CS Paper Radar

Fast, Cheap, and Fair? Evaluating Decision Models

Muhammad Uzair Ul Haq, Davide Rigoni, Alessandro Sperduti, Flavia Fabris

cs.AI ·submitted 2026-11-03 08:34 UTC · v1
code/data

Abstract

Industries are increasingly adopting AI-driven systems to automate a wide range of tasks, including high-stakes decisions in human resources, such as candidate screening and recruitment. This makes evaluating their fairness essential, particularly when decisions directly affect individuals' opportunities. Accordingly, the EU AI Act classifies recruitment AI systems as high-risk, imposing strict requirements on their deployment. In this context, compact ``System~1'' decision models offer a fast and cost-efficient alternative to general-purpose LLMs, yet their fairness remains largely unexplored. This article presents the first systematic bias and fairness audit of \jev{}, a typed-decision model targeting recruitment applications. The study evaluates how explicit demographic attributes and implicit candidate cues influence screening scores, rankings, and shortlisting outcomes. These effects are compared against a noise floor derived from name substitutions and typographical variations. The evaluation also examines output validity, latency, and cost. Counterfactual CV datasets and evaluation code are released for reproducibility.

Comment
submitted for review

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Applied and Filtered: An End-to-End Algorithmic Fairness Audit of A Public Employment Agency

cs.CY ·2026-08-13 ·Gemma Galdón-Clavell
similarity 0.72
Abstract

Algorithmic fairness evaluation commonly assesses AI systems as bounded technical components, abstracting away the organizational context in which they operate. We present, to our knowledge, the first independent end-to-end fairness audit of a semi-automated hiring system operated by Barcelona Activa, a public employment agency using the third-party TalentClue platform for candidate search and shortlisting. We analyze approximately 497,000 candidate-vacancy pipeline entries from September 2017 to September 2022, covering seven pipeline stages that span automated processing, human discretion, candidate data, and employer decisions. Aggregate outcomes across binary genders are statistically indistinguishable, yet this parity masks substantial disparities by salary level, age, and gender identity. Women face adverse impact in mid-salary shortlisting (DIR = 0.786, p < 0.001), alongside salary disparities in 15 of 20 sectors and a compounded disadvantage for women aged 46-55 (DIR = 0.77). Non-binary candidates are shortlisted at less than one third the rate of men (DIR = 0.295), although this estimate rests on a small sample (N = 285). Candidates aged 55 and over are entirely absent from the pipeline despite comprising 15.6% of Barcelona's labor force. The gender gap in shortlisting narrows over time, from 6.5 percentage points in 2017 to 1.3 in 2022. The audit further reveals a vendor-deployer information asymmetry: Barcelona Activa lacks access to key information about TalentClue's matching logic and evaluation. Fairness outcomes can thus arise from interactions among automated processing, human discretion, data quality, vendor opacity, and pipeline structure. We build on prior calls for sociotechnical, end-to-end fairness evaluation, showing empirically why model-level assessment alone can be insufficient for understanding fairness in deployed systems.

0.04

Counterfactual Bias Testing for Application Tracking System

cs.AI ·2026-08-27 ·Sai Yashwant, Shruti Bansal, Anurag Dubey, Samaroha Chatterjee, Satyam Kumar +2 more
hot direction similarity 0.70
Abstract

Automated candidate-job matching systems are increasingly classified as high-risk AI under emerging regulation, yet auditing them for demographic bias is expensive: classical correspondence-audit studies require hand-crafted resumes and manual submission, which does not scale to fast pipeline retraining cycles. This paper presents a general, reusable methodology that (1) uses task-specialized LLM agents to synthesize identity-neutral base resumes and inject controlled demographic treatments across five protected-characteristic axes (sex/gender, age, residence, language, disability), producing a K x (1+N) correspondence-audit matrix; (2) qualitatively flags inferred protected characteristics per an EU AI Act-aligned prompt; (3) ranks candidates against a job description via a fine-tuned sentence-embedding model and cosine similarity; and (4) computes a nine-metric fairness suite spanning counterfactual (score delta, mean absolute rank change, flip rate), group-fairness (top-K retention, four-fifths/impact ratio), and merit-aware (Recall@K, nDCG@K, equal opportunity, equalized odds) families, each with bootstrap confidence intervals, significance tests, and Benjamini-Hochberg correction, culminating in an automated PASS/INVESTIGATE/FAIL report with a composite risk score. On an example corpus of 5 job orders, 100 base candidates, and 10 demographic treatments (90 metric x variant evaluations): score shifts, top-K retention, and merit-aware rate gaps stay within tolerance for every treatment, but a rank-stability metric (MARC) and nDCG@K each surface borderline findings - including one on the neutral baseline itself - that a score- or retention-only view would miss. The results argue for multi-metric, multi-family auditing over any single aggregate score, and for LLM-agent-generated audits as a practical, low-cost complement to human-curated audits for any candidate-job matching pipeline.

0.23

Linguistic Triggers of Gender and Racial Bias in Open-Weight LLMs Applied to Recruitment

cs.CL cs.AIcs.CY ·2026-09-16 ·Kosuke Kitahara, Nobuhiro Yamaguchi
published similarity 0.68
Abstract · Accepted at the 9th AAAI/ACM Conference on AI, Ethics, and Society (AIES 2026). Extended version with Appendices A-B (prompt templates and f…

Open-weight large language models are rapidly entering hiring pipelines, yet their discriminatory failure modes -- and the regulatory exposure these create under the EU AI Act high-risk classification (Annex III) and U.S. EEOC adverse-impact analysis -- remain poorly understood. We present the first systematic, multi-model audit of open-weight LLMs that treats job-posting language as the primary experimental variable, evaluating six models (Llama 3.2, Mistral, Gemma 3, Qwen 3, Phi 3, DeepSeek-R1) across four controlled experiments that jointly probe recruiter-simulation and job-seeker-simulation tasks. We find that (1) agentic posting language depresses recruiter recommendation scores for female candidates (r_rb = 0.309, p_Bonf = 7x10^-5; model-fixed-effects r_rb = 0.448), while communal language partially reverses the penalty; and (2) coded-exclusion language suppresses non-White recruiter scores at large effect sizes (r_rb = 0.646-0.758) and, on the job-seeker side, selectively deters non-White personas from expressing interest -- operationalizing a chilling-effect mechanism at scale. A label-ablation experiment isolates the explicit demographic persona label as the primary causal driver, and Word Embedding Association Tests corroborate these findings at the representational level (d = 1.01-1.45 under Caliskan et al.'s multi-word gender attribute lists). We translate these results into a concrete pre-deployment audit protocol -- posting-vocabulary scoring, persona-conditioned LLM probing, and adverse-impact flagging against the four-fifths threshold -- that operationalizes the documentation and risk-management obligations Annex III imposes on high-risk AI in recruitment.

0.35

Applications of Risk Science to AI Fairness Evaluation: Principles, Challenges, and Best Practices

cs.CY cs.AI ·2026-08-30 ·Kyra Wilson, Sabrina Kang, Saloni Dash, Aylin Caliskan
publishedhot direction similarity 0.67
Abstract · Accepted at AIES 2026

Scholarly work which aims to describe potential societal impacts (e.g., risks) of proliferating technology (especially related to artificial intelligence or other algorithmic systems) is likely to have an impact beyond the scientific communities it was written for, given that general society itself is a primary object of study. However, it is an open question whether the current practices of AI evaluation scholarship follow the principles and best practices established by risk science, which aims to systematically generate knowledge related to understanding, assessing, communicating, managing, and governing risk. In this work, we examine this in depth by conducting a literature review of scholarly works purporting to evaluate the bias or fairness of technological systems used for tasks related to hiring and employment. Through analysis of 22 common fairness evaluation metrics and studies using them, we find that most characterize the severity of bias- or fairness-related consequences but do not follow best practices to characterize the uncertainty around either the occurrence of these consequences or severity estimates. Next, we conduct a case study of fairness evaluation for an AI-mediated resume screening task and demonstrate how principles of risk science can be incorporated into such an evaluation. Finally, we propose the AI Risk Report Card, which facilitates the reporting and communication of risk assessment results to stakeholders in positions to act based on the predicted risks. The outcomes of these activities suggest that further research at the convergence of risk science and AI evaluation can lead to advancements in AI assessments of societal impact by enabling shared frameworks to evaluate and discuss AI risks both within and outside of the scientific community.

0.36

Counterfactual, Per-Decision Bias Auditing for Automated Hiring: Localizing and Explaining Disparate Impact in Applicant Tracking Systems

cs.CY cs.CR ·2026-08-21 ·Jay Barach
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 10 pages, 5 figures, 8 tables

Automated applicant tracking systems increasingly decide who advances in hiring, and litigation and regulation now demand that those decisions be auditable. Existing tools sit at two extremes. Group fairness metrics such as the disparate impact ratio summarize a whole population but cannot say which individual decisions were unfair or why, while local explainers such as SHAP attribute a single prediction but are not connected to the legal standard by which hiring bias is judged. We present the AI Bias Firewall (AIBF), a method that audits an applicant tracking system one decision at a time. AIBF neutralizes a candidate's protected-attribute proxies, re-scores the decision, and measures the resulting counterfactual shift, which yields a signed per-decision bias in score points, a flag for decisions the protected attributes changed, and a plain-language explanation naming the responsible factors. We evaluate on two real public datasets, Adult and COMPAS, rather than on synthetic data. The per-decision counterfactual shift is faithful, aggregating to reproduce the known group level disparity, for example a mean shift of +7.5 points for the privileged group and -8.0 for the disadvantaged group on Adult, consistent with the measured statistical parity difference. AIBF identifies the decisions that protected attributes flipped with an area under the ROC curve of 0.963 on Adult, against 0.672 for a baseline that flags by group membership, and it identifies the harmed candidates so precisely that reviewing only five percent of decisions surfaces fifty-five percent of them, against six percent under group based review. We also report a limitation: correcting flagged decisions raises the disparate impact ratio substantially but not to legal parity, because features labeled as merit carry residual proxy correlation. AIBF is released under the Apache 2.0 license with code and experiments.

0.10

AI evaluators favor job applications written by certain AI models, independent of candidate quality

cs.CY cs.AIcs.MA ·2026-10-30 ·Nicolò Pagan, Michael Andreas Ebling, Stefania Ionescu, Anikó Hannák
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Job applicants increasingly use large language models (LLMs) to write cover letters, while employers deploy LLMs to screen them. In this all-AI setting, we ask whether the \emph{choice of model} affects hiring outcomes independently of candidate qualifications. We introduce a multi-model auditing framework pairing eleven LLM writer agents with nine API-hosted evaluator agents across ten job descriptions and fifty candidates per job. Four findings emerge. First, we identify a generative preference hierarchy: a consistent global ranking of writer models by evaluator acceptance, in which locally hosted models are systematically disadvantaged regardless of their license, compounded by self-preference bias where evaluators favour their own outputs. Second, evaluator models differ substantially in how much bias they introduce based on applicants' tool choice, offering actionable guidance for fairer screening design. Third, this hierarchy has measurable competitive consequences: in the most adverse pairing, approximately two (1.8) out of twenty-five qualified candidates are filtered out purely due to model mismatch. Fourth, a common mechanism explains the patterns above: writer preference and self-preference trace to a combination of how much each writer leans on specific stylistic cues and how strongly evaluators, often unanimously, reward or penalise those same cues. A further check finds little evidence that an unmeasured "writer fingerprint" remains once these same features are accounted for. We discuss implications for algorithmic fairness in employment, regulation of AI-assisted screening, and the design of auditing frameworks that can be reapplied as the model landscape evolves.

0.21

Fairness Beyond Anonymization? Demographic Leakage in German LLM-Generated Resumes

cs.CL cs.LG ·2026-08-28 ·Charlotte Leininger, Helena Veit, Matthias Aßenmacher, Andreas Bender
hot direction similarity 0.67
Abstract · Accepted at ECML PKDD 2026 Workshop on Bias and Fairness in AI [BIAS 2026@ ECML/PKDD]

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly integrated into AI-assisted hiring pipelines, including automated resume generation and screening. Under the EU AI Act, the hiring domain is classified as high-risk, making fairness and transparency critical requirements. Existing work has primarily focused on explicit hiring decisions, while less attention has been paid to whether generated resumes themselves encode recoverable demographic information. In this work, we conduct a two-stage audit of demographic leakage in German-language LLM-generated resumes. First, we use ChatGPT (GPT-4o-mini), Gemini 2.5 Flash-Lite, and multiple scales of the open-weight Qwen 3 model family (4B, 8B, and 14B) to generate resumes from real anonymized job-matching profiles, systematically varying gender- and ethnicity-associated names while holding qualifications constant. Second, we simulate a downstream resume screening scenario, where the generated resumes are first anonymized and gender-neutralized, before demographic leakage classifiers are trained on the resulting texts. We find that, despite these interventions, classifiers reliably distinguish between resumes generated with male and female names. This leakage is not driven by overtly gendered wording, but by subtle differences in the usage of semantically equivalent, formally gender-neutral terms in German. In contrast, ethnicity-related leakage remains comparatively weak across models. Our findings demonstrate that apparently neutral resume generation can still preserve highly predictive demographic signals, raising concerns about anonymization-based fairness interventions in multilingual AI hiring pipelines.

0.33

A Taxonomy-Driven Synthetic Dataset for Retrieval Effectiveness and Fairness Evaluation in Hiring

cs.LG cs.CLcs.CYcs.IR ·2026-11-06 ·Warren Jouanneau, Morgane Hoffmann, Emma Jouffroy, Marc Palyart
benchmark similarity 0.65
Abstract

While machine learning hiring tools are ubiquitous, the need for privacy regulations and commercial sensitivity makes public benchmarking legally complex. We address this challenge by introducing a taxonomy-driven, fully synthetic HR dataset and benchmark to simultaneously evaluate retrieval effectiveness and algorithmic fairness. Grounded in 660K real freelancer profiles, our multilingual corpus features candidate profiles, project briefs, and counterfactual demographic twins. Auditing state-of-the-art embedding models reveals performance divergence from general MTEB scores, alongside fairness disparities in grammatically gendered languages. This demonstrates that general benchmarks are insufficient for HR, requiring tailored evaluations to identify Pareto-optimal models that balance semantic accuracy and fairness.

0.25