CS Paper Radar

VIPBench: A Human-Aligned Benchmark for Voice Identity Perception in the Age of Voice Cloning

Xudong Tang, Matthew Groh

cs.SD cs.AIcs.CYcs.MM ·submitted 2026-11-03 21:21 UTC · v1
publishedbenchmarkcode/data

Abstract

Speaker-recognition benchmarks test how accurately a model recovers the speaker label of a recording, treating voice identity as a property of the person who produced it. However, these benchmarks do not evaluate how humans perceive voice identity. Whether a listener hears two voices as the same person has consequences for intellectual property rights, cybersecurity, and everyday life. We introduce the Voice Identity Perception benchmark (VIPBench), which contains 124,876 same-or-different judgments from 1,290 listeners on 9,800 recording pairs from 100 public figures. The pairs include real recordings, voice clones generated by a text-to-speech system, and morphs between two speakers' voices. We also define four tasks that evaluate the alignment between speaker-representation models and human identity perception. The first two tasks measure how well a model's similarity score predicts the proportion of listeners who respond "same" and the majority response. The other two measure whether a model and listeners find the same speaker pairs similar, and whether a model's relationship to listener judgments holds equally for real and synthetic recordings. We evaluate eleven publicly available speech models. Listener judgments diverge from speaker labels most often for voice clones: in 41% of responses, listeners judged a clone and a real recording of the same speaker to be different people. No model reaches the noise ceiling; the best model explains 61% of the explainable variance. Models trained with speaker labels align with listeners better than self-supervised models do, yet a model with a 12% error rate on speaker labels aligns with listeners as well as models with error rates below 2%. VIPBench enables the evaluation of speaker models against human perception on real, cloned, and morphed speech, and our results motivate training speaker models directly on listener judgments.

Comment
Accepted at NeurIPS 2026, Track on Evaluations and Datasets (poster). 30 pages, 12 figures, 22 tables. Dataset and code: https://huggingface.co/datasets/sendfuze/vipbench

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Character Identity is not Speaker Identity: KyaraBench and KyaraEmbed for Character Verification

eess.AS cs.SD ·2026-10-05 ·Joonyong Park, Jerry Li
benchmark similarity 0.70
Abstract

A dubbed character keeps its identity while the voice actor changes, so character identity and speaker identity are distinct properties of one recording, yet speaker verification measures only the latter. To address this gap, we propose KyaraBench, a benchmark that scores character voice directly instead of speaker voice, built from 85 human-audited identities in a dubbed anime corpus. It poses two challenging conditions: one that swaps the performer under a fixed character, and one that fixes the performer under changing characters. Listening studies with 78 participants provide human reference scores for cross-performer verification and same-actor discrimination. Speaker-verification baselines show increased errors under these character-specific conditions. We then train KyaraEmbed, a compact encoder using multilingual character supervision, same-actor negatives, and a language-alignment term. The model achieves the best performance on all character-specific conditions in the main comparison. We release the benchmark, protocol, and encoder publicly.

0.19

Beyond EER: Multi-Dimensional Evaluation of Information Leakage in Speaker De-Identification

cs.SD cs.AI ·2026-09-16 ·Seungmin Seo, Oleg Aulov, P. Jonathon Phillips, Kevin Mangold, Jonathan Eskin
published similarity 0.68
Abstract · Accepted to IJCB 2026 (Main Track)

Speaker de-identification (SDID) aims to preserve privacy by concealing speaker identity while maintaining speech utility. However, current evaluations often reduce privacy to a single dimension - biometric verification performance - typically measured by Equal Error Rate (EER). This narrow focus ignores critical leakage channels, such as soft biometric inference, embedding-level re-identification, and structural template similarity, which threaten the unlinkability and irreversibility of biometric references. We propose a holistic evaluation framework across five complementary metrics: (i) EER, (ii) soft biometric leakage score , (iii) cumulative match characteristic re-identification analysis, (iv) canonical correlation analysis and Procrustes embedding alignment, and (v) intelligibility via word error rate and semantic similarity. Evaluating five SDID systems from the IARPA ARTS program, we demonstrate that these metrics capture independent dimensions of information leakage. Our results indicate that reliance on a single metric can misrepresent the privacy properties of an SDID system.

0.38

Your Voice Cloning System is Secretly a Voice Anonymizer

cs.CL ·2026-08-27 ·Romolo Muletta, Felix Matthias Saaro, Mark Cieliebak, Jan Deriu
code/data similarity 0.67
Abstract

Speaker anonymization suppresses speaker-identifying attributes from speech while preserving linguistic content and quality. We propose repurposing XTTSv2, a multilingual voice cloning model trained on 27k hours of speech, for speaker anonymization without retraining. Our key insight is that XTTSv2's voice cloning capabilities preserve prosodic structure independently of speaker identity, enabling voice conversion by conditioning on a pseudo-speaker. We introduce an iterative refinement strategy that balances privacy and utility by maximizing a harmonic mean of speaker dissimilarity and intelligibility. Evaluated on seven European languages across CommonVoice and Multilingual LibriSpeech, our system achieves near-optimal privacy (EER $\approx$ 0.49), competitive intelligibility, and substantially better speech quality than dedicated anonymization baselines, while requiring no language-specific training. We release the code here: https://github.com/rm00cr/coqui-tts.

0.29

Rethinking Automated Voice Similarity by Shifting from EER to Embedding Geometry

eess.AS cs.SD ·2026-09-27 ·Szu-Chi Chen, Jia-Kai Dong, Yi-Cheng Lin, Sung-Feng Huang, Hung-yi Lee
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 5 pages. Submitted to ICASSP 2027

Speaker verification (SV) models are commonly assumed to better capture nuances among speaker characteristics as verification accuracy improves, leading to their widespread use as automated proxies for human voice similarity in speech generation tasks. However, by establishing a human perceptual alignment metric and conducting systematic analysis, we demonstrate that perceptual alignment is governed far more by how a model is trained (its learning objective) than by how well it performs (EER). Notably, standard margin-based classification losses (e.g., AAM-Softmax) yield substantially lower perceptual alignment than prototypical metric losses, while EER itself fails to track human judgment, directly challenging the community's implicit assumption. We trace this divergence to embedding geometry, where a model's effective dimensionality ($d_{\mathrm{eff}}$) tracks perceptual alignment with a $-0.95$ rank correlation, revealing that the dimensional spread favored by classification losses fundamentally clashes with the low-dimensional nature of human voice perception. Imposing a dimensionality bottleneck compresses $d_{\mathrm{eff}}$ and raises perceptual alignment ($ρ_{\mathrm{align}}$) from 0.08 to 0.74, establishing a principled geometric criterion for evaluating voice similarity.

0.33

Who Said What, and Will It Be Remembered? Evaluating Persistent Speaker Attribution Across Meetings

cs.SD cs.AI ·2026-09-30 ·Shantanu Vispute, Aditya Mishra, Siddhartha Saxena
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract · A short version is accepted at IEEE SLT 2026, Demo Track

Speech transcripts used as long-term memory must preserve both words and stable speaker identities. Existing meeting-transcription metrics either ignore speakers or remap anonymous speakers independently in each recording, so they cannot measure whether the same person retains one identity across meetings. We evaluate persistent speaker attribution with Speaker Identified cpWER (SI-cpWER), which scores a corpus under one global speaker-ID assignment. The benchmark covers five commercial diarize-then-identify cascades, two open academic baselines, and ThyVoice on the full 129-meeting CHiME-8 NOTSOFAR evaluation set in clean and noiseaugmented form, plus CHiME-6. ThyVoice is our end-to-end reference system; it repairs overlap and gates the evidence used to create and update voiceprints. Requiring persistent identity changes the commercial ranking: ThyVoice records lower SI-cpWER than every evaluated commercial cascade in all three conditions and the lowest mean in the full panel, 47.13 versus 54.75 for the next system. Complementary lexical, diarization, per-recording attribution, and speaker-clustering diagnostics characterize upstream error surfaces in the final attributed record. These results show why persistent attribution must be evaluated directly in systems that reuse conversations across time.

0.25

HEAR: Real Voices, Real Bias: A Large-Scale Human-Recorded, Demographically Diverse Benchmark for Audio Language Models

cs.SD cs.AIcs.CY ·2026-09-28 ·Shen Yan, Duc Le, Irina-Elena Veliche
benchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract

We introduce HEAR (Human-recorded Evaluation of Audio-LLM bias by Real speakers), a large-scale, ecologically valid benchmark comprising 87k real human audio samples from 843 demographically diverse participants. HEAR enables comprehensive evaluation through Multiple Choice Question Answering (MCQA) and open-ended long-form tasks. To our knowledge, this is the first large-scale voice benchmark grounded entirely in authentic human speech. We evaluate model behavior across both real-time speech-to-speech and speech-to-text architectures. Our results reveal that voice-conditioned bias is a model-specific property. Furthermore, we demonstrate that personalization instructions consistently exacerbate demographic disparities. Our findings establish that voice bias is a controllable model characteristic, providing a foundational framework for future bias mitigation and evaluation in Audio-LLM development.

0.37

Preemptive defense against re-identification attacks on voice anonymization via adversarial perturbation

eess.AS ·2026-10-05 ·Michele Panariello, Yibo Bai, Massimiliano Todisco, Nicholas Evans
published similarity 0.66
Abstract · Accepted to IEEE Spoken Language Technology (SLT) 2026

Voice anonymization (VA) is used to conceal the voice identities in speech data. Performance is usually estimated using automatic speaker verification (ASV) as a proxy to judge the capability of an attacker to re-identify speakers after anonymization. The defender anonymizes test utterances; the attacker compares them to equally anonymized reference utterances to infer voice identity, with degraded ASV performance indicating successful anonymization. Thus, the defender's protection is one-sided and only applied to test utterances via VA. Though unexplored so far, there is an opportunity to enhance anonymization by protecting reference utterances too. We present a new, preemptive VA paradigm: reference utterances are protected using adversarial noise to degrade their potential to infer voice identity. Preemptive protection does not degrade the perceived quality of reference utterances and is independent of the specific ASV system used for identity inference. By combining preemptive protection and regular test-side VA, ASV equal error rates can be increased from 14\% to 45\% (near-perfect privacy).

0.30

VoxTubeS: Distributable Speaker-Anonymized Synthetic Speech Corpora and Their Analysis

eess.AS ·2026-09-11 ·Zhe Zhang, Yexin Lu, Junichi Yamagishi
hot direction similarity 0.65
Abstract

Large speech corpora support research, but recordings can expose speaker identity because voice remains a recognizable biometric. Meanwhile, speech data derived from media can be difficult to redistribute reliably. We present \emph{VoxTubeS}, a family of speaker-anonymized synthetic speech corpora designed for redistribution, comprising three method families and seven variants derived from the VoxTube corpus, which is distributed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, using 1.29M quality-filtered English utterances from 1,511 speakers. The synthesis methods span voice conversion, latent-space anonymization, and controllable text-to-speech. We evaluate VoxTubeS using utterance-level unlinkability, conversation-level linkability and singling-out, downstream speaker verification, linguistic consistency, speaker diversity, and fairness metrics for gender and accents. Our comprehensive analysis exposes a complex trade-off: stronger identity suppression often reduces linkability but sacrifices utility and population diversity, whereas speaker consistency training improves both utterance- and conversation-level privacy while retaining comparable utility and a broader speaker space. Fairness varies independently of aggregate performance. No method dominates; VoxTubeS therefore treats corpus construction as a choice among operating points that balances privacy, utility, diversity, fairness, and responsible redistribution under the source license.

0.23