CS Paper Radar

Keel: A Verified In-Kernel Proof Checker for Proof Carrying BPF

Yalu Cai, Tung-Che Chang, Santosh Nagarakatte

cs.PL ·submitted 2026-11-08 04:03 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

Recent systems such as the eBPF Certificate Framework (BCF) and Proof-Carrying BPF address the imprecision in the Linux eBPF verifier with proof-carrying code. When the verifier's abstract domains cannot prove a safety condition, an in-kernel proof checker checks an untrusted user-space refutation proof. A single bug in this checker can compromise the security of the entire kernel. While formalizing BCF's in-kernel checker, we discovered 13 bugs such as unsound rewrite rules, silently unchecked proof steps, and memory safety errors. We demonstrate that forged certificates can trick the kernel to accept arbitrary unsafe eBPF programs. To address this problem, we propose Keel, a formally verified in-kernel proof checker for the Linux eBPF verifier. First, we specify the checker as a pure functional program in Lean and prove its soundness against bit-vector semantics. We decouple the steps of the proof certificate checker from the mathematical rewrite rules, which enables us to extend the rewrite rules without the need to change the checker. Second, we implement the checker in EmbC, a deeply embedded C fragment, and prove that our C implementation refines the functional specification without undefined behavior or memory leaks. Third, using an amortized potential argument, we prove linear time and memory bounds for the C checker. Keel is correct-by-construction while also being faster than the BCF checker inside the kernel, 1.3X in total and 2.0X on the slowest 1.4% of certificates.

Comment
66 pages

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Verifying deployed bytecode against executable EVM semantics, with exact gas and no added axioms

cs.PL cs.LO ·2026-10-14 ·Seulkee Baek
theory similarity 0.72
Abstract · 37 pages, 5 tables, 4 figures. Verification package: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23351349

Much of Ethereum's most consequential code is immutable bytecode: old output of unverified compilers, and protocol logic run as contract code. We show that such bytecode can be verified as it is, without trusting what produced it, without simplifying the machine it runs on, and with no axioms beyond Lean's own. Blanc, a Lean 4 verification stack, reads fixed runtime bytes via kernel-checked certificates and states every theorem against Jaune, an executable semantics of the EVM and block processing that passes all 34,205 blockchain-test cases of Ethereum's fixture release v20.0.2 that involve only forks that have governed mainnet since May 2025. Eight artifacts, deployed from 2017 to 2026, come from seven compiler versions and an assembler. For the EIP-7002 contract, we prove that the end-of-block call to it, whose failure would invalidate the block, succeeds whatever its storage holds, and that each block's withdrawal requests are exactly the oldest pending submissions; mainnet met these theorems' starting premises when Prague began. For a Uniswap V2 pair, we prove that after any valid history whose hashed slots stay apart, from any checkpoint representing its Solidity model's state, the storage represents that model replayed over exactly the committed calls, a balanced liquidity ledger stays balanced, and, under a premise on token answers, geometric-mean reserves per share fall only through the protocol fee. Exact gas makes liveness provable: a tracked WETH9 holder without code can withdraw by a transaction whose gas has a closed form, matching all 3,748 comparable mainnet receipts of its shape in 30,000 blocks. On Curve pool bytes compiled with the lock bug exploited in 2023, Jaune executes such a reentrancy from deployment; for bytes from a fixed compiler, we prove the lock excludes it. AI agents wrote the proofs in fifteen days under one author's direction, atop an existing stack.

0.21

Enforcement of In-Kernel Stateful Security Policies via eBPF

cs.CR cs.PL ·2026-09-12 ·Letterio Galletta
top venue similarity 0.69
Abstract · This is the extended version of the paper appearing in Proc. ACM SIGSAC Conference on Computer and Communications Security (CCS '26). It inc…

Many attacks against workloads running on multi-tenant systems are multi-step and history-dependent: sequences of innocuous operations whose malicious nature emerges only over an execution trace. Defending against them requires security policies that are stateful, are enforced within the kernel, and have a precise semantics. Currently deployed proposals fail on at least one count: kernel's built-in syscall filtering and classical MAC frameworks are stateless, while current eBPF-based tools express their policies through ad hoc YAML rules that cannot capture temporal relations among events, and whose semantics is defined only by the implementation. We present BPFence, an in-kernel runtime-verification framework that satisfies the properties above. BPFence provides a policy language with a formal semantics that can express temporal relations among events. It also provides a type system that statically distinguishes events the kernel can control from those it can only observe. Every well-typed policy is compiled into a finite-state monitor proved correct with respect to its semantics, and then into eBPF programs that run inside the kernel. We evaluate BPFence on seven case studies drawn from real-world attack patterns, and on a set of micro- and macro-benchmarks to show that the enforcement overhead remains compatible with production deployment.

0.33

Blame-aware Recomposition for Secure Compilation Proofs of Low-Level Compartment Isolation

cs.PL cs.CR ·2026-10-19 ·Basile Schlosser, Jérémy Thibault, Catalin Hritcu
similarity 0.68
Abstract

The security guarantees of existing formally verified compilers for compartmentalized programs in unsafe languages like C stop at a rather high level, assuming a built-in protection mechanism and a block-based memory model. Verifying a concrete, low-level enforcement mechanism for compartment isolation is still a major challenge for current proof techniques. In particular, Abate et al.'s proof technique fails because one of their proof steps, recomposition, essentially requires hiding all information about the code of each compartment, which is not practically achievable at a low level. We propose an extension of their proof technique to a low-level setting where compartments can fully observe each other's code. To do so, we introduce an overlay semantics that allows us to characterize these observations as a form of undefined behaviour, and we use a novel variant of recomposition that we call blame-aware recomposition, which essentially allows recomposing executions as needed in the original high-level proof technique, even if the low-level context observes the code, because this context is ultimately going to be discarded. We apply this new proof to a compartment isolation mechanism that uses a programmable tag-based reference monitor.

0.26

Automatically Building Machine-Checked Assurance Cases from C Codebases to Requirements

cs.PL cs.SE ·2026-09-30 ·Haokun Li, Zhongyi Wang, Guanyan Li, Xiao Yi, Shengchao Qin +2 more
benchmarktheory similarity 0.66
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) have shown promise in automating interactive theorem proving, yet verification of real-world C codebases requires more than discharging individual proof goals. The task involves jointly constructing expressive function specifications and their proofs, and ensuring that library interfaces compose along intended call sequences even without a designated client. This paper presents CCV, an LLM-assisted framework for building machine-checked assurance cases: structured, auditable artifacts supporting the claim that a C codebase meets its intended requirements. To model intended cross-interface use in open libraries, CCV constructs an interface protocol that exposes permitted call sequences and resource assumptions for review, with a conditional safety guarantee under verified contracts and caller obligations. CCV coordinates two complementary phases: (i) requirement-guided analysis and bottom-up construction of candidate specifications and protocols; and (ii) modular proof construction with feedback that revises the specifications and proofs. Implemented using VST in Rocq, CCV verifies memory safety and leak freedom for all 299 function definitions across six C benchmarks, including industrial cryptographic components, with less than one person-day of reported human effort per benchmark. The guarantees depend on disclosed contracts and assumptions; human review supplies the conformance judgments connecting the formal artifacts to the intended requirements.

0.09

Attestable Audit: Property-Based Attestation for Proprietary Workloads without Artifact Disclosure

cs.CR ·2026-10-03 ·Takuma Imamura
published similarity 0.66
Abstract · Accepted at the International Workshop on Hardware and Architectural Support for Security and Privacy 2026 (HASP 2026), held in conjunction …

Trusted Execution Environments (TEEs) prove the integrity of code and data to a remote peer through remote attestation: the TEE issues an attestation report by signing, with a hardware-bound key, its configuration information, including measurements (cryptographic digests) of the code loaded inside it. A verifier appraises the report by matching these measurements against reference values. When the measured artifact is proprietary, however, the verifier cannot derive the reference values itself: it can only confirm that something with a given measurement is running inside the TEE---not that the program behaves as expected---forcing full trust in the reference value provider. We propose an architecture that closes this gap without disclosing the artifact, composing two TEE workloads: attestable build (Hugenroth et al., 2025), which binds a source code digest to a build artifact measurement, and attestable audit (proposed in this paper), which binds the same source code digest to the verdicts of automated audits---fuzzing, static analysis, AI code auditing, formal methods---executed inside a TEE. Both are instances of Confidential Computing Proofs: TEE attestation viewed as a hardware-backed zero-knowledge proof. Chaining the two certificates lets the verifier conclude that the running artifact was built from source code satisfying the audited properties, without disclosing either the source code or the build artifact. A proof-of-concept implementation on Intel SGX with the Gramine Library OS, running the Bandit security analyzer on Python code, demonstrates the practicality of the approach.

0.26

How Stable Are LLM-Generated Proofs Under Program Refactoring? A Stress Test for Verifiable Code Generation

cs.AI cs.LOcs.SE ·2026-10-26 ·Aravind Mandiga, Guoming Li
published similarity 0.65
Abstract · Accepted at the NeurIPS 2026 Workshop on AI for Verifiable Coding

Benchmarks for verifiable code generation usually test a proof against one fixed implementation. We ask whether the same proof remains valid after a program refactoring that preserves behavior. We introduce RefactorProof, which derives 458 Lean-certified variants from the 185 VERINA tasks that compile in our pinned environment while holding the specification and evaluated proof fixed byte-for-byte. VERINA supplies reference proofs for 46 tasks, all from its basic split; the primary model-versus-reference comparisons further match on 21-25 short, non-recursive tasks. Structural refactorings expose substantial brittleness across proof sources: task-normalized structural PSR is 4.3% for the supplied references and 13.3-26.8% for the specialized provers. On the matched tasks, specialized prover proofs nevertheless have higher overall unchanged-proof survival than the supplied reference artifacts: +15.6 points for DeepSeek-Prover-V2-7B, +18.8 for Goedel-Prover-V2-32B, and +20.3 for Goedel-Prover-V2-8B; all three 95% CIs exclude zero. The ordering persists after excluding universally survived T1 variants, under family-balanced aggregation, and under alternative deployable valid-proof selection rules. However, unchanged-proof failure is not the same as high repair cost: predefined one-identifier edits repair 51/54 eligible reference structural failures and 58/85 eligible prover failures. RefactorProof therefore measures unchanged-proof stability under program refactoring, not the cost of maintaining a proof after it breaks.

0.30

Scaling Verification of Cryptographic Software with Aeneas, Rust, and Lean

cs.CR ·2026-09-14 ·Son Ho, Cédric Fournet, Jonathan Protzenko, Michael Naehrig, Joshua Clune +5 more
hot direction similarity 0.65
Abstract

We develop a new methodology for verifying cryptographic software. We target production code written in Rust for performance and system integration, rather than verification convenience. Rust's ownership discipline enables Aeneas to extract a pure model of this code in Lean, relieving us from low-level reasoning about pointer liveness and aliasing. Lean's extensibility lets us develop tactics and libraries that greatly simplify reasoning about extracted Rust code. We design and tune our toolchain to facilitate the use of AI. Agents autonomously write formal proofs, which are independently verified by the Lean kernel. Agents also assist in the formalization of cryptographic standards and platform-specific intrinsics, which still requires expert design and review. We apply our methodology to SymCrypt, Microsoft's cryptographic provider. We verify its implementations of algorithms such as SHA-3 and ML-KEM, which were ported from C to Rust. We also extend SymCrypt with experimental optimizations and implementations of algorithms such as FrodoKEM, ML-DSA, and HPKE to explore the scalability of writing, adapting, and verifying cryptographic code. Our 237~KLOC Lean development establishes safety, panic-freedom, and functional correctness of 16.7~KLOC of Rust code supporting post-quantum cipher suites for x86-64 and ARM platforms. Our evaluation shows that verified Rust can meet SymCrypt's performance, portability, deployment, and maintainability requirements.

0.28

Access Control as Verified Parse Constraints

cs.CR ·2026-09-11 ·Saranachon Iammongkol, Zhiyi Huang, David Eyers
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 12 pages, 2 figures

Commercial security gateways repeatedly ship implementation bugs in the code path between the network and the policy decision: hand-written enforcement logic that diverges from the policy author's intent, and ad-hoc request parsers at the network boundary that introduce memory-safety flaws of their own. In both cases the bug is in the deployed enforcement code, not in the policy. Existing approaches either leave the enforcement runtime unverified or connect a formal model to a hand-written engine only by differential testing. Our contribution is a class result: a forward-only, backtrack-free EverParse validator is a verified recognizer for a bounded, finite-state class, and access-control decision functions with fixed-offset fields and bounded disjunction belong to it, so one machine-checked proof transfers to every policy in the class rather than being re-established per policy. Concretely, we encode a bounded policy language's decision function into a fixed-size byte buffer and verify the enforcement code once---covering all byte values---with an SMT solver, proving the validator accepts if and only if the decision function accepts, for every policy, request, and session. Editing rule content over a fixed endpoint set then needs no new proof; adding endpoints reruns the toolchain; extending the language needs new proofs. We establish faithful enforcement of a policy, not that a policy is itself secure. The verified gate is platform-independent, requiring only EverParse/Z3 and a C compiler, whose correctness we assume. We demonstrate a deployment on the seL4 microkernel, which ensures every request passes through the gate and that unverified components cannot corrupt the verified enforcement chain.

0.30