CS Paper Radar

Dynamic investment and coordination in teams: Theory and experimental evidence

David Gill, Victoria Prowse, J. Lucas Reddinger

cs.GT econ.GN ·submitted 2026-11-09 20:57 UTC · v1
benchmark

Abstract

Teamwork requires more than the general skills that team members bring. In successful teams, members invest in team-specific skill or capital that accumulates within the team and raises the return to coordinated production. We provide the first systematic analysis of dynamic investment in such team skill. Adopting a dynamic game approach, we develop a novel theoretical framework where investment in team skill creates persistent benefits but is risky because the benefits depend on successful team coordination. We then take this framework to the laboratory to study empirically the factors that influence dynamic investment in team skill. We find underinvestment compared to the efficient benchmark. However, investment responds strongly to incentives, in line with specific theory-predicted patterns. Pre-registered traits (theory of mind and propensity to coordinate) predict investment and team-level efficiency. We conclude that careful design of team incentives and selection of team members can facilitate the development of team skill.

Comment
90 pages, including appendices. JEL: C73, C92, D91, J24

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Team Stability: Theory and Evidence

cs.SI econ.EM ·2026-11-14 ·Anton Badev
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Teams emerge organically when individuals decide on their own their activities and collaborators. I develop and test a theory in which teams form with consent, interactions reflect team composition, and payoffs feature externalities and several forms of congestion. Stability constraints concern group interactions and require each team member to be willing to remain rather than withdraw or pursue a project alone. Empirical analysis of research collaborations among economists at the Federal Reserve Board suggests that: (i.) these constraints help explain observed teams beyond the payoffs to collaboration; (ii.) estimated violations point to large teams of entrants that appear to be assigned; (iii.) a compensatory mechanism mitigates the effects of variation in policy workload, which appears to affect team composition more than total research output; and (iv.) shifting workload toward experienced economists increases entrants' research output and collaboration, at the cost of lower output among experienced economists who compensate for this shift in policy workload with increased interactions with entrants.

0.37

A Conceptual Framework for Modeling Team Adaptation in Cooperative Games Through Ludic Knowledge

cs.HC cs.MM ·2026-08-28 ·Caleb Vatral
published similarity 0.59
Abstract · 10 pages, 4 figures, To be presented at AHFE: Hawaii International Conference 2026

With the increasing importance of teamwork skills for modern workplaces, development of teamwork training programs has received substantial attention. Game-based teamwork training is one promising approach that is engaging, cost-effective, and well-suited to increasingly decentralized workplaces. However, design of effective game-based teamwork training requires understanding how a game elicits specific desired teamwork behaviors. Significant progress has been made in characterizing these relationships. However, despite its critical importance, little work has examined how a game's design influences team adaptability behaviors. This paper presents a preliminary framework for analyzing adaptability in cooperative games by conceptualizing adaptive stimuli as retrieval or disruption of players' ludic knowledge. We illustrate this framework through a qualitative case study that applies interaction analysis methods to gameplay videos of a Overcooked!, a cooperative cooking game. We examined instances where game events led to players altering their behavior and connected the game's design features that resulted in each event with three adaptive stimulus cue categories. Although exploratory and limited to a small case study of a single game, the proposed framework is grounded in established theories across teamwork research and game studies, and it offers an initial vocabulary for describing how cooperative games can be designed to create demands for team adaptation. With this continued development, the framework may provide an analytic tool to help inform the design and evaluation of purpose-built game-based teamwork training environments.

0.39

Which Models Work Well Together? Measuring Heterogeneity for LLM Team Selection

cs.CL cs.LGcs.MA ·2026-09-29 ·Liangyu Teng, Hengsong Liu, Juncen Guo, Jingyu Zhang, Yang Liu +2 more
unusual similarity 0.54
Abstract

The performance ceiling of an LLM team is constrained not only by individual model capabilities, but also by inter-member error resonance and predictive differences. Although heterogeneous teaming is often observed to be effective in practice, existing approaches lack complementarity metrics that are computable, interpretable, and optimizable, leaving team composition to rely on heuristics. We propose a heterogeneity-driven team selection framework that performs offline profiling to characterize individual capability along with two complementary signals: one captures decorrelation in error patterns to reduce co-failures, while the other measures divergence in predictive behavior to capture strategy diversity. We formulate team selection as a standardized quality--complementarity combinatorial objective and apply an efficient greedy search to select a small team from a candidate pool. Experiments across multiple benchmarks demonstrate that our framework consistently outperforms quality-only baselines under controlled candidate pools and team sizes, establishing reusable selection principles for multi-LLM systems.

0.29

The Price of a Chance in Artificial Societies

cs.CY ·2026-10-29 ·Shuqi Zhao, Boyu Wang, Shuangyue Niu, Chenhao Zhang, Zhanzhan Zhao
similarity 0.52
Abstract

Rapid advances in large language models (LLMs) have enabled autonomous agents to interact, coordinate, and pursue individual goals in artificial societies. However, our understanding of how reward structures shape their competitive behavior and collective outcomes remains incomplete. We simulate 200 LLM agents competing over 50 rounds to maximize individual wealth. We define overcompetition and lying flat as population investment above and below a Bayesian adaptive baseline, respectively. At the lowest tested reward, populations lie flat; at the two highest, they overcompete, most strongly at intermediate winner coverage. The investment committed to pursuing an uncertain reward constitutes the price of a chance. Agents near the qualification cutoff can invest heavily yet receive no prize, finishing poorer than nonwinners who invest less. Agents' stated rationales link investment decisions to perceived qualification prospects and expected returns. At the collective level, greater investment does not consistently improve ability selection. With a fixed total prize budget, offering smaller prizes to more winners can reduce investment while preserving selection quality relative to the corresponding top-ability target. Further broadening reward coverage yields additional savings but reduces selection quality. These findings show how reward design shapes overcompetition and lying flat, distributes the costs of pursuing opportunity, and influences what competition collectively achieves.

0.24

When Does a Skill Add Value? Task-Conditional Gain Prediction for Selective Skill Use

cs.AI ·2026-09-26 ·Anjie Xu, Zhiyu Zhang, Ruiqing Ding, Fengli Xu, Leye Wang
code/data similarity 0.52
Abstract · 22 pages, 7 figures. Code: https://github.com/TankTechnology/skilldelta

Agent skills are expected to improve task performance. Yet we find that they often provide no benefit, and can even hurt performance while incurring additional token costs. Can we predict whether a skill will help before the agent acts? We introduce SkillDelta, a framework for predicting task-conditional skill gains from paired executions of the same agent with and without the skill. A local predictor transfers these historical gains to new tasks without retraining the agent. Under explicit transfer assumptions, our analysis links support coverage, representation mismatch, and execution noise to prediction error and decision regret. Across five benchmarks and three target agents, paired history improves observed-gain ranking over skill-assisted outcomes alone in 12 of 15 settings. At matched expected skill-use rates, SkillDelta improves success over random activation in all 15 settings, with an average absolute gain of 4.3%. Most of this advantage comes from allocation across task groups. Evidence for additional within-group selection value is strongest on ToolQA and weaker elsewhere. Code is available at https://github.com/TankTechnology/skilldelta.

0.45

Cognitively Constrained Partners for Zero-Shot Coordination in Real-Time Partitioned Control

cs.LG cs.HC ·2026-10-22 ·Ash Simmons, George De Ath, Richard M. Everson
published similarity 0.52
Abstract · 30 pages, 6 figures, 5 tables. Accepted at the NeurIPS 2026 Workshop on Human-AI Coevolution: Measuring Human-Agent Teams in the Agentic Era

Effective human-machine teaming requires agents that coordinate with unpredictable human partners. Reinforcement learning from live human feedback or large behavioural datasets is expensive, while purely simulated training overfits to artificial conventions and fails at Zero-Shot Coordination with real people. We propose a framework for training teaming agents against Cognitively Constrained Partners: simulated partners whose diversity emerges from procedural constraints grounded in human physiological literature, specifically reaction delays and perceptual limitations, rather than from reward shaping or historical training checkpoints. In a modified Lunar Lander environment, we report preliminary evidence that these partners play more like real people than unconstrained agents do, and that agents trained against them match the strongest cross-play baselines while being the only ones whose performance does not depend on how their training partners were generated. We also describe a human-participant study designed so that its rankings can be compared directly against cross-play, testing how well that standard evaluation predicts real human-agent teaming.

0.25

GM League Arena: An Interactive Long-Horizon Task Benchmark Based on Professional Sports League Management

cs.CL ·2026-11-03 ·Junkai Zhou, Ziming Pan, Zhaoyi Zhang
benchmark similarity 0.51
Abstract

Long-horizon decision-making under sustained competition requires large language models (LLMs) to balance immediate investment with future resource needs. However, local success in multi-step interactions can not adequately capture cumulative decision effects or demonstrate long-term goal achievement under resource constraints and sustained competition. To address this gap, we introduce GM Bench, a benchmark for managing professional sports teams across seasons under resource constraints and competition among teams. We build the environment simulators for four sports and add financial constraints, player demands, and market mechanisms to establish a unified task across sports. Diverse rosters of comparable strength are constructed from real-world player data, and each LLM is evaluated as a team general manager to assess its long-term management capabilities. We evaluate competitive performance, cash reserves, and cross-season improvement across four sports. Over five NBA seasons, Claude Opus 5.5 ranks first among 29 LLMs, while GPT-6 Astra and GPT-6.1 Sol combine strong performance with larger cash reserves.

0.23

Cooperation Without Adaptation: LLM Agents in a Collective-Risk Dilemma

cs.GT cs.AIcs.CLcs.MA ·2026-10-16 ·Trung-Kiet Huynh, Dao-Sy Duy-Minh, Chi-Nguyen Tran, Phu-Hoa Pham, Phu-Quy Nguyen-Lam +2 more
similarity 0.51
Abstract · 10 pages, 5 figures, 50-page supplementary material appended

Language-model agents are increasingly deployed to act on behalf of people in settings where individual decisions shape shared outcomes. We examine whether five production models adapt their contributions to changing risks and partner behaviour, or instead follow a relatively fixed strategy. In a collective-risk dilemma game (CRG), six players contribute to a shared pool over ten rounds; if the pool falls short of its target, a catastrophe may destroy their remaining resources. Four models contributed approximately an equal share at every positive risk level, and four of the five also contributed when risk was zero, even though contributing could not improve their payoff. Explicitly stating that only the agent's own payoff mattered reduced zero-risk contributions for most models, while a more neutral prompt did not. Several models correctly identified which action offered the higher expected payoff at different risk levels, yet their contributions changed little. Against fixed partners, no model consistently chose the payoff-maximising response, and in mixed-model groups, a single agent's shortfall in the final round could cause an otherwise successful group to fail. Payoff-based selection also depended on population composition: in a single six-agent group, it favoured the model that contributed least and reduced group success, whereas in larger, randomly mixed populations, it favoured an exact fair-share model at moderate and high risk. These findings show that cooperative self-play alone is not evidence of strategic adaptability. Consistent with a machine-behaviour approach, evaluations of agents in multi-agent systems should test how they respond to incentives, partner actions, and population composition.

0.28