CS Paper Radar

Counterexamples to the Happy Edge Conjecture in Plane Spanning Trees

Oswin Aichholzer, Joseph Dorfer, Peter Kramer, Christian Rieck, Birgit Vogtenhuber

cs.CG math.CO ·submitted 2026-11-03 18:12 UTC · v1

Abstract

We study the problem of reconfiguring plane, straight-line spanning trees on point sets in the plane. A flip is a reconfiguration step in which one edge of a tree is replaced with another, yielding again a plane spanning tree. For a given point set $P$, the flip graph has a vertex for each plane spanning tree on $P$, and an edge between any two trees that differ by a single flip. The folklore happy edge conjecture suggests that any edge shared by both the initial and the target tree (a happy edge) is never flipped in a shortest flip sequence. This conjecture was computationally verified for up to 10 points in convex position. In this paper, we disprove this conjecture both on general point sets and on point sets in convex position by providing two counterexamples on $16$ and $30$ points, respectively. The counterexample for point sets in general position also holds for compatible flips, while the happy edge property holds for compatible flips in convex point sets as shown by Aichholzer, Dorfer, and Vogtenhuber [GD 2025].

Comment
17 pages, 5 figures, 5 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Quadratic Reconfiguration of Plane Spanning Paths on Two-Layer Point Sets

cs.CG ·2026-11-02 ·Samuel Avril, Yan Gerard, Guilherme D. da Fonseca
similarity 0.69
Abstract

Consider a crossing-free polygonal path with $n$ vertices and a flip operation that removes an edge and adds another one, without changing the vertex set and keeping the path crossing free. It is conjectured that any two such paths can be transformed into each other by a sequence of flips. Recently, Kleist et al. (2024) proved the conjecture for the special cases of vertices arranged in two convex layers. However, the number of flips in their proof may be exponential. In this paper, we show that $O(n^2)$ flips suffice. More precisely, for a two-layer point set $S=L_0\cup L_1$, where $L_0$ and $L_1$ denote the outer and inner layers, respectively, our method uses $O(|L_0|+|L_1|^2)$ flips.

0.23

Independent set reconfiguration is hard at treewidth four

cs.CC cs.DMmath.CO ·2026-11-15 ·Hussein Abbas, Haydar Hamieh, Amer E. Mouawad, Ali Slim
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Independent Set Reconfiguration asks whether one of two given independent sets of equal size can be transformed into the other by moving one token at a time while keeping the occupied vertices independent. In token sliding, a token moves along an edge. In token jumping, it may move to any unoccupied vertex. For both rules, the problem is solvable in polynomial time on trees and is PSPACE-complete on graphs of treewidth at most $c$ for some fixed constant $c$. For each rule, the smallest treewidth bound that suffices for hardness has long been open. We narrow this gap by proving that both versions are NP-hard on graphs of treewidth four.

0.22

Flip Graphs for Eight Points in Three Dimensions Are Connected

cs.CG ·2026-09-13 ·Marc Khoury
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract

We prove that every configuration of four through eight points in three-dimensional space, with no four points coplanar, has a connected full geometric flip graph under $2 \leftrightarrow 3$ flips. Every point remains fixed and present throughout the sequence. The proof brings each tetrahedralization into placing form at a convex hull vertex: the tetrahedra not incident to that vertex fill the convex hull of the remaining points. This reduction allows us to establish connectivity by induction, using the connectivity of regular tetrahedralizations. The main geometric tool is radial projection, which turns the tetrahedra incident to a hull vertex into a planar triangulation. When this planar triangulation is regular, varying its lifting heights produces legal spatial flips that progressively shrink the region occupied by the incident tetrahedra and reach placing form. Planar lifting criteria and compatibility constraints between the projections at different hull vertices resolve the remaining small cases. For eight points, at most 35 flips are needed to reach placing form.

0.25

Hull Games of Induced Path Convexities in Graphs

cs.DM math.CO ·2026-09-21 ·Eurinardo Costa, Leon Almeida, Rudini Sampaio
theory similarity 0.58
Abstract

In 1984, Frank Harary introduced the first convexity games in graphs, all of them based on the geodesic convexity, which is the graph convexity related to shortest paths. In 2024, Araújo et al. obtained the first PSPACE-hardness proofs on some of these geodesic games and generalized them to any graph convexity. In this paper, we investigate convexity games on several known induced path convexities: the monophonic $\mathrm{m}$-convexity and the $\ell_k$-convexities, based on induced paths and on induced paths of size at most $k$. We prove that the hull games $\mathrm{CHG}_{\mathrm{m}}$, $\mathrm{CHG}_{\ell_k}$ and their misère variants are PSPACE-complete for every $k\ge2$ even in graphs with diameter at most 3. We also use the Sprague-Grundy Theory to obtain a polynomial time algorithm to decide the winner of the games $\mathrm{CHG}_{\mathrm{m}}$ and $\mathrm{CHG}_{\ell_k}$ for any $k\ge2$ in disjoint unions of paths and cycles. For $k\ge3$ odd, we prove that Alice (1st player) wins $\mathrm{CHG}_{\ell_k}$ in the path $P_n$ if and only if $n$ is odd and she wins in the cycle $C_n$ if and only if $n=3$ or $n=α\cdot (k+1)-1$ with $α\ge2$. For $k\ge2$ even, the only periodic nimber sequences of $\mathrm{CHG}_{\ell_k}$ obtained through extensive computational testing occurred for $k=2^h-4$ with $h\ge3$, e.g, $k\in\{4,12,28,60,\ldots\}$. In this case ($k=2^h-4$ with $h\ge3$), we prove that the nimber sequences of $\mathrm{CHG}_{\ell_k}$ in $P_n$ and in $C_n$ are periodic and Alice loses (resp. wins) in $P_n$ (resp. $C_n$) with $n>k$ only when $n=3k+4$ (resp. $n\in\{2k+1,5k+3\}$). Finally, we show that, for $k=2$, the game $\mathrm{CHG}_{\ell_2}$ in paths $P_n$ is closely related to the classical game \emph{Couples-are-Forever} of J. H. Conway: it is still an open problem if the nimber sequence is periodic or not and Alice loses only for 12 values of $n$ up to $150$ million.

0.12

Nim heaps in the Game of Cycles: the parity conjecture fails on trees

cs.DM math.CO ·2026-10-10 ·Muchen Xu
theory similarity 0.58
Abstract · 35 pages, 3 figures, 7 tables. Ancillary files contain all programs and data

The Game of Cycles, invented by Francis Su, is a two-player game in which the players take turns drawing arrows on the edges of a plane graph, never creating a sink or a source. On a tree only the sink-source rule matters, and the player who makes the last move wins. Several authors conjectured that on a tree the second player wins exactly when the number of markable edges is even. We show that this parity conjecture is false, and we explain why. The explanation is a hidden game of Nim: a path segment that is blocked by an arrow at one end and free at the other behaves exactly like a nim heap whose size is its length. Combined with a calculus for cutting and gluing trees at vertices next to leaves, this shows that the conjecture fails as soon as a single tree has Grundy value at least 2. The smallest counterexamples have 15 vertices. Trees with Grundy values 2 and 4 first appear at 17 vertices, and every value up to 63 occurs, which answers a question of Fokkink and Zandee. We also refute a related conjecture of Zandee. We then look closely at spiders. The spiders S(2,3,z) violate the conjecture for every z >= 14. The Grundy values of S(1,2j,z) are given by an exact formula governed by binary carries. For 99 pairs (x,y), the value of S(x,y,z) is eventually the parity of z. On the positive side, the conjecture holds for all trees in which every thread has at most two edges, and this bound is sharp. Along the way we prove a twin-branch reduction, give an algorithm that is polynomial for spiders with a fixed number of legs, and collect the questions that we could not answer. The boldest asks whether every non-negative integer is the Grundy value of some tree.

0.32

A Polynomial-Time Algorithm for $k$-Path Vertex Cover Reconfiguration on Trees under Token Sliding

cs.DS cs.DM ·2026-10-22 ·Duc A. Hoang
similarity 0.56
Abstract

A $k$-path vertex cover ($k$-PVC) of a graph is a set of vertices meeting every path on $k$ vertices. In Token Sliding, one token occupies each vertex of a cover; a move slides one token along an edge to an unoccupied vertex, preserving the cover property. We study whether two covers of a tree are joined by such moves. The case $k=2$ admits a linear-time decision algorithm. For every integer $k\geq2$, we give an $O(kn^2)$-time decision algorithm on trees of order $n$, with $k$ part of the input. Two covers are reachable precisely when their rigid tokens, which never move, occupy the same set and every component remaining after their deletion has the same token count. The proof transforms configurations of equal size without rigid tokens into a canonical configuration built on properly rooted subtrees, whose paths on $k$ vertices pass through their roots. A rooted-subtree recurrence identifies movable candidate tokens. We also give a direct recursive construction between the supplied endpoints, returning at most $8n^2\,3^{\lceil n/2\rceil}$ slides in $O(n^{10}3^{n/2})$ time. ChatGPT 6 Pro and Claude Fable 5.1 were used to assist with developing and reviewing mathematical arguments and drafting and revising the paper. The author takes full responsibility for the correctness and content of the paper.

0.20

Dynamic Edge Orientation via Random Walks: From Trees to Outerplanar Graphs and Beyond

cs.DS ·2026-08-25 ·Gabriel Marques Domingues, Minh Hang Nguyen, Shay Solomon
theory similarity 0.56
Abstract · Abstract truncated to fit arXiv limits

We study the \emph{fully dynamic edge orientation problem}, focusing on \emph{worst-case} time bounds. An undirected graph undergoes edge insertions and deletions, and the goal is to maintain an orientation with small {\em maximum outdegree} (hereafter, outdegree) and small worst-case update time. The outdegree of any orientation is at least $α-1$, where $α$ is the graph's \emph{arboricity}, i.e., the minimum number of forests into which its edge set can be partitioned. When $α= O(1)$, it is long known that both the outdegree and the worst-case update time can be bounded by $O(\log n)$. Despite numerous follow-ups, no $o(\log^3 n)$ worst-case update time is known for maintaining constant outdegree, even for very basic graph families---with a notable exception, \emph{forests}. For forests, a \emph{simple folklore} algorithm maintains outdegree 2 via \emph{random walks}: When an insertion creates a vertex of outdegree 3, the algorithm repeatedly chooses a uniformly random outgoing edge until reaching a vertex of outdegree at most 1, and then flips the resulting directed path. As the underlying graph is cycle-free, the path length is easily shown to be $O(\log n)$ in expectation, and also with high probability for polynomially long update sequences. We prove that this simple random walk paradigm extends to \emph{outerplanar graphs}. Our algorithm maintains constant outdegree with $O(\log n)$ worst-case update time, where the time bound holds in expectation, and also with high probability for polynomially long update sequences. We give a \emph{tight analysis}: outdegree 4 is achievable with $O(\log n)$-length paths, while outdegree 3 incurs $\mathtt{poly}(n)$-length paths. We also extend the argument to $K_{2,t}$-minor-free graphs, for any $t \ge 2$, with the outdegree bound depending only on $t$ and with the same update time guarantees. The locality of [...]

0.27

A Low-Diameter Nash-Williams--Tutte Theorem

cs.DM math.COcs.DS ·2026-11-03 ·Pin-Hsian Lee, Peng-Ting Lin, Meng-Tsung Tsai, Ting-An Wu
theory similarity 0.55
Abstract

The Nash-Williams--Tutte theorem characterizes the existence of $k$ edge-disjoint spanning trees by a condition on every vertex partition. We prove that, for simple graphs, the same condition guarantees $k$ edge-disjoint spanning trees, each of diameter $O(n/δ)$ and with $O((n/δ)\log(δ+1))$ internal vertices, where $n$ is the number of vertices and $δ$ is the minimum degree. Both bounds hold simultaneously for every tree, with absolute implicit constants independent of $k$, and each is asymptotically optimal in general. Our proof is constructive and yields a randomized algorithm with expected running time $\tilde{O}(n^5)$. We derive applications to short edge-disjoint routes and weak linkages, small Steiner trees, and survivable networks with short paths. The joint bounds also yield low-diameter spanning Eulerian subgraphs and short tours for postman and general routing problems.

0.29