CS Paper Radar

Pairing Expert Critique with LLM-Driven Refinement: An Iterative Approach for Curating Quality AI Evaluation Datasets

Honson Ling, Kidus Admassu, Stephanie Rosenthal

cs.HC cs.AIcs.LG ·submitted 2026-11-03 23:38 UTC · v1

Abstract

Evaluating and improving domain-specific LLM responses requires high-quality reference data and rubrics, yet expert authoring is slow and expensive, and synthetic datasets may fail to capture practitioner preferences unless they are grounded in expert judgment. We present SME-C (Subject Matter Expert Critique), a human-AI workflow that captures expertise through lightweight critiques of candidate responses and complements it with LLM-driven analysis and refinement to iteratively curate response datasets and evaluation rubrics. We validate SME-C in the domain of financial business briefs, collecting 3,853 critiques from 411 finance professionals on 520 queries across two survey rounds. We evaluate two LLM-driven refinement strategies: one guided by the experts' written critiques and one that infers critique solely from their preference votes. In a blind validation survey with 100 additional professionals, we found that both strategies significantly improved quality over the experts' top-ranked baseline responses. The gains were concentrated among weaker original responses, and the two strategies excelled in different ways: critique-based refinement produced more domain-grounded improvements, whereas vote-based refinement was more effective at identifying and removing irrelevant content. The resulting rubrics and refined dataset support reproducible offline evaluation and benchmarking of LLMs, suggesting that structured expert critique is a viable alternative to expert authoring for building high-quality, domain-specific evaluation resources more quickly, at scale, and at lower cost.

Comment
20 pages, 7 figures, 9 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Judging LLM-as-a-Judge: Concerning Rubric Artifacts in LLM-based Automated Text Generation Evaluation

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-08-31 ·Anshul Bagaria, Sowmya S Sundaram, Gokul S Krishnan, Balaraman Ravindran
top venuehighly cited similarity 0.68
Abstract · Accepted for publication at EMNLP 2026. 5 pages, 6 figures

LLM-as-a-Judge pipelines are increasingly used to evaluate AI-generated text, based on the assumption that judgments arise from reasoning over candidate responses with respect to a rubric. We show that this assumption warrants further scrutiny. Classifiers trained only on rubric text, without access to any evaluated response, achieve nontrivial predictive performance on judge outputs. This suggests that rubric formulations encode recoverable evaluative signals, allowing scores to be partially anticipated independently of model outputs. Finally, counterfactual perturbations reveal that judges often fail to reliably update their decisions when either the candidate response or the rubric criterion is reversed. Our findings raise concerns about the reliability of rubric-based LLM evaluation and highlight the need for further methodological study of automated evaluation via LLMs.

0.67

Experts Rise Where LLMs Disagree: Using Cross-Model Disagreement to Target Expert Effort in LLM Codebook Revision for Large-Scale Annotation

cs.CL cs.AIcs.HCcs.LG ·2026-09-22 ·Zeyu He, Zhuqian Zhou, Kirk Vanacore, Rene F. Kizilcec, Ting-Hao 'Kenneth' Huang
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Large-scale text annotation brings expert insight to millions of documents, often through a codebook that AI annotators follow. Developing a robust codebook, however, takes months. Large language models (LLMs) could speed this process by applying an early codebook to the data, surfacing cases with strong LLM disagreement, and eliciting expert feedback to address them. We examined three ways experts can provide feedback for LLM codebook revision: (i) editing LLM-generated revisions driven by cross-LLM disagreement (Codebook Verifying), (ii) answering questions about LLM disagreements (Question Answering), and (iii) labeling disagreement cases with rationales (Rationale Labeling). Experiments on thousands of tutoring-session transcripts show that Rationale Labeling yielded the highest LLM-labeling accuracy (64.9%) against expert labels, outperforming the expert-revised codebook (57.8%). The best Question Answering setting also outperformed it (60.5%). Our work shows that LLMs can be used to strategically target expert attention, shortening months of codebook revision to days without sacrificing labeling performance.

0.43

FinAutoRubric: Expert-Guided Automatic Rubric Generation for Evaluating Financial Research Agents

cs.AI q-fin.CP ·2026-09-28 ·Hoyoung Lee, Suyeol Yun, Jack Haverty, Yunju Cho, Meesong Kim +15 more
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract · preprint

Evaluating finance research agents requires rubrics that reflect expert standards and fix the values correct as of an information cutoff. Expert-reviewed finance benchmarks rely on fixed, per-item rubrics, which are costly to extend and cannot encode each institution's own standard. In FinAutoRubric, experts specify reusable evaluation guidance, while agents and code carry out query-specific rubric generation, review, and validation. This expert guidance governs every agent, as prompts and as rules that code enforces, and a Task Bank of reusable criteria carries it across tasks. In long-horizon loops that follow the expert guidance, a writer agent researches every expected value and a reviewer agent verifies it, and failures escalate to a human. On three expert-authored finance benchmarks, its rubrics track expert scoring as closely as the strongest evaluated generator while stating the expert rubric's expected value for more criteria, their scores agree with human grading, and in-house analysts prefer them in a blind review. The released 100-query FinAutoRubric Benchmark, built from in-house analysts' key questions across 78 tasks and eight asset classes, shows that rubrics from an earlier model generation still leave headroom for a later one.

0.30

AppliedScientist: Automated Scientific Revision Through Iterative AI Reviewing

cs.AI ·2026-09-13 ·Vidushee Vats, Karun Sharma, Shengzhi Li, Shichao Pei
similarity 0.65
Abstract · v2: Updated Table 3

Automated reviewing systems are increasingly evaluated based on the quality of the reviews they produce. Yet a review is only useful if acting on it leads to a measurable improvement in the paper. We present AppliedScientist, a closed-loop system that couples an autonomous AI scientist with an AI reviewer, and evaluate it by iteratively revising rejected papers from a range of research subfields. To mirror how human authors build on earlier drafts, the AI scientist has access to its previous versions during revision. To avoid bias from prior judgments, however, each review is generated independently, with the reviewer having no memory of earlier feedback or scores. We compare three revision settings: one initialized with the original venue reviews, one initialized with AI-generated reviews, and autonomous self-revision using the same fixed prompt in every round. Because the reviewer both guides and evaluates the revision, we also assess the human-initialized revisions using Stanford Reviewer as an independent evaluator. Reviewer-guided revision consistently improves more than fixed-prompt self-revision, and Stanford Reviewer also assigns higher scores to later revisions. AppliedScientist resolves 128 of 150 execution-related weaknesses (85.3%), but only 2 of 18 idea-related weaknesses (11.1%), suggesting that iterative revision is effective at improving experiments and implementation, but rarely changes concerns about novelty or significance.

0.24

RubricAtlas: Mining Type-Level Rubrics from Expert Reports to Evaluate Deep Research Agents

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-10-27 ·Delin Wang, Sinuo Wang, Rui Sun, Beidi Luan, Qiming Shi +3 more
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Deep research agents conduct multi-step Web searches and synthesise retrieved information into analytical reports. Evaluating these outputs requires checking which analyses they deliver, beyond the presence of relevant facts. Query-specific binary rubrics make individual requirements explicit, but task-level checklists may leave the overall analytical structure underexamined. We introduce RubricAtlas, which derives type-level analytical requirements from expert reports on different objects within the same research type and organises detailed checks around recurring analytical questions. The requirements give related tasks a shared standard for what to analyse, without prescribing their answers. Our framework links binary checkpoints to report passages and evaluates completeness separately from argument validity. Built from 3,079 Chinese financial research reports, RubricAtlas covers 99 research types. Reference-report selection experiments show that individual reports cover only about half of their type's analytical questions, and that selecting requirements from different reports changes evaluation scores and agent rankings. Across ten agents, two judge pipelines achieve checkpoint agreement of $κ$ = 0.71 and agent-ranking agreement of Kendall $τ$ = 0.87. Controlled deletions reduce scores on the affected analyses, while padding produces no detectable increase. These findings support type-level rubrics for comparing the analytical completeness of Web deep research outputs, with individual decisions traceable to report evidence.

0.24

JudgmentLens: Human-AI Sensemaking of Complex Legal Judgments

cs.HC ·2026-09-07 ·Xinyi Chen, Ruijie Li, Yuelu Li, Chen Liang
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Judicial judgments are increasingly available, yet dense language and distributed relationships among facts, evidence, reasoning, and rulings remain difficult for non-experts to interpret. Through a mixed-methods formative study with Chinese non-expert readers (survey N=34; interviews N=6), we identified structural, interpretive, verification, and action breakdowns. We developed JudgmentLens, an AI-augmented reading system combining persistent case representations, adaptive explanations, and traceable links from generated interpretations to judgment passages. In a counterbalanced within-subject evaluation (N=16), participants completed tasks faster with JudgmentLens than with conventional PDF reading and reported lower workload and greater self-reported decision understanding, while rubric-scored comprehension did not differ reliably. An exploratory PDF+DeepSeek probe suggested that conversational AI supported formulated questions while leaving question formulation, answer integration, and source checking largely to users. We contribute an empirical account of non-expert judgment sensemaking and design strategies for inspectable, source-grounded AI mediation.

0.20

The Lifecycle of LLM-as-a-Judge for Large-Scale Recommendation Explanations

cs.AI ·2026-08-18 ·Emma Yanyang Kong, JJ Tan, Ishan Gupta, Lars Olds, Claire Campbell +6 more
benchmarkposition similarity 0.64
Abstract

LLM-as-a-Judge, which leverages a large language model to evaluate natural language generated by another AI application or model, has become a standard, scalable approach for accelerating and extending costly human evaluation. Yet most work treats a judge as a static artifact, evaluating it once at construction or against a fixed benchmark. We argue instead that an LLM judge operating in a deployed system is better understood as having a lifecycle. It must be built, trained, deployed, and continuously maintained as the surrounding data evolves, and each phase poses distinct technical and operational challenges. We present such a lifecycle for the LLM judges that evaluate recommendation explanations at Netflix. Everything we report comes out of a series of controlled online member-facing experiments, in which our pipeline generated and the judges assessed hundreds of thousands of distinct show-level explanations per week across a changing catalog. Our framework has four phases. (I) Birth defines the evaluation criteria and builds curated benchmark datasets with human labels and rationales. (II) Training refines the judges' rubrics via Reasoning-Aligned Rubric Tuning (RART), which uses a meta-judge over reasoning output as the learning signal. (III) Deployment puts one judge in two online roles, quality gating and reflective generation. (IV) Monitoring runs a continuous Human-in-the-Loop (HITL) alignment process that detects drift and triggers re-tuning behind a human review gate. We report results from a five-week online A/B test over tens of millions of members on the Netflix mobile app, in which judge-aligned explanations shifted member viewing toward novel content (previously unwatched) and increased successful browse-to-play sessions relative to a no-explanation control, with no quality-related escalations.

0.17

EnGRICH: Enhancing Generative Reward Modeling with Critiques from Humans

cs.AI ·2026-10-04 ·Xuancheng Li, Beining Wang, Haitao Li, Heng Wang, Yujia Zhou +5 more
position similarity 0.64
Abstract

Generative reward models (GRMs) are important for LLM optimization. Unlike scalar reward models, GRMs generate natural-language critiques alongside preference judgments, providing finer-grained evaluation signals. Their effectiveness depends heavily on critique reliability. However, existing GRM training typically uses final preference correctness as outcome supervision. Because the preference outcome space is highly constrained, unreliable critiques can still yield correct outcomes and thus be reinforced. Recent work leverages human critiques for process supervision, but such critiques are scarce and are often reduced to scalar rewards, leaving their fine-grained evaluative information underutilized. We argue that evaluative criteria learned from human critiques can be generalized to broader outcome-only preference data. To this end, we propose \textbf{EnGRICH}, a GRM training framework that pairs the GRM with a training-time MetaCritic learned from a small set of human critiques. MetaCritic constructs response-specific rubrics and uses them to evaluate the evidence coverage and correctness of generated critiques. The resulting signals provide both process rewards for fine-grained credit assignment and structured guidance for exploring better critiques. During GRM training, MetaCritic is further optimized to generalize human-grounded evaluative criteria to outcome-only data. At inference, the trained GRM operates independently. Experiments across seven reward-model benchmarks show that EnGRICH consistently improves over competitive baselines, while further analyses validate the effectiveness of its core mechanisms.

0.17