CS Paper Radar

Performance Portability Explained: Insights from accelerating ICON microphysics

Faveo Hörold, Georgiana Mania, Panagiotis Adamidis, Harshada Balasubramanian, Jörg Behrens, Yakup Budanaz, Alexandru Calotoiu, Nicoletta Farabullini, Andreas Herten, Torsten Hoefler, Yannik Koenneker, Ioannis Magkanaris, Philip Müller, Ralf Müller, Edoardo Paone, William Sawyer, Bjorn Stevens, Hannes Vogt

cs.DC cs.PFcs.PL ·submitted 2026-11-10 15:24 UTC · v1

Abstract

Scientific computing is under increasing pressure to adapt to HPC hardware that is shaped by AI workloads. In these modern ecosystems, extracting reasonable performance without investing major engineering effort is a central issue for domain scientists. Correctness constraints and intricate reference implementations represent further impediments to development. Instead of using a double-precision implementation as a reference, considering the underlying scientific problem directly opens more opportunities for performance improvements when updating and rewriting applications. We take seven different portability frameworks---covering pragma-based, DSL, and data-centric approaches---and evaluate them on a microphysics kernel of the ICON climate model. Our performance benchmarks show that each different HPC system benefits from a different combination of optimizations, so we develop the measure of framework expressivity to gauge how easily each framework can customize portable implementations in this way.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Integrating a Python Dynamical core into ICON

cs.DC ·2026-08-21 ·Mauro Bianco, Till Ehrengruber, Enrique González Paredes, Andreas Jocksch, Christos Kotsalos +17 more
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 10 pages, 8 figures. ACM format

The transition of Earth-system models to exascale is often hindered by rigid, monolithic Fortran codebases and maintenance-heavy compiler directives. While high-level DSLs offer a solution, they frequently fail due to cumbersome integration. We present the integration of a Python-based ICON dynamical core into the original Fortran simulation code. Leveraging the GT4Py DSL and the Data-Centric (DaCe) optimization framework, we demonstrate that high-level Python can be seamlessly integrated into legacy infrastructure without performance loss. Our results challenge the assumption that Python orchestration introduces prohibitive HPC overhead. In production-grade global simulations, our Python dynamical core achieves a 20--30\% performance improvement over the highly-optimized Fortran+OpenACC implementation, with a 10\% improvement on the total time for a coupled setup. Driven by advanced data-flow optimizations and automated kernel fusion, this approach replaces hardware-entangled directives by generating optimized device code from a single, portable Python source. This work proves that Python can provide a sustainable, efficient, and hardware-agnostic future for global climate modeling.

0.25

Mixed-Precision Computing for Scientific Discovery: Formats, Co-Design, and Responsible Approximation

cs.AR math.NAcs.MS ·2026-09-29 ·Emmanuel Agullo, Hartwig Anzt, Daniel Bauer, David Bindel, Alfredo Buttari +35 more
similarity 0.58
Abstract · 41 pages

Reduced and mixed precision have moved from a niche optimization to a central design axis in scientific computing and engineering, driven by energy constraints, heterogeneous accelerators, and the convergence of simulation and machine learning. This paper organizes the landscape around seven coupled themes---number formats, floating-point emulation, emerging architectures, hardware/software co-design, relation to other approximations, software design, and precision as a multilevel resource ---and, for each theme, synthesizes the state of the art, future directions, and open questions. We emphasize \emph{energy per trusted solution} as the core objective, and we frame \say{recklessly responsible} computing as a pragmatic doctrine: exploit low precision aggressively, but with systematic detection, escalation, and certification pathways.

0.52

Performance Reporting of Mathematical Library Installations with LAAB - An Overview

cs.PF cs.MS ·2026-08-13 ·Aravind Sankaran, Paolo Bientinesi
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.56
Abstract · 10 pages, 3 figures

We present the Linear Algebra Aware Benchmarks (LAAB) framework for systematically assessing and reporting the performance of mathematical library installations on HPC systems. Mathematical libraries provide interfaces for operations that form the computational building blocks of scientific applications. Reporting their performance is important for assessing application efficiency, estimating compute-time requirements, and preparing resource-allocation requests. In this paper, we define four objectives for performance reporting: 1) traceability, linking each report to the exact library installation and execution settings; 2) compatibility, relating library-operation performance to higher-level scientific applications that use them; 3) reliability, supporting interpretation in the presence of measurement variability; and 4) accessibility, ensuring that reports, benchmark definitions, and relevant metadata are available for inspection and reproduction. We then present the design of LAAB and show how it addresses the challenges associated with these objectives.

0.26

Energy-Aware Performance Characterization of Kokkos Kernels Across Precision Levels

cs.PF ·2026-10-22 ·Maria Patrou, Andrey Prokopenko, Aditya Kashi, Oscar Hernandez, Jean-Luc Fattebert
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.56
Abstract · 13 pages, 4 figures, Accepted at the 3rd International Workshop on Energy Efficiency with Sustainable Performance: Techniques, Tools, and Be…

Kokkos is a performance-portable programming model used in GPU-accelerated HPC applications comprising kernels with diverse computational and memory behaviors. We characterize kernels from two applications to evaluate how FP32, FP64, and mixed FP32/FP64 affect arithmetic intensity, performance throughput, and GPU energy consumption. We introduce an Energy-Aware Roofline Model that incorporates energy into performance analysis and a Thermal-Aware Inter-Kernel Energy Model that visualizes energy consumption alongside duration, GPU temperature, and execution order. We study both applications with: (1) fine-grained, application-level instrumentation through the Kokkos Performance Tools PAPI Connector and (2) coarse-grained PAPI instrumentation applied to a dedicated-kernel benchmark using vendor-specific power management components. Our analysis shows that precision effects vary by application, kernel, and workload. Mixed FP32/FP64 kernels generally achieve arithmetic intensity comparable to FP32, with modestly lower throughput and, in most cases, a modest increase in energy consumption. FP64 kernels generally exhibit the highest energy consumption among the evaluated precision configurations.

0.35

FP64 Performance and the Limits of Ozaki Emulation on HPC Systems

cs.DC math.NA ·2026-11-09 ·Katarzyna, Swirydowicz, Nicholas Malaya, Noah Wolfe, Paul Bauman +2 more
similarity 0.55
Abstract · 11 pages, 7 figures

A growing industry narrative holds that native double precision can be deprioritized in HPC accelerators, on the hypothesis that low-precision tensor cores can emulate FP64 on demand, and that most HPC workloads are bandwidth-bound. This paper evaluates some of those claims and explores the importance of FP64 in scientific computing. We show roofline profiling data of representative HPC workloads, across a variety of common computational motifs, to evaluate the arithmetic-intensity and accuracy requirements of these workloads. We also consider FP64 emulation via the Ozaki method to ascertain some of the possibilities and limitations of these approaches. These results indicate that Ozaki emulation should not be evaluated as a general replacement for FP64, but as an optimization for the subset of workloads whose dominant computation is sufficiently large, dense, and GEMM-shaped. Our analysis indicates this is less than 10\% of the HPC ecosystem. Furthermore, even in this favorable regime, standalone GEMM speedup is not enough to accelerate (or avoid performance regression) for the application: numerical behavior, workspace requirements, matrix shape, and integration overhead determine whether the benefit survives at application scale. This paper characterizes those boundaries empirically. Furthermore, we show that dense GEMM accounts for only a small fraction of FP64 computation across HPC workloads, leaving most application-level FP64 work beyond the reach of GEMM-based emulation.

0.28

Productivity in HPC: A Critical Review from SLOC and Performance Portability to AI-Assisted Programming

cs.DC ·2026-10-05 ·Ami Marowka
similarity 0.54
Abstract · 39 pages, 2 figuers, 2 tables

Productivity has long been recognized as a central concern in high-performance computing (HPC), yet it still lacks a workable formal definition and a broadly accepted metric for quantified assessment. Recent attempts to incorporate productivity into performance-portability analysis have introduced code-divergence, convergence, and semantic measures, but have not established a convincing formal relationship between productivity and performance portability. More recent language and compiler systems, including JACC, Mojo, JLIR, and Accl++, pursue productive performance portability through higher-level abstractions, multi-level intermediate representations, automatic kernel generation, and runtime compilation. These systems demonstrate substantial engineering progress, while productivity is still commonly represented through programmability, ecosystem reuse, code size, or reduced implementation burden rather than direct measurement of human effort. This paper presents a critical review of HPC productivity measurement, tracing its development from source lines of code (SLOC), static complexity, and empirical usability studies to development-time models and semantic approaches. We also examine how automated migration and artificial-intelligence(AI)-assisted programming weaken the correspondence between code transformation and human effort, shifting effort toward verification, correction, and performance tuning. The reviewed methods are compared in terms of what they measure, directness, objectivity, reproducibility, practicality, and their relationship to performance and portability. We conclude by identifying the principal limitations and open challenges for quantified HPC productivity assessment.

0.34

What Bloats Your Floats? Right-Sizing Numerical Precision for Scientific Computing

cs.DC ·2026-10-06 ·Pratyai Mazumder, Alexandru Calotoiu, Marcin Copik, Yakup Koray Budanaz, Shriram Chandran +1 more
published similarity 0.53
Abstract · Accepted at SC '26: The International Conference for High Performance Computing, Networking, Storage, and Analysis, November 15-20, 2026, Ch…

While FP64 (binary64) remains the standard representation of real numbers in scientific computing, hardware trends increasingly favor low-precision formats optimized for AI workloads. This shift prioritizes throughput and energy efficiency over full-precision capabilities. We challenge the necessity of high-precision arithmetic in PDE-governed simulations, where spatial and temporal discretization errors introduce a physical noise floor that masks the lower-order bits of the FP64 format, rendering them irrelevant. We propose a criterion based on the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) with respect to spatial and temporal refinements to evaluate the impact of safe precision reduction on scientific computations. Finally, we present an automated dataflow-centric workflow for targeted lowering within mixed-precision subgraphs in complex scientific applications. Large-scale evaluations of weather and climate applications show that strategic precision reduction on GPUs achieves up to 1.8x speedup without compromising physical fidelity.

0.36

Trust, but Verify: Rigorously Profiling Best-Effort High-Performance Computing for Digital Evolution

cs.NE cs.DC ·2026-08-25 ·Matthew Andres Moreno, Santiago Rodriguez Papa, Charles Ofria, Luis Zaman, Emily Dolson
position similarity 0.53
Abstract

Developments in high-performance computing (HPC) technology continue to drastically increase quantities of available processing power. In the context of digital evolution, this explosive growth offers opportunities to advance both hypothesis-driven explorations of multi-scale biological phenomena and application-driven evolutionary optimization targeting hard problem domains. A particular opportunity arises from emerging next-generation AI/ML hardware accelerator platforms, such as the 880,000-processor Cerebras Wafer-Scale Engine (WSE). Such hardware, however, constrains on-device data storage and movement --- a challenge compounded by vulnerability to failures arising over numerous device components. Best-effort relaxations that depart from a traditional deterministic computing paradigm can help accommodate such constraints, but complicate reproducibility and risk introducing artifactual biases. We explore these concerns, developing a framework to measure runtime behavior of best-effort code and examining case studies of best-effort computing in digital evolution projects. The first case study applies best-effort CPU-cluster multiprocessing to a multicellularity evolution model, which provides 92% scaling efficiency at 64 processes ($2.1\times$ speedup) and exhibits robust median quality of service, even under hardware anomalies. The second case study examines WSE-based simulations, demonstrating best-effort strategies to track spatiotemporal population history --- through sparse, asynchronous device-to-host sampling that tolerates hardware faults. In sum, across potential forms and scopes of best-effort relaxation, we argue that digital evolution is uniquely positioned to contribute in developing post-deterministic HPC paradigms.

0.17