CS Paper Radar

Perceived Agency During Agent-Avatar Control Transitions in Virtual Reality

Jingyi Zhang, Ruijun Sun, Klara Brandstatter, Nels Numan, Anthony Steed

cs.HC cs.AI ·submitted 2026-11-09 15:03 UTC · v2

Abstract

Prior beliefs about whether a virtual human (VH) is controlled by a human or a computer can shape how users interpret and respond to its behaviour. As emerging hybrid VH systems allow control to transfer between human operators and computer programs during an ongoing interaction, it remains unclear whether perceived agency updates with the actual controller or continues to reflect users' prior beliefs and first impressions. We investigated this question in a within-subject VR study with 24 participants across four conditions: always computer-controlled, computer-to-human, human-to-computer, and always human-controlled. We designed an interaction task in which participants acted as interviewers, asking the VHs a fixed set of questions. Before each interaction, participants were informed whether the VH was human- or computer-controlled, matching the actual controller at the beginning, but were unaware of possible control transitions. We found that perceived agency was strongly influenced by the controller presented at the beginning of the interaction, with no evidence of updating following the control transitions. Social evaluations including likeability and co-presence were generally higher in conditions where human control occurred later and covered a greater proportion of the interaction. The results suggest that prior beliefs and first impressions continued to shape perceived agency, whereas social evaluations were more sensitive to the VH's actual behaviour over the interaction.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Wait for It: A Component-Level Analysis of Latency Feedback Mechanisms for LLM Agents in VR

cs.HC ·2026-10-16 ·Pratham Arora, Abhinav Lodha, Siddharth Siddharth
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Delays in AI responses pose a significant challenge to immersive Virtual Reality experiences. While previous research demonstrates that feedback can reduce the perception of waiting, we lack understanding of which types work best and why. We conducted a within-subjects study with 18 participants to systematically compare three isolated feedback approaches during VR agent interactions: verbal fillers (e.g., um..., hmm...), visual indicators (loading spinners), and embodied gestures (thinking animations). Our results revealed that embodied gestures significantly outperformed visual loading indicators across multiple dimensions, making agents feel more lifelike and socially present. Interestingly, explicit visual feedback like loading spinners actually degraded perceived humanness and broke immersion by forcing users to shift from social to technical mental models. These findings suggest that natural, behavior-based feedback maintains the illusion of conversing with a thinking entity, while technical indicators expose the computational substrate. We present empirically-grounded design guidelines for creating more engaging AI-powered VR agents.

0.08

Can People Distinguish Human and AI Agency in Humanoid Teleoperation? A Preliminary Study of Agency Perception

cs.HC cs.RO ·2026-09-06 ·Xiang Li, Koya Dendo, Keigo Minamida, Yuto Nakamura, Per Ola Kristensson +1 more
published similarity 0.66
Abstract · 3 pages, accepted by ACM UIST 2026 as a poster

Can people distinguish between human and AI agency in humanoid teleoperation? To explore this question, we developed \textit{Ghost-in-the-Loop}, a teleoperation framework that supports both human-operated and AI-generated control of a robot's voice, facial expressions, and gestures while maintaining a consistent embodiment. We conducted a preliminary online study ($N=50$) in which participants viewed short interaction clips generated by either a Human Operator or an AI Control and judged the perceived source of control. Results suggest that participants often struggled to distinguish between the two conditions in brief interactions. Qualitative responses indicate that judgments were primarily influenced by perceived naturalness, temporal coordination, and consistency across speech, facial expression, and gesture. These findings provide initial insights into agency perception in embodied human--AI communication and motivate future investigations of blended human--AI telepresence systems.

0.27

Listening and Mirroring: The Effects of Verbal Attunement and Behavioral Mimicry on Social and Empathic Perceptions of Embodied AI Agents in VR

cs.HC cs.AI ·2026-09-23 ·Nathalia Gomez, Haig Shamlian, Omar Khan, Tiffany D. Do
published similarity 0.66
Abstract · 11 pages. Accepted to ACM VRST 2026

As embodied agents take on increasingly social and relational roles in VR, visual realism and embodiment alone may be insufficient; users must also perceive these agents as emotionally attuned, supportive, and humanlike. Prior work suggests that verbal attunement and nonverbal mimicry can each improve users' social evaluations of embodied agents. However, behavioral mimicry has largely been studied outside of real-time, conversational AI interactions, leaving limited understanding of how users respond when an agent simultaneously generates contextually responsive dialogue and adapts its nonverbal behavior during an immersive conversation. To address this gap, we developed an embodied AI counselor that combines conversational AI with real-time facial-expression and posture mimicry, while producing either verbally attuned or neutral responses. We evaluated the system in a 2 X 2 within-subjects study with 20 participants, manipulating verbal attunement and behavioral mimicry. Results showed that verbal attunement was the most reliable driver of perceived empathy. Behavioral mimicry showed a marginal relationship with perceived humanness, while greater mimicry exposure showed preliminary, exploratory positive associations with empathy, positivity, and humanness, particularly among female participants. Together, these findings show that multimodal synchrony is not a simple additive strategy for designing empathic conversational agents in VR and underscore the need to consider how verbal and nonverbal behaviors are combined during real-time interaction.

0.23

Judgement and the Feeling of Agency When Instructing a Computer to Act

cs.HC ·2026-08-10 ·Johanna Didion, Diego Garaialde, David Coyle
similarity 0.66
Abstract

In cognitive psychology, the sense of agency refers to the feeling of controlling an external event through one's own actions. This paper asks how people experience agency when they give an instruction to a computer, which then acts on their behalf. Research in human-human interaction has found that while people experience agency over the initial actions taken by another in response to their command, they may not experience agency over the ultimate outcome of those actions. We present two experiments. The first draws on prior studies of human-to-human interaction but replaces a human co-actor with a computer. The second study addresses potential limitations in the first, exploring the effect of more meaningful outcomes, and assessing both pre-reflective feelings and post-reflective judgements of agency. We find that participants experienced agency over the initial action taken by the computer in response to their command, but did not experience pre-reflective agency over the final outcome. Interestingly, however, they did judge themselves to have caused the final outcome when it was meaningful and their command specific. This difference between the pre-reflective feeling and post-reflective judgement of agency has important implications for design. If designers want people to feel in control and take responsibility for outcomes that result from instructions given to a computer, they cannot rely on pre-reflective intuition. Instead, we should design systems that encourage people to reflect on their actions and make deliberative judgments regarding responsibility.

0.04

Exploring the Effects of Personality in Human-Agent Interactions: A Study on User-Agent Synchrony with Human-based Vocalics

cs.HC ·2026-10-04 ·Kai Alexander Hackney, Jhonathan Sora-Cardenas, Aibek Musaev, Pedro Guillermo Feijóo-García
similarity 0.61
Abstract

User trust is paramount in human-agent interactions, as it allows users to feel comfortable being themselves around an agent. The process of building user rapport starts in how an agent was designed, from its modality to the setting, to any of the many features and characteristics that can be tailored. All these aspects can affect whether users will be able to properly interact with the virtual agent and achieve the intended purpose. One such feature that is critical in human-human interactions is personality. A person's personality can strongly influence whether those that interact with them perceive them as trustworthy. This study used virtual agents generated from human voices with known personality traits to evaluate user perceptions. We found that extraverted agents were deemed to be more likeable by users, and that there was no significant effect of user-agent synchrony on user perceptions of the agent. In addition, it was found that user personality, without regard for agent personality, affected user perceptions of the agents. Our observations suggest that user perceptions may depend more on agent-topic synchrony than user-agent synchrony, and contribute to the broader community with considerations for the design of effective human-agent interactions.

0.26

When2Talk: When Should a Proactive In-Car Agent Talk?

cs.HC cs.CV ·2026-09-11 ·Kaiser Hamid, Peihang Li, Nade Liang
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Proactive in-cabin agents can help passengers understand automated-vehicle (AV) behavior, but communicating every ride event may introduce unnecessary interruptions. We investigated how communication should adapt to event priority and passenger activity. In a mixed-methods within-subject study, 41 participants rode as passenger in a VR simulated fully-automated vehicle. We compared an event-triggered (ET) policy that communicated immediately at every event with a context-sensitive (CS) policy that selected \textit{Immediate}, \textit{Delayed}, or \textit{Silent} communications. CS increased communication appropriateness and substantially reduced perceived interruption. Perceived trust did not differ between policies, although baselines dispositional trust differentiated communication preferences. Findings highlight event consequence, passenger activity, continuing information value, and confirmation need as key considerations for selective in-cabin communication.

0.25

Comparing Hand and Controller Avatars with Hand Tracking and Controller-Based Interaction

cs.HC ·2026-09-18 ·Natalia Ocampo, J. Felipe Gonzalez, Robert J. Teather
top venuehighly cited similarity 0.60
Abstract

Previous research suggests that the congruency between common VR input devices - such as controllers or hand tracking - and their visual representations (e.g., hand or controller avatars) influences user experience and performance. However, the specific effects of input-avatar combinations remain underexplored. We study the effects of common input devices (hand tracking and controllers) and visual representations (hand and controller avatars) on performance and perceived success in target acquisition tasks. We included both grasping and pinching gestures across 16 combinations of input, avatar, and target size. Results indicate that hand tracking benefits from any form of visual representation - even when mismatched - achieving up to 5.8% greater accuracy compared to having no avatar, likely due to its reliance on visual feedback in the absence of a physical prop. Controllers were generally preferred and offered faster task completion. However, mismatched avatars had a stronger negative effect with controllers, particularly when the virtual gesture did not align with the physical action, leading to a 5.6% drop in accuracy compared to the matched condition - suggesting that inaccurate feedback can be more disruptive than having no avatar feedback at all.

0.65

Following Delegation Traces to Study Human Oversight in Interaction with Multimodal AI

cs.HC cs.AIcs.CV ·2026-10-15 ·Agnese Chiatti, Matteo Matteucci, Viola Schiaffonati
survey similarity 0.59
Abstract

As multimodal AI systems are becoming our everyday thought partners, the shift towards studying how users transfer control to these systems becomes especially urgent. In this paper, we report an overview of findings from an online study with n=56 AI-literate participants and 392 Video Question Answering trials. After inspecting each multimodal AI response, participants rated task-specific trust and selected one of three intended policies for an analogous future task: reject AI assistance, use it with verification, or delegate fully to the AI. Within participants, post-interaction trust strongly predicted the user's delegation choices (OR=14.97, 95% CI [7.14,31.37]). Trust and delegation nevertheless remained distinct. Verification was the dominant policy and often co-occurred with high trust. Delegation also increased with task order after adjustment for momentary and participant-level trust (OR=1.22, 95% CI [1.02,1.45]), indicating an experience-related component that self-reported trust ratings alone could not capture. These findings motivate a shift from intended delegation to a non-intrusive observation of how delegation is enacted in collaborative human-AI tasks. We therefore conclude by proposing enacted delegation traces as a methodological framework for future studies of multimodal and agentic AI use.

0.13