CS Paper Radar

Patch correctness in automated program repair: A five-dimensional evidence framework and cross-benchmark audit from classical repair to coding agents

Shuai Wu, Yanna Feng, Yufang Li, Xue Li, Zhijun Wang, Bolun Liu, Weilin Cai

cs.SE ·submitted 2026-11-07 16:30 UTC · v1
benchmarkcode/data

Abstract

Tests guide automated program repair and determine which candidate patches are reported as successful. Repository-level coding agents extend this feedback loop by generating tests and revising code after observing execution results. This technical report introduces a five-dimensional evidence profile and reporting protocol to audit how test observations support patch-correctness claims across classical repair systems and coding agents. We assemble an audit dataset of 39 benchmark and evaluation artifacts: 32 primary empirical studies, one institutional technical audit, and six prior taxonomic baselines. We code the 33 primary contributions along five dimensions: test provenance and exposure, behavioral scope, oracle basis and dependence, execution integrity, and label adjudication. The central distinction separates checks visible during repair search from evidence reserved for final assessment. Four worked comparative audits show how changed candidate populations, oracle rules, or execution budgets alter reported detection rates. Additional tests can expose missed faults while rejecting valid alternatives or reducing correct-repair yield under a fixed budget. Repository-level audits separate issue reproduction from candidate-patch discrimination and distinguish automated discrepancy detection from requirements-based adjudication. An evidence matrix links each coded decision to supporting passages and records shared benchmark ancestry. We specify a reporting protocol for repair benchmarks and maintenance pipelines that retains uncertain judgments and records validation cost alongside fault detection and valid-patch retention.

Comment
Technical report. 24 pages, 2 figures, 6 tables. Dataset and evidence matrix available at https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23639376

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Experimental Settings in LLM-Based Program Repair: A Study of Inputs, Tool Access, Feedback, and Validation

cs.SE ·2026-09-16 ·Xushu Dai, Yicheng Cai, Nanqing Luo, Pei-Yu Tseng
benchmark similarity 0.76
Abstract · 11 pages, 1 figure, 3 tables

Evaluations of automated program repair (APR) systems commonly report the benchmark, the number of repaired defects, and the tests used for final patch validation, but these items no longer fully specify the repair task presented to a system. Recent LLM-based systems differ in the information supplied before repair, the repository and testing operations permitted during repair, and the feedback returned after unsuccessful attempts, allowing the same benchmark to instantiate substantially different repair tasks ranging from localized patch generation to repository-level diagnosis and iterative repair. We present a framework for explicitly specifying the experimental settings associated with reported APR results. We analyze reported experimental settings from systems evaluated on Defects4J and SWE-bench and characterize each result by its task unit, fault-localization assumptions, initial input, tool access, repair-time feedback, final validation, and resource budget. Our analysis shows that benchmark identity alone is insufficient to reconstruct the evaluated task or determine the appropriate scope of comparison across reported repair rates. We therefore introduce a machine-readable schema for specifying each experimental setting to improve reproducibility and make the scope of cross-system comparisons explicit.

0.19

SWE-Gate: Passing Functional Tests Is Not Enough for Software Engineering Agents

cs.SE cs.AI ·2026-09-03 ·Xin He, Yanlin Wang, Mingwei Liu, Jiachi Chen, Hongyu Zhang +1 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.75
Abstract · 11 pages, 2 figures, 5 tables

Repository-level software engineering benchmarks have significantly advanced the evaluation of coding agents, but existing benchmarks primarily measure whether generated patches pass functional tests and overlook review-derived acceptance constraints (review constraints) that often influence whether a patch is acceptable in real-world software development. We introduce SWE-Gate, a repository-level benchmark for software engineering agents that explicitly evaluates review constraint compliance alongside functional correctness. SWE-Gate derives review constraints from real pull request review comments and synthesizes repository-level repair instances around these constraints. Each instance provides separate functional and constraint tests, together with non-compliant and gold patches, enabling explicit separation between issue resolution capability and review constraint compliance. We construct SWE-Gate with 303 repository-level repair instances spanning 75 open-source Python repositories across diverse software domains. Experiments with four LLM backends spanning different capability levels under a common coding-agent scaffold reveal a substantial gap between functional success and success under the complete repair specification: among 644 repairs that pass the functional tests, 221 fail to satisfy the provided review constraints. These findings show that functional-only evaluation overestimates agents' ability to satisfy the full requirements of repository-level repair tasks. The replication package including code, data, and experimental results is available at https://github.com/DeepSoftwareAnalytics/SWE-Gate.

0.50

From Software History to Executable Regression Tasks: A System for Evaluating Software Agents

cs.SE ·2026-10-18 ·Ruikai Shi, Zhengran Zeng, Rui Xie, Shikun Zhang, Wei Ye
similarity 0.75
Abstract · 22 pages

As software agents increasingly generate and modify code, evaluating their ability to review changes and discover defects becomes important. Such evaluation needs executable project environments for investigation and reliable defect references supported by reproducible behavior. Existing code review benchmarks provide limited support for this combination. We present a system that constructs executable regression instances from historical introducing--fixing commit pairs and developer tests. The system extracts candidate tests from fixing-side changes, then uses constrained agents to transplant them and configure version-specific environments while preserving production code and test expectations. Independent replay and evidence-based review verify whether tests that fail on the introducing version and pass on the fixing version support the proposed regression relationship. Accepted instances retain both versions' replay recipes, validated tests, and execution evidence. Repair-supported analysis and human review add root-cause locations, tested repairs, and causal explanations. These instances support bug detection and localization in code review, and enable bug repair and regression-test generation on the same defects. The system constructs 172 validated instances from 522 candidates across 11 Python projects. We evaluate three software agents with ten models and additional reasoning-effort settings on 83 manually selected, enriched instances across the three tasks. Precise root-line localization remains challenging, while baseline combinations achieve repair and regression-test generation success rates of up to 68.7% and 77.1%, respectively. Leading configurations differ by task, and higher task performance does not necessarily yield greater API-cost efficiency. Our approach provides reusable executable evidence for studying agents' defect discovery, repair, and testing capabilities.

0.17

PonyEval: Evaluating LLM-Based Program Repair for Capability-Safe and Actor-Oriented Pony Software

cs.SE ·2026-08-20 ·Bang Xie, Hao Liu, Zhenyu Shi, Zhiyuan Peng, Xin Yin +6 more
benchmark similarity 0.74
Abstract · 9 pages, 1 figure, 5 tables

Repository-level issue-resolution benchmarks have made executable evaluation central to software-engineering agents, but their language coverage remains concentrated in mainstream ecosystems. Pony presents a different regime: it combines actors, reference capabilities, ahead-of-time compilation, and a rapidly evolving historical toolchain, making both patch generation and faithful replay difficult. We introduce PonyEval, a SWE-bench-style benchmark of 291 real GitHub issue-pull-request pairs from 15 Pony repositories. Every instance binds an issue statement, a historical base commit, a developer gold patch, a black-box test patch, and a reproducible runtime mapping. The frozen release passes an offline audit requiring the issue-specific test to fail on the base state and pass after the gold patch; it contains no duplicate instance identifiers or canonical repository-PR pairs. In a separate full-set semantic selection audit, three isolated machine reviewers label all 291 instances as include or exclude; their Fleiss' kappa is 0.8968, with 249 unanimous inclusions and 32 unanimous exclusions. To replay eleven years of repository history, we reconstruct 72 runtime images covering 289 unique base commits and verify their availability on five heterogeneous compute nodes. We define a matched evaluation with mini-SWE-agent 2.4.6 for GPT-5.6-sol, DeepSeek-V4-Pro, GLM-5.2, MiniMax-M3, and Kimi-K3, followed by strict patch application, compilation, and hidden-test validation. Across the patches actually produced by each model, conditional resolution rates range from 10.21% to 24.68%. These rates characterize the quality of generated patches rather than success over all 291 benchmark tasks.

0.23

Externalizing Requirement-to-Repair Artifacts as Observable Traces for LLM-Based Program Repair

cs.AI cs.SE ·2026-09-14 ·Zewen Tao, Shin-nosuke Ishikawa
code/data similarity 0.74
Abstract · Accepted at REALM Workshop, EMNLP 2026. Code: https://github.com/ForeverMJ/THEMIS

Repository-level repair requires not only correct patches but also inspectable records that explain how issue requirements are translated into code changes and post-edit evidence. We contribute THEMIS, a stage-aware repair workflow that externalizes this requirement-to-repair process through semantic interpretation, a runtime requirement-code graph, graph-derived Developer guidance, retained repair rationale and patches, and post-edit audit records. A retrospective audit of 300 SWE-bench Lite cases demonstrates that these artifacts provide broad support for cross-stage inspection: a complete Developer rationale is available for 288 cases, and 214 cases (71.3%) retain a complete audited field set connecting the selected stages. The retained records further enable systematic measurement of cross-stage correspondence: target symbols recur in 62.6% of Developer rationales and in 62.8% of patches, rising to 75.8% when related symbols are included. In a paired 100-case comparison, the relational workflow resolves 19 cases versus 9 for the direct same-input condition; because the two conditions also differ in Analyzer output, graph-derived distillation, and Judge records, we report this as preliminary, workflow-level evidence rather than a causal effect of the graph component. Together, these results show that THEMIS makes otherwise implicit requirement-to-repair transitions inspectable, enabling systematic examination of how repair decisions persist, align, and evolve across stages.

0.36

Finding the Pivots to Repair Broken Source-Test Evolution Using LLMs

cs.SE ·2026-11-02 ·Xiao Chen, Songqiang Chen, Jialun Cao, Yun Peng, Chun Yong Chong +1 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.71
Abstract

Repairing obsolete tests in response to source code evolution is critical for test suite reliability and software quality assurance. While large language models (LLMs) have emerged as promising tools for automating many software development tasks, the effective supply of context and the orchestration of repair pipelines in this source--test co-evolution scenario remain poorly understood. Moreover, although reasoning is found helpful for LLMs on some complex coding tasks, it remains unclear which reasoning steps actually contribute to effective test repairs and how the insights learned from LLMs' behaviors benefit coding agents. In this paper, we present a systematic empirical study of test repair for source-test co-evolution empowered by LLMs, investigating the effective setups and typical LLM behaviors. To support this study, we construct a new benchmark of 500 real-world source-test co-evolution cases from commits submitted between May 2024 and April 2026 across 15 highly-starred open-source Java projects. Our experimental results reveal several key insights for effective LLM-based test repair: the complementary benefits of combining test failure symptoms, source code changes, and supportive code context, as well as the effectiveness of self-repair rounds. We further derive a common reasoning action taxonomy from LLMs' reasoning traces, which proves instrumental in guiding LLMs to repair tests more effectively while at a lower financial cost. Applying our findings to the Codex agent further improves its repair success rate on challenging cases by 66.7%.

0.27

Groundability, Not Scale Alone: When Weak Reviewers Can Audit Strong Coding Agents

cs.SE cs.AIcs.CL ·2026-10-01 ·Junyu Guo, Shangding Gu, Ming Jin, Javad Lavaei
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Coding agents can return plausible patches that omit required behavior. These failures are hard to review because long traces and confident summaries often hide what was missed. We ask when a nominally weaker reviewer can reliably decide whether a patch solves its issue. We study 411 execution-labeled traces from three agents and 101 controlled cases. On 154 GPT-5.4 traces, structured but unchecked evidence raises both defect catch and over-rejection. We then provide official execution evidence as an upper-bound diagnostic. After choosing and freezing one of two formats per reviewer, five of six reviewers improve both rates on 122 held-out traces; two classify every trace correctly. Reviewer size is not a consistent predictor of quality. Because official tests are unavailable in deployment, we also evaluate a frozen cascade with patch-caused static errors and generated tests that first fail on the unpatched repository. On 121 scored held-out GPT-5.4 traces and 59 Gemini traces, its coverage is 0.89 and 0.86, risk is 0.33 and 0.26, catch is 0.76 and 0.80, and over-rejection is 0.66 and 0.67. Most false rejections occur when unresolved cases reach the reviewer. Official execution evidence shows the potential of weak review when decisive checks are available. Producing equally reliable checks without official tests remains the main bottleneck.

0.45

Make Every Expansion Count: Learning to Search Efficiently in LLM Code Repair

cs.LG cs.AIcs.SE ·2026-10-11 ·Elad Sharony, Ido Greenberg, Jialin Song, Shie Mannor, Gal Chechik +1 more
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Large language model (LLM) code-repair systems fix faulty programs by repeatedly generating and testing revisions. Each revision is costly, making the choice of which repair to pursue important for efficiency. Existing search policies rely on test pass rates and search statistics, ignoring the details of test failures and proposed edits. We introduce CodeTriage, a learned policy that prioritizes edits before their revised programs are generated and tested. Its 0.6B-parameter model reads the test output, failure diagnosis, and proposed edit, then predicts a distribution over the number of repair steps needed to reach a fix through that edit. These predictions prioritize all pending edits across programs before generating and testing the revised code. On held-out repair tasks, CodeTriage finds fixes with 21% fewer program revisions and 12% fewer output tokens than the strongest baseline on each metric. Without retraining, it achieves the highest average success across search budgets for each of 11 unseen repair LLMs. Ablations show that both the failure context and edit text, as well as comparisons across programs, improve search. We also release a corpus of 12.2 million program versions from four LLMs, organized into repair trees with proposed edits and test results.

0.19