CS Paper Radar

Beyond One User and One Model: Rethinking LLMs as Mediators in Collaborative Sensemaking and Ideation

Pengqi Wang, Emily Kuang

cs.HC ·submitted 2026-08-20 13:37 UTC · v1
publishedposition

Abstract

As LLMs enter qualitative data workflows, they are predominantly designed for individual researchers rather than collaborative teams, which risks disrupting the collective negotiation essential to sensemaking, driving premature consensus, and potentially erasing marginalized voices. In this position paper, we argue that LLMs must be reconceived as active team mediators. Grounded in empirical studies of human-LLM collaborative analysis, we propose three design directions: quote-level traceability to preserve accountability of human and LLM contributions, controllable delegation boundaries to maintain researcher agency across workflow stages, and structured dissent mechanisms to surface interpretive conflicts that teams might otherwise suppress. We ground these directions in accessibility research as a domain where methodological rigor and representational equity are obligatory.

Comment
Accepted by 2026 Co-Data : Cultivating Effective Human-LLM Collaboration for Collaborative Data Processing Workshop at ACM CHI

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Disentangling Threads: Exploring the Potential of LLM-Supported Discussion Forum Analysis for Community Insight

cs.HC ·2026-08-20 ·Tony W. Li, Zhiqing Wang, Thanh-Nha Tran, Yu-Chun Grace Yen, Steven P. Dow
published similarity 0.63
Abstract · Accepted to ACM Collective Intelligence Conference, 2026

Online discussion forums enable people from diverse backgrounds to share ideas, feedback, and perspectives. These organic discussions can help researchers understand communities' collective viewpoints, but insights are often difficult to uncover given their freeform reply structure. Large language models (LLMs) support qualitative text analysis but can misalign with researchers' analytical intent and miss key insights. To inform design considerations for forum sensemaking tools, we manually analyzed a forum discussion, synthesized an exploratory analysis framework from relevant literature, built a design probe, and interviewed 21 researchers to uncover perceived opportunities and barriers with LLM representations of collective discussions. We provide recommendations for community sensemaking tools to support flexible analytical goals grounded in raw user data and enable follow-up research processes, while balancing anonymous free expression with the desire for contextual information on commenters.

0.40

Inspectable LLM-Simulated Participants for Qualitative Interview Rehearsal

cs.HC ·2026-10-19 ·Hangyue Zhang, Qiran Hu, Ziyi Zhang, Hyanghee Park, Yun Huang
similarity 0.60
Abstract

LLMs are increasingly used across research workflows, including research ideation, qualitative analysis, and participant simulation. Within work on participant simulation, prior studies have largely evaluated simulated participants by how realistic or human-like their responses appear, leaving less known about how researchers use and critique these materials when revising interview protocols before fieldwork. We present Rehearsim, an inspectable research probe that treats LLM-simulated participants as materials for methodological rehearsal rather than substitutes for human participants. Rehearsim combines literature-grounded participant construction, interactive interview rehearsal, and traceable thematic review while keeping protocol decisions under researcher control. In a study with 21 qualitative researchers, participants used simulated materials to surface assumptions and gaps, reconsider participant populations, revise target populations, and develop follow-up probes. They also identified risks, including the concealment of weak questions, dismissal of unexpected synthetic details, and interpretive anchoring from generated themes. We derive an inspectable-rehearsal framework emphasizing traceability, contestability, researcher control, and epistemic boundaries.

0.20

Working with Agentic `Teammates': When a New Organizational Actor Collides with the Human Ecosystem of Work

cs.HC cs.AI ·2026-09-24 ·Rida Qadri, Remi Denton, Michael Madaio, Mahima Pushkarna, Leslie Lai +11 more
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Enterprise AI is transitioning from single-user, reactive tools toward proactive, multi-user 'teammates,' but our empirical understanding of this transition is limited. In this paper, we present an in-situ qualitative study of a persistent, proactive AI agent 'teammate' deployed across multiple teams in a large technology company. Our findings reveal the boundaries of the human-agent workplace are actively in flux, triggering breakdowns and negotiations across: 1) tacit rules of collaborative human workflows, 2) the relational boundaries of this new non-human actor, and 3) the redistribution of trust and human agency. We use these early micro-negotiations as signals to chart a new research, design, and organizational agenda that intentionally preserves human agency in a workplace shared with non-human organizational actors.

0.24

Supporting Allyship in Virtual Collaboration with Artificial Intelligence: A Scenario-Based Study

cs.HC ·2026-10-06 ·Crescentia Jung, Ricardo E. Gonzalez Penuela, Prashita Biswas, Seungyoon Kwon, Shiri Azenkot
top venue similarity 0.58
Abstract

Recent research has revealed that accessibility in virtual collaboration is not only a technical problem but also depends on allyship: the informal, interpersonal practices through which people support others' accessibility needs. Yet little research has examined how artificial intelligence (AI) might support allyship in collaborative accessibility contexts. To address this gap, we conducted a study where 18 participants (10 disabled, 8 non-disabled) reflected on four allyship scenarios with novel AI tools. Participants valued AI designs that they anticipated could help teammates express, interpret, and coordinate around access needs by reducing repeated disclosure and making allyship more actionable. At the same time, participants raised concerns when AI acted without consent, misrepresented users' intentions, or displaced the interpersonal work of allyship. Based on our findings, we introduce allyship-support tools as a class of accessibility technologies, offer design guidelines, and discuss AI in particular as a means of supporting allyship.

0.32

Human and LLM Facilitation in Collaborative Design Meetings: A Computational Behavioral Comparison

cs.LG ·2026-10-09 ·Mohammed Azeez Khan, Aaron Dsouza, Ashutosh Mishra, Ummul Faiz Z. Bibi, Neha K. Nair +1 more
similarity 0.57
Abstract · 17 pages, 7 figures, 6 tables

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being explored as facilitators of group discussion and collaborative work, but the behavioral differences between LLM-generated and human facilitation remain insufficiently characterized. We compare human Project Manager facilitation turns from scenario-based collaborative design meetings with Llama 3.1 8B Instruct responses across 199 paired contexts from the AMI Meeting Corpus. The analysis covers five confirmatory dimensions: contextual semantic distance, a lexical elaboration proxy, empathyand-hedge lexical density, topic divergence, and phase-vocabulary alignment. An exploratory directiveness measure failed domain validation and is not interpreted. The sampled human Project Manager turns were higher on contextual semantic distance (r = 0.644) and on empathyand-hedge lexical density (r = 0.203). The second contrast is carried mainly by hedge terms, so we read it as lexical hedging rather than psychological empathy. Llama-generated facilitation was higher on topic divergence (r = 0.703), the lexical elaboration proxy (r = 0.288; lengthconfounded), and instruction-conditioned phase-vocabulary alignment (r = 0.382). A secondary no-phase check left the Llama-higher phase contrast in place. The system prompt still requested a facilitation move, so that check is not evidence of spontaneous phase awareness. These differences should not be interpreted as a ranking of facilitation quality. The resulting behavioral profile provides a reference point for later comparisons of LLM facilitators, human facilitators, prompts, models, and collaborative settings.

0.29

Teamknitt: Configuring, Observing and Intervening in LLM-Agent Teams through the Lens of Dynamical-Systems and Human-Team Theory

cs.MA physics.soc-ph ·2026-11-09 ·Goran Mitevski
code/data similarity 0.57
Abstract · 17 pages, 3 figures, 6 tables. Reference implementation v0.9.0: https://github.com/JeranRolevs/teamknitt

Most frameworks for teams of large language model (LLM) agents fix the team's shape inside the software: who talks to whom, how much is passed along, and what a human can do once a run has started. Human-team research has long asked those questions: where team phenomena live (in members or in their interaction), how team-level properties arise, and what separates what a team does from how a team is. I propose using that theory as the organizing lens for configuring, observing and intervening in LLM-agent teams, without assuming its findings transfer. I introduce teamknitt, a framework and open reference implementation in which a user configures a team of 1-16 AI agents for task completion, solution generation, achieving a goal or a research mission; selects one of fourteen deterministic routing topologies or a custom directed graph; chooses a sharing profile that limits what may travel along permitted routes; and binds sources, representations, work dependencies, handoffs and an expertise directory. The recorded process can be observed through non-system views (member reports and behavior) and system views (distributed problem-solving, differentiated transactive memory, interactive coordination, team dynamics). Interventions are explicit and human-led: reviewed reconfiguration between runs, planned disturbances, and private feedback, pause, resume or stop applied at dependency-wave boundaries, with "queued", "applied", "assembled", "understood" and "improved" kept as separate claims. Emergent states such as trust and shared understanding are declared unmeasured. This is an idea and system-description paper with falsifiable hypotheses on topology, information flow and intervention timing, including whether the fractal scaling of communication output between members, and between members on different models, relates to task and team performance. No comparative result is reported.

0.23

LLMs and the Organization of Scientific Work

cs.CY ·2026-11-02 ·Stefano Bianchini, Georgiana-Ioana Coroama
similarity 0.57
Abstract

The advent of large language models (LLMs) represents a technological revolution for science. Their diffusion may reshape not only how scientists conduct research, but also how they organize their work within teams. Here, we develop a conceptual framework in which LLMs expand individual capabilities across a range of research activities, reducing reliance on complementary human inputs within tasks and facilitating a more specialized division of labor among team members. We further propose that teams' history of collaboration may constrain their ability to reorganize in response to the new technological capabilities. Using CRediT contribution statements from approximately 120,000 PLOS ONE articles published between 2018 and 2025, we investigate changes in the division of labor within scientific teams following the release of ChatGPT in late 2022. We document three main findings. First, participation in scientific tasks falls below its previous trajectory, particularly in conceptualization, execution, and writing. Second, researchers become more specialized, exhibiting narrower task portfolios and less overlap in their contributions with co-authors. Third, these changes are concentrated among newly formed teams, whose members have no prior collaboration ties, whereas established teams, whose members have all collaborated previously, exhibit considerably greater organizational inertia. Our findings suggest that, in the wake of LLM diffusion, scientific work is being reorganized around greater individual autonomy and an increasingly specialized division of labor within teams.

0.22

The Interface Is Downstream: Designing the Terms of Human-Agent Collaboration

cs.HC ·2026-09-23 ·Hector Ouilhet Olmos
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Before an agent responds or acts, much of the experience has already been designed. Memory and retrieval shape what it notices. Evidence rules shape what it may claim. Permissions shape what it can do. Learning rules shape what it carries into the next encounter. The argument comes from Alicia, a personal agent I've built and used since January 2026. A fine-tuning pilot produced no defensible model-performance result. It exposed a provenance failure: Alicia repeated an interpretation from a retrieved synthesis, cited a source note credited by that synthesis, and left the synthesis out of the visible chain. In a model-blind review of thirty-three citations, one reviewer judged that the retrieved intermediary supplied the claim in sixteen relayed citations and part of it in four. Five of twelve citations to directly retrieved targets lacked support in the target excerpt supplied for review. These judgments remain unadjudicated, and the packet is not public. I call the shared setting a humorphic environment: a persistent computational setting that translates a human practice into software. The first Humorphism paper translated partnership. This paper translates the studio, the room where practice happens. The failure prompted an audit of attention, evidence, action, and learning, with a review artifact and available recourse for each. The test is whether the person can inspect and contest what shaped the teammate's behavior. The output is downstream. Correction, consent, and learning carry the collaborative interface back upstream.

0.11