CS Paper Radar

Same Contacts, Different Rooms:Meeting Format Shapes LLM Group Influence Beyond Pairwise Contact Counts

Zhexi Gu, Shusheng Cao, Runping Zhu

cs.CL physics.soc-ph ·submitted 2026-11-07 10:30 UTC · v1
code/data

Abstract

Simulations of LLM agent collectives usually summarise interaction as a pairwise contact network. We test that summary with a contact-matched intervention: the members, their initial stances and every pairwise contact count stay fixed while the meetings are reorganised, and each member gives a one-step support readout after reading the arguments of everyone present. Across six open-weight LLMs and 14 debate topics, merging triads into five-person meetings (resize) moves group support more than reshuffling who meets in triads (regroup), although both move the same 60 dyadic exposures. The root-mean-square change is 4.36 versus 2.59 percentage points (pp), larger for resize in all six models and in 81 of 84 model-topic cells. Resizing also has a consistent direction: it amplifies the initial majority of the merged members by 1.72 pp, in every model, whereas regrouping has no direction (<= 0.03 pp). A contact network cannot represent regrouping at all, yet pairwise rules applied meeting by meeting explain up to 76% of its effect, and with identical weights they raise resize R^2 by 0.51-0.58 for two models. We show that the gap between the two placements is an exact Jensen gap of the sigmoid readout, bounded by how much a member's predicted logits vary across meetings; this dispersion tracks the gap with log-log r=0.97 and tells a modeller when contact counts are a safe summary. Meeting format is a first-class variable for LLM social simulation.

Comment
10 pages, 5 figures, 9 tables. Code: https://github.com/ZachGu-00/llm-meeting-format

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Collective Regimes in Multi-Agent LLMs under Reasoning Effort and Communication Topology

cs.MA ·2026-09-27 ·Machiko Hirota, Akshara Nadayanur Sathis Kanna, Ujwal Kumar, Phan Xuan Tan
hot direction similarity 0.60
Abstract

Multi-agent LLM systems are increasingly used for deliberation and evaluation, often under the assumption that greater peer interaction leads to more reliable consensus. Existing work largely evaluates these systems through final accuracy or aggregate agreement. However, such measures do not reveal how agreement is organized in the panel. In this paper, we study N = 50 stateless LLM agents that update their predictions from locally visible peers, and characterize their behavior using both global and local measurements of agreement. We identify three collective regimes: synchronised, twisted (locally ordered but globally incoherent) and chimera-like, where coherent and incoherent subpopulations coexist. Increasing reasoning effort in gpt-5-mini shifts panels from variable, often fragmented outcomes toward locally ordered twisted states, and a small follow-up shows such states can also form from permuted initial conditions, whereas increasing communication connectivity drives them toward global synchronisation. Fragmentation collapses faster as algebraic connectivity increases across rewired graphs. The topology effect also appears on a non-circular judging task and across models from three providers. Finally, low spatial heterogeneity does not guarantee global consensus: 40% of trials with Delta Z below 0.03 retain a twisted configuration through the final 20 turns. These results show that reasoning effort and communication topology control different aspects of multi-agent coordination, and that aggregate agreement alone is insufficient to characterize collective LLM behavior.

0.35

From Process Loss to Assembly Bonus: Human-Grounded Diagnosis of Multi-Agent LLM Collaboration

cs.MA cs.AIcs.CL ·2026-09-06 ·Ala N. Tak, Teruhisa Misu, Kumar Akash, Zhaobo K. Zheng, Kevin H. Joo +1 more
top venuehot direction similarity 0.59
Abstract · Accepted at EMNLP 2026. Camera-ready version

LLM agents are increasingly used for collaborative problem solving and human-group simulation. This makes outcome-only evaluation insufficient: if LLM groups are used as models of human groups, we need to know whether they succeed or fail through human-like deliberative mechanisms. We compare human group chats with matched LLM deliberation traces on Wason-style deductive reasoning, then test whether the same process signatures generalize to analogical, abductive, and analytical tasks. Humans and LLMs show the same assembly bonus asymmetry: discussion improves the average member more often than the best initial member. Initial-answer diversity accounts for the effect of model heterogeneity, increasing movement in both corrective and destructive directions. The main differences are process-level. Compared with humans, LLM groups follow majorities more often, surface less unique information, and converge earlier; correct minority signals succeed mainly when re-expressed early. Interventions motivated by human group-decision research yield modest improvements in collective outcomes, but do not remove the coordination bottleneck. Together, these results suggest that LLM groups can reproduce some outcome-level patterns of human deliberation while diverging in the mechanisms that generate assembly bonus and process loss, with implications for group simulation and human-AI collaboration.

0.50

LLM Facilitation of Group Decision-Making

cs.HC ·2026-11-14 ·José Córdova, Chun-Wei Chiang, Miriam Schirmer, Ming Yin, Emőke-Ágnes Horvát
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Human groups often fail to integrate information distributed across their members, converging on incorrect decisions. We ask whether large language models (LLMs) can help groups reach the correct decision in such settings. In an online, chat-based experiment, 138 three-person groups (N = 414) completed a hidden-profile hiring task that required selecting the best candidate using public information available to all group members and private information available only to individual members. The randomized human-subject experiment included three conditions: no facilitation, an individual-level LLM that messaged each member privately, and a group-level LLM that messaged the whole group. The LLM facilitation consisted of adaptive interventions that summarized the discussion, nudged quiet members, and played devil's advocate. The LLM did not know which candidate was correct. Both LLM conditions significantly increased the rate at which groups reached consensus on the correct candidate, from 32.6% without facilitation to 56.5% with LLM facilitation. LLM-facilitated groups exchanged more consensus messages signaling agreement on the group's choice. Participants in the group-level condition also disclosed significantly more information about the correct candidate, whereas those receiving individual-level facilitation repeated public information less often. Finally, group-level facilitation received more favorable usability ratings than individual-level facilitation. These results show that LLMs can deliver adaptive, theory-informed interventions that improve group decision-making, and that the design of these interventions may shape how people respond to them.

0.27

GenAI as an 'Invisible Hand' in Opinion Dynamics: Evidence from a Group-Level Simulation Study

cs.SI cs.AI ·2026-10-18 ·Thomas Grisold, Johannes Schneider
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Recent arguments suggest that genAI can act as an invisible hand that gradually shapes social structures, such as collective beliefs and norms. The argument is that if millions of people repeatedly consult genAI tools, their generated outcomes quietly shape what becomes acceptable, reasonable or conventional. We study this in the context of collective opinion dynamics, i.e., how groups form opinions around controversial dynamics. We present the findings of a simulation including 50,000 group discussions across 50 controversial statements, three LLMs, and different social configurations. We vary two characteristics of LLM interaction-agreeableness and personalization-and compare the influence of genAI in homogeneous and heterogeneous groups. Our findings indicate that profile-specific personalization increases LLM influence when models adopt a non-neutral stance, i.e., when they agree or disagree with the user. Furthermore, we find that neutral LLMs have a stronger effect in homogeneous groups. Based on our simulation, we generate a set of hypotheses to specify how, why and when AI-related features and social configurations jointly shape collective opinion making.

0.19

Topological collapse of higher-order interactions bottlenecks collective intelligence in AI agent societies

cs.SI ·2026-08-16 ·Shuo Lu, Weicheng Meng, Aijing Yu, Kun Shao, Jian Luan +2 more
code/data similarity 0.57
Abstract

Current paradigms in artificial intelligence concentrate on scaling the capabilities of individual models, yet the collective behaviour of interacting agents is shaped by the topology of their interactions rather than by individual cognition alone. Here we show that the binding constraint on collective behaviour in agent societies is topological. Analysing a macroscopic AI social platform of 1.6 million registered agents (174,458 active in the interaction record), we identify a phenomenon we term topological collapse: extreme hub dominance degrades higher-order group interactions into star-shaped broadcast patterns, suppressing the cohesive structure that discontinuous social contagion requires. We formalise this constraint through a Hyperedge Irreducibility Score (HIS) and an analytical topology amplification factor ($Φ$). Across 22 frontier language models from ten vendors, 1,040 controlled simulations and empirical human networks, the bottleneck proves model-agnostic: under a fixed interaction protocol the topological indicators are invariant across models (cross-model HIS s.d. = 0.000 in the pairwise condition) even as behavioural outcomes diverge widely. These findings reframe the design of artificial societies around the geometry of interaction rather than the optimisation of individual cognition, with implications for AI sociology, algorithmic group dynamics, hybrid human-AI ecosystems and collective alignment. The code is publicly available at https://github.com/Darwin-Agent/topological-collapse-agent-societies.

0.58

Language-model groups overstate consensus when replaying human deliberation on a reasoning task

cs.AI cs.CLcs.CYcs.MA ·2026-09-17 ·Tengfei Shao
code/data similarity 0.56
Abstract · 37 pages, 4 figures. Preregistration: https://osf.io/5jp7s . Code and data: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21318346

Full-consensus rates are often treated as indicators of collective cognition, yet depend on how participation and final states are operationalized. We replayed 100 held-out human Wason groups with matched large language model (LLM) agent groups, seeding one belief-anchored agent per participant's pre-discussion answer and scoring agents and people with the same code. Across human scoring definitions, estimates ranged from 24.0% to 57.0%; about one fifth of participants never posted, whereas agents almost always did. Agent groups remained more consensual in two post-unblinding sensitivity analyses: the submit-based comparison (n = 98) yielded gaps of 34.0 and 43.9 percentage points for chat and reasoning modes, and the participation-matched comparison (n = 45) yielded gaps of 34.1 and 44.4 points. These complementary routes reduced different measurement asymmetries yet converged within 0.5 percentage points. The gap persisted without early stopping and under a reparameterization removing the memorizable answer; reasoning-mode groups then agreed nearly unanimously, mostly on incorrect answers. Simulated consensus did not track collective accuracy, and belief-anchored agent groups were biased estimators of the human group-outcome distribution in this setting. These analyses provide a scoring-explicit basis for assessing simulated-group estimates of human deliberative outcomes.

0.41

AI agents reshape consensus formation in human groups

cs.CL cs.CYcs.SI ·2026-09-02 ·Lin Chen, Ziyi Liu, Xia Hu, Yong Li
similarity 0.56
Abstract

As large language model (LLM) agents shift from tools to participants in human groups, a fundamental question for collective behavior is how their growing presence reshapes consensus formation. Here we study mixed human-AI groups in a collaborative description game, in which shared conventions emerge through repeated rounds of random pairwise communication. Varying the proportions of LLM agents, we identify three distinct regimes of consensus formation: low agent proportions facilitate human-led consensus, intermediate proportions disrupt convergence, and high proportions restore strong consensus while shifting it toward agent-led conventions. Crucially, these regimes differ not only in the strength of convergence, but also in the semantic grounding and communicative form of the resulting consensus: human-led consensus is more concrete, holistic, and grounded in shared real-world analogies, whereas agent-led consensus is more abstract, less information-dense, and more geometrically segmented. Mechanistically, agent influence arises from a shared linguistic prior that places agents near one another in the expression space, combined with relatively stable expression choices across rounds; humans initially resist adopting expressions from partners perceived as AI but gradually yield to conformity pressure. These findings provide evidence that AI composition can shape the emergence, content, and perceived legitimacy of group norms, making agent proportion and transparency important design variables for human-AI systems.

0.19

Drivers of LLM Consensus Formation Under Competing Incentives: A Simulation Study

cs.AI cs.MA ·2026-10-14 ·Isabel Jones, Matthew Edwards, Janina A. Hoffmann
code/data similarity 0.56
Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly deployed in multi-agent environments that produce unanimous agreement, both in intended interactions that need coordination and in unintended emergent interactions. Consequently, understanding how LLMs with competing incentives reach consensus is crucial to better interpret and design LLM collectives. We introduce an evaluation, based on the Network Consensus game, to assess the mechanisms driving this process. Here, a network of agents must agree on one of two colours to receive a payoff, but agents are offered different payoffs for the agreed colour. We vary components such as communication access and network structure and assess six open-source models and one closed model (ChatGPT 5.6-sol). We find that open-source LLMs reach consensus less often than humans in comparable experiments and only if messages are communicated across the global network. ChatGPT 5.6-sol, however, is able to reach consensus with communication limited to its neighbours and with no communication ability. This is achieved through lower stubbornness and higher majority-following tendencies, and by providing more information about its neighbours' states in messages. However, situating agents in a highly clustered graph reduces consensus, regardless of these traits, demonstrating that both system design and individual model traits drive collective outcomes.

0.32