CS Paper Radar

Full Provenance on the COSS Causal Axis: An Event-Level Closure of Causal Attribution and Confused-Deputy Exclusion

Nicola Gallo

cs.CR cs.DC ·submitted 2026-11-04 21:42 UTC · v1
publishedtheory

Abstract

Provenance Identity Continuity (PIC) represents an authority-use event as an operation/resource behavior situated in a causal lineage, $(o,r,\ell)\in O\times R\times L$. We make the causal occurrence itself primitive: a represented security-relevant causal graph $(E,\to_c)$ in which each occurrence has a unique causal history, so the consistent event-lineage space is canonically isomorphic to $E$. The modeled execution has one causal partial order; distinct lineages are distinct causal histories inside it and may share a root while diverging into incomparable branches. PIC's $O\times R\times L$ is the authority-behavior projection of this space, and Causally Ordered Security-State (COSS) continuity generalizes it to an arbitrary behavior product over the same causal execution. On this semantics we prove an architecture-independent confused-deputy exclusion theorem. PIC continuation requires $C(e')\subseteq C(e)$ on every ordinary causal edge, so descendants are bounded by their ancestors; at an ordinary join, authority available on only one incoming branch cannot be resurrected, even when branches share a common root. Non-conservative combination must be an explicit authorized composition or relaxation event. With protected-effect mediation, an effect caused by request $q$ through an ordinary authority segment can exercise only authority in $C(q)$, so a confused-deputy state is contradictory. The result holds for any system whose protected request-to-effect causes are faithfully represented and whose ordinary authority transport satisfies PIC. We revisit Rajani, Garg, and Rezk: their value, control-flow, and initial-heap attacks are different witnesses of causal ancestry, so full provenance is an evidence mechanism for recovering edges of the causal graph, not the foundation of the PIC theorem. Finally we lift it to the COSS product of heterogeneous security-state coordinates.

Comment
19 pages
DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23102373

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Beyond Proof of Possession: A Relational Theory of Authority

cs.CR cs.DC ·2026-11-04 ·Nicola Gallo
publishedtheory similarity 0.73
Abstract · 30 pages

Proof-of-Possession (PoP) establishes that an executor controls an artifact (key, token, credential, or capability), but such control alone determines neither the executor's relational profile nor the causal history of an execution occurrence. We separate PoP from Proof of Relationship (PoR), the semantic property that one execution occurrence validly continues another, and from authorization, which is occurrence-sensitive. The foundational change is in the semantic domain of authorization: from holders and authority-bearing artifacts to execution occurrences situated in causal histories. We give authorization models an observation-based occurrence verdict and a separate transition-admissibility relation; kernel inclusion yields a partial order on observation-kernel classes. Building on Provenance Identity Continuity (PIC) and Proof-of-Continuity (PoC), we classify executors by authorization-relevant equivalence relations whose quotients form relational profile spaces, with positive predicates over profile transitions forming a distributive lattice. This adds relational attenuation to authority attenuation: along a valid causal history, $C_{i+1}\subseteq C_i$ and $ρ_{i+1}\Rightarrowρ_i$. We prove dual monotonicity, combined closure, and origin relational closure. Two occurrences of the same authenticated executor, with the same profile and possession evidence, need not be authorization-equivalent, and within a valid PIC lineage a deputy's independent authority cannot be imported outside the origin context. Finally, we prove that the executor-dependent decision factors through the relational profile and is invariant under sound mechanisms establishing it: successor-side PoP is a possible evidence mechanism, not a necessary premise of authorization. Under explicit Witness Assumptions, a boundary-witnessed checkpoint construction realizes the premises without successor-side PoP.

0.69

Causal Effect Identifiability in Causal Abstractions: A Strict Hierarchy of Criteria

cs.AI ·2026-10-09 ·Clément Yvernes, Marianne Clausel, Emilie Devijver, Eric Gaussier
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Identifying causal effects from observational data typically requires a fully specified causal graph, an assumption that is often unrealistic in complex or high-dimensional settings. Causal abstractions address this limitation by retaining only partial causal information, thereby defining equivalence classes of compatible causal graphs. In this paper, we study causal effect identifiability directly at the level of these graph collections, rather than at the level of individual causal diagrams. We formalize several notions of identifiability in this setting and organize them into a hierarchy that clarifies their relationships and differences. In particular, we establish that a causal effect may be identified over a collection of graphs without admitting a single causal derivation that holds uniformly across all compatible graphs. These results help reveal gaps and clarify ambiguities in the existing literature.

0.11

Graph Surgery and the Do-Operator: A Precise Correspondence for Acyclic Structural Causal Models

cs.AI cs.PL ·2026-08-18 ·Satpreet Makhija
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract

The $\operatorname{do}$-operator is described graphically by deleting arrows into its targets and functionally by replacing their mechanisms with constants. To call these operations equivalent is not yet a mathematical statement: one returns a graph and remembers only the targets, whereas the other returns mechanisms and also remembers the imposed values. We make a dependency-level comparison precise for deterministic acyclic structural causal models with finitely many endogenous variables. If $\operatorname{Graph}(F)$ extracts the dependencies of a mechanism family $F$, our main theorem is $\operatorname{Graph}(F^ι)=\operatorname{Surg}(\operatorname{Graph}(F),T_ι)$. Thus replacing target mechanisms removes exactly the dependencies removed by graph surgery. For a model $M=(G,F)$ whose graph may contain unused arrows, we characterize when the same equality holds with $G$ in place of $\operatorname{Graph}(F)$; it holds for every intervention exactly when $G$ records the dependencies of $F$ exactly. We then define the intervened model, characterize its run, show how sequential interventions combine, and prove that an outcome depends only on interventions at its actual dependency ancestors. All principal results are machine-checked in an accompanying Lean 4 development.

0.25

Concurrency, Causality and Conflict via Independence in Reversible Calculi

cs.LO ·2026-09-16 ·Clément Aubert, Gabriele Cecilia, Iain C. C. Phillips, Irek Ulidowski
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract · 45 pages, 18 figures

Among the different ways of approaching the semantics of process calculi, true-concurrency models stand out for their ability to highlight subtle interplays between events. At their heart lie three crucial relations: concurrency, causality and conflict. This paper shows that reversibility, when endowed with a notion of independence, provides a rich tooling to study and characterise these true-concurrency relations. First, we prove that systems admitting pre-reversibility (i.e., that can be extended with an independence relation satisfying some basic axioms) have a unique notion of independence, events, concurrency, causality and conflict. We then analyse the relationship between independence and the true-concurrency relations, establishing novel independence-based characterisations of causality and conflict. Our second series of contributions revolves around two concrete process calculi and two syntactic notions defined on their transition labels, namely independence and dependence; we prove that they partition connected transitions and characterise elegantly concurrency on adjacent transitions. This part of our development was machine-checked using the proof assistant Beluga. Last, we study how the key mechanism commonly used in reversible process algebra can be used as a proxy to retrieve causality and core independence on past events. We conclude by discussing how our results extend beyond reversible systems.

0.25

Renaming or Tightness: Enforcing Disjunctive Information Flow Policies

cs.CR cs.LOcs.PL ·2026-08-10 ·Xin Xu, Siru Tao, Kaizhen Tan
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 13 pages, 3 figures, 1 table. Under review

A disjunctive policy allows a value to depend on at most one of two secrets and never on both: an analyst may consult one client's file or the other's, a share of a split secret may be released but not its sibling. Such policies are not lattice-shaped, and Hunt and Sands introduced the quantale of information to give them a semantics, leaving the enforcement layer open. We build the flow-sensitive type system family that the quantale calls for, and show that the object which makes such families useful, the universal type object from which every member specialises, splits in two, with a consequence for enforcement. Over the free commutative quantale on the program variables the whole mechanism survives for every policy: monotone renaming, canonical derivations, principal typings, internal completeness. Over the free object with idempotent generators the certified bound is strictly more precise and still sound, because it records that two reads of one source honour one disjunct. The gap cannot be closed from inside the independent-attribute family: no mechanism of that shape whose labelling maps support monotone renaming certifies a bound more precise than the first, and for principal typings under generator-exact homomorphic specialisation the two coincide. Under the ethical-wall and secret-sharing labels the second read of a disjunctive source therefore drives every such certificate to no guarantee, and programs that satisfy the policy are rejected. The literal transcription of the lattice-era object is no escape either: it is a further quotient that loses branch disjunction. Precision is recovered by deferring specialisation to the judgement level, and the resulting read-out map is the least sound join-preserving one.

0.12

Decreasing Diagrams are Complete for Confluence

cs.LO ·2026-10-05 ·Jörg Endrullis, Ievgen Ivanov, Femke van Raamsdonk
theory similarity 0.57
Abstract

Confluence is a fundamental property of nondeterministic computations, arising from parallelism, concurrency, or freedom in the evaluation order. It guarantees that such a computation always yields the same result, regardless of the order in which steps are taken. The decreasing diagrams technique of van Oostrom is one of the most versatile methods for establishing confluence of transition systems (abstract rewriting systems). It reduces global confluence to local confluence: a system is confluent whenever its transitions admit a locally decreasing labeling. Essentially all classical confluence criteria arise as corollaries. A central question, posed by van Oostrom in 1993, asks whether the decreasing diagrams technique is complete: Does every confluent transition system admit a locally decreasing labeling? This is Problem 56 of the RTA List of Open Problems. A positive answer was known only for countable systems, and recently up to the first uncountable cardinal $\aleph_1$. The general case remained open. We settle this thirty-three-year-old problem in full. We prove that every confluent transition system admits a locally decreasing labeling using only three labels. This bound is optimal, as two labels do not suffice even at the first uncountable cardinality. It follows that this single criterion can, in principle, certify the confluence of every confluent system, and hence of every confluent program. The entire development is machine-checked in the Isabelle/HOL and Lean proof assistants and relies only on classical logic and the axiom of choice.

0.23

Identity-Bound Governance Under Execution Uncertainty: An Accountability Proof Block for LLM Agent Persistent Halts, with Cryptographic Implementation and Cross-Model Calibration

cs.CR ·2026-09-30 ·Marcelo Fernandez
theorycode/data similarity 0.57
Abstract · 24 pages, 7 tables, 2 propositions. Paper 8 of the Agent Governance Series. v2: RFC 8785 canonicalization, event_id uniqueness (V5), k-of-n …

A correctly governed LLM agent can reach a state in which neither continuing execution nor automatically halting is admissible: the system has detected a persistent failure of its observability or drift-detection layer, but cannot itself decide who has the authority to resume, deny, or recalibrate the deployment. We call this an identity-bound governance event and formalise the mechanism that resolves it. We introduce the Accountability Proof Block (APB): a system-constructed evidence block, a human-supplied decision block, and an ed25519 signature binding both to a registered principal. The system cannot forge the signature, and the principal cannot alter the evidence undetected. We prove four theorems: Protocol-Bounded Governance Completeness, Non-Repudiability, Impossibility of Anonymous Re-Authorization, and Finite-Time APB Construction Termination. The implementation uses RFC 8785 JSON canonicalization and a UUID4-based replay predicate. Empirically, governance completeness holds over 3,812 halt events with zero unresolved cases; the verifier detects 100% of 1,800 attacks across 9 adversarial vectors; a k-of-n multi-principal variant shows 0 false acceptances in 2,000 single-key capture attempts. A study of six open LLMs finds the drift threshold T* stable within model (sigma/T* < 2%) but varying across models, refuting size-monotonicity: the largest model did not drift. T* must therefore be measured per deployment, and the APB is the vehicle by which that threshold yields accountable authority transfer.

0.32

Replay Is a Family of Assertions: Fork-Safety in Event-Sourced Agent Runtimes

cs.PL cs.SE ·2026-08-29 ·Yohei Nakajima
code/data similarity 0.57
Abstract · 27 pages; executable specification, validation harness, and conformance vectors: https://github.com/yoheinakajima/agent-runtime-laws

Event-sourced agent runtimes commonly claim deterministic replay, cheap forking, and lineage. These are families of assertions, not one guarantee. A fixed-log fold may be deterministic while reactive settlement remains schedule-sensitive; a recorded oracle result can enable zero-call replay while the original interaction still changed cost or world state; and a prefix copy cannot undo an action in a discarded suffix. We present an executable F# contract that separates facts from effect requests, makes scheduling explicit, and assesses a cut relative to projection, strict execution replay, external continuation, or a declared counterfactual-world observation. Preserved counterexamples show that general settlement is neither terminating nor confluent and that disjoint declared writes do not prevent read/trigger interference. Against 5,540 public runtime logs, all 317,296 projection cuts satisfy the stated observation, while 36,251 cuts split a model request and do not license continuation; another 120,969 are Conditional because a committed oracle result must be served from the record without re-execution. In 121 observed forks, 16,625 retained-prefix events have zero structural mismatches, but none crosses an external-effect boundary. A separate public offline conformance fork crosses a committed, recorded oracle boundary. Its generator observes that the inherited result is served without a second fixture-oracle call; its verifier checks receipt/log consistency and a fork-bound HMAC assertion under a public conformance key. The result reframes cheap forking as a property-indexed semantic contract with explicit evidence and environment preconditions.

0.33