CS Paper Radar

One Strategy Does Not Fit All: Rethinking Data Labeling for Just-in-Time Vulnerability Prediction

Quan Tran, Duong Nguyen, Thanh Le-Cong, Triet Huynh Minh Le, M. Ali Babar, Hoang Dieu Vu, Quyet-Thang Huynh

cs.SE ·submitted 2026-11-03 14:57 UTC · v1

Abstract

Just-In-Time Vulnerability Prediction (JIT-VP) identifies security risks in code changes at commit time, enabling early feedback before vulnerabilities enter software systems. However, its practical reliability is challenged by the difficulty of constructing accurate labels. Multiple strategies with different trade-offs have been proposed to identify vulnerability-fixing commits (VFCs) and vulnerability-introducing commits (VICs) for dataset construction, leading to substantially different datasets. This makes it difficult to separate model performance from dataset construction. Moreover, real-world quality assurance requires not only classification but also prioritizing high-risk commits and localizing vulnerable causes. This paper presents an extensive empirical study of how labeling strategies affect these downstream tasks. We constructed 28 datasets using four VFC and four VIC labeling strategies across OpenSSL and Linux kernel, then evaluated six representative JIT-VP models for classification, prioritization, and localization. Our results show that labeling effectiveness is strongly task-dependent. Manual VFC labeling combined with vulnerability-specific VIC labeling provides the most reliable performance for classification and prioritization, significantly outperforming 11 of 15 alternatives. Meanwhile, precision-first VFC labeling combined with LLM-assisted VIC labeling performs best for localization, significantly outperforming 7 of 15 alternatives. These findings demonstrate that no single labeling strategy is universally optimal and highlight the importance of task-oriented dataset construction.

Comment
29 pages

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Beyond a Single Commit: Anchor-Guided Reconstruction of Multi-Commit Patches

cs.CR ·2026-11-06 ·Jialiang Dong, Willy Susilo, Xu Gai, Liuhuo Wan, Chao Zhang +2 more
similarity 0.74
Abstract

Vulnerability patch identification plays a critical role in software security by linking reported vulnerabilities and the corresponding fixes, enabling reliable vulnerability analysis, mitigation, and automated security tool development. As software systems evolve in complexity, vulnerability remediation has increasingly shifted from single-commit fixes to multi-commit fixing processes. Although many studies have been proposed to identify fixing commits associated with target vulnerabilities automatically, they often suffer from inaccurate semantic analysis or excessive workload for language models. These limitations reduce both the effectiveness and comprehensiveness of fixing commit identification. To improve patch identification, we propose an effective and comprehensive patch identification framework, HARPOON, which not only enhances the accuracy of identifying individual fixing commits, but also investigates dependencies among commits to achieve comprehensive commit recognition for target vulnerabilities. Experimental results show that HARPOON significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art approaches. HARPOON successfully identified 895 vulnerability patches that were not previously maintained in public vulnerability databases. Among them, 663 are previously unrecorded fixes associated with 323 CRITICAL- or HIGH-severity vulnerabilities.

0.09

Cyber-JEV: Matched Contrastive Fine-Tuning of Language Models for Fast Source-Code Vulnerability Triage

cs.CR ·2026-11-02 ·Zhuyi Zhao, Shengjie Yuan, Shengyu Wang, Kang Wei, Wang Yang +2 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.72
Abstract · 8 pages, 3 figures, 5 tables. Added project page (manuscript unchanged): https://ricardoz-kisara.github.io/cyber-jev/

Single-pass scoring models such as Jev give each code function a vulnerability probability, so that security teams can rank many functions for review without generating written explanations. Training an open-weight model for this task is limited by data. Benchmarks with both vulnerable and non-vulnerable labels keep few vulnerable functions once examples related to the test data are removed, while larger public vulnerability records mostly contain vulnerable functions only. Mixing the two lets the data source predict the label, and training on the labeled data alone leaves a model that often scores a fixed function above its vulnerable original. We present Cyber-JEV, a fine-tuning method that uses fix commits to turn these records into comparison groups. Each group holds a vulnerable function, its patched version and up to two unchanged functions from the same file, so the model sees the change that removed a recorded defect. One shared model learns two tasks: classifying functions from the labeled reference data, and ranking the vulnerable function above the other members of its group. At test time the input is one function and the output is a vulnerability score. On a test benchmark of 7,270 functions, an ensemble of five fine-tuned Qwen3.5-4B models reaches an area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 0.814, compared with 0.743 for Jev 1.13. With the 4,031 alerts of Jev as the review budget, it misses 16 of 322 vulnerable functions instead of 39. Compared with training on the reference data alone, it ranks the vulnerable version above the patched version 14.8 to 29.2 percentage points more often on three sets of real fixes. Such scores can order the changed functions of a pull request or a release for review under a fixed budget.

0.25

How Reliable Are NVD CWE Labels? A Large-Scale Semantic Audit with Seclometry

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-08-22 ·Yu Nong, Yao Du, Majid Behravan, Haipeng Cai
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.71
Abstract

CWE labels in the National Vulnerability Database (NVD) are widely treated as ground truth for vulnerability search, scanner evaluation, benchmark construction, learning-based security tools, and vulnerability prioritization. Yet their reliability has not been systematically measured at scale, despite growing concerns about NVD's enrichment backlog and anecdotal reports of inaccurate, ambiguous, or missing labels. This paper presents a large-scale, code-semantics-grounded measurement of CWE labeling quality in NVD. We build CWEAgent, a validated auditing instrument based on seclometry, a structured representation of vulnerability semantics that captures the root cause, trigger condition, violated security property, exploit mechanism, and impact of vulnerable code. On a manually curated benchmark of 100 open-source CVEs, CWEAgent achieves 85% top-1 accuracy and 92% ambiguity-aware accuracy. Applying CWEAgent to 15,556 open-source CVEs disclosed from 2017-2026, we find that only 49.70% of NVD CWE labels exactly match the code-grounded label. Another 31.37% are defensible alternatives under taxonomy ambiguity, while 3.63% are evidence-inconsistent likely errors. Label reliability varies sharply by assigning organization and weakness type, and apparent project- or language-level differences are largely composition effects of those underlying weakness types. Evidence-inconsistent labels have also increased over time. Through manual review of 434 confirmed mislabels, we identify six recurring error patterns, showing that CWE noise is a structural problem in vulnerability metadata rather than isolated annotation mistakes.

0.28

COMPASS: Predicting the Relationship of Multiple Patches for Vulnerabilities with LLMs

cs.SE ·2026-09-30 ·Yi Song, Dongchen Xie, Xiaoyuan Xie, He Zhang, Lin Xu +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.71
Abstract

Modern software heavily relies on code reuse, so upstream vulnerability fixes do not automatically propagate to downstream codebases. Downstream maintainers must manually adopt patches to eliminate known risks. In practice, a single vulnerability often corresponds to multiple patches, which greatly complicates downstream patch adoption because different patch relationships imply different adoption strategies. To address this challenge, we first manually inspect large-scale multi-patch vulnerabilities (about 1K) in the real world and interview experienced developers, summarizing six typical types of patch relationships, i.e., Merge, Mirror, Better Solution, Fixing-of-Fixing, Collaboration, and Separation. Based on these observations, we propose COMPASS, an automated approach that predicts the relationships of multiple vulnerability patches with large language models. Given a CVE as input, COMPASS follows a four-phase pipeline that (i) identifies the patch group and pre-scans explicit relationships, (ii) performs individual patch analysis, (iii) infers relationship instances via a hierarchy-guided prompt, and (iv) validates completeness and consistency of the inferred results. As output, COMPASS reports the predicted relationships within the patch group and visualizes them as a relationship graph. We evaluate COMPASS on a benchmark of 300 multi-patch CVEs and compare it against mainstream learning-based and LLM baselines. Results show that our method achieves strong and consistent prediction effectiveness and outperforms SOTA by 85.04% on average. We publicly release an online querying website to support community reuse of patch relationships knowledge: https://patch-relation.com.

0.14

VulContextBench: A Benchmark for Security Context Retrieval in Coding Agents

cs.CR ·2026-09-26 ·Yikun Li, Jinfeng Jiang, Yuheng Yieh, Ting Zhang, Yide Yin +4 more
benchmark similarity 0.71
Abstract

Vulnerability-detection benchmarks score the verdict an agent reaches, not the evidence it gathered. A model that recalls a CVE from pretraining therefore scores the same as one that traced the data flow. We study a task where this difference matters, deciding whether a commit introduces a vulnerability. Instead of scoring the verdict, we score whether the agent retrieved the code its conclusion depends on. We present VulContextBench, a benchmark of 111 vulnerability-introducing commits (VICs) across 83 repositories, 63 CWEs, and five languages. Existing datasets label such commits by tracing a fix back through the version history, which often points to the wrong commit. We therefore audit every case by hand against an explicit four-criterion definition of a VIC, so the benchmark does not inherit that label noise. Each case is annotated with gold context, 464 code blocks in total, each tagged by its role in the evidence for the vulnerability. We evaluate seven frontier models with precision, recall and F1 at three granularities (file, block, and line), scored separately on the context an agent viewed while exploring and on the context it finally declared as evidence. The gap between the two is the main finding. Every model opens most of the gold context while exploring, but reports only part of it as evidence. At the level of code blocks, the share of the gold context a model reports is 37 to 73 percentage points below the share it viewed. Qwen3-Coder-Next views 86.3% of the lines in annotated code blocks but cites only 12.9% in its final report. GPT-5.5, which cites the most, views 73% and reports 36%. These results highlight a gap between finding relevant code and selecting it for the final report, which verdict-level benchmarks cannot reveal.

0.13

Towards Early Warning of Real-World Vulnerabilities: An Evidence-Aware Decoupled Method for CVSS Vector Prediction Based on Unstructured Disclosures

cs.CR ·2026-11-04 ·Jianhong Ma, Wenhao Li, Xixing Li, Chenyu Yan, Haowen Chen
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.71
Abstract · 21 pages, 12 figures; includes 3 pages of supplementary material

Early assessment of Common Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS) vectors from Open Source Intelligence (OSINT) can reduce the delay between initial public disclosure and official National Vulnerability Database (NVD) scoring. Existing predictors, trained mainly on standardized late-stage descriptions, degrade on noisy and incomplete pre-NVD reports. We introduce PARSE, a vulnerability-disclosure lifecycle model, and VPre, an early assessment framework built on two-level Evidence-Aware Decoupling. Decoupling Level I, Security-Evidence Screening, separates security-relevant evidence from noisy early reports at the report and sentence levels. Decoupling Level II, Evidence-Matched Routing, decouples the prediction task of the eight CVSS metrics into a scattered-evidence class and an explicit-evidence class based on validation-set measurements, matching each with a targeted predictor: large-language-model reasoning for the former, lightweight supervised classification for the latter. On the 851-report held-out test split of the 5,581-report VPre-Bench, VPre achieves a mean absolute error of 0.7239 -- 44.7% below the reproduced BERT-Small-NVD early-transfer baseline; paired timestamps across the full benchmark show an average 38-day lead before official scoring (observed range 21-60 days). Under the 38:1 PARSE-Triage noise setting, STDU's report-level screening reaches 0.98 precision, 1.00 recall, and 0.99 F1. Controlled ablations support the contributions of both decoupling levels.

0.28

Predicting CVSS and CWE from CVE Descriptions with Fine-Tuned Small Language Models

cs.LG cs.CR ·2026-10-16 ·Tara Dixit, Jessie Dong, Summer Li
similarity 0.71
Abstract · 23 pages, 5 figures, 21 tables

Until April 2026, the National Vulnerability Database labeled nearly every published Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVE) entry with a Common Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS) v3.1 vector, a severity tier, and a Common Weakness Enumeration (CWE) weakness type. Now, NIST enriches only the high priority CVEs, leaving many newly published vulnerabilities unlabelled with the classifiers that security teams use for patch triage. In CVE enrichment, we predict the eight base components of CVSS v3.1 vector, base score, severity tier, and CWE from the vulnerability's textual description alone. To prevent leakage between near-duplicate descriptions, all systems are trained only on CVEs published in 2022 and 2023. Results are evaluated on all 36,325 usable 2024 CVEs in the pinned NVD snapshot. All scores are either directly predicted, or calculated from predicted vectors using the CVSS formula. A fine-tuned 3.8B-parameter model Phi-3.5-mini, trained with LoRA in 2.5 hours on a single Apple M5 Pro chip, achieves 69.9% accuracy on severity and 70.9% on CWE. It matches the official vector exactly for 48.8% of test CVEs, outperforming TF-IDF logistic regression by 2.8 to 4.7 points on all accuracy metrics based on zero-exclusion paired bootstrap intervals. When we evaluate the base model with a zero-shot prompt, it achieves 20.8% accuracy on severity in a sample of 2,000 CVEs. In this same sample, its stated scores match its own vector precisely for only 3.4% of CVEs. However, deriving scores from predicted vectors boosts the critical recall of TF-IDF logistic regression from 50.7% to 73.3% with no additional cost. And since the errors of the fine-tuned model and TF-IDF affect different CVEs, at least one system matches the correct severity tier for 75.8% of test CVEs.

0.09

On Predicting Vulnerability Severity Using In-Context Learning: An Industrial Case Study

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-08-22 ·Daniel Rodriguez-Cardenas, David Nader Palacio, Anna Schmedding, Yiyang Lu, Aadil Mallick +6 more
publishedcode/data similarity 0.70
Abstract · 11 pages, 6 figures

Modern software systems require earlier and more scalable vulnerability severity assessment to reduce exposure to high-impact security flaws. Security analysts typically assign CVSS scores, but this manual triage does not scale with the growth of disclosed vulnerabilities and often depends on cloud LLM services that raise confidentiality concerns. This paper presents an industrial case study on predicting CVSS v3.1 scores directly from vulnerable C/C++ snippets using in-context learning with locally deployable, open-source LLMs. We compare proprietary data with the Big-Vul dataset, showing sufficiently aligned CVSS distributions to justify Big-Vul as a proxy for industrial data when constructing prompt-based testbeds. We then vary in-context configurations and model parameters, evaluating CodeLlama2-7B, CodeLlama2-13B, Mistral-7B, gpt-oss, and GPT4o-mini using mean squared error (MSE) and feasibility metrics. Our results show that medium-sized open-source code models, particularly CodeLlama2-7B, can approximate the best cloud performance for CVSS regression when guided by lightweight, output-constraining prompts, offering a practical, privacy-preserving building block for severity triage in industrial settings.

0.40