CS Paper Radar

Assessing Alignment in Automatic Piano Transcription Datasets: A Benchmark for Scoring Methods

Lucas de Souza Brandão, Lucas Gris, Joaquim Cavalcante, Chukwuemeka Nkama, Andrea Poltronieri

cs.SD eess.AS ·submitted 2026-11-10 18:13 UTC · v1
benchmark

Abstract

Automatic Music Transcription (AMT) relies on paired audio--MIDI datasets, implicitly assuming near-perfect temporal alignment. However, widely used piano datasets have been shown to contain alignment errors that may bias model evaluation and training. We propose a framework for evaluating audio--MIDI alignment scoring methods through controlled temporal, pitch, and structural MIDI corruptions. We also introduce STI, a scoring method built on AMT models, and benchmark it against existing alignment scoring approaches. Our results show that STI, together with methods based on CENS and spectrograms, achieves the strongest overall performance, with STI exhibiting the highest sensitivity to fine-grained temporal misalignments, the main alignment error in AMT datasets. We then apply the best-performing methods to widely used piano AMT datasets and identify trends in their relative alignment quality. These results support more informed dataset curation, model training, and AMT evaluation.

Comment
6 pages

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

MIDI-REPA: Improving Text-to-Music Generation with Symbolic Representation Alignment

cs.SD cs.LGeess.AS ·2026-10-14 ·Song-Ze Yu, Fang-Duo Tsai, Yi-Hsuan Yang
similarity 0.78
Abstract · 5 pages, 2 figures. Submitted to ICASSP 2027. Demo and code: https://midi-repa.vaclis.net

State-of-the-art text-to-music models increasingly rely on scaling model capacity, data, and compute, while still learning musical structure directly from dense audio. Yet melody, rhythm, harmony, and structure can be represented compactly in symbolic form. We introduce MIDI-REPA, a representation-alignment framework that derives MIDI supervision from automatic music transcription (AMT) to align intermediate representations of a flow-matching DiT. Building on the 122M-parameter FluxAudio-S baseline from the 2026 ICME Academic Text-To-Music Challenge, we investigate what, where, and when to align. Aligning a MuScriptor-derived piano roll with an early DiT layer throughout the full flow trajectory performs the best. Without additional training data or techniques, MIDI-REPA remains competitive on the ATTM objective metrics while remaining trainable on a single RTX 3090 in about 31 hours. Our results highlight symbolic supervision as a simple and inexpensive learning signal for improving text-to-music generation. We release our transcription pipeline, JamendoMIDI, training code, and audio samples at https://midi-repa.vaclis.net.

0.13

Gangqinpu: A Multi-Genre, Multi-Task Piano Dataset with Aligned Audio, MIDI, and Musical Scores

cs.SD cs.AIeess.AS ·2026-10-26 ·Wei Zeng, Anvay Mathur, Ye Wang
datasetcode/data similarity 0.78
Abstract · 9 pages, 3 figures

Aligned audio, performance MIDI, and musical scores provide valuable supervision for music analysis and performance modeling, yet datasets that jointly align all three modalities remain scarce and limited in scale and genre diversity. We introduce Gangqinpu, a multi-genre piano dataset containing 18,786 score-performance pairs and 1,007.1 hours of source audio, with automatic note-level alignments and derived beat/downbeat annotations. It spans diverse genres, including pop, classical, jazz, folk/traditional, rock, and blues. Our automated pipeline transcribes piano audio, aligns the resulting MIDI with musical scores, assigns genre labels, and filters out non-expressive performances with a score-informed binary classifier. We further construct joint splits with ASAP using conservative score-similarity grouping to reduce data leakage. We evaluate Gangqinpu on performance MIDI-to-score transcription, expressive performance rendering, and beat tracking. Downstream experiments demonstrate the value of Gangqinpu as complementary training data, with cross-dataset gains in beat tracking and primarily in-domain benefits for transcription and expressive performance rendering. The code and dataset are publicly available at https://github.com/wei-zeng98/gangqinpu.

0.22

SheetSage2: Coherent Lead-Sheet Transcription with Synthetic Supervision

cs.SD ·2026-10-04 ·Junyan Jiang, Ruibin Yuan, Jiahao Pan, Wei Xue, Yike Guo +2 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.76
Abstract

Transcribing music into a human-readable score requires a coherent understanding of rhythm, harmony, melody, and form. Two obstacles limit this goal: annotated recordings are scarce, and accurate local predictions can still produce inconsistent musical sequences. We present SheetSage2, a unified music transcription framework that combines synthetic data, task-specific structured decoding, and autoregressive distillation. Automatically annotated MIDI, rendered into audio, provides scalable supervision across music understanding tasks. Task-specific structured decoders integrate complementary musical cues and their temporal dependencies to produce musically coherent scores. Autoregressive distillation further retains transcription accuracy without task-specific dynamic programming at inference. Across eight benchmark collections, a single SheetSage2-AR model exceeds the listed prior systems on 12 of 15 benchmark--metric pairs in our evaluation, substantially improving over SheetSage1 and surpassing task-specific models on several benchmarks. Model weights and inference code are publicly available.

0.46

DuET: Note-Frame Dual Encoding for Piano Performance-to-Score Transcription

cs.SD cs.LGeess.AS ·2026-10-15 ·Wei Zeng, Ye Wang
code/data similarity 0.76
Abstract · 14 pages, 3 figures

Transcribing expressive piano performances into scores requires interpreting individual note timings within an underlying metrical structure. However, score attributes are associated with notes, whereas beats may occur without coincident note onsets. We introduce DuET, a Dual-Encoder Transformer that jointly learns note-level performance MIDI-to-score (PM2S) transcription and frame-level beat and downbeat tracking. Bidirectional cross-attention connects note and frame encoders, while an autoregressive decoder alternates between their representations to predict structured score attributes. We further introduce TimeRoPE and Time-Pitch Rotary Positional Encoding (TPRoPE) to establish a shared performance-time reference and explicitly encode relative temporal and pitch relationships. Evaluations on ASAP, a classical piano dataset, and our curated Gangqinpu dataset, which spans multiple genres with a focus on popular piano music, demonstrate improvements in score timing and notated duration. Compared with the strongest baseline on each dataset, DuET reduces MUSTER mean error from 6.56% to 3.64% on Gangqinpu and from 11.30% to 11.22% on ASAP. Ablations support the benefits of frame-level context, time-based positional encoding, and decoder-history masking. Code, weights, and demos are available at https://github.com/wei-zeng98/DuET.

0.29

Randomized Scores and Diverse Timbres: Augmenting Automatic Music Transcription with Online-Generated Data

eess.AS ·2026-10-08 ·Haiwen Xia, Chao Zhang, Qiuqiang Kong
similarity 0.73
Abstract · 5 pages

Automatic music transcription (AMT) is limited by the scarcity of audio recordings paired with precise symbolic annotations. Synthetic data can provide supervision at scale, but it remains unclear whether effective transfer depends on realistic score structure or broad timbral coverage. We study these factors separately through an online sampler--renderer pipeline. A unified corruption sampler ranges from unmodified MIDI clips through partial corruption to deeply randomized note-event distributions. The renderer converts these events to audio while independently controlling instrument and timbral coverage. A fixed transcription model is trained jointly on offline recordings and newly rendered examples. Controlled ablations reveal an asymmetry between the two factors: moderate corruption of the note-event distribution does not impair transfer and can improve it, whereas broader renderer-side timbral support consistently improves out-of-domain generalization under a fixed note-event distribution. Finally, online-rendered examples complement real and existing synthetic data in a strong combined-data regime. These results suggest that synthetic AMT data should prioritize coverage of note-level attributes and their timbral realizations over realistic joint score structure.

0.22

A Learned Musical-Time Coordinate for Piano Audio-to-Score Transcription

cs.SD eess.AS ·2026-10-21 ·Min-Hsing Wang, Tsung-Ren Huang
similarity 0.71
Abstract · 5 pages, 2 figures, 2 tables. Submitted to ICASSP 2027

End-to-end piano audio-to-score (A2S) transcription is the task of reconstructing a notated score from an audio recording in a single system. Existing A2S approaches usually rely on pre-segmented excerpts, and few handle whole pieces without external segmentation. This raises the question of whether a musical-time coordinate can guide score transcription while also helping the system segment whole pieces. Previous work on jazz saxophone A2S uses an external beat tracker to obtain such a coordinate for score prediction. We introduce downbeat phase, a musical-time coordinate learned jointly with score transcription that represents each audio frame's relative position within a notated bar. With this coordinate, our system can not only condition its score decoder on downbeat phase but also self-segment at bar boundaries and stitch the segments into a whole piece. Evaluation suggests that the coordinate improves metrical structure and supports whole-piece transcription with comparable notation quality.

0.27

Piano2Pop: Expanding Piano Demos into Pop Productions Without Aligned Supervision

cs.LG cs.SD ·2026-10-22 ·Yun-Chen Cheng, Chih-Pin Tan, Tzu-Hung Huang, Yi-Hsuan Yang
similarity 0.70
Abstract · Submitted to ICASSP2027

We introduce Piano2Pop, a music-expansion task that transforms piano MIDI into instrumental pop productions. Enabled by recent advances in music generation and polyphonic music transcription, our pseudo-supervised approach conditions a pretrained flow-matching model on piano rolls without aligned piano-pop supervision. We train on synthetic piano-instrumental pairs derived from pop recordings, comparing pair-free transcription, including function-selective (FST) and register-density (RDA) augmentations, with a pair-supervised piano-cover generator as pseudo-demo sources. On 476 testing real-world piano-cover/pop pairs, the pair-supervised approach achieves the best Frechet Audio Distance, Accompaniment Prompt Adherence, and spectral shape on real-piano inputs, while FST mitigates piano-heavy outputs in pair-free training and remains a promising alternative. All fine-tuned systems significantly outperform the zero-shot baselines, which suggests a role for task-specific modeling.

0.23

MAJEPPA: Morphing and Assessing in a Unified Piano Performance Space

eess.AS cs.MM ·2026-08-11 ·Jinwen Zhou, Huan Zhang, Weixi Zhai, Jinhua Liang, Aidan O. T. Hogg +1 more
benchmark similarity 0.70
Abstract

We present MAJEPPA, a self-supervised framework to learn piano performance representations that span the full skill spectrum, from beginner practice sessions to virtuoso concert recordings. We curate the MAJEPPA dataset, comprising ~4,000 annotated recordings across six expertise levels and six recording contexts. We adapt a single pre-trained MIDI autoregressive model with a joint objective: next-token prediction learns score-conditioned performance generation at various skill levels, while InfoNCE and supervised contrastive losses align abstract score and performance representations in a joint embedding space. The proposed model both generates and understands performances in a unified framework. By introducing the EVPMR benchmark, a suite of downstream tasks spanning quality assessment, competition ranking, mistake and technique classification, we evaluate the learnt representations, demonstrating progress towards a real-world model for the piano performance space.

0.04