CS Paper Radar

Homological Barriers to Stable Learning of First-Order Nash Equilibria

Ashkan Soleymani, Gabriele Farina, Patrick Jaillet, Georgios Piliouras

cs.GT cs.LG ·submitted 2026-11-08 23:28 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

We identify a homological barrier to stable learning of local Nash equilibria, also known as first-order Nash equilibria (FONE), in constrained non-concave differentiable games. We consider continuous deterministic learning dynamics that fix every FONE point and aim to attract all initial conditions to the full FONE set. We show that this convergence guarantee is impossible when the target set has nontrivial positive-degree cohomology, such as that arising from a loop, and the state space is compact and contractible. We exhibit this barrier in a simple non-concave quadratic zero-sum game on a box whose exact FONE set consists of a diagonal six-edge loop and an isolated point. Consequently, no such dynamics can make the full FONE set a stable global attractor. We further show that degree two is the minimal polynomial degree at which this barrier can arise and extend the construction to obtain nontrivial homology in arbitrarily high degrees. Finally, we establish that the barrier persists for sufficiently small approximate-FONE targets under small perturbations, yielding an open, positive-volume family of quadratic zero-sum games with the same homological barrier.

Comment
The Fortieth Annual Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS) 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Planning Against Learning in Rank-1 Games

cs.GT ·2026-08-18 ·William Overman
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Learning algorithms are often used to make decisions in repeated multi-agent environments. When another player understands how a learner adapts from past experience, that player can plan strategically across rounds to influence the learner's future behavior. Recent work shows that optimizing against Replicator Dynamics, the continuous-time analogue of Multiplicative Weights Update, is tractable in zero-sum games but can be hard in unrestricted general-sum games. We study the first structured class beyond zero sum: bimatrix games satisfying $\text{rank}(A+B)=1$, for which Nash equilibria can be computed in polynomial time. Our main result shows that this equilibrium tractability does not extend to planning against learning dynamics. Unless $\mathsf{P}=\mathsf{NP}$, approximating the optimizer's optimal continuous-time reward within a fixed additive constant is NP-hard even when $\text{rank}(A+B)=1$, the learner starts from the uniform state, and the optimizer is restricted to constant strategies. The hardness persists for bounded payoff matrices and polynomially bounded horizons. We complement this result with structural characterizations of several tractable special cases. Thus rank-one games already separate efficient equilibrium computation from strategic planning against a learning opponent.

0.06

Metric-Based Equilibrium Selection in Noncooperative Differentiable Games

cs.GT eess.SY ·2026-10-05 ·Karan Mahesh, Runyu Zhang, Michael R. Benjamin, Gioele Zardini
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 8 pages, 2 figures

Metric conditioning can change which equilibrium attracts learning dynamics without moving the equilibria of a differentiable game. We study how to use state-dependent symmetric positive-definite (SPD) metrics to select among known equilibria by keeping a designated equilibrium attracting while making a rival unstable. Building on classical results on matrix stability under positive-definite multiplication, we characterize when such destabilization is possible and show how restricting the metric to act independently on each player limits the stability changes that can be achieved at differential Nash equilibria. We then combine a stabilizing metric at the selected equilibrium with a destabilizing metric at the rival through smooth interpolation, yielding a single metric field that preserves every equilibrium of the game while assigning the desired local stability types. We also derive a step-size condition for implementing the method in discrete time. The approach is validated on a continuous-commitment stag hunt and an entropy-regularized iterated prisoner's dilemma, where it selects the desired equilibrium in both settings.

0.28

Polynomial-Time Computation of Extensive-Form Proper Equilibria in Two-Player Zero-Sum Games

cs.GT cs.AIcs.MAecon.TH ·2026-11-04 ·Sam Ganzfried
similarity 0.62
Abstract

We give a deterministic polynomial-time algorithm for computing an exact extensive-form proper equilibrium in a finite two-player zero-sum extensive-form game with perfect recall and rational data. Properness is understood in the agent normal form: an action at an information set is penalized relative to a better action while all other local behavioral choices, including the player's own future actions, remain fixed. Our algorithm assigns each information set a geometric permutahedron of allowable action probabilities. A scaled doubly stochastic representation embeds these restrictions in a polynomial-size sequence-form polytope; a saddle point then satisfies the local $\varepsilon$-properness inequalities. To obtain an exact equilibrium rather than a solution at an arbitrarily small numerical perturbation, we establish sign stability of a parametric linear system, construct a persistent feasible basis, and extract the limits of behavioral ratios. The resulting probabilities are rational and have polynomial encoding length, including at information sets whose realization probabilities vanish.

0.25

Stabilization Limits of Payoff-Based Higher-Order Replicator Dynamics

eess.SY ·2026-08-15 ·Hassan Abdelraouf, Vijay Gupta, Jeff S. Shamma
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Replicator dynamics (RD) is a fundamental model in learning in games, connecting evolutionary game theory and online learning. This paper studies payoff-based higher-order variants of RD represented as a cascade interconnection between an integrator in parallel with an auxiliary linear time-invariant (LTI) system and the softmax mapping. We investigate learnability of Nash equilibria under this Nash-stationary learning rule. First, we revisit recent results that establish convergence to Nash Equilibrium whenever the auxiliary LTI system is strictly passive and prove a converse passivity result: if the auxiliary LTI system is not passive, then there exists a static strictly contractive game whose interior Nash equilibrium is unstable under the closed-loop learning dynamics. Second, we show that there exists a class of games with isolated interior Nash equilibria that cannot be locally asymptotically stabilized by any payoff-based higher-order RD whose auxiliary LTI system is asymptotically stable and strictly proper. Finally, we show that if Nash stationarity (i.e., all Nash equilibria are stationary points of the learning dynamics) is relaxed, then generalized exponential RD (Ex-RD) can locally asymptotically stabilize a logit equilibrium for any continuously differentiable game. The stabilized equilibrium can be viewed as an entropy-regularized approximate Nash equilibrium.

0.04

Optimistic Hedge in General-Sum Games: Fundamental Limits and Regret Bounds via Temporal Approximation

cs.LG cs.GT ·2026-11-04 ·Yuval Dagan, Nadav Eisen, Liad Erez, Tomer Koren
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract

Optimistic Hedge, a multiplicative weight update with one step of extrapolation, is one of the most natural regret-minimizing dynamics for games, and characterizing its regret has been a longstanding open question. Daskalakis, Fishelson and Golowich proved that if all $m$ players in a finite general-sum game follow Optimistic Hedge with a fixed learning rate, each player's regret is polylogarithmic in the horizon $T$. Subsequently, Ha showed that an appropriate choice of learning rate makes each player's regret bounded independently of $T$. This bound, however, is non-constructive and its dependence on the number of actions $n$ is not explicit, leaving open whether Optimistic Hedge can achieve a constant regret bound which is polynomial in the size of the game. We show that the answer hinges on the number of players. In two-player games, there is a learning rate for which Optimistic Hedge guarantees $O(n\log n)$ regret independent of the horizon. In three-player games, however, no such bound is possible: for any learning rate up to an absolute constant and for sufficiently large horizon $T$, there is a game with $n$ actions per player in which some player's regret is $2^{Ω(n)}$, and more generally, for every $m\ge3$ we construct $m$-player games in which some player's regret is $2^{Ω(mn)}$; for learning rates above $2^{-Ω(mn)}$, that player's regret even grows linearly in $T$. Our upper bound is based on a temporal approximation framework for the analysis of Optimistic Hedge. Starting from the variance-based RVU bound of Daskalakis et al., we approximate the losses over time-localized windows by well-behaved functions, whose total variation is a small fraction of their cumulative variance. In $m$-player games, the same framework gives a significantly simplified proof of the recent $O(\sqrt{m}\log n\log T)$ regret bound due to Ha.

0.16

From Scalar Games to Unconstrained Network Zero-Sum Games: Transfer Principles for Gradient-Based Learning

cs.GT ·2026-10-30 ·Gaoqi Xue, James P. Bailey
similarity 0.59
Abstract

We show that, for a broad class of gradient-based learning rules, scalar zero-sum games form a complete test family for convergence in unconstrained network zero-sum games. Specifically, suppose a learning rule achieves last-iterate or time-average convergence on every scalar game of magnitude $a$ whenever $η\leq f(a)$, where $f$ is nonincreasing. Then the same guarantee holds on an arbitrary network zero-sum game with stacked game operator $\mathbf{G}$ whenever $η\leq f(\lVert\mathbf{G}\rVert_2)$. More generally, finite-time rate guarantees transfer mode by mode: the network response is bounded by the largest response of its scalar canonical games, and under compatible linear initialization conventions the worst-case finite-time network response is exactly the largest scalar canonical rate. Thus, understanding the learning dynamics on scalar games is sufficient to characterize universal convergence and worst-case rates over the corresponding class of network games. The result follows from the classical planar decomposition of real skew-symmetric game operators. Related mode-wise reasoning has appeared implicitly in spectral analyses of particular learning algorithms and in prior work using these decompositions for game representation and visualization; here we isolate the resulting transfer principle for gradient-based learning. We discuss implications for simplifying convergence analysis, time-average guarantees, low-dimensional geometric arguments, accelerated-method design, and worst-case numerical testing.

0.18

Fixed Sets and the Hardness of Computing Correlated Equilibria

cs.GT cs.CCcs.DScs.LG ·2026-10-20 ·Ioannis Anagnostides, Constantinos Daskalakis, Gabriele Farina, Noah Golowich, Tuomas Sandholm +1 more
similarity 0.57
Abstract · V2 adjusted cross-reference labels; no changes to the technical content

We show that computing an approximate correlated equilibrium of a polytope game is PPAD-complete, and thus polynomial-time equivalent to finding a Nash equilibrium. This challenges the conventional view in game theory that correlated equilibria are more tractable objects than Nash equilibria. From a conceptual standpoint, we connect correlated equilibria to a natural generalization of fixed points, which we call fixed sets. A fixed set of a continuous function $f$ is a nonempty finite set $S$ such that $S \subseteq \operatorname{conv} f(S)$. Our main technical contribution is to prove that computing a fixed set is PPAD-hard even at inverse polynomial precision.

0.14

Equilibrium Numbers in Non-Square Bimatrix Games

cs.GT math.CO ·2026-09-21 ·Constantin Ickstadt, Thorsten Theobald, Bernhard von Stengel
theory similarity 0.57
Abstract · 32 pages

Bimatrix games may have an exponential number of mixed Nash equilibria if both dimensions of the game are allowed to grow. Bounds on their maximal number give structural insights that have been used to construct hard-to-solve games. We show new sharp or asymptotically sharp bounds on the (polynomial) number of equilibria for generic games where one dimension of the game is fixed and the number of strategies of the other player grows. These results go beyond the hitherto studied square games. Our methods employ combinatorial properties of polytopes, and recent obstructions that relate to the graph of those polytopes. For $n\ge5$, we construct $3\times n$ games that have all $2n+1$ vertices of the best-response polytope as equilibrium strategies, proved using a simple case of the 4-color theorem for planar graphs. Generic $4\times 5$ games are shown to have at most 17 equilibria, using computer calculations with existing datasets for all combinatorial types of the relevant polytopes. For $d\times n$ games, we construct games where all but a fraction of $O(1/n)$ of the maximum number of vertices are equilibrium strategies.

0.29