CS Paper Radar

Tight bounds for fractional and randomized truthful scheduling

Georgios Anastasiadis, George Christodoulou, Elias Koutsoupias, Annamaria Kovacs, Conrad Schecker

cs.GT ·submitted 2026-11-04 15:23 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

We resolve one of the longest-standing open problems in algorithmic mechanism design by showing that randomization cannot yield a sublinear approximation for truthful scheduling on unrelated machines, even when truthfulness is required only in expectation. Our main technical result concerns fractional scheduling, where tasks may be split among machines. We prove that every deterministic truthful fractional mechanism on $n$ unrelated machines has worst-case approximation ratio at least $(n+1)/2$, even against the optimal integral makespan. This matches the known upper bound exactly and settles the optimal approximation ratio of truthful fractional scheduling. Since the expected allocations and payments of a truthful-in-expectation mechanism define a truthful fractional mechanism, the same lower bound applies to all truthful-in-expectation mechanisms and, in particular, to all universally truthful mechanisms. On the positive side, we give a universally truthful mechanism with approximation ratio $n/2+o(n)$. Together, these results establish the optimal leading constant $1/2$ for randomized truthful scheduling. Thus, randomization improves on the optimal deterministic approximation ratio by an asymptotic factor of two, and no more.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Universally truthful mechanisms for scheduling

cs.GT ·2026-09-11 ·Georgios Anastasiadis, George Christodoulou, Elias Koutsoupias, Annamaria Kovacs, Conrad Schecker
theory similarity 0.83
Abstract

We consider universally truthful randomized mechanisms for the problem of scheduling $m$ jobs on $n$ unrelated machines. We prove a lower bound on the expected approximation ratio of every such mechanism whose probability distribution has discrete support. We show that no universally truthful randomized mechanism in this class can achieve approximation ratio smaller than $n/12 - o(n)$ with respect to the optimal makespan. We match this, up to a constant factor, by a mechanism with approximation ratio $n/2 + o(n)$.

0.49

Sharp Bounds for Truthful-in-Expectation Scheduling

cs.GT ·2026-11-03 ·Yunpeng Li
theory similarity 0.78
Abstract

We study randomized mechanisms for scheduling indivisible jobs on $n$ unrelated machines. Each machine is controlled by a selfish agent who privately knows its processing time for each job. A mechanism assigns every job to a machine and makes payments. We require truthfulness in expectation: no agent can increase its expected payment minus its expected processing cost by misreporting, regardless of the other agents' reports. The makespan is the maximum total processing time assigned to a machine; the objective is to minimize its expectation. We prove that the optimal approximation ratio is $(n+1)/2$ for every $n\ge7$, relative to the minimum makespan of an integral assignment. The lower bound holds for every $n$ and allows unrestricted computation and arbitrary correlations among assignments, assuming finite expected payments and a guarantee uniform over all finite job counts. The matching mechanism uses correlated rounding and runs in expected polynomial bit time on rational inputs. These guarantees hold for all finite nonnegative processing times. For two machines, we characterize the optimal approximation ratio exactly as an analytic constant, approximately $1.505995705434$, and give a mechanism attaining it. For three machines the optimal ratio is $2$. For four, five, and six machines we obtain upper bounds of $3$, $105/32$, and $29/8$, respectively, compared with the general lower bound $(n+1)/2$. The proofs for $n\ge7$ do not rely on computer-assisted certificates; the two- and three-machine results use exact rational computer-assisted certificates.

0.18

Tight Analysis of Randomized Truthful Scheduling: An $(m+1)/2$ Lower Bound

cs.GT ·2026-11-03 ·Wenqian Wang, Chenyang Xu, Yuhao Zhang
theory similarity 0.77
Abstract · 42 pages, 2 figures

The Nisan-Ronen conjecture, a central problem in algorithmic game theory, asserts that no deterministic truthful mechanism for makespan minimization on $m$ unrelated machines can achieve an approximation ratio better than $m$. Christodoulou, Koutsoupias, and Kovács resolved it in 2023, but the optimal approximation ratio achievable by randomized truthful mechanisms remained open. Recently, Anastasiadis, Christodoulou, Koutsoupias, Kovács, and Schecker extended techniques from the deterministic proof to establish a $(3/2-\sqrt{2})(m-1)$ lower bound for universally truthful mechanisms with discrete support and gave a universally truthful mechanism with approximation ratio $m/2+o(m)$. For the broader class of truthful-in-expectation (TIE) mechanisms, however, the gap remained large: the best known upper bound was $(m+5)/2$, while the lower bound was only $2-1/m$. We prove a lower bound of $(m+1)/2$, determining the optimal TIE approximation ratio up to an additive constant as $m/2+Θ(1)$. Our result also improves the leading constant in the lower bound for universally truthful mechanisms from $3/2-\sqrt{2} \approx 0.0858$ to $1/2$. Together with their $m/2+o(m)$ upper bound, our result determines the optimal approximation ratio for universally truthful mechanisms up to lower-order terms.

0.20

Truthful-in-Expectation MMS Allocations for Chores

cs.GT cs.DS ·2026-09-28 ·Zehan Lin, Biaoshuai Tao, Xiaowei Wu, Yuhao Zhang
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract · 35 pages, 6 figures

We study truthful-in-expectation (TIE) mechanisms for allocating indivisible chores alongside ex-post maximin share (MMS) guarantees. For goods, Bu and Tao (FOCS 2025) established a (1/n)-approximation for TIE mechanisms, and this was substantially improved by Babaioff, Feige, and Manaker Morag (FOCS 2026), who established an Ω(1/\log n) approximation, where n is the number of agents. The corresponding problem for chores has received less attention. The best-known result is due to Aziz, Li, and Wu (MAPR 2024), who gave a TIE mechanism with an O(\sqrt{\log n}) MMS approximation guarantee that holds only in expectation. They also established a 6/5 lower bound for TIE mechanisms for two agents. In this paper, we present the first TIE mechanism for chores that achieves a constant ex-post MMS approximation guarantee. Specifically, our mechanism guarantees an ex-post ratio of 1.97 for any number of agents n, which improves to 4/3 for n=2 and 3/2 for n=3. On the hardness side, we tighten the two-agent lower bound to 4/3, showing that our mechanism is optimal for n=2. More generally, we establish a lower bound of 13/12 on the ex-post MMS approximation ratio achievable by TIE mechanisms for every n\ge 3.

0.29

Randomized Algorithm for MMS Allocation of Chores with Online Agent Arrivals

cs.GT ·2026-10-11 ·Haolong Li, Fangxiao Wang, Xiaowei Wu
similarity 0.64
Abstract

We study the fair allocation of $m$ indivisible chores among $n$ agents in the agent-arrival model against an oblivious adversary. The chore set and the number of agents are known in advance. When agent $i$ arrives, her nonnegative additive cost function $c_i$ is revealed, and the algorithm must immediately and irrevocably assign her a subset of the unallocated chores. We focus on the notion of maximin share (MMS) and measure the fairness of the realized allocation $X$ by the ex-post MMS approximation ratio $ρ(X)$. We measure an algorithm's performance by its expected ratio, and also the guarantees that hold with high probability. For binary additive costs, we achieve an expected ex-post MMS ratio of $3/2+o(1)$, and show that every randomized online algorithm has an expected ratio of at least $3/2-o(1)$. For every $n$, the expected ratio is at most $1.755$. A variant of our algorithm guarantees an approximation ratio of $2$ with high probability, which is optimal. % For general additive costs, we present a weighted-rounding algorithm that achieves an expected ratio of $2+o(1)$, which also holds with high probability. The expected ratio is at most $2.594$ for every $n$. We also show that similar algorithms extend to additive goods, achieving a constant expected ex-post MMS ratio and guaranteeing every agent an $x$-fraction of her MMS with probability at least $1-85x^2$ for every $x\le1/15$.

0.39

Optimal Rank Lotteries for Truthful Unit-Interval Covering

cs.GT ·2026-08-25 ·Alexandros A. Voudouris
theory similarity 0.63
Abstract

In truthful interval covering, each agent has a private interval of unit length, and the goal is to decide where to place a public unit interval so as to minimize the total uncovered length while incentivizing the agents to be truthful. Previous work proposed a universally strategyproof lottery over order-statistic mechanisms with approximation ratio at most $5/3$, and established a lower bound of $3/2-o(1)$ for this class of mechanisms. We close this gap by characterizing the approximation ratio of every report-independent lottery over order-statistics. In particular, we show that, for every $n\ge2$, the optimal approximation ratio for this class is $\frac32-\frac{1}{2\lfloor n/2\rfloor}$. Beyond rank lotteries, we show that every universally strategyproof randomized mechanism has approximation ratio at least $9/8$.

0.07

Speedup-Aware Rounding for Scheduling Malleable Tasks with Precedence Constraints

cs.DS ·2026-11-11 ·Chi-Yeh Chen
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 31 pages; ancillary files contain the numerical verification programs

We study the scheduling of malleable tasks with precedence constraints on $m$ identical processors to minimize the makespan, assuming that the processing time of a task does not increase and its work does not decrease with the number of processors, and that the work is a convex function of the processing time. The standard two-phase method solves a linear program, rounds the fractional processing times to allotments, caps the allotments at a threshold $μ$, and runs list scheduling. We propose \emph{speedup-aware rounding}, which rounds a task to its slower allotment exactly when this allotment is at most a factor $a$ slower than the fractional processing time. We determine the worst-case increase of the work under this rule exactly and show that no per-task rounding rule with time factor $a$ does better. With $μ=\lceilβ(a)m\rceil$ the algorithm achieves the approximation ratio $13(30+\sqrt{493})/225\approx3.0162$ for every $m$, which improves the previous bound $2+\sqrt2\approx3.4142$; a single task with linear speedup shows that its ratio is at least $\approx2.9558$. For concave speedup functions, which include the roofline, communication, Amdahl and power-law models, the ratio becomes $\approx2.9739$, which improves the ratio $\approx3.2919$ of Jansen and Zhang. We also revisit the strictly decreasing case of our earlier work (Chen and Chu, 2013): the reported ratio $2.9549$ relies on an elimination step that is not valid. In this case the algorithm coincides with that of Jansen and Zhang up to its parameters, and with parameters chosen by the corrected analysis it guarantees their ratio $\approx3.2919$. Finally, without convexity no per-task rounding improves the known time--work trade-off, and the analysis cannot go below $(3+\sqrt5)/2$.

0.23

Gaps and Augmentations in Bayesian Scheduling

cs.GT ·2026-09-27 ·Ahuva Mu'alem
benchmarktheory similarity 0.63
Abstract

The recent resolution of the Nisan--Ronen conjecture~\cite{NR,CKK} establishes that the optimal worst-case approximation ratio of deterministic truthful mechanisms for makespan on m unrelated machines is exactly m. We ask how prior information, Bayesian incentive compatibility (BIC), randomization, and machine-side resource augmentation change this barrier. We obtain three main results. First, we prove an asymptotic 4/3 lower bound for randomized BIC mechanisms with two machines, strengthening the previous 1.2 deterministic-BIC lower bound~\cite{MS}. Second, in the prior-free setting for two machines, randomization improves the known truthful ratio from 2 to 7/4~\cite{NR}. We show that randomized BIC scheduling mechanisms are likewise strictly more powerful than their deterministic counterparts, exhibiting an asymptotic BIC-integrality gap of 8/7. Thus, optimality in prior-dependent BIC scheduling can strictly require randomization. This parallels the role of lotteries in multidimensional revenue maximization, where randomization can strictly improve revenue~\cite{MV,BCKW}. Third, we show that when job assignments are sufficiently well spread across machines (more formally, when the pairwise collision parameter $Δ_r$ is bounded by a constant independent of both the number of machines m and the number of sampled layers r), then $O(m/\varepsilon)$ sampled layers suffice for the standard truthful MinWork mechanism to achieve a $1+\varepsilon$-approximation to the original first-best benchmark. Equivalently, $O(m/\varepsilon)$ sampled replicas per machine suffice. This resource-augmentation result parallels the Bulow--Klemperer perspective~\cite{BK,EFFTW}. As a by-product, in the standard unaugmented model, MinWork achieves a $(1+\frac{Δ_1(m-1)}{2})$-approximation to the first-best benchmark for every prior.

0.24