CS Paper Radar

Scaffolding GenAI Use in Ethical Essay Writing: A Three-Year Experience Report in Introductory Computing

Asma Shakil, Paul Denny, Jun Seo, Gauravkumar Hirani, Sean Longyu Ma, Claus Brabrand

cs.CY ·submitted 2026-11-05 18:24 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

As society, ethics, and professional practice become increasingly integrated across the computer science curriculum, technical courses need practical ways to support ethical reasoning. Ethical essay assignments offer one approach, but little is known about how students use GenAI when writing such essays. This experience report examines GenAI use across three years of ethical essay assignments in a large first-year computer systems course. Across six post-essay surveys from 2024 to 2026, we analyzed 1,894 responses, linked survey data with essay grades in 2025 and 2026, and introduced a scaffolded responsible-use workflow in 2026. Under voluntary-use policies, AI adoption remained steady at around two-thirds of students, rising above 90% when use was scaffolded. Students reported mainly using AI for help with grammar and style, while tool use diversified beyond ChatGPT in 2026. Grade-linked analyses showed that AI use did not independently predict essay quality, while marker evaluations indicated high levels of critical engagement when use was scaffolded. Overall, GenAI's pedagogical value appears to depend on how assessment design guides students to evaluate and critically engage with AI-generated suggestions.

DOI
10.1145/3857222.3860166

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Judgment-Centred Software Engineering Education: A Post-Hype Review and Framework for AI-Augmented Learning

cs.SE cs.CY ·2026-09-24 ·Qusay H. Mahmoud
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 22 pages, 1 figure, 3 tables

Generative artificial intelligence has moved from a disruptive novelty to a recurring part of software-development and computing-education workflows, while software agents are beginning to act across repositories, command lines, browsers, tests, and other tools. The educational problem is no longer whether students should be allowed to generate code, but whether software-engineering (SE) programs can preserve and assess human understanding while preparing students to work responsibly with increasingly capable AI systems. This paper presents a structured integrative review of research and practice from 2023 through 23 September 2026, supplemented by established work on AI literacy, technical debt, and human-AI collaboration. The evidence supports a conditional conclusion: GenAI can improve access to explanations, feedback, practice, and short-term task completion, but learning outcomes depend on prior knowledge, scaffolding, verification, task design, and assessment. We examine student help-seeking and authorship, faculty assessment and policy demands, and the wider SE risks created when generated artifacts persist across repositories, teams, architectures, and deployed systems. We extend the concept of comprehension debt: the deferred learning and maintenance cost that arises when AI-assisted production outpaces a learner's or team's ability to explain, test, modify, and justify the resulting software. We then refine the AI-Augmented Software Engineering Education (AASEE) framework into five non-linear integration levels and four cross-cutting evidence obligations: explain, verify, modify, and account. The framework links delegation to evidence, governance, and recovery mechanisms appropriate to its consequences.

0.33

Who Should Grade My Work? Student Perspectives on Transparent AI-Assisted Writing Assessment in Higher Education

cs.AI ·2026-09-04 ·Rayed AlGhamdi
similarity 0.65
Abstract

The integration of GenAI tools into higher education assessment raises important questions about how students understand, interpret, and respond to AI-mediated evaluation. As instructors increasingly explore AI tools for providing feedback, prior research has examined whether GenAI-generated feedback improves writing performance and how students perceive its usefulness; comparatively little is known, however, about how students interpret such evaluation when they are explicitly informed that an AI system, rather than a human instructor, produced the feedback and the score. This study reports findings from a qualitative pedagogical inquiry conducted in an undergraduate technical communication course for computing students at a Saudi public university. Thirteen male undergraduate computing students completed an in-class handwritten writing task; the scanned submissions were evaluated by ChatGPT using a rubric-based prompt aligned with the task objectives. Students were then explicitly informed that ChatGPT had generated the score and feedback and were invited to reflect on the evaluation in writing. Inductive thematic analysis of these reflections identified four themes: perceived usefulness of feedback; awareness of AI's contextual and pedagogical limitations; conditional trust, distinguishing feedback utility from evaluative authority; and reflection on the institutional and pedagogical role of the human instructor. Participants accepted GenAI feedback as useful for surface-level revision but consistently positioned the human instructor as the appropriate authority over grading decisions. The study identifies this as a distinction between feedback utility and evaluative authority, two judgments that students treat as analytically separate rather than as opposite ends of a single approval scale...

0.22

AI-written admissions essays are widespread but penalized

cs.CY ·2026-09-18 ·Calvin Isley, Johann D. Gaebler, Sharad Goel
similarity 0.64
Abstract

AI is rapidly transforming higher education, including the application process, yet relatively little is known about its use and consequences. To help close this gap, we analyze nearly 7{,}500 applications submitted between 2020 and 2025 to a large public policy master's program in the United States. We find that in the 2025 admissions cycle, the majority of applicants submitted at least one essay that was primarily AI-generated---despite an explicit prohibition against using AI. Leveraging the abrupt introduction of ChatGPT in November 2022, we find that the availability of AI assistants improved the writing quality of submitted essays. These improvements, however, came with an apparent AI penalty: Applicants submitting AI-written essays were admitted less often than comparable non-users. To help explain this penalty, we conduct an experiment with admissions officers, finding that they can often recognize AI writing and rate essays they believe to be AI-generated lower than essays they believe to be human generated. These findings indicate that AI is changing both how applicants write and how that writing is evaluated, raising questions about whether admissions practices and policies designed for a pre-AI era remain appropriate.

0.49

Evaluation in the Age of AI: Output as Evidence of Learning

cs.CY ·2026-08-23 ·Md Zarzees Uddin Shah Chowdhury, Samin Rahman Khan
position similarity 0.64
Abstract · 12 pages, 1 figure, 1 table

The rapid adoption of artificial intelligence (AI), particularly large language models (LLMs), has fundamentally disrupted how learning is demonstrated and evaluated in higher education. Tasks that once served as proxies for understanding-such as writing essays, solving problem sets, or producing computer code-can now be generated superficially by AI systems with minimal human effort. This paradigm shift raises a critical ethical question: how should learning be evaluated when traditional indicators of competence are easily outsourced? This paper examines the ethical challenges of educational evaluation in the age of AI from a university-level perspective. We argue that the core problem extends beyond academic dishonesty to a deeper misalignment between assessment practices and the learning outcomes they are intended to measure. Evaluation regimes that rely on artificial constraints risk measuring compliance, access, or concealment rather than genuine understanding, reasoning, or judgment. By analyzing institutional responses and presenting empirical survey data, we highlight the need for alternative assessment models that emphasize process over product. The goal is to establish ethically informed assessment strategies that preserve student agency and accountability in an automated age.

0.23

Wording Matters: Understanding How GenAI Policy Rules Shape Teachers' and Students' Workflows and Perceptions

cs.HC ·2026-11-08 ·Sabiha Mehreen, Xiangzhe Yuan, Rishab Nithyanand, Naimul Hoque
similarity 0.63
Abstract

The growing use of generative AI (GenAI) in higher education has led institutions to develop policies governing its applications. However, we have little knowledge about how teachers and students adapt and adhere to the policies. In this paper, we analyzed GenAI policies from 101 U.S. universities, identifying nine recurring rules for GenAI use, and interviewed 20 students and 20 faculty members about the rules. We find that the wording of the rules can change how students perceive and act on the rules while introducing different challenges that teachers face in enforcing them in practice. For example, rules such as "Passing off AI-generated content as your own constitutes academic dishonesty" and "Students are accountable for any inaccurate, biased, or unethical content" both outline the acceptable use of AI, but the former can make students hide their use of AI out of fear of unwanted scrutiny, whereas the latter can encourage students to take responsibility and ownership of their use of AI and be more transparent. Students described uncertainty about acceptable use, fear of penalties and unfair treatment, and stigma that discouraged acknowledging AI use. Teachers took on approval workload, had to interpret acceptable use, and lacked reliable ways to verify compliance. We summarize these impacts in a policy-impact matrix linking each rule to its effects on teacher and student workflows and perception.

0.28

WIP: Exploring Student-Created AI Agents and Instructional Videos to Foster Engagement in Computing Education

cs.CY ·2026-11-17 ·Lucas G. Zangari, Olufisayo Omojokun, Pedro Guillermo Feijóo-García
published similarity 0.62
Abstract · This work was presented at 2025 ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in Education (FIE)

This work-in-progress (WIP) research-to-practice study examines the use of student-created artifacts to promote active learning in a large undergraduate Software Design and Engineering (SWE) course. Active learning strategies have been shown to significantly enhance student engagement, comprehension, and motivation, particularly in computing education. In this work, we explore the use of student-created artifacts to foster student engagement in higher-level Computer Science (CS) courses. Specifically, we examine the experiences of undergraduate and graduate CS students who participated in the creation of two types of artifacts: instructional video tutorials and conversational AI agents. The goal being to understand how designing these artifacts could support students in applying and learning course content. Students raised valuable insights regarding both experiences. Concerning the creation of instructional videos, they appreciated the interactivity brought through multimedia to their learning experiences, although some found the strategy to be time-consuming. Similarly, when designing conversational AI agents, students enjoyed the novelty and practical application of the task, while some encountered challenges related to the complexity of tools such as \textit{Google Dialogflow ES}. We report on the potential of student-created artifacts to foster deeper engagement with course material, encouraging both creativity and critical thinking in computing education.

0.13

Critical Thinking with Generative AI: A Constraint-First Design Pilot of a Thinking-Partner Intervention

cs.HC ·2026-09-29 ·Fatima Tuz Zahra, Jiangen He, David M. Bowers, Wei Wang
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 53 pages, 5 figures

Generative AI (GenAI) tools entered higher education classrooms faster than the field was able to study their effects on learning. One concern is that GenAI may displace the critical thinking and AI literacy that students will need after graduation. This paper reports a Design-Based Research pilot of a GenAI-assisted critical thinking framework, in which ChatGPT was used as a thinking partner in an undergraduate research methods and statistics course during Spring 2025 (N = 14). The mixed-methods design combined pre- and post-intervention measures of statistical learning (AASCDM), AI literacy (MAILS), and critical thinking (WGCTA) with instructor field notes, student artifacts, and student-AI interaction logs. Pre-post tests showed gains on every AASCDM dimension and on eight of nine MAILS dimensions, while WGCTA percentiles did not change. Qualitative analysis identified four themes: the ways students positioned the LLM (as answer generator, validator, or co-thinker); the depth of student engagement (procedural vs. conceptual); occasional humanizing of the tool; and the role of curriculum design in shaping each of the prior three. Read together, the findings indicate that one semester of GenAI-assisted instruction can move domain learning and self-reported AI literacy but does not move standardized critical thinking, and that the modal student-LLM relationship is one of validation instead of dialogue. We end with design principles for the next iteration of the framework and implications for research on adaptive and personalized learning.

0.20

A Guided Inquiry Approach to Students Co-Designing Generative AI Course Policies

cs.CY ·2026-08-28 ·Ashish Hingle, Aditya Johri
top venue similarity 0.62
Abstract · Accepted for publication in Artificial Intelligence and Education (Emerald)

As generative AI (GenAI) use among students increases, educators face growing questions about how to support learning while addressing ethical and institutional concerns. This exploratory study examines a guided inquiry activity in which students co-designed a GenAI course policy. Students first developed individual policy proposals focused on appropriate and ethical use of GenAI, then collaboratively refined them by incorporating diverse stakeholder perspectives. The following research questions guided the study: 1) what practical factors do students prioritize in their GenAI use policies, and how do they justify these choices? and 2) how do participants reflect on the policy design process? Participants first completed readings, then used GenAI to brainstorm initial policy ideas. Next, they articulated their own perspectives through a written assignment and a course policy they designed individually. Finally, they incorporated diverse stakeholder perspectives by collaborating with peers to develop a collective policy. Analysis of student artifacts and group discussions showed that participants prioritized training for students and instructors, standardized procedures for disclosing AI use, and stronger institutional support. Participants also wanted greater involvement in GenAI-related decision-making. They described the policy design process as a way to engage with multiple perspectives and the inherent trade-offs involved in governing AI use. This study offers pedagogical insights into how policy co-design activities can surface student values, concerns, and sensemaking about GenAI in educational contexts.

0.38