CS Paper Radar

Implementing Set-Theoretic Types

Mickaël Laurent, Kim Nguyen

cs.PL ·submitted 2026-09-25 12:52 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

Set-theoretic types provide a rich type algebra that supports unrestricted unions, intersections, and negations, together with a decidable type constraint-solving algorithm known as tallying. These types are particularly well suited for typing dynamic languages, where functions often exhibit both generic and overloaded behavior. However, the complexity of their implementation has hindered their widespread adoption. In this paper, we introduce a modular representation for set-theoretic types and revisit the algorithms for subtyping and tallying. We compare our approach with the historical CDuce implementation and evaluate the performance impact of some optimizations and design choices.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Typechecking without Minimum Types: Finite Bases and Backward Checking for $F_{<:}^{\top}$

cs.PL ·2026-10-14 ·Mingkun Xiao, Yixuan Sun
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract · 44 pages, 8 figures, 2 tables. Includes appendices

System $F_{<:}^{\top}$ has decidable subtyping but lacks minimum types. We prove that typechecking is decidable for arbitrary explicitly annotated terms with unrestricted subsumption. The difficulty is that type abstraction uses a variable's declared bound to type its body, while quantified subtyping forgets that bound. We construct finite covers that preserve all required subtype comparisons across this change of context. These covers yield a compositional finite typing basis and a decision procedure. We then derive a backward checker that propagates acceptable targets without constructing the complete typing basis. Rectangularity of typing families gives a uniform elimination domain while retaining every result type, even when the canonical type is not least. Finite inverse families transport targets through type substitution. The same inverse specification recovers bound forgetting and yields finite type-avoidance families. Both typechecking procedures are total Rocq functions proved equivalent to the original typing judgment. For a separate symbolic word-RAM realization, we prove a quartic worst-case work bound. We measure family representation sizes and comparison storage in independent OCaml prototypes on synthetic checking judgments.

0.25

Revisiting Soundness for Occurrence Typing, Semantically

cs.PL ·2026-09-14 ·Yuquan Fu, Carlo Angiuli, Sam Tobin-Hochstadt
positiontheory similarity 0.63
Abstract

Over the past two decades, numerous systems have brought some of the benefits of dependent typing to a wide variety of new programming languages, often by restricting which terms can appear inside types. Such techniques are known as refinement types, occurrence typing, liquid types, and path dependent types, among others. However, the restrictions adopted by these systems often break the substitution property, because they explicitly disallow the ability to substitute arbitrary terms for variables inside types. This leads to significant complexity in the design and metatheory of these systems, increasing the possibility of significant errors. We consider a specific line of work on occurrence typing, namely, the calculus underlying Typed Racket due to Tobin-Hochstadt and Felleisen 2010. We show that the fundamental challenge of substitution into types resulted in multiple flaws in the formalism and the syntactic type soundness theorem of this work. These flaws are replicated in several other papers building on this work, and also surface as a soundness bug in Typed Racket itself. We identify and repair these problems, revising the core calculus of Typed Racket and giving a \emph{semantic type soundness} proof using step-indexed logical relations, formalized in Lean. We argue that this approach is simpler than it may seem, and easily scales to handle the complexity of the occurrence typing in Typed Racket.

0.33

More Powerful Constant Value Checking with SMT Solving

cs.PL ·2026-10-04 ·Jonas Mittnacht, Florian Lanzinger
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Pluggable type systems extend the basic type system of a programming language by introducing additional type hierarchies to specify more complex properties and dependencies between variables. We consider the Constant Value Checker, a pluggable type checker for Java implemented using the Checker Framework, which provides various pluggable type systems and corresponding checkers. The Constant Value Checker lets users specify restrictions on the values a primitive integer or boolean variable can hold using a set or range of constant values. However, the current implementation of the Value Checker makes use of a limited set of syntactic typing rules that, in practice, often fail to verify well-typedness of more complex code. In this paper, we introduce an extension to the Checker Framework using Satisfiability Modulo Theories (SMT) solvers to address these limitations by creating corresponding first-order logic formulas for expressions whose type checks fail with the current syntactic typing rules and determining their well-typedness based on the satisfiability of these formulas. Furthermore, we introduce new dependent types for specifying allowed values with expressions that can depend on other variables in the program.

0.22

Contravariant Universe Subtyping, Formalized, Mechanized

cs.PL ·2026-10-10 ·Shengyi Jiang, Jason Z. S. Hu
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract

In a type theory with a cumulative universe hierarchy, \emph{subtyping} is often incorporated to lift lower universe levels to higher ones. In practice, kernels of proof assistants typically implement universe subtyping conservatively: subtyping only propagates covariantly into the output types of $Π$ types, while input types must be equivalent. A full-blown subtyping relation also compares the input types contravariantly. However, contravariant subtyping is not justified by the existing set-theoretic model, and poses challenges in the development of a complete subtyping algorithm. We present \mclttsub, a complete mechanized study of contravariant universe subtyping for a core Martin-Löf type theory (MLTT), built as an extension of the verified McTT kernel in Rocq. We re-establish the syntactic meta-theory and the soundness and completeness properties of the normalization-by-evaluation (NbE) algorithm. To complete the verified pipeline for a type-checker, we give two complete and sound subtyping algorithms. The first one \emph{renormalizes} output types in every $Π$ iteration. Despite a simple completeness proof, this algorithm incurs additional computational cost. The second algorithm hence circumvents this cost by avoiding the renormalization at all. It simply recursively compares two already normalized types structurally. Nevertheless, a completeness proof of this algorithm in a semantic approach requires to reason about normalization in sub-contexts, a capability beyond what the current semantic gadget offers. Instead, we conduct a program equivalence proof through bisimulation relations. Using this technique, we prove that the NbE algorithm returns equal normal forms in sub-contexts up to universe levels, and successfully conclude the completeness of the subtyping algorithm.

0.33

Record Types Everywhere

cs.PL ·2026-10-20 ·Matthew Toohey, Ara Jamalzadeh, Ningning Xie
similarity 0.58
Abstract

This paper introduces a novel calculus that models first-class environments and function application paradigms using standard record types. By proposing new extensions to general record types, we achieve a design that is remarkably simple and principled. We formalise this design in a core calculus and prove several desirable properties, including type soundness, normalization, and a simulation of the simply typed lambda calculus. Additionally, we extend the design with mutable references. The calculus, its semantics, along with the extension, and all stated properties are fully mechanized in the Lean 4 proof assistant, alongside an interpreter formally verified to be equivalent to the operational semantics.

0.27

Unifying Function- and Argument-First Bidirectional Type Systems

cs.PL ·2026-09-02 ·Takuma Yoshioka, Taro Sekiyama, Atsushi Igarashi
publishedtheory similarity 0.58
Abstract · Accepted as a short version at APLAS 2026 (Springer LNCS). This extended version includes substantial new material and results

Bidirectional typing mixes type synthesis and type checking into a single process. Existing bidirectional type systems can be classified into two styles based on whether, given a function application, a bidirectional typing algorithm synthesizes the function's type first and typechecks the argument against the synthesized argument type, or it synthesizes the arguments' types first and typechecks the function against the synthesized arguments' types. We call the former _function-first_ and the latter _argument-first_. Not only do the two styles significantly differ in how the type systems and typing algorithms are formalized, but also they lead to incompatible typeabilities, forcing a language designer to select one style and to give up the other's typeabilities. In this paper, we unify the two styles and develop \lang with a new bidirectional type system for higher-rank polymorphism. Key ideas of the unification are twofold. Each function application is annotated with a bit of information to represent whether function- or argument-first typing is used, to allow a language designer (or even a programmer) to switch between the two styles at their discretion. We reformulate the function- and argument-first type systems by using ideas from colored types and boxy types, which can specify which part of a type should be synthesized or used for checking in a flexible manner. We also develop a typing algorithm based on the worklist approach by Zhao et al. The (declarative) type system of $λ^{BH}$ is shown to be sound and to subsume two representative function- and argument-first systems. Our typing algorithm is shown to be sound with respect to the type system of $λ^{BH}$ and complete with respect to representative function- and argument-first systems. We mechanically prove the metatheorems using the Abella theorem prover.

0.29

DueList: A Theory of Lists with Combinators for SMT Solvers

cs.PL ·2026-09-24 ·Pierre Goutagny, Aymeric Fromherz, Raphaël Monat
hot direction similarity 0.56
Abstract · Revised from Q1 2026 submission

Formal verification tools commonly rely on SMT solvers to automatically reason about programs, leveraging a range of logical theories, e.g., linear integer arithmetic, arrays, or strings, to encode program constructs and verification conditions. Despite recent advances, such solvers still struggle when reasoning about recursive data structures such as lists, which are pervasive in modern functional languages. Additionally, lists are commonly used in conjunction with higher-order combinators to, e.g., generically apply a function to all elements of the list. In this work, we provide first-class support for reasoning about lists within SMT solvers. We focus on lists of arbitrary size that, following the map-reduce paradigm, can be manipulated exclusively through a set of abstract combinators. To this end, we introduce DueList, an abstraction-refinement approach geared towards list reasoning, which we implement on top of off-the-shelf SMT solvers. To evaluate the efficiency of our approach, we assemble a diverse set of 752 benchmarks curated from previous works and real-world programs, and compare DueList against state-of-the-art solvers such as Z3 and CVC5. Our experimental evaluation shows that DueList extends reasoning facilities of existing solvers, allowing to conclude about the (un)satisfiability of a larger range of problems, while outperforming existing solvers in the vast majority of previously supported cases.

0.30

A sound pure type system with ranks as sorts and Type-in-Type

cs.LO math.LO ·2026-10-18 ·Pavel Sokolov, Alexander Kuklev
code/data similarity 0.56
Abstract · 28 pages, 3 figures, supplementary material to be found at http://github.com/TurtlePU/pts-rk

We present a dependently typed pure type system that contains a circular axiom $s : s$ for a certain sort $s$ and is nonetheless strongly normalizing. Girard's paradox is avoided because our sorts are not closed under a $Π$-former: function types are placed in sorts according to their rank. Turns out that this system has a unique set of characteristics: it has similar normalization behaviour as STLC (so complexity of normalization is TOWER-complete) while at the same time allowing non-uniform representation of arbitrary elementary recursive functions; furthermore, it has a nontrivial set-theoretical model in ZF+GCH and allows to carry out nontrivial proof developments. Base normalization proof is surprisingly simple (modulo general metatheoretical properties of pure type systems) and has been fully formalized in vanilla Rocq (formerly Coq) without additional axioms.

0.30