exponentially many value queries or $Ω(k)$ changes per update. Furthermore, we characterize the impact of curvature by establishing a sharp threshold of $1-(\sqrt{2}-1)\vartheta$ for consistent submodular maximization, where $\vartheta\in[0,1]$ denotes the total curvature. Surprisingly, for weighted coverage objectives, we devise a poly-time randomized algorithm that can match the optimal $(1-1/e-\varepsilon)$-approximation with $O(\varepsilon^{-1})$ worst-case recourse, thereby separating coverage maximization from general submodular maximization in the consistent settings.

0.45

Testing Implies Distance Estimation with Polynomial Loss

cs.DS math.CO ·2026-11-03 ·Gaia Carenini, Cameron Seth
similarity 0.55
Abstract

A tester decides whether a graph has a property or is far from having it. A distance estimator asks for more: it must approximately determine how many edges need to be changed. A property is said to be testable if there is a tester with a number of queries bounded independently of the graph's order for each conceivable distance. Similarly, if a property admits an estimator with a number of queries bounded independently of the graph's order, it is said to be estimable. Fischer and Newman proved that, in the dense graph model, every testable property is also estimable. We show that the passage from testing to estimation requires only a polynomial increase in query complexity. This resolves a long-standing open problem in property testing, previously tackled by Fiat and Ron, by Hoppen, Kohayakawa, Lang, Lefmann, and Stagni, and by Gishboliner, Kushnir, and Shapira.

0.27

Symmetric Submodular Minimization from Comparisons

cs.DS ·2026-10-07 ·James Fox, David P. Woodruff
theory similarity 0.55
Abstract

Given value-oracle access to a symmetric submodular function $f:2^V\to\mathbb{R}$ with $|V|=n$, a nontrivial minimizer can be found using $O(n^3)$ value queries. We study the weaker comparison model, in which a query on $S,T\subseteq V$ reveals only whether $f(S)$ is smaller than, equal to, or larger than $f(T)$. We give a deterministic polynomial-time algorithm that finds a nontrivial minimizer of any symmetric submodular function using $O(n^3)$ comparisons, matching the best-known deterministic value-oracle bound despite not knowing the function values. More generally, the same $O(n^3)$-comparison bound holds for minimization over the nonempty members of any downward-closed family. Our algorithm combines the minimum-capacity ordering recently introduced by Iwata and Konno with the contraction framework of Goemans and Soto. Applying this result to weighted graph cut functions resolves the main open question of Cohen-Addad et al., who gave an $\widetilde{O}(n^3)$-comparison algorithm that runs in exponential time and asked whether a weighted minimum cut can be found in polynomial time using comparisons. For graphs with $m$ edges of integer weight at most $B$, we also give a deterministic polynomial-time algorithm that finds a minimum cut using \[ \widetilde{O}\!\left(n^2+\min\!\left\{mB,\,nB^2\right\}\right) \] comparisons, improving on the $O(n^3)$ bound when $B$ is small. Finally, we show that every randomized algorithm that outputs a minimum cut with probability at least $2/3$ makes $Ω(n \log n)$ expected comparisons in the worst case. Under the stronger assumption that all edge weights are polynomially bounded integers, we obtain an $Ω(n \log \log n)$ expected comparison lower bound. These bounds contrast with the value-oracle model, where no $ω(n)$ lower bound is known even for deterministic algorithms.

0.33

Universal set families for maximization of nonnegative submodular and XOS functions

cs.DS ·2026-09-17 ·Chandra Chekuri, Richard Ueltzen, Jan Vondrak
theoryhot direction similarity 0.54
Abstract · The main results were obtained with ChatGPT-5.6 Sol

We consider the question of designing a universal family of sets $F \subset 2^{[n]}$ such that for any function $f:2^{[n]} \to R_{\geq 0}$ in a certain class, we have $$\max_{S \in F} f(S) \geq c(n) \cdot \max_{S \subset [n]} f(S).$$ We prove that there is a family of subpolynomial size such that for any nonnegative submodular function, $c(n) = Ω(\frac{\log \log n}{\log n})$, and there is a family of logarithmic size such that $c(n) = Ω(\frac{1}{\log n})$. We also prove that pairwise independence (which achieves a constant factor for graph cut functions), or even $k$-wise independence, does not imply a bound better than $O(\frac{1}{\sqrt{\log n}})$ for submodular functions. On the other hand, we prove that for any polynomially representable subclass of nonnegative submodular functions (such as the matroid connectivity functions for matroid representable over $F_q$), a constant-factor universal family of polynomial size always exists. For absolute XOS functions (a class that we introduce, in the form $f(S) = \max_i |\sum_{j \in S} w_{ij} + c_i|$ where $w_{ij}, c_i \in R$), we design a family of polynomial size such that $c(n) \geq \sqrt{\frac{\log n}{n}}$, and prove that there is no polynomial-size family achieving a factor better than $O(\sqrt{\frac{\log n}{n}})$.

0.51

Near-Linear Lower Bounds for Testing Directed Acyclicity

cs.DS ·2026-11-03 ·Artur Czumaj, Pan Peng, Yuyang Wang
similarity 0.54
Abstract

We study testing acyclicity of directed graphs in the bounded-degree incidence-lists model, where a tester can query the outneighbors of a vertex but not its inneighbors. Despite significant effort, no tester with $o(n)$ queries is known, while the best established lower bounds are $\widetildeΩ(n^{5/9})$ for one-sided testers (Chen, Randolph, Servedio, and Sun, 2022) and $Ω(n^{1/3})$ for two-sided testers (Bender and Ron, 2002). We show that a query exponent arbitrarily close to one is necessary: for every fixed $η\in(0,1)$, there exists a constant $\varepsilon_η>0$ such that, for every constant $d\ge2$, every randomized adaptive two-sided $\varepsilon_η$-tester for acyclicity of simple $n$-vertex directed graphs whose indegrees and outdegrees are at most $d$ makes $Ω(n^{1-η})$ queries. Our proof overcomes two barriers. First, in previous constructions, the acyclic part of the graph is easy to recognize, which helps an algorithm stay inside the cyclic part. We hide a high-girth cyclic core inside a hierarchy of acyclic masking regions, in which each region imitates the levels below it and can be told apart from them only through rare events, and an iterated information-theoretic argument shows that every exploration observes only small, low-diameter forest components of the core. Second, a two-sided tester may exploit the statistics of collisions without ever seeing a cycle, and at a near-linear budget collisions are unavoidable. We compare complete transcripts with those of an acyclic input built on a fixed core by counting injective embeddings of the observed forest: in high-girth cores, all connected collision patterns of bounded order contribute identically, which makes the two transcript distributions statistically indistinguishable.

0.24