CS Paper Radar

Integrality Gap of 3.4 for Santa Claus: A Topology-based Analysis

Kimon Boehmer, Chien-Chung Huang

cs.DS cs.DM ·submitted 2026-11-11 12:15 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

In the \textsc{Max-Min Allocation} problem, a set of indivisible items are to be assigned to a set of players and the goal is to maximize the minimum value among all players. A much studied special case, the \textsc{Santa Claus} problem, assumes that an item has a fixed utility but a player is only interested in a subset of items. The main technique for designing approximation algorithms for \textsc{Santa Claus} is the configuration LP, introduced by the Bansal and Sviridenko. A long line of research has progressively improved the upper bound of the integrality gap, mostly relying on the combinatorial arguments of Haxell for finding perfect matchings in certain hypergraphs. Remarkably, a recent paper of Haxell and Szabó (SODA '23) introduced a novel topology-based analysis, by which they are able to obtain the current best upper bound of $3.534$. In this work, we adapt the approach of Haxell and Szabó to analyze the integrality gap. The main new ingredient in our adaptation is that we stop the process of "edge explosions" in a graph used by Haxell and Szabó when it becomes too costly. This early termination of explosions, combined with a new lower bound on a topological connectivity parameter based on a theorem of Aharoni, Berger, and Meshulam, allows us to improve the integrality gap to $3.4$. Our analysis has the additional advantage of being simpler.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

An Unconditional Space-Approximation Lower Bound for Semi-Streaming Matching

cs.DS ·2026-10-27 ·Yang P. Liu, Kheeran Naidu, Hoai-An Nguyen, Janani Sundaresan
theory similarity 0.65
Abstract

We prove the first unconditional lower bound tradeoff between the number of passes and the approximation factor of maximum matchings in the semi-streaming model. Specifically, we show that any algorithm that outputs an $(1-\varepsilon)$-approximation to maximum matching requires $Ω(\log(1/\varepsilon))$ passes for constant $\varepsilon \in (0,1)$. Prior to our result, such tradeoffs were proven only conditioned on a certain combinatorial assumption about the density of Ruzsa-Szemerédi graphs. The state-of-the-art unconditional lower bound rules out any approximation factor better than $(8/9)$ in two passes but leaves open the possibility of a $(1-\varepsilon)$-approximation for any $\varepsilon > 0$ even in three passes. We provide two different proofs of our result: the first proof uses the recent hierarchical-embedding framework of Assadi, Konrad, Naidu, and Sundaresan (STOC 2024) along with combinatorial constructions using Ruzsa-Szemerédi graphs. The second extends the two-level Ruzsa-Szemerédi hierarchy of Konrad and Naidu (SODA 2024) beyond two levels and proves the corresponding communication lower bound directly by induction, rather than through a reduction to Index.

0.19

Remote Matching: Exact-Cardinality Approximation and Tight UGC Hardness

cs.DS ·2026-09-22 ·Arash Ahadi, Morteza Alimi, Sharareh Alipour, Shayan Tayefeh
similarity 0.64
Abstract

In the unrestricted max--min metric $T$-join problem, one seeks an even terminal set $T$ maximizing the cost of a minimum $T$-join. Iwata and Ravi gave a factor-$3/2$ approximation for this problem. We show that this guarantee is tight under the Unique Games Conjecture: no polynomial-time approximation with factor strictly smaller than $3/2$ exists under UGC. We then consider the exact-cardinality variant, which prescribes an even number \(k\) of terminals. Writing \(p:=k/n\), we give a deterministic polynomial-time \(ρ(p)\)-approximation for every feasible cardinality, where \[ ρ(p)= \begin{cases} 7/2, & \makebox[1.5em][r]{$0$}<p\le2/7,\\ 1/p, & 2/7\le p\le2/3,\\ 1/[2(1-p)], & 2/3\le p\le7/8,\\ 4, & 7/8\le p<1. \end{cases} \] In particular, a factor-\(4\) approximation holds throughout the entire feasible cardinality range, the factor is at most \(7/2\) whenever \(0<k\le 6n/7\), and equals \(3/2\) at \(k=2n/3\). The algorithmic framework is based on optimal laminar cut packings, their weighted tree representations, exact-cardinality rounding, and tree dynamic programming.

0.13

A Better-Than-$3$ Approximation Algorithm for Demand Matching via Knapsack Intersection LP and Contention Resolution

cs.DS cs.DMmath.CO ·2026-09-15 ·Michel X. Goemans, Yuchong Pan
theory similarity 0.63
Abstract

The demand matching problem generalizes both the knapsack problem and the $b$-matching problem. In this problem, each edge of a graph has a demand and a weight, and each vertex has a capacity. The goal is to find a maximum weight subset of edges such that, at each vertex, the total demand of the incident selected edges does not exceed the vertex capacity. Parekh [IPCO 2011] proved that, if each edge is individually feasible, the natural LP relaxation for demand matching has integrality gap at most $3$, yielding a $3$-approximation algorithm. This bound is tight for the natural LP relaxation, matching the lower bound of Shepherd and Vetta [Math. Oper. Res. 2007]. We present a randomized $(3/2 + \sqrt{2} + \varepsilon) \approx (2.914 + \varepsilon)$-approximation algorithm for the demand matching problem for every $\varepsilon > 0$, giving the first approximation ratio strictly better than $3$. For bipartite graphs, we obtain a randomized $(2 + \varepsilon)$-approximation algorithm for every $\varepsilon > 0$. Both algorithms run in time polynomial in $1/\varepsilon$ and the input length. Our algorithms use a strengthened LP relaxation based on intersecting the integral knapsack polytopes associated with the vertices, together with a multiple-choice generalization. As a key ingredient, we prove the existence of a $(q, 1/(1+q))$-balanced contention resolution scheme for the integral knapsack polytope for every $q \in [0, 1]$, which may be of independent interest. The balance guarantee $1/(1+q)$ is tight in the worst case over all knapsack instances.

0.23

Improved lower bounds on the approximability of Multiway Cut using Sherali-Adams relaxations

cs.DS cs.CC ·2026-11-03 ·Joshua Brakensiek, Neng Huang, Aaron Potechin, Uri Zwick
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract · 66 pages

The Multiway Cut problem is among the most well-studied problems in the area of combinatorial approximation algorithms. The currently best approximation ratio for the problem is 1.2787, obtained recently by the authors (2026). The best lower bound on the approximation ratio that can be achieved for the problem in polynomial time, under the Unique Games Conjecture (UGC), is 1.20016, obtained by Bérczi, Chandrasekaran, Király, and Madan (2020), building on and slightly improving a bound of $\frac65=1.2$, obtained by Angelidakis, Makarychev, and Manurangsi (2017) by introducing the important framework of non-opposite multiway cuts. We obtain a substantially improved lower bound of 1.22232 on the approximation ratio of the Multiway Cut problem. Manokaran, Naor, Raghavendra, and Schwartz (2008) showed that under UGC, the approximation ratio of Multiway Cut is equal to the integrality ratio of a simple LP relaxation, known as the CKR relaxation, introduced by Călinescu, Karloff, and Rabani (2000). Thus, stronger LP relaxations are not required for obtaining an optimal approximation algorithm for the problem. We show, however, that relying on the framework of Angelidakis, Makarychev, and Manurangsi (2017), stronger LP relaxations from the Sherali-Adams hierarchy for non-opposite multiway cuts can be used to obtain improved integrality ratios for the CKR relaxation, and hence improved lower bounds on the approximation ratio of the Multiway Cut problem. One of the novel features of our analysis is considering a continuous limit of discrete LPs defined on a simplex. Our proof of the new 1.22232 bound is completely analytic. We also present strong numerical evidence that suggests that our techniques can be used to improve the lower bound to at least 1.23003.

0.32

Minimum Membership Dominating Set and Its Generalization: Leafage vs. Asteroidal Number

cs.DS ·2026-11-10 ·Yuma Tamura, Daichi Wakayama, Akira Suzuki, Xiao Zhou
published similarity 0.62
Abstract · Accepted for publication in IPEC2026

The Dominating Set problem is known to be fixed-parameter tractable when parameterized by leafage, a structural graph parameter defined on chordal graphs. We investigate whether this tractability extends to its variants with natural constraints. Specifically, we study the Minimum Membership Dominating Set problem and its generalization, the Min. $(σ, ρ)$-Dominating Set problem. Given a graph $G$ and a positive integer $\ell$, Minimum Membership Dominating Set asks whether there is a dominating set $D$ such that every vertex in $G$ is dominated by at most $\ell$ vertices in $D$. We first show a negative result: Minimum Membership Dominating Set parameterized by leafage plus $\ell$ is W[1]-hard, demonstrating that even this natural constraint serves as a severe barrier to designing FPT algorithms. To complement this, we present an XP algorithm for the Min. $(σ, ρ)$-Dominating Set problem parameterized by asteroidal number plus $μ$, where $σ$ and $ρ$ are finite sets of non-negative integers and $μ$ is the maximum value in $σ\cup ρ$. Note that asteroidal number generalizes leafage to arbitrary graphs. Combining this algorithm with our structural bound that every graph $G$ admits a dominating set such that no vertex is dominated by more than $7\mathsf{an}(G)-6$ vertices, where $\mathsf{an}(G)$ denotes the asteroidal number of $G$, we show that Minimum Membership Dominating Set admits an XP algorithm parameterized solely by asteroidal number.

0.32

Integrality-Gap Bounds for Weighted Matchoids and Matroid Intersection

cs.DM math.CO ·2026-09-18 ·Yu Cong, Yajie Zhao
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract

The weighted $k$-matroid intersection problem asks for a maximum-weight set that is independent in each of $k$ matroids on a common ground set. The natural LP relaxation optimizes over the intersection of the $k$ matroid independent set polytopes. It is conjectured that this LP has integrality gap at most $k-1$. The conjecture is known for $k\le3$, but for $k\ge4$ the best general upper bound was $k$. We improve this bound to $k-1+1/k$. More generally, we prove that the natural LP of a $p$-matchoid has integrality gap at most $p-1+1/p$, with a deterministic LP-relative algorithm attaining the same factor. The matchoid extension resolves the $p$-matchoid part of a conjecture of Lee, Sviridenko, and Vondrák; projective planes give explicit tight instances whenever one of order $p-1$ exists.

0.25

Improved Pass Complexity for Semi-Streaming Matching in General Graphs via Budgeted Price Approach

cs.DS ·2026-10-15 ·Tatsuya Terao
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 11 pages

We present a simple deterministic semi-streaming algorithm that computes a $(1-\varepsilon)$-approximate maximum matching in general graphs in $O(1/\varepsilon^{2})$ passes. This matches the pass complexity of the auction algorithm of Assadi, Liu, and Tarjan~[SOSA'21] for bipartite graphs, and answers Open Question~2 of Assadi~[SOSA'24 \& TheoretiCS'25]. Our approach, which we call the \emph{budgeted price approach}, is very different from the previous $\mathrm{poly}(1/\varepsilon)$-pass semi-streaming algorithms for $(1-\varepsilon)$-approximation of matching in general graphs and improves their pass complexity. All previous approaches are augmenting-path-based and use $O(1/\varepsilon^{19})$ passes by Fischer, Mitrović, and Uitto~[STOC'22], $O(1/\varepsilon^{6})$ passes by Mitrović, Mukherjee, Sankowski, and Sheu~[ICALP'25], and $O(1/\varepsilon^{4})$ passes by Izumi, Kitamura, and Yamaguchi~['25].

0.26

Submodular Maximization over Bipartite Perfect Matchings and Matroid Intersection Bases

cs.DS ·2026-09-18 ·Chandra Chekuri, Lars Rohwedder, Neta Singer, Jan Vondrák, Rico Zenklusen
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Motivated by applications in fairness and foundational questions, we consider the problem of maximizing a monotone submodular function $f\colon 2^E \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_+$ over maximum cardinality sets in the intersection of two matroids on a common ground set $E$. An important special case is submodular perfect matching in bipartite graphs. Prior to this work, its approximability was poorly understood with only constant inapproximability known, despite not even a $\frac{1}{o(\sqrt{|E|})}$-approximation being known. Even when allowing to violate the cardinality constraint slightly, only a bicriteria approximation with a significant loss in the objective was known. Here, we obtain two results. First, we show that, within constant factors, the problem is approximation-equivalent to Submodular Orienteering in directed graphs. This yields an $Ω(1 / \log |E|)$-approximation in quasi-polynomial time together with an almost-matching hardness result. Second, we obtain an improved polynomial-time bicriteria approximation via a local search framework. More precisely, if $f(T^*)$ is the largest submodular value of a common independent set in both matroids of size at least $K$, we find a common independent set $T$ such that $|T| \geq (1 - ε) K$ and $f(T) \geq (1/2 - ε) f(T^*)$. In contrast, previous work only guarantees a value of $Ω(ε) f(T^*)$ while ensuring that $|T| \geq (1 - ε) K$.

0.40